Sermon Series: Lectures

  • The Bible and Rhetoric

    The Bible and Rhetoric

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered March 2, 1998.

    About this sermon

    Classical rhetoric cares about ethics and persuasion, and biblical rhetoric exists to proclaim an event more than to illustrate an idea. Fundamentalist and evangelical preaching each fall short of that standard in different ways. Concrete examples of biblical rhetoric close the Lectures series.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    I’ve been told that he even has a better laugh than I. I’m happy to be here with you and I know a number of you made acquaintance with some of you last year I know some of you better than others. Some of you have been in my congregation in Swickly, Pennsylvania, and it’s really good to see you again, too.

    My interest in rhetoric began when I was a seminary student. It began because of my interest in preaching. Now, you’ll note that this is a lecture on biblical literature, and we’re not going to be focusing specifically on preaching, but that’s where my interest began. I was somewhat distressed as a student at Westminster to look at some manuals on homiletics, or theory of preaching, because as I looked at some of the more respected volumes from the last century, I recognized that they had a particular interest in rhetoric.

    In fact, they looked at preaching as a baptized form of classical rhetoric. You had such volumes as William G. T. Shedd’s Homiletics and Pastoral Theology and Robert Dabney’s Sacred Rhetoric, volumed by that title, and it was their idea that you merely took the standards of classical rhetoric and you applied them to the pulpit task or to the preaching task.

    I abhor that approach. I will tell you right now. And so I was definitely in reaction. through my seminary years to that approach to preaching, and it will probably show in the course of this lecture, but I haven’t really picked up much from the classical rhetoric tradition. I didn’t memorize my lecture, for instance.

    Some of you who have had rhetoric know that’s what you’re supposed to do. The other thing that I think is important to say at the beginning is that there has been a resurrection or a renaissance of interest in classical rhetoric. In fact, there are those who are saying now that it is an indispensable part of a proper education, even a Christian education. I’m not too sure about that. unless certain things are understood, certain things are done to the enterprise as a whole.

    And I think that that will become apparent this evening. I will make apologies at the beginning of this lecture, and if I have my wits about it at the conclusion, I’ll make the comment again. I only wish that I had the ability, or better yet, the grace from God to be what I say, and for my message to be an exposition of the gospel itself, and my own person a communication to you. And if you will remember this statement as we go through the lecture this evening, I think it will be more intelligible to you.

    I’m not interested in simply the science of public communication. And I don’t think the Bible is interested in that either. Okay. You have an outline of the lecture on the back. You will find, I think some, I trust some helpful material on the parables that will be handy for you when we get to that section. Opening up then, rhetoric and biblical literature. First of all, classical rhetoric. Comments about that.

    Susan Wardner has described classical rhetoric as that form of communication invented for the specific purpose of persuasion in the public arena. Rhetoric is that form of communication invented for the specific purpose of persuasion in the public arena. As such, classical rhetoric is concerned with what we might call the living voice in public discourse, the living voice in public discourse. This living voice could be, as the art developed, either oral or written.

    It was not simply interested in the rational and emotional sides of its presentation, but with the way in which it appeared and sounded. Out of concern for effective communication, classical rhetoric concentrated as much on tone and cadence as it did on cogency.

    Classical rhetoric took shape in Sicily and Greece in the 5th century BC. Figures of importance were Corax, Socrates, and by way of extension Plato. together with Isocrates and his school of rhetoric. In the fourth century, Aristotle formalized rhetoric as an art turned to the practical purpose of persuading and impressing.

    An art turned to the practical purpose of persuading and impressing. As you can well imagine, such an art drew to the center questions about ethics. Plato had already engaged the sophists on the ethics involved in rhetoric, their abandonment of moral purpose, and their commitment to the goal of winning an argument through any persuasive means, led Plato to attack them for their deceit and insincerity. But since rhetoric concerned itself with persuading and impressing, it invariably drew the attention of those who mastered it as an art for manipulation.

    Therefore as the study of rhetoric developed very much at the heart of things had to be the discussion about a communicators ability and His goodness The moral dimension of rhetoric continued to command attention great attention into the Roman era and Both Cicero and Quintilian were preoccupied with it. Quintilian’s desire to equate the great orator with the good man, however, was undermined by the progressive but rapid erosion of Roman culture, an erosion that turned rhetoric into theatrics and entertainment. art form especially employed to debate hypothetical historical and legal questions as Well as to enhance public gatherings such as festivals birthdays marriages and funerals The classical world meets the church The appearance of the Christian Church and the spread of Christianity brought great change to the Greco-Roman world. The rise of Christianity even had a great effect on the revered domain of rhetoric.

    For one thing, the Church registered a renewed moral stability and zeal within a culture facing moral collapse. However, you should understand the church did not achieve this primarily out of her concern to renew moral stability and zeal. You see, Christianity in its apostolic or pristine form had such an impact upon that ancient world, not because it chose to have such an impact, but because it was otherwise directed. For example, Christianity reoriented the rhetorical enterprise within itself. away from the morally suspect political, judicial, and theatrical focus of society, and toward the gospel and the ecclesiastical and evangelistic interests of the believing community.

    We could put it like this. In the hands of the church, the rhetorical enterprise was moved in its concern from the enjoyment of life and the hope of a better life in this world to the promise of eternal life in heaven. Such a radically different outlook went a long way in addressing the place of ethics in rhetorical presentations. Since the Church, again in its apostolic and pristine form, has no inherent compulsion to promote itself for its own sake, nor any motivation to use its rhetoric to manipulate its audience in order to ensure its own wealth, privilege, or power in this world. But beyond this reorientation and the reformation it brought, to moral perspective.

    Christianity introduced into the classical world more directly and pervasively than Judaism had been able to do the challenge of Hebraic or biblical reality. The challenge of Hebraic or biblical reality. According to this reality, There are not many gods, only one God, who is utterly distinct from his creation, who, in the event of his own sovereign self-disclosure, reveals himself so that his people, by his grace, might participate with him in a transcendent bond of perpetual fellowship. Because the event of God’s self-disclosure is central to biblical or Hebraic reality, rhetoric within the Christian context could never be summarized by the traditional categories of classical rhetoric.

    It could not even be synonymous with the logic of judicial, deliberative, or demonstrative persuasion. Rather, biblical reality must first of all be proclamation. proclamation not of an idea, but of an event. Not a thought in someone’s head to be argued for or defended, but an event most certainly having taken place and determinative.

    The rhetoric of the Church, if it can even be called rhetoric then, proclaims, preaches, teaches God’s mighty acts, His saving works, and principally, His final sufficient saving work in Jesus Christ. Therefore, the rhetoric of the Church is not the presentation of, or the defense of an idea, it is the announcement at root of the event of God’s self-disclosure, His self-revelation, His saving, mighty act.

    Another way the Church brought great change within the classical world was by challenging the canons of rhetorical art with the canon of the Scripture. This meant more than the replacement of one textbook, such as Aristotle’s Rhetoric, with another, namely the Bible. What it meant was this. The living voice was now uniquely, and with unparalleled authority, the divinely inspired written voice. The Bible was a completely different kind of book than the textbooks known to those who were engaged in rhetorical pursuits. By the Church, it was acknowledged to be a living, authoritative word from God, in which and from which the Church and her preachers were compelled to formulate their own words. beneath which they were continuously and rigorously scrutinized.

    In its most radical effect, this shift in focus from the rhetorical canons of the Greco-Roman world to the Bible displaced what might be called the rhetorical moment. The rhetorical moment. That moment was no longer the immediate moment in which the speaker presented his case or made his appeal. Instead, that moment was the historical inscripturated moment, the moment assumed or declared in the text to which the speaker and the hearer were related, into which they were drawn in order to believe and obey the one who spoke definitively in his word.

    The effect of the Church’s proclamation was to draw the audience into the event. The effect of the living Word of God and the communication of it was to pull the audience into the event, declared and described in the Word. so that you became a participant in it. It is this very truth, namely that the living voice is the written inspired voice which encourages the church to consider seriously then the rhetorical nature of biblical literature.

    Part two, modern approaches to rhetoric and the Bible. First of all, what we might call traditional innocence or fundamentalism and rank-and-file evangelicalism. For many, the relationship between biblical literature and rhetoric amounts to no more than a naive awareness of certain fundamental features to the text, such as outline, theme, climax to a given book or passage, This innocent or naive approach to the Bible is often made a blind method of Bible study for those most sincere and devout in their allegiance to the Scriptures. But by leaving matters rest at this superficial level, These often very godly people inadvertently promote ignorance of the Bible’s profound depths. They have also helped to leave higher-level Bible studies a much more open field for those with less than orthodox views on the Bible and the Christian faith.

    Enter modern sophistication. When we turn to the modern scientific sophisticated investigations of the Bible, we are often faced with a very disturbing fact. Many of those given to these investigations pursue them with the claim that they are Christian and that they are spokespeople for the church, when in fact their belief system stands quite contrary to the biblical religion and historic Christianity.

    J. Gresham Machen called these confused and dishonest people liberals. Others have called them modernists because they have absolutized the modern situation. They see everything from the perspective of the present situation.

    Now, for convenience sake, we will be dealing with two kinds of liberals and their approaches to rhetoric and the Bible. And I am not going to be dealing so much with their methods as I am with their religious direction and intention. First of all, classical liberalism as represented in George Kennedy. The classical liberal position begins with the assumption that the Bible is ancient literature, unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness. Unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness, unique practically because of its sustained usefulness and cultural importance, since it continues to inform the ethical ideas of society. That might be worth repeating for you so that you have that. understanding of liberalism. It approaches the Bible as ancient literature, unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness, unique practically because of its sustained usefulness and cultural importance since it continues to inform the ethical ideas of society even today. But in order to profit most from the Bible, we must hear it, suggests Kennedy, as did those who originally received it.

    Rhetorical analysis helps us to do this effectively, since it alerts us to the rhetorical devices employed in the text to enhance and maximize the effectiveness of a particular piece. Once we have heard the text by way of rhetorical analysis, we are better able to differentiate in it between dismissible culturally specific and universally valid material. This means we are able then to discard what might be called parochial propaganda. Parochial propaganda, including primitive supernaturalisms, and especially the primitive eschatological vision and commitment of the biblical text.

    But now, having gone through the rhetorical enterprise or exercise With the universally valid material from the Bible in hand, we having discerned that we are able to translate the scriptures for our modern audience, we are likewise able to generate our own distinctively modern religious rhetoric sensitive to our times.”

    Well, that’s classical liberalism. What about radical liberalism? The position of Wilhelm Wellner, While the classical position is interested in society’s moral stability, the radical position concerns itself with the overturning and reinventing of social structures. To put it bluntly, it pursues revolution.

    To begin with, the radical position approaches ancient texts, including the Bible, as social discourse. social discourse. This means the text was the product of the dynamic interaction between the author, his intended audience, the community out of which each arose, and the political and ideological environment in which they lived. Becoming quite complex, isn’t it? Rhetorical criticism provides service by peeling back the layers of the text in the interest of uncovering a valid human description obscured by the text’s sociological and political prejudices. But you should understand The radical position connects present society to those in the text’s original setting in a dialogue with the text.

    We now in dialogue with the text, we also in dialogue within the text itself. In this ongoing discussion between text, original audience, and present reader, modern culture becomes all the more capable of pursuing life’s true meaning. namely the transformation of society. And you thought rhetoric was harmless. Don’t be so naive. There are many with grand designs when it comes to rhetoric. Upon this basis, the ancient text and modern reader unite in the common goal of empowerment for the oppressed and mutual resistance to all kinds of systemic absolutism, every form of exclusionary politics and religious dogma.

    Orthodox response Now we have a time for a full response to these liberal positions however Let me make a few observations for you first of all Neither the classical nor the radical liberal position is committed to a divinely inspired infallible Bible that should be obvious For both, the Bible is a human book testifying to the progress of humanity’s religious quest.

    Secondly, both positions assume the supremacy of the present moment. The now of our present circumstance is qualitatively different from the then of the world in which the Bible was written. That is axiomatic. You live in a qualitatively different world. than those who lived in Bible times. Thirdly, both positions assume that the distance between the then and the now is overcome to the extent that that distance can be overcome by the tools of scientific research, such as rhetorical criticism. By use of these tools, they suggest that we are able to reach the levels in and beneath the text helpful for identifying helpful for identifying humanity’s common moral interest. In this context, the Bible is a signpost. The Bible is a signpost.

    It is a directional aid, never the product in space and time of the direct action of a God such as the Bible describes, since no such God as the Bible describes does or even can exist. much less is there any such God who can provide definitive instruction in a faith once for all delivered to the saints, as the Bible itself claims.

    But it is precisely at this point, namely what the Bible claims for itself, that the greatest problem to the liberal approaches becomes obvious to us. While claiming to stand within the community of faith, those who hold to liberalism are clearly committed to positions plainly at variance with the Bible’s own point of view. In fact, liberalism, both classical and radical, has determined that the biblical record is primitive and even inferior. Worse still, the Scriptures are deceptive, a deceptive witness endorsing not just mythological notions, but oftentimes morally corrupt social and political agendas.

    The Bible is not supportive of female ordination. The Bible, therefore, is a morally inferior document. The Bible is repressive when it comes to the homosexual agenda. The Bible is therefore morally primitive and inferior to our enlightened convictions.

    You see where this is going. Only modern historical and rhetorical research can make the Bible then useful to improve society through a truly worthwhile view of life. The irony for this type of rhetorical study of the Bible is that it is oblivious to the Bible’s own rhetoric.

    That rhetoric presents a God who calls for believing response to his intrusive saving activity. In the Old Testament, the rhetoric centered on the event of the Exodus, the saving event of the Exodus. And it was this event with which the heroes about that event, the audience, were called to interact.

    One great example of this interaction is found in Exodus 13, verse 8. where the Jewish father tells his son in the context of the Exodus and in the context of the celebration of the Passover, this is what the Lord did for me when he brought me out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. You see, it doesn’t matter how far in time that father is removed from the Exodus event, he still says the same thing. It doesn’t matter whether it’s in the 1400 B.C. period or it’s in the 700s. The Jewish father says the same thing to his child.

    This is what the Lord did for me when he brought me out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bodies. But Dad, you weren’t even there. Oh yes, I was. You have a completely different way of thinking. intruding on the consciousness of these Hebrew people. And the rhetoric of Scripture is picking that up in such a way so as to draw the audience, the hearers, into the event. The Father was there.

    I can tell you now that it is only covenantal theology, it is only Reformed theology that appreciates that. It is only Reformed theology that can appreciate it. But if that isn’t good enough for you, and you say to yourself, well, that’s the Old Testament. What about the New? I’m getting a little rhetorical here. Paul, being the good Hebrew that he is, better than most, will do the same thing.

    Only now, the great intrusive saving act is not the Old Testament exodus, a political and social deliverance for the children of Israel. It is the religious and spiritual deliverance realized through the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. The great intrusive saving act of God now, to which the Old Testament Exodus pointed, is achieved, realized, in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. And keeping in mind what that Hebrew father said back in Exodus 13, Paul expresses participation in this event now in fine covenantal style.

    I am crucified with Christ, yet I live. Yet not I, but Christ liveth in me, and the life that I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” Paul, you weren’t even at the crucifixion or the resurrection. Oh, yes, I was. Now, if I were to become sermonic here, I would tell you, so were you.

    But why do you hesitate to take those words from Galatians 2.20 and make them your own? To speak about yourself, the first person, singular pronoun in the same way that Paul speaks.

    The two modern liberal approaches which I have described to you are incapable, incapable. They talk about the impossibilities for us, let’s talk about the impossibilities for them. I mean, you can’t believe in a God like that. That’s what they were saying, right? The modern liberal approaches which I have described to you are incapable of the covenantal saving confessions that are expressed in Exodus 13 and Galatians 2.

    These liberals have thereby severed their connection to the Bible’s rhetorical intention. And sadly, tragically, they are complete strangers to it. Part three. rhetorical analysis, and the scriptures. Having offered a preliminary critique of liberalism’s proposals about rhetoric and the Bible, I don’t mean to discount sincere efforts at higher levels in biblical scholarship to hear more clearly, more carefully, what the text is saying. Let me give you three examples of a more positive approach. Lamentations. Say, wait a minute. Positive? This is going to be the positive approach? Oh yes.

    The Old Testament book of Lamentations is generally accepted as the work of the 6th century B.C. prophet Jeremiah, who was a witness to the destruction of Jerusalem and its temple at the hands of the Babylonians in 587 B.C. Of interest to us is the way this book is divided.

    It is divided along chapter lines now, composed of five laments. Five laments. A lament per chapter. The last chapter in the form of a prayer. Now, in looking at the book, you will notice the symmetry. chapters 1, 2, 4, and 5, 1, 2, 4, and 5, and thus, laments 1, 2, 4, and 5, each have 22 verses.

    While chapter 3, the one we left out, the third lament has 66 verses, a multiple of 22. If you read Hebrew, you would see further what Jeremiah is doing. He is building a repeating acrostic based on the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. A repeating acrostic based on the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Laments 1, 2, and 4 have a verse per letter. Lament 3 has three verses per letter. However, now, further analysis of these laments, one through four, reveals that each has a chiastic pattern.

    You know what a chiasm is? It’s the goalpost. You know chiasms, everybody? Shake your head if you know what a chiasm is. A, B, B, A. Okay, you with me? A, B, A, B, C, C, B, A. You can go on one side, back up the other. Okay, that’s chiasm. Each of these laments, one through four, has a chiastic pattern. In other words, and here is what might be, for us, the rhetorical impact. Each lament in this chiastic form is like a verbal whirlpool. a verbal whirlpool, sucking the hearer into its center before throwing that hearer back out to the circumference for the next descent.

    You’re going to go down again. The rhetorical impact of this structure for the first four laments registers hard upon a people which has witnessed the total devastation of their nation, capital city, and temple. In fact, you sense something in this structure of the repeating history of Israel as a nation. At the edge, being sucked into the center, thrown out to the edge again, then sucked back down into the center because of her corruption. And it happens again and again and again. But what about the Fifth Lament? Chapter 5. It is neither an acrostic nor a chiasm. You’re with me. It is neither an acrostic or a chiasm.

    In other words, the pattern of the previous four laments, rhetorical effect. The first four laments underscore the collapse of the world in which the Jews had come to trust, even to the neglect of their genuine commitment to Jehovah. The breaking of the pattern in the fifth lament serves as a rhetorical statement of hope. The repeated descent into the maelstrom of lament ends now, here in the fifth chapter, in a soulful prayer for restoration.

    A soulful prayer for restoration. As to the power of this prayer, if you had it in front of you presently, you would note that it is not a request for the restoration to the land, the city, or the temple, but a prayer for restoration to God Himself. And in this sense, Lamentations becomes profoundly prophetic. and instructive to all of Israel and even to the church presently.

    You must move past the land, past the city, past any religious structure to God himself, and that becomes the legacy of Judaism. Rightly understood. God is the inheritance. God is the reward, not the land not the garden, not a restored earth, God himself. Thus Lamentations ends. Turn thou us unto thee, O Lord, and we shall be turned.”

    Matthew 13, the parable chapter. You can get a sense of where I’m going with this on the back of the outline. In dealing with Jesus’ rhetoric, we will remember his audience. Matthew helps us in our appreciation of this by his presentation of the parables here in Matthew 13. In this chapter we find two expressed audiences. The multitudes who receive the first four parables, the parables about the sower, the wheat and the tares, the mustard seed and the leaven, taking us through the 35th verse, and then the second audience his disciples who received the last three parables, the parables about the treasure, the pearl, and the dragnet, from verse 36 on.

    At the center of the message from the parables is the event, once more underscoring that, the event of God’s self-disclosure through Jesus Christ in the arrival of the kingdom of heaven. Jesus’ parables illustrate the kingdom in its present reality in relationship to its future completion. If you hold on to that, you have a key to unlocking the parables. Jesus’ parables illustrate the kingdom in its present reality in relationship to its future completion.

    What can be confusing, however, is the fact that the two audiences, the multitudes and the disciples, approach Jesus and his message about the kingdom with different attitudes and different questions. The multitudes are ambivalent, even skeptical, about Jesus and ask, in effect, this can’t be the kingdom, can it? The first four parables in Matthew 13 address this question. The Jews expected immediate and uniform response to the kingdom. They did not see such response to Jesus.

    Jesus tells them in the parable of the sower that the kingdom has indeed come in the sowing of the seed, but the kingdom’s impact is limited and long-term, culminating in a harvest at the end of the age. Each of the following parables directed at the multitudes deals with the same dynamics. Interestingly, the Church, again being drawn into the text and living from it, has precisely the same rhetoric as Jesus had when dealing with multitudes who are ambivalent and skeptical, even to this day. While the disciples are also confused, somewhat like the multitudes, they have a different attitude and question. They trust Jesus, but their question is, what is our life like now that the kingdom has come? What is our life like now that the kingdom has come.

    Jesus tells them the parable about the treasure in the field, for the sake of which a man sacrifices everything. The parable about the pearl of great price follows the same end. And finally, the parable about the dragnet sets before the disciples their mission of catching men for the sake of the kingdom until the day when the good are separated from the evil. The church being drawn into the text has precisely the same rhetoric in its message toward the faithful today.

    What is the life of the disciple like? What is the life of the church like? The forsaking of everything in the interest of the kingdom. the treasure in the field, the pearl of great price, and the commitment to a mission that sees the faithful gathered out of the world until the end.

    Finally, 1 Corinthians 13 and the Apostle Paul. He’s going to miss the best part. You’re still awake, right? Good. All right, here we go. When we come to Paul, we come to a most interesting case in terms of rhetorical analysis. This is because, on the one hand, Paul attacks rhetoric. On the other hand, he seems so adept in its use.

    His disclaimer of rhetoric is found in the early chapters of 1st Corinthians. where he sets God’s wisdom in the cross of Christ over against the wisdom of speech. Chapter 1, verse 17. He sets God’s wisdom in the cross of Christ over against the wisdom of speech. What he is describing here as the wisdom of speech is wisdom that belongs to this world and is incapable of bringing people to a knowledge of God.” Verse 21. Chapter 1.

    It would seem then, that according to the Apostle Paul, God has His own rhetoric. His own distinctive rhetoric. And that rhetoric isn’t like anything. the Greeks have imagined, or the Romans. That rhetoric, if we can term it such, is in fact the cross. Which Paul is determined to present?

    Chapter 123, chapter 2, verse 2. For I am determined to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ and Him crucified.” Paul goes on to say, in effect, to resort to the wisdom of men is to reject the power of God resident in Christ and His cross. Chapter 2, verse 5.

    We then watch in amazement as Paul builds his arguments out of the substance of Christ’s cross. And that brings us to 1 Corinthians 13. He will build his arguments out of the substance of Christ’s cross. The cross itself becomes method. It’s not simply message. It becomes method. Now, you know, 1 Corinthians 13, you probably have it memorized. Famous love chapter. It is an excellent example of Paul’s method. Here Paul mocks. Now, I underscore that.

    You may not pick that up from your reading of the text, nor from the way in which 1 Corinthians 13 is invariably read. You know, it’s always in a serious tone, and we seem to be trying Here in the 13th chapter, Paul mocks the spiritually vain within the Corinthian church. He does this through a presentation of Christ and Christ’s cross.

    But you, in calling 1 Corinthians to mind now, or maybe you even have it open in front of you, can’t remember in it, can’t pick up any reference in it, of either Christ or his cross. Now, even though you’re right, as you scan through the verses of 1 Corinthians 13, or as you think in your mind, calling to mind that chapter, that there are no mentions of Christ or His cross in it, be assured, Paul means here to communicate both Christ and His cross.

    In the first place, Paul intends here no presentation of an abstract definition of love. 1 Corinthians 13 is not a general philosophical or ethical discourse. This should be apparent to us from verses 4 through 7, where Paul tells us love is patient, kind, free of jealousy, boasting, arrogance, and the like. That’s my paraphrase.

    Now, it is a particular kind of hermeneutical obtuseness that has refused to see Jesus Christ at root in this description. Paul here is not expounding an idea, the idea of love, or a feeling, the feeling of love, or even an attribute of character, he is expounding Jesus Christ.

    Specifically, he is expounding the cross. After all, in the cross of Christ, Christ himself refuses to seek his own advantage or glory. It is in the cross that he shows himself unprovoked, It is in the cross that Christ does not take into account a wrong suffered. In the cross, Christ bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, and endures all things. He is working off of Christ. But Christ and his cross do more than lie beneath the surface of Paul’s words. They form, as well, the very substance to his method in argumentation. The very substance in his method of argumentation. This takes place in two ways.

    First, Paul is fighting spiritual pride among those at Corinth who boast in their particular gifts in the Spirit. At the opening of 1 Corinthians 13, Paul subtly mocks these people. He subtly mocks these people. He means what he writes here to be a humorous, though controlled, attack. He mocks these people by taking their gifts and heightening them to such a level that they are placed beyond the realms of actual reality or even possibility.

    Beginning with the tongues of men and of angels, verse 1, he goes on to an understanding of all mysteries and all knowledge, the possession of all faith, and an absolute demonstration of charity, so-called, through immolation. I’ll burn my body. You get to that third verse and you wonder where in the world is this guy coming from? Just come out of the Bible, come out of the background of our understanding of what it means to serve God, you’re going to burn your body. Who does not?

    Pagans, I get it. It’s certainly an understatement. By the time we get to the part about him burning his body, we should have perceived the twinkle in his eye. Paul is saying sarcastically here, is sarcasm a proper pious rhetorical device? Yes. Paul is saying sarcastically Even if I had these gifts, and I don’t, nor does anyone else, and had not love, I’m nothing. But you will notice now how he tempers his barb. He tempers them by his use of the first person singular pronoun, I. Though I speak, though I have, though I bestow, he rhetorically controls his sarcasm by placing himself in the middle of the humorous assault by making himself look ridiculous. He says, though I, not though you.

    This is nothing less than the effect of Christ and his cross expressing itself in his approach. Paul labors to humble himself even in his most barbed communication. But then later, in verse 9, Paul says, For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. Here, the expression of Christ and His cross deepens.

    He uses now the first person plural pronoun, we. This pronoun is as deliberate as it is inclusive. You see, everyone gifted and non-gifted is included in the we. Everyone gifted and non-gifted is included in the we. In fact, Paul himself is included in the we. And Paul has the greatest gift.

    He’s the apostle. He’s included himself amongst those who know in part and prophesy in part. The effect of Paul’s language is not merely the recognition of the uniform limitation under which all in the church serve, but equally the uniform level to which even the least gifted, even the ungifted, are exalted so as to participate with one as distinct as an apostle in the body. He literally takes those who are considered to be nothing in Corinth, and with the inclusive we, he exalts them to a level which he has as apostle. Is that not the operation of Christ in his cross? Whereby he humbles himself to our level, he having the greatest gift He being the most gifted, He being the most exalted, and by that action in the cross, He elevates us to share in His Sonship.

    The manner, the method of Paul’s argumentation in itself is the preaching of Christ and the event of his cross. As Paul places himself as a prime example of the absurd folly to which some of the Corinthians have fallen prey, in this imitating Christ on his cross, but as well exalting all to the level of his own extraordinary gift, thus reproducing in his argumentation the glorious effect of Christ on the cross. So much is Paul bound up in Christ, so much does he find his life in Christ, that even his method of argumentation, his rhetorical method, preaches Christ.

    I hope you have been able to see that the Bible affects, even rejects, but always subordinates rhetoric to greater concerns. Actually, it co-ops rhetoric and transforms it into an extension of the biblically declared saving work of God, where the event of God’s accomplishment dominates all ideas about that event. The Bible, therefore, intends its presentation to bring the hearer into direct and spiritual contact with God’s saving act, whether the destruction of Jerusalem and its temple in the case of Jeremiah, or the tension of the already not yet of the kingdom in the case of Jesus, or the cross of Christ in the case of Paul. The message and the method in the Bible’s rhetoric are so intertwined that in the end, the method itself communicates the message. The world’s rhetoric, for all its artistry and scientific precision, in the end, by contrast, too often comes off only transparently contrived, but anemic, if not vacuous.

    And that’s it. Now we’re going to do a question and answer session now and we’re going to pass this around right now. Do you want to stop this and then start it up again? Okay, now we’re going to enter the question-answer section of the lecture series, The Bible and Rhetoric. Take one. Uh-oh, I see a hand.

    I think it’s got to be something more than just making us feel accepted. It seems like there’s an existential link there between Paul and Christ. I can see that between Paul and Christ, or the believer in Christ, but what about the believer in the other section of the text? I think one of the things that we should keep in mind is that the Scriptures are sufficient, and the intention of God is to make it plain to us that not only has he provided for us completely within the text, but he’s thought of everything. And so the pull which is affecting us is always toward the Word and into the Word, that we might see in the Word its treasures, its riches, and the way in which it opens up the greatness of God and the fact that He has thought of everything. So, the history of the world is in the Bible. the life of the Christian or the church to the end of the age is in the Bible. It’s there. It is the task of the church through her preachers and teachers to make that apparent to the congregants, the faithful, the community of faith, the body.

    And invariably we become confused and we become disoriented when that’s not as clear to us. Where we begin self-consciously to walk off in other directions. Now the crisis of our time is that now it is being accepted as an axiom both for liberalism and for evangelicalism generally.

    I might say that there is a qualitative difference between the now and the then. So you live in a completely different world. And the advances scientifically confirm that. Or the advances socially, in the minds of many politically, confirm that. We live in a qualitatively different world.

    And I just do not believe that that’s the Bible’s point of view. You have, for instance, volumes that are being produced now about preaching, for instance. You have Gray Donnis’ book, The Modern Preacher in the Ancient Text. which unfortunately is assuming that distinction between the then and the now. You have John Stott’s book, Between Two Worlds, and the two worlds he has in mind is the biblical world and the world of today, not this world and the next. So there are problems that have now intruded upon the church and its consciousness, which makes it increasingly difficult for the church to live in and from the text. In fact, Scripture becomes an appendage to life. It becomes a volume for proof texts. It’s not a place to dwell. It’s not a habitation. It becomes a place to go in order to get various texts to prop yourself up or to apply. I don’t… So, God wanted to do that. He gave us this truth that we are to be identified with the Scriptures and with the Word. Well, what about the corruption of man’s mind? I mean, unless he gives us a sufficient word, where are we going to turn? Well, I’ll turn to my own mind. That’s where I’ll turn. I’ll think it up on my own. Or, you know, I’ll just build on the the building blocks that God’s given me here, and I’ll be content with the structures and the forms that I come up with.

    Does not our doctrine of total depravity and the threat to us from our own sin drive us back to the Word and its sufficiency? I think he’s putting us in our place. I think that’s for sure. He’s trying to, you know, cut off all roads of escape. I mean, you’re going to stand at the Red Sea and you’re going to see the salvation of the Lord. And the only way for you to live is to go through that sea.

    Now you might say, you know, I’m being poetic, I’m being, you know, metaphorical, you know. How is this helpful for the day-to-day detail of life and all of the things that you face in your problems? And I’m telling you that the answer to those issues are found in the text and they don’t minimize your life presently at all. They maximize it. Because the effect of it is to, after you’ve lost your life, to the Word. You see, that’s a religious act. You’re actually giving up your life now to live in the text. You see what you’re doing? It is a religious act. It is an extension of the cross itself. See?

    If you sacrifice your life, and what’s the consequence of that? What’s the result of that? The result of that is that your life is given back to you. To what end? so that you can get the things that you lost when you gave the world up? No, that you might be a servant, self-consciously aware of your relationship to the world as you live in your present circumstance. You are given back to the world in service. For the sake of what? Well, for the sake of preserving the planet, right? No. For the sake of God Himself. You do it for God. That’s your motivation.

    One technical sense seems like often times in the gospel narrative Jesus presents some counter-arguments due to the Pharisees’ interpretation, you know, they’re always asking him things that he’s always saying something that he’s not saying. So, is Jesus a Galenicist in the classical sense? If he is, what does that do to your thesis? If he isn’t, then what’s his intention in confounding them, if it’s not, to persuade them?

    Well, I don’t know what rhetorical method or polemical method would be involved when he, you know, looks Nicodemus in the eyes and says, you know, you must be born again. What kind of an argument is that? That was exactly Nicodemus’ response. What kind of an argument is that? Doesn’t it become obvious that Jesus is operating on a completely different matrix?

    I mean, he is seeing heaven, he’s seeing God, he’s seeing everything clearly. And you’ve got people down here that want to debate, want to argue, want to be clever. We know that you’re a teacher come from God. We know. That’ll put him off his guard. Nicodemus comes as the sort of classical polemicist, doesn’t he? He wants to argue about this stuff. He’s not coming as the innocent inquirer. Don’t think that. That’s one of the ways in which he’s invariably interpreted. That’s what’s going on in John 3. I mean, he’s coming for the deliberate purpose of laying Jesus low, of besting Jesus in the argument. And he points out the absurdity of Jesus’ statement. You know, it’s ridiculous. How can a man be bored again? And for the second time in his mother’s womb? It’s quite humorous. should go through there.

    So, I mean, whether you’re saying that Jesus, of course, has mastered the polemical arts, He’s beyond them. And you see, He’s not talking about here an exchange of ideas. Well, of course, Nicodemus, you have an idea, I have an idea, and we’re going to have a nice discussion here, or a debate, or an argument about whose ideas are best. Jesus is going to declare to him the reality of which the Bible speaks, and the fact that now the rebirth of which he is speaking is available. It’s event-centered. You know, Van Til’s point is that the Jews of Jesus’ day have been Hellenized.

    They want to polemicize it in the sense of a classical rhetorical argument. Okay, let’s get into debate. We love it, don’t we? It’s just a way to make a living. And Jesus is not here fooling around with ideas. He is declaring to them the reality of God’s coming and the availability now of new birth. from above, from heaven. Impossibilities to a Hellenistic mind.

    It seems like your main point is more about a philosophy of history or of the nature of sociology in that it is historical, event-centered, than it is about rhetoric. Like, for instance, if you were dealing with liberalism, particularly, I think, radical liberalism, your focus is on the falsity of their philosophy of history. I thought more than any particular rhetorical philosophy or perspective. And so I was wondering if that’s the case and why you’re couching the, or why it’s called rhetoric and Bible as opposed to the Bible and history.

    Well, what I’m going to do, of course, is to subordinate language to history. And as far as I’m concerned, that’s irrefutable. I realize that there are those who are contending for an abstract consideration of language and logic in relationship to language structures. But to me, for me, that is a completely indefensible position, and that is a completely unbiblical position.

    The priority of history is established in Genesis 1.1, in the beginning. It’s a time statement. It’s a historical statement. Language for us, language as God communicates to his world, is placed in a time-space frame. It is an historical context. It can’t be avoided. You can’t get out of it. You can’t go anywhere to escape it. And to assert such stuff, in my judgment, is absurd, is nonsense.

    So if we’re going to talk about rhetoric in relationship to the Bible, it is going to be subordinated to the Gospel, to what is central to the Scriptures, the events of God’s activity. That’s why I couched it the way I did, that the Hellenistic world was confronted with Hebraic reality. Not Hebraic ideas, but Hebraic reality. Oh, I wish I could say that.

    I was asked, is there a theme that connects all these lectures together? And I said, No. The next two nights are similar in that they deal with Jay Dressen Nation and the history of somewhat of the OPC. But, you know, tonight, this is this is Yeah, this is this. We’re in and out on this one. Oh, oh, yeah. I mean, it’s Of course, you’re going to see the connections as we go through the three lectures. I mean, it’s going to be obvious. Yeah. Yes.

    But that still leaves a wide open matter of style, I guess you could call it. The modern equivalent of classical rhetoric is advertising of many forms. So we have biblical rhetoric or whatever you want to call it. overriding purpose or goal, like the proclamation of the gospel, and that’s going to give us some ethical bounds within which to work. But that doesn’t say anything about, you know, can we be sarcastic, or, well, as you were talking about, what Paul was doing. It seems like there’s still a wide field of questions about homiletics. That is central and that to me and I don’t think that we’ve done or that I’ve done a very good job of living in and from the proclamation itself so that in my demeanor, in my posture I become a means by which the message itself is communicated.

    The man becomes an extension of the message. You perceive the cross in him. You perceive Christ in him, as well as in the method and, of course, in the message. It’s the total thing. Such is the life in Christ that Paul is trying to advocate, and he says as much. You might recall in 2 Corinthians 2 and 3 where he’s taking on those who are.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Van Til and the Identity of the OPC

    Van Til and the Identity of the OPC

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered June 1, 1996.

    About this sermon

    Van Til’s personality shaped how startling his apologetic sounded to its first hearers, including in the dispute between Machen and Buzzwell over how to receive it. Dutch theologians gave Van Til his background, and he reworked what he drew from them. The OPC formed part of its identity by standing outside the American religious establishment.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    My original title for this lecture was Van Till, the Church in the 60s. That was until I found out that Van Till said nothing about the Beatles, LSD, and Timothy Leary. Actually, the title of the lecture is Cornelius Van Till and the identity of the OPC, and it will be an expansion on the article that recently appeared in New Horizons. The minutes of the 6th General Assembly of the OPC, 1939, included this entry.

    The vote for moderator of the assembly was taken. The tellers reported that the Reverend Cornelius Van Till, Ph.D., had received a majority. It appeared that Dr. Van Till had not been on the floor when he was nominated, and after election he requested that for definite reasons he be relieved of the office. The request was granted.

    Presumably, the definite reasons persisted throughout Dr. Van Til’s long life, since he, although regularly attending GAs, never did serve as moderator. In fact, I don’t believe that he was ever again nominated. Van Til was a brilliant man. He knew that he was not brilliant enough, however, to penetrate the mysteries of Robert’s Rules of Order, or to wield a gavel over an assembly of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

    But truly, this incident does provide us some insight into the personality of the man. He was a faithful churchman. He was regular in his worship attendance. He was also always present, but somewhat retiring in the courts of the church. He was important to assembly proceedings at certain points in his career, and we will be talking about some of these.

    But even here, he tended to remain in the background and influence more by reputation than by direct involvement in debate. At the same time, He was a very prominent figure in the beginning history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and played a major part in confirming the identity of the OPC as a distinctively Reformed and Catholic denomination. This lecture in the 60th anniversary year of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church However, unworthy of Dr. Van Til’s high standards and achievements is an effort to honor him and his service to Christ the King within the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

    On December 4th, 1936, about six months after the formation of what would come to be known as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, J. Oliver Buswell, president of Wheaton College, minister in the newly formed denomination, and member of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions, wrote J. Gresham Machen for the last time.

    Machen would die about a month later before he could finish a response. Always prompt in his correspondence, Machen had trouble with his reply to Buswell’s letter. A draft fragment of a reply, however, does survive and reveals Machen’s frustrations with Buswell. At least three things in Buswell’s letter disturbed him. First, Buswell constantly equivocated on Scofield dispensationalism. A month before, and in other correspondence at the same time, Manchin had not hesitated to identify Scofield dispensationalism as heresy.

    Secondly, Buswell had the audacity to suggest that Manchin’s recent ousting by him and others from the position of president in the Independent Board was in the spirit of democracy, since Machen and his followers at Westminster Seminary and in the newly formed denomination had become, quote, dictatorial, unquote.

    But thirdly, and most importantly for our purposes this afternoon, Boswell attacked the Westminster apologetic, as he called it, at the center of which was the figure of Cornelius Bentil. Buswell charged that the seminary was moving in a novel direction. He personally supported the historical apologetics and biblical exegesis of such scholars as James Orr, Robert Dick Wilson, and Machen himself, as evidenced in Machen’s works the origin of Paul’s religion and the virgin birth. But now the seminary was promoting a philosophical apologetic that was dangerous and wrong because it weakened the critical capabilities of the students and compromised their practical usefulness. For Buswell, the Westminster apologetic was, quote, substance-less theorizing, unquote.

    Where Machen stood on Van Til’s apologetical position continues to be debated. The late Greg Bonson has argued forcefully that Van Til and Machen’s apologetics were, after all, and in the end, quite compatible, if not somewhat the same. But this position, in my own estimation, can be successfully maintained only by ignoring Machen’s continued reliance upon a traditional formulation of the proofs for God’s existence and his continued commitment to a natural theology. Even into the last year of his life, Machen invoked the classical Princeton method, as is shown by his radio talk, How May God Be Known? included in the book The Christian Faith in the Modern World. Where Dr. Bonson has tried to bring Machen and Van Til together on the apologetics question, Alan McRae has endeavored to keep them apart.

    According to McRae, Machen privately scoffed at, privately laughed at, Van Til’s position. Whether Machen did so privately, it would seem only McRae can say. However, such a private attitude hardly squares with Machen’s public behavior. Van Til himself recalled his two-day train ride with Machen. Going to and returning from Chicago, Van Til, as he recalled, carefully explained to Machen his approach. Later, Van Til confessed that he didn’t know how much Machen had picked up.

    The conversation was quite technical. Still, as much as Machen failed to grasp, and as much as he personally continued in the apologetic position in which he had been schooled, he was publicly committed to Van Til. I believe there were at least two reasons for this. The first, to put it quite bluntly, was political. Machen was very much concerned that Westminster Seminary present a united front before a watching world. He knew this much.

    In Van Til he had a man as fiercely loyal to Westminster Seminary and the movement of which it was a part as he was himself. Furthermore, in Van Till, he had someone without traditional American Presbyterian attachments, who, when things got rough, would not always be looking over his shoulder. Here was someone, in other words, Machen could count on. The mention of Van Till’s distance from traditional American Presbyterian attachments introduces the second reason for Machen’s public commitment to Van Till. You see, Machen found himself undergoing a re-education in the latter years of his life. This re-education began formally in 1929 with the organization of Westminster Seminary, in which Machen found himself soon the student to the faculty he had assembled. Machen’s orthodoxy had not left him immovable.

    A very, very important point. He was a man open to persuasion. He was not intractable as his enemies contended. Here was a man in his latter years in transition, moving from a sort of provincialism attached to the American Presbyterian scene to the Catholic positions of a more articulate, more thoroughly alert confessional Calvinism. In other words, under the tutelage of the faculty at Westminster, Machen was learning that being reformed meant more than he had dreamt. This re-education for Machen was theological in the deepest sense.

    Prior to 1929, for instance, we find very few references to the distinctive reformed doctrines. Only general references to the reformed faith and, yes, reference to Presbyterianism But it seems as if the idea of Presbyterianism is as elevated as the reality itself. After 1929, specifics begin to surface about the covenant, predestination, limited atonement, eschatology, the active obedience of Christ, and even the subject of the Church itself. In fact, Machen begins to speak about the distinctive content of the whole of the Reformed Lossach.

    According to Oswald T. Alice, a member of that faculty at Westminster, Machen’s interaction with and response to dispensationalism took place in the last years of his life. It was as if, said Alice, He were learning about dispensationalism for the very first time.

    The most difficult area in Machen’s re-education, to be sure, was apologetics. For Van Til was certainly no quick study. Given Machen’s reticence to speak on issues in which he lacked competence, he did not express himself in Van Til’s terms. At the same time, he remained publicly committed to the man, and yes, open to his method. But such commitment and openness would cost Nachen greatly.

    Not with liberals in the PCUSA, who could have cared less about increasingly rigorous Calvinist direction of Machen or anyone else, but with the fundamentalists who had attached themselves to Machen and were a part of the movement that brought about the new church.

    The fundamentalists in the OPC in those early days were typically Americans before they were Calvinists or Presbyterians. They hailed from that branch of early 20th century Christianity that, despite all of its pre-millennial pessimism about the world, was actually bully on America.

    Fundamentalism connected its evangelistic and moral zeal to patriotic ardor. It championed American individualism and democracy, and opposed big government and socialism. Fundamentalists have little difficulty blending their energetic evangelistic enterprising with the commercialism of their day. George Marsden’s comparison between Carl MacIntyre’s brand of fundamentalism and the sales division of a modern corporation is very telling. Much more telling, I think, than George intended. But further, The OP fundamentalists, like fundamentalists generally, generated a strong protectionist spirit, highly suspicious of and downright hostile to foreign influences.

    H. McAllister Griffiths, for instance, one time confidant of Machen, who because of his fundamentalist convictions turned on Machen charged that those who dominated Westminster Seminary and the OPC, quote, were not of American Presbyterian background, unquote. He had in mind John Murray, who was from Scotland, and also Professors R. B. Kuyper, Ned B. Stonehouse, and Cornelius Van Till, whom he identified as of, quote, Holland Dutch extraction.

    It’s really bad. Alan McRae, another fundamentalist of the OPC, would give as his reason for resigning from the faculty at Westminster Seminary in April 1937, the fact that the seminary had come under the control of, quote, a small alien group without American Presbyterian background, unquote.

    Later, he indicated he meant no offense to Murray. Only the Dutchman. And among the Dutchman, he singled out Van Til and said, the effect of Van Til’s teaching upon the students had more to do with my resignation from the seminary than anything else. From McCrae’s perspective, Van Til’s apologetic was as alien as the man himself. Both were pushing the church and the seminary in directions foreign to the American fundamentalist vision. The battle between the fundamentalists and the confessionally reformed aliens came to a head at the Third General Assembly in June 1937.

    The issue on the table, or rather the issues on the table, were the future of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions and Temperance. The Fundamentalists favored continued support of the Independent Board. The Aliens favored a denominational committee on missions. The fundamentalists favored abstinence from alcoholic beverages. The aliens favored liberty of conscience, where the Bible itself did not prescribe. While the aliens won on both of these counts, the real victory was for a more Catholic, more theologically aware, more Calvinistic identity for the OPC.

    Fourteen ministers and three elders subsequently withdrew from the Church and in the next year helped to organize the Bible Presbyterian Synod. But it was becoming apparent that fundamentalism would not define the new church. But this being true, a very startling thought suggests itself. Although The OPC had advertised itself as the continuation of the Old Church, the mainline PCUSA, and although Machen had used this very line of argument, it now appeared that the OPC was not a continuation. The fundamentalists, who were at one time comfortable in the Old Church, were not comfortable at all in the New. This thought would go even deeper, for the new church would prove to be at odds with the old church in a far more significant sense than is ordinarily recognized. Here, after the loss of Machen, the figure increasingly taking center stage in the consciousness of the church was Van Til. Bantill has been rightly known for his impact in the area of Christian apologetics. His apologetic is startling in many ways. I will cite three.

    First, he did not see the task of apologetics as that of establishing the validity of first principles upon the basis of neutral reason and in the interest of a natural theology. as had been the classical position expressed at Old Princeton and, by and large, in the old church. For Van Til, apologetics was the defense of the faith, not the defense of the possibility of believing this, that, or something else. Apologetics presupposes, then, the truth of the biblical revelation about the ontological Trinity, and about the Bible’s own self-confessed center, the self-attesting cross.

    This means that Van Til’s apologetic is essentially redemptive historical in character. As Van Til was to say, Quote, logic and fact have meaning only in terms of the Christian story, unquote. That is the story of salvation found in the Bible. But further and secondly, the faith which Van Til sought to defend was that of the Reformed church as expressed in the Reformed creeds. Therefore, Van Til’s apologetic was self-consciously ecclesiastical.

    This leads into his understanding of the separateness of the Church. But along these lines, his apologetic was also decidedly and militantly antithetical. Van Til would speak of this antithetical and militant posture in a letter to a friend late in his career. being quite critical of a speaker he had recently heard, he wrote, there was very little of Augustine’s picture of the struggle between the city of God and the city of man, there was little of Kuiper’s idea of the antithesis between regenerate and non-regenerate mankind, and there was nothing of Machen, who wanted to put the flag on the top of the highest peak and do it, if necessary, alone. That captures it. But thirdly, Van Til’s apologetic had a deliberate philosophical interest, and this because he was very much aware of and understood the deep undercurrents of theological discussion.

    Particularly, he recognized in mainline Protestantism and the old mainline Presbyterian Church, the streams of philosophical thought in variance with the genius of biblical religion. Especially, he recognized the streams of Enlightenment thought. In fact, these streams were no quiet tributaries. Instead, they had become a raging flood.

    Historian Henry Steele Cominger has confirmed Van Til’s position on American society in general. That society was, from the 18th century, thoroughly informed by the Enlightenment ideal. Mark Noll has confirmed Van Til’s position with respect to American Presbyterianism with his analysis of John Witherspoon. And the way in which Witherspoon, while using the common sense philosophy of the Scottish realists, also promoted, however unwittingly, the Enlightenment’s ideal. The end result was a gentleman’s Presbyterianism.

    Combining a church religion that retained the language of salvation by the triune God of the Bible, and a public civil religion that had no room for the Trinitarian declarations and confessions of the Church whatsoever. The difficulty for a Church population still holding to the salvific religion of Scriptures would be the situation in which the Church’s religion became more like the public civil religion. more like religion in keeping with the Enlightenment ideal. What happens, for instance, when mainline Presbyterians, who have banked on the alliance of church religion and civil religion, in the interest of the common cultural vision of the establishment, find the alliance broken, and the generic, naturalistic, non-Trinitarian, anti-Salvific religion of the public square now the religion of the pulpit.

    What do Presbyterians do when they discover the establishmentarian and cultural positioning that has historically defined them as Presbyterians demands that they now surrender the gospel? Do they hold on to their precious establishmentarian Presbyterianism and let the gospel go? Or do they, like Machen and others with him, hold to that gospel and let goods and kindred go, even though they find themselves not only outside of the establishmentarian church, but outside of the establishment altogether? You see, when Machen was defrocked, he was disenfranchised from the Presbyterian establishment. And when he was disenfranchised, the movement identified with him was as well.

    But this very painful experience actually becomes the opportunity for the reassessment of Presbyterianism. The OPC, therefore, is not simply the continuation of the old established Presbyterian Church beholden to a deadly alliance with the Enlightenment ideal or the primacy of the intellect. much less the national and cultural credentials held dear by fundamentalists. Something of the pilgrim identity of Christ’s true church has intruded upon this denomination, as she, for the sake of her true reward, God himself, is being prepared to lose everything for him.

    Here is the crucial issue in the question about OPC identity. For the OPC, the place within the establishment has been lost. The one time defining tie to American culture, inherent to American Presbyterianism itself, has been severed. And it is this fact as much as anything else, namely the fact that the OPC is a Presbyterian anomaly, and she has no cultural bridge, no establishment, dependence, or aspiration that defines her.

    Van Til’s identity as an alien he being of Holland-Dutch extraction, and his philosophical apologetic would speak effectively to and for the new church. His message about the antithetical nature of the faith was ready-made for the church’s stand in the world. But his message also helps the church appreciate why she cannot be a mere continuation of the old church. For the old church, even at its best, was critically flawed, and he pointed that out time and again in his writings.

    It would not do, therefore, to long to return to the establishmentarianism of the American Presbyterian model. But the great struggle for OPC identity, in which the figure of Van Til would play such an important part, was not the battle with Presbyterian fundamentalism in the 30s, but with the growing New Evangelicalism and a residual Presbyterian elitism in the 40s.

    This struggle played itself out in two episodes. The first involved the Committee of Nine, erected by the Eighth General Assembly in 1941. The purpose of this committee was, quote, to study the relationship of the OPC to society and to other ecclesiastical bodies, unquote, in order to make recommendations about how the OP might, quote, meet the needs of this generation, and have an increasing area of influence and make a greater impact on life today.” The thriving force behind this committee was Edwin H. Ryan, a Presbyterian elitist, who although he wrote the fine book, The Presbyterian Conflict, dreamed of the OPC as a large Presbyterian body with the cultural clout of the PCUSA.

    The majority in the committee stood with Ryan, two dissented, of whom one was Van Till. The minority feared the establishment out of this committee of a permanent bureaucratic fixture that would dominate the church’s future. But more importantly, it feared the loss of the vigorous proclamation of the OPC’s distinctive faith. The minority sensed that the Committee would be the means to return to the lost Presbyterian heritage, a move which, under the leadership of someone like Ryan, spelled disaster. The Assembly was persuaded by the minority, and the Committee was dissolved.

    But this defeat signaled for Ryan a breach between him and many in the denomination, including many at Westminster Seminary, where he served as President of the Board of Trustees. Things came to a head when he and some at Westminster, such as Van Til, became involved in the Christian University Project. Ryan thought this university should stand in the interests of the American cultural line. Van Til and others disagreed. Because of this disagreement and the suspicion that Ryan, as General Secretary of the University Association, had misused funds, the Association removed Ryan from office in the fall of 1946.

    And upon being informed that the Presbytery of Philadelphia was preparing to move against him, judicially, he withdrew from the OPC. Later he returned to the PCUSA claiming that he had re-read the fourth book of Calvin’s Institutes and had become convinced that Nathan and the OPC had been schismatic all along. In actual fact, Ryan was merely returning to the cultural identity of the church that he had never really left.

    The second episode the struggle during the 40s in which the figure of Van Til was so important involved those who were of a more evangelical point of view. The rise of the broad and modern evangelical movement is a study in itself. But let me mention a few of its features. First, It has redefined the word evangelical, so that it no longer carries the sense it had for Luther and for Calvin. The Reformers used the word evangelical to describe the Church. The modern evangelical uses it to describe personal commitments. that have as much to do with devotion to the autonomy of the individual conscience and voluntarism as they do to any distinctive Christian doctrine. It is not without reason, therefore, that Van Til saw evangelicalism as inherently Arminian. Secondly, modern evangelicalism has tended to be dominated by personality cults and the parachurch.

    As a result, the visible church has been pushed into the background. In fact, the visible church, in order to justify itself, must be redefined as an evangelical institution, no longer unique and offering an absolute obligation, The visible church sits at the level of other evangelical institutions, forced to compete for the believer’s interests and money. Thirdly, modern evangelicalism aspires to cultural parity, the position of an equal.

    It aspires to acceptance. It is not schizophrenic about the culture as are the fundamentalists. It is not controlled by the aristocratic notion of privilege, as was Ryan. It craves acceptance. Ralph Reed, executive director of the Christian Coalition, recently spoke about his organization having arrived at the apex of evangelical aspiration.

    We now have, he said, what we have always wanted, a place at the table. Paul Woolley spoke more to the point in assessing such an attitude. These people, said Woolley, like to read about themselves in the newspaper. Woolley made that statement in 1944 specifically addressing evangelical discontent within the OPC.

    Now, it would be unfair to say that those who in the 1940s represented the evangelical cause in the OPC lacked Reformed convictions and specific commitments to a Reformed understanding of the Church. At the same time, they had been influenced by the broad and rapidly developing evangelical movement at many points. What they perceived as OPC isolation and even contrariness provided opportunity for certain features of evangelical thinking to dominate their minds.

    As you probably know, the struggle in the 40s between the evangelical mind and orthodox Presbyterianism centered on the theological positions of Gordon Clark and Cornelius Van Till. The theological issues are treated in many places, including in fighting the good fight. I do not mean to reduce in any way the magnitude and the importance of those theological issues. However, my purpose here is to draw your attention to the wide cultural and ecclesiastical dynamics.

    In a certain sense, both Van Til and Clark were front men. for the groups that lined up behind their positions and personalities. The Van Til group, whether consciously or not, pursued a course in line with OPC disenfranchisement and the antithetical posture of a rigorous Calvinism.

    Those lining up behind Clark were much more of the mind of Ryan’s failed Committee of Nine, but not for elitist reasons. Instead, for evangelical reasons. Specifically, behind Clark stood a group devoted to a, quote, program for action, unquote, that would move the OPC into alliance with fundamentalists and evangelicals for greater impact upon American society. Once more, as in the earlier debate with the fundamentalists, the cry went up that the OPC was under the thumb of men from, quote, other lands, unquote. Men without American evangelical Presbyterian background or roots.

    This second episode in which the figure of Van Till was so prominent came to a head at the 14th General Assembly in 1947. The Clark party determined to make an effort to gain control of the denomination’s foreign missions committee. After extensive discussion and debate, the Clark party lost in their quest by the margin of one vote. The effect of that loss was much greater than the margin in the vote. Before the next assembly, Clark and many who stood behind him had left the church many of these individuals for enculturated Presbyterian bodies.

    As sad as these departures were, and as devastating as was their effect, the OPC, not irrespective of the figure of Cornelius Van Till, was confirmed and furthered in its identity as a Presbyterian anomaly, resistant to efforts that pushed it back into the American mainstream or endeavored to make it an extension of American Presbyterian provincialism.

    Instead, because of the influence of Van Til and others, the OPC was moved in Catholic and more rigorously more insistent reformed directions. This is not to say that Van Til triumphed in every respect in the OPC. His commitment to Kuiper’s program for the reformation of culture would not win the day. The OPC’s antithetical posture has proved itself no more comfortable with the ethnic Dutch perspective of neo-Calvinism than the ethnic American perspectives from which it had distanced itself.

    But where then does this leave the Orthodox Presbyterian Church? If it stands in some regard beyond its American environment, and even beyond Van Till in the full analysis of his perspective, where then does the OPC stand? Could it be that the OPC stands in an alien and disestablished position, furthered by Nathan’s experience and Van Til’s articulately antithetical theology in the interest of the identity of God’s true church as a pilgrim people without nationalist or ethnic portfolio? Could it be that the OPC, by her existence, stands as a very helpful reminder that Christ’s Church is stamped with an essential and proper other-worldliness?

    She is to exhibit a heavenly-mindedness that does not seek to regain the world that has been forsaken, but rather seeks how to be of service to the Lord in that world until the Lord returns. Indeed, the true Church of Jesus Christ must always confess, here have we no continuing city, but we seek one to come. Our citizenship is in heaven, is it not? Our life is hid with Christ. in God.

    I answered all the questions. Yes. So that’s what she said. She talked about the possibility that Chertab, if any, would have ultimately gone to the plaintiff. And secondly, what was contemplated in Chertab, who is a member of something I later proved to be true, was that she was involved in a joint project with the EPA. Yes, the question is with regard to responsibility that Christians have to society and to culture and within the society and culture as a whole. Is that the scope of the question?

    That is that we can never abandon our identity as citizens of heaven as we are in this world. We take that with us. That is who we are. And therefore our lives are the implementing of that heavenly perspective at heavenly life. If I could put it like this, by our union with Christ, we are exalted into the heavens, and we participate in his life in glory. But having been joined to him by faith, we see the one who bears the wound marks of his own humiliation, and we likewise therefore make ourselves as it were of no reputation, and we choose service in the world in imitation to our Savior, in imitation of our Savior, even being given over to conformity, such conformity that may lead us to death.

    That is the agenda. You start there. You must start with what has been given you already by grace. What has been given you is heaven. You are now living out of that reality. To do anything else is to allow works to intrude. And that is what is happening. Under the banner of being relevant, we are witnessing the triumph of moralism.

    So whatever the answer to the question is, it must start from that biblical point of view. I dare say that the life of the church looks like the life of Jesus. And that’s what the Gospels are about. The Gospels are not written just simply to give us biographies of Jesus. They are written to give us the life of the church in the life of the Savior. That’s what it means to be covenantal in your approach to the Gospels. So if you want to know how to live, Look to Jesus. Let me press that question a little further.

    Does there remain a cultural mandate for Christians? Do Christians have any task in politics? You pointed out that the OPC has rejected the sort of Hyperionism of Vance Hill. What would you say about Christians’ obligations in politics, in the arts, in science, and so on?

    That all is going to have to rise exegetically. It’s all going to have to rise out of Scripture. Do we believe the Bible is sufficient or don’t we? Is the answer in Scripture or is it not? If it is, then it behooves us to to ferret that out, to see it in scripture.

    Where might we look with regard to the question of the Christian in politics? It seems to me that in an alien environment, one of the places you might look is to the exile and how believers and God functioned within that situation. It seems to me that if you’re thinking about Christians in politics, you might do well to consider Theophilus. The title that he bears is most excellent. very suggestive of office, privilege within the society. What is the nature of Luke’s address to Theophilus, both in the Gospel and the Book of Acts?

    It’s going to arise out of that. And I contend that it will be there that you will find the implementation of the heavenly point of view. The alien character, the stranger character of the people of God It doesn’t exclude the people of God from pursuing political tasks, political position, political responsibility. But they must go into that with this eschatological self-consciousness, or this epistemological self-consciousness, never forgetting who they are, never being deluded as to what this is all about.

    Is it really the improvement of society, the betterment of the world? We might all live longer. These are nice advantages, but is that the true perspective of the gospel? The better life? Lawrence? I have a question. Can you tell me your destination? Is that still a priority? The question is whether or not the perspective of Van Til is, or of course, his contribution to OP identity is being kept alive or whether it is diminishing. I don’t know how to answer that question. I will say this. There is something strange about the OPC. That’s why I call the OPC a Presbyterian anomaly. There is something strange and peculiar about this church. And I think it’s as strange and peculiar as Nathan’s own pilgrimage.

    I really don’t believe that Machen would choose the route of disenfranchisement. He’s forced to it. That’s merely to say that God is at work in history. He forces us to conclusions that we wouldn’t choose. I think the women at the end of the Gospel of Mark are going to be forced to conclusions that they don’t arrive at on their own. History itself is forcing us in directions we wouldn’t choose. In other words, it’s not our ideas that control history. It’s not because I make a decision that we end up going in this direction. It’s because I have such fine theology. And I’m so true to it. I’m such a stalwart for the reformed faith.

    That’s not why history is moving the direction it is. That’s not why we’re here today. It’s because God has overcome our pretentiousness and our own self-importance, the estimations that we have of our own value, and he pulls us where we don’t want to go. He does that at the end of John’s Gospel too. The figure is Peter. He’s not going to want to be crucified or die in a death honoring to me, but that’s how it’s going to work out. So as I say about the OPC, we are a strange, peculiar people, and we are an anomaly. And we are being forced in directions that we don’t choose. We voted ourselves out of existence twice.

    Consider that, gentlemen. Consider that. So, with regard to the influence of Dan Till, Dan Till is himself being sanctified by this history, as we all are, and it is the history of Christ that is at work in us, pulling us on to glory and our conformity to Him. We don’t worship nature, we don’t worship Dan Till. They would be the first to tell us that. So if there is an ongoing impact of Van Til, I judge in this peculiar church to this point in our history that it’s going to be in ways that maybe Van Til would not have chosen.

    Nor would we ourselves. And maybe even in ways we don’t even recognize. Our isolation, for instance. Is it choice? Or is it providence? Well… Any other questions? You can see if you ask me a question, I get wound up, so you probably don’t want to ask any more. The front row down here is getting worried. Yes, key frame?

    The New Testament of American politics. I find it very good that the American people, in the form of Christian and the whole faith, American culture, the way it was developed before, it was such a wonderful, wonderful and beautiful country. War and The question is to what degree do we see the OPC actually living out a countercultural position?

    And I think we fight against that at every point. Again, it doesn’t seem to be our choice, naturally. We’re driven into corners. We’re forced to make decisions. And our identity is confirmed upon us. Our meaning becomes more our existence than our self-understanding. So yes, I think that the struggle with American culture and our identity in it continues to be an ongoing battle. But to this point, I’m confident of the Lord’s leading of this denomination. That’s it. So on behalf of the committee of historians, we are thankful that you attended.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • History of the OPC III: Confirmation

    History of the OPC III: Confirmation

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered January 1, 1996.

    About this sermon

    Colossians 3:1-2’s call to set the mind on things above governs the OPC’s forced name change in 1939, when the new denomination called itself ‘Orthodox’ in place of simply American. Dropping ‘in America’ from its name confessed which city the church belongs to. God’s own sovereignty confirmed that choice, more than the denomination’s survival did.

    More sermons from Colossians · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    This is the third lecture to the title, Here We Have No Continuing City, the Meaning of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. The first lecture was entitled Prelude, the Second Meaning, and this third lecture is entitled Confirmation. As we begin, I would like to read from Colossians chapter three. verses one and two. If ye then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above, where Christ sitteth on the right hand of God. Set your affection on things above, not on things on the earth.

    On June 27, 1938, The Court of Common Pleas No. 5 of the City of Philadelphia issued its final decree in the case of the Presbyterian Church USA’s suit against the small, struggling church of about 4,000 members, the Presbyterian Church of America. by this decree was therefore forbidden use of its name, the Presbyterian Church of America, because the court agreed with the suit of the larger parent body that the name of this newly organized church was much too close to the name Presbyterian Church in the United States of America and could be used to mislead the public, particularly in matters of contributions. When the small denomination organized just two brief years previously realized the costs involved in its appeal of this decision, and the slim hopes of winning its case, it moved to abandon the appeal process. So on February 9, 1939, a special General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of America convened at Westminster Seminary in Philadelphia for the purpose of choosing a new name. The Presbytery of Ohio had forwarded an overture, and that overture recommended that the name of the Presbyterian Church of America be changed to the Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America.

    The story goes that the motivation for this proposed name came from two sources. The first source was Machen himself. Before his death, and even before the organization of the Presbyterian Church of America, Machen had written a strong editorial for the Presbyterian Guardian. In that editorial, he considered a number of options that might describe his own position.

    He rejected the term fundamentalist. because he saw himself and those who stood with him belonging to, quote, the great current of the Church’s life, the great tradition that comes down through Augustine and Calvin to the Westminster Confession of Faith, unquote.

    The term fundamentalist was for Machen much too novel and vague to describe him. Machen was not committed to a few fundamentals of the faith. Rather, he was committed to the full-orbed expression of the Reformed faith. But if the term fundamentalist would work for Machen, what about the term conservative? He was a good term, it would seem. something that might even enable Machen and those who stood with him to attach themselves to a general movement in the culture and within society. But here, Machen reacted to what he considered the coldness and intractability of the term. Conservatives often hold to something Machen said, just because it is old. Machen did not find the term conservative useful in describing his position. But if fundamentalist and conservative were out, what about the word evangelical?

    Certainly here is a term that Machen would resonate to. But this term also was judged to be inadequate, because in Machen’s estimation it wasn’t distinctive enough. To merely call someone evangelical didn’t attach that individual specifically to the doctrines of Presbyterianism as they were expounded in the Westminster Standards. The term was just too liquid. It was too inexact.

    So Machen came, finally, to the term orthodox. That term means right or straight thinking. And for Machen, it positively suggested the standard of God’s word as a plumb line for the faith. Right or straight thinking, with respect to what?” Machen would ask. Well, of course, with respect to the word of God. Machen wanted to be known, therefore, as orthodox in his Presbyterianism. Now, Everett C. Develde, Sr., pastor of Trinity Church in Cincinnati, Ohio, was greatly taken with Machen’s editorial and essay.

    And he pressed the case for the name Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America within his own presbytery. But now we come to the second influence upon the decision for this name. Formation’s editorial was not the only influence upon de Velde. Here we have before us, then, that second motivation for the name, Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America.

    It seems that de Velde had among the members of his church in Cincinnati, the Shillito to a department store fortune centered in that city. These wealthy ladies had taken a liking to the name Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America, and had promised substantial funds to the denomination if their preference was honored. The prospect of these monies for missions and other enterprises during the early days of the denomination, and in the midst of the lean depression years, together with an understandable desire on the part of this pastor, Mr. de Velde, to please such generous women, shall we say, to keep them happy. is reason enough to be gracious to Mr. de Velde in overlooking whatever weakness he showed in the situation. In the end, I’m sure that de Velde personally formed his justification for the name by an appeal to Machen’s editorial, not to the Some time during the mid-afternoon on the 9th of February, 1939, the Fifth General Assembly received into nomination names for the renaming of the Church.

    Eleven names were proposed, to which another was added before the balloting was concluded, making a total of twelve. a number symbolic in its own right. Among the names suggested were the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, the American Presbyterian Church, the Presbyterian Church of Christ, a name supported by the Presbytery of California, I might add, which, because of the time of year and the distance to the assembly, had no one present to vote for it. Another name suggested was the Seceding Presbyterian Church of America. You might note that the acronym for this church is the SPCA, and my personal favorite, the True Presbyterian Church of the World. Of course, among the proposals was the name the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. On the fifth ballot, this name prevailed over the name Protestant Presbyterian Church, and so the Assembly declared that as of March 15, 1939, the Church formerly known as the Presbyterian Church of America would now be known as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. The choice of the word Orthodox to describe our Church, the choice of that word to be included in our title carries a powerful message.

    Not only was this Church bound in its name to the plumb line of Scripture reflected in the commitment of historic Presbyterianism, but with this name this Church was making it blatantly clear that it stood separate from unorthodox, or even better, heterodox Presbyterians. Such a stand set the OPC apart from two major movements that were very much operative within Presbyterianism at this time. One was evangelical Arminianism. Yes, there were Arminians in the Presbyterian church and within the Presbyterian movement generally.

    Within the Presbyterian churches during the last century, many biblically committed and sincere conservative Presbyterians had begun to chafe beneath what they judged the theological determinism of John Kelvin as expressed in the Westminster Standards.

    Needed was a more sympathetic interpretation of God’s eternal decree, of God’s eternal counsel, a more positive proclamation of God’s love for the lost. and that expressed indiscriminately. And also an unambiguous declaration that all children dying in infancy are safe. Very much at work in these convictions was commitment to the autonomy of human experience. and the unobstructed freedom of the individual will. One doctrine among the many in historic Calvinism that made these people squirm was the doctrine on the extent of the Atonement, Calvinism historically having affirmed that Christ had died for the elect only.

    The evangelical Arminians in the PCUSA, together with others about whom we shall speak momentarily, were able to engineer the 1903 revisions and additions to the Westminster Confession of Faith, as well as the 1906 reunion with the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, a church that had separated from the PCUSA in 1810, in part because the Cumberland Church rejected the doctrine of the limited atonement. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church was appropriately named in that it stood for full commitment to historic Presbyterianism and against the unorthodox positions of an evangelical Arminianism. The second major movement from which the OPC, as expressed in its name, stood apart was, of course, liberalism. The liberals were not just unorthodox Presbyterians, as were the evangelical Arminians. The liberals were heterodox, or more to the point, anti-Orthodox in their views. Liberalism was that system that absolutized the modern situation from the perspective of naturalism.

    It read every age in terms of itself. It reinterpreted the gospel in keeping with the spirit of the scientific worldview. The supernaturalism of the Bible, therefore, was judged symbolic at best, and Christianity was transformed into a religion of morality. But now, with the redemptive and even supernatural message of the Bible removed, The most positive biblical figures were then called upon to aid in the development of the most sublime ethical religion. Not even Jesus is excluded at this point. He himself is revalued along these lines. Jesus, therefore, is a moral example. He is a sublime moral example. And by the force of that moral example, we are encouraged along the lines which he pursued. This, for the betterment of society, the betterment of the world.

    For Machen, such a position was no variation on Christianity, but an entirely different religion. But most frustrating for Machen was the way in which liberalism hid behind the pillar of Christianity and used orthodoxy’s vocabulary. Interestingly, on December 30, 1923, the Sunday after the drafting of the Auburn Affirmation in upstate New York, Machen preached a very bold sermon at the First Presbyterian Church in Princeton. That sermon was entitled, The Issue in the Church. As if he had been a spy at the Auburn meeting, Machen mocked the liberals’ use of double-talk. The point was that the liberal was accustomed to use Orthodox language in the interests of an anti-Orthodox religion.

    Machen cited as an example the doctrine of Christ’s bodily resurrection, a doctrine to which the liberal could not subscribe in all honesty. In an imaginary exchange, Machen went on, but to then deny an article in the Apostles’ Oh no, replied the liberal, I accept the Apostles’ Creed and recite it religiously, week by week. I accept the article, the third day he rose again from the dead, but I reserve the right to interpret that article in a way consistent with the times in which we live. Therefore, I reserve the right to interpret this article in the Creed to mean the third day he did not rise again from the dead. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church, building on the legacy of Machen and his hostility to anti-Orthodox liberalism, this, our Church by its name, has declared its perpetual hostility against such views.

    But something else should be noted about the name of our denomination, and the process by which it came to be adopted. Maybe you noticed it. Actually, the name Orthodox Presbyterian Church was not the name proposed in the Vivaldi overture from the Presbytery of Ohio. His proposal was for the name the Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America. The geographical reference of America, something that De Veldi’s proposal shared with the original name of our denomination, somewhere along the line from overture to the floor of the assembly was dropped.

    Although the excuse could be made that the loss of the geographical reference would be advantageous, and therefore practically useful in developing contacts and even churches beyond regional borders, Still at the same time, the loss of the geographical reference has far more significance, for it is symbolic of the great shift in our culture that has now been formalized in the organization of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

    In order to understand this, it is helpful to think once more about nature. You see, when Machen was defrocked by the Presbyterian Church USA, early June 1936, he was not only, in effect, booted out of the Church, but also out of the culture of which that Church was an integral part.

    Presbyterianism and this nation, historically, belong together. They move together. was almost as if they were moving to the beat of the same drum. The Presbyterian Church USA, as Presbyterianism generally, was establishmentarian by nature. But now, with Nathan’s disenfranchisement, the church that organized from his efforts bore the stamp of Baptist enfranchisement. It was marked as surely as Machen was himself. As such, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church is a Presbyterian anomaly. That is, she is an expression of Presbyterianism that just simply does not fit the ordinary mold. Presbyterians have tended to be defined in terms of national identity. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church is not identified in terms of its national context.

    To be very frank about it, we are not an American Church. Now, please understand me at this point. This does not mean that we are an un-American or anti-American church. It is just to say that in a very real and existential way, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church could not be defined by her tie to American culture or by some aspiration for a position within the American mainstream.

    In the providence of God, the severance from an American identity becomes for us the opportunity anew to be the pilgrim people of God, a people whose mind is well directed to our true commonwealth. Our citizenship is in heaven. Philippians 3.20. It will be as citizens by grace of the higher commonwealth that we labor to be good citizens of the lesser. And most definitely, I might add at this point, not vice versa.

    Because that would mean a triumph for a religion of works. A religion that has at the center of it labor and effort and work on behalf of the commonwealth of this creation. and in terms of the aspirations and hopes of that commonwealth, and that then displacing our identity in, by grace, that commonwealth above. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church is a reminder to us, then, of the full sufficiency grace of God, by which we have been translated out of the kingdom of darkness into the kingdom of Christ’s own domain. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church has been born out of a great travail of culture, therefore. All Western society, and now with the twentieth century, all American society, has been undergoing a tremendous cataclysm. Taking shape has been a culture of unbelief.

    Interestingly, in this regard, for writers like Fitzgerald and Hemingway, whom we’ve mentioned before, Even though they used biblical imagery in their titles—Fitzgerald in his book, this side of Paradise Hemingway, in his book The Sun Also Rises—neither God nor Christianity figure in any positive manner in their writings. By and large, God has been reduced to a swear word. Even when Fitzgerald later repented As indicated in his short story Babylon Revisited and in his novel Tender is the Night, belief in God is never revived. But that is not to say that while Fitzgerald’s godless repentance led him to an early grave, one aided and abetted by alcoholism, the positive use of biblical imagery did not itself revise.

    This is evidenced in the language of T.S. Eliot, the American-born but English-trained poet, the man who professed conversion at the end of the twenties and then began to write about his conversion experience and the perspectives that it brought to view. But more particularly for an American audience, the biblical imagery was revived in John Steinbeck, and most specifically in his 1939 novel, The Grapes of Wrath.

    Here, Steinbeck wrote about a new religion that preached belief in humanity and in humanity’s indomitable spirit to face any adverse situation. Humanity had within itself the answer to the problems it faced. It could rise above the devastation of the Depression years. It could survive, it would survive. Here was a new gospel.

    The obvious and great tragedy in all this is the Church which, in its efforts to address the great shift in the culture, actually capitulated to the culture. because it feared for its own relevance and continued viability. In the words of Jesus, it sought to save its life in this world.

    Sadly then, the established Church embraced cultural and American unbelief, and in its leadership essentially spit on the cardinal doctrines or the cardinal truths of the Christian religion. But later, when the cultural mood changed, and there became an obvious and openness to biblical imagery, the Church applauded the revival of this language and imagery in the interests of a new cultural religion—humanism. a religion that now came to expression in the social paternalism stretching from the New Deal to the Great Society. If there has been further movement in this cultural religion in our present situation, it has been in the direction of recognizing that all societies, not just American, all cultures, all habits, all peoples, all living things, the earth itself, are divine. And the conclusion of the established church is that for the language and images of scripture and of Christianity… to have any validity at all, they must be used in the interests of such commitments.

    Is it any wonder that we have witnessed in this century the eclipse, the loss of the heavenly city to the secular city? And in this situation, Christianity, if it is to be positively judged at all, is now viewed as the process of social and political action in keeping with a program of reconciliation such as is perceived according to liberal predilections within Jesus of Nazareth himself. But who is this Jesus of Nazareth? Certainly the citizens of the secular city cannot say, since they have already abandoned the historical reliability of the gospel records.

    The best they can do is to propose or project a Jesus consistent with their best efforts and aspirations for humanity. Lately we have been treated to the revolutionary Jesus, You know, the one who crusaded for the rights of Galileans against the powerful priestly temple system in Jerusalem. Or maybe our interest should be more in the ecological Jesus, the one who in his parables actually preached the religion of nature, possibly you didn’t know that. Or what about the PC Jesus, the politically correct Jesus? who is the champion of a first-century equality movement, the principles of which lead us to renounce all oppression of women, homosexuals, and other minority groups.

    It is obvious, is it not, that neither nation nor we of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church can proceed down these lines. Neither Machen nor we could begin with a position in which we allow culture, the culture, however subtly, however admirable in some regards that culture may be, to determine our relationship to the gospel. For this reason, by the marvelous and profound providence of God, Machen and we have been delivered from the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America. And for this reason, by the marvelous and profound providence of God, we must not be the Presbyterian Church or the Orthodox Presbyterian Church of America. Indeed, for this reason, by the marvelous and profound wisdom of God, we cannot be even the true Presbyterian Church of the world, because as part of the true biblical Church, we are not of this world, but of another world altogether.

    The Orthodox Presbyterian Church exists for the recovery of this truth in the consciousness of Christ’s Church. Our meaning and mission are intrinsically tied to the issue of the Church’s essential other-worldliness. This is confirmed even by what many would judge an indifferent thing—our name. It should now be apparent to us all that the meaning of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church is no simple matter.

    In fact, our meaning is not found in our own clear-headed pursuit of a particular idea, a thought in our brains. It is not found even in a well-worked-out philosophy and theological system in the mind of J. Gresham Machen. But at the same time, neither is our meaning found within our resilient wills. or the superiority of our moral character. It is not as if, by our appeal to some idea or to some strength in our wills or in our moral character, we have formed a church to our own liking and established, even created, the meaning of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. And I might add at this point that our meaning isn’t even found in our own perceptive self-analysis and understanding. Rather, it is found in that to which we are being pushed by the providence of God. History is what God does to us. events in keeping with God’s providence force us in directions that we would not choose for ourselves.

    Machen would not have chosen either the circumstances or the environment in which he departed from this world. He was brought to these in the providence of God. Machen would not even have chosen his own disenfranchisement, let alone the disenfranchisement of the Church that grew out of his efforts. The providence of God in history moves him in these directions.

    They are greater than the man, and more significant than him, but that providence, having moved also moved us, and continues to move us, away from a worldliness, away from an attachment to things here, so that we might live out of our appropriate attachment to and union with Christ and to glory. If ye then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above, where Christ sitteth on the right hand of God. Set your affection on things above, not on things on the earth, for ye are dead, and your life is hid with Christ in God. When Christ, who is our life, shall appear, then shall ye appear with him in glory. No. I will. Okay, Bob. Correct. Yes, that was the name that came to this. I have no idea how that happened. I thought that is the name that was proposed to the assembly. I had deleted the geographical reference.

    The other is different. The question of whether we’re in America or not. What do you do with the with the parallelism or at least seeming to me it is the scripture Pauline epistles are addressed to churches in Galatia, not in heaven. Yes, right. Where they live. Yes. Good point. Good point. In the reality of the life and the community and the culture and the bad things that are brought to them from that culture. Yeah. Yeah. Sure.

    And this church is also, but I think that I’m sorry, yes, OK, and he’s asking me to reflect on the fact that in Scripture we do have Paul speaking specifically to churches in particular locale, whether or not those would be considered the official names of the churches is a consideration and certainly by any.

    By any means, by which the apostle addresses those churches, he certainly is always setting before them their transcendent identity. The tragedy is, though, that the transcendent identity begins to be lost in the consciousness of American Presbyterianism.

    You can see it. I challenge anyone to go back and review the Westminster Standards out of the 17th century. These men had expressed in those standards the hope of heaven. That was the goal. But that consciousness is being lost, and as it is being lost, the expectations are very much being attached to the prospects of the nation. I think we all realize what happened in the last century as the Civil War was fought out. I mean, people were fighting this war in the interest of God’s will. And particularly in the north, they saw this as the mechanism by which God would bring the kingdom of God, the kingdom of God on Earth. This was going to be heaven on Earth. That’s why we don’t have the battle hymn of the Republic in the Trinity Hymnal. I think everybody realizes that, don’t they? Okay. Yes. Amen. Yes. See, there’s been a very some of you. Oh, I’m sorry. Yes. Would it.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • History of the OPC IV: Finale

    History of the OPC IV: Finale

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered January 1, 1996.

    About this sermon

    Christ’s own words to Pilate, ‘my kingdom is not of this world,’ frame the OPC’s own heavenly-mindedness as it entered the 1940s, still finding its identity against the old-school Presbyterian establishment. Geerhardus Vos’s own theology, unique and largely ignored in his lifetime, is read as the resource the young denomination did not yet know how much it needed. The series closes where it began: with a kingdom not measured by earthly success.

    More sermons from John · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    And as well, we thank you and praise you for his passive obedience as well. We thank you that because of his active and passive obedience, there is indeed hope, hope of heaven, hope of eternity, hope of being with you throughout all eternity, that the prayer of Christ indeed will in time be answered, that where he is, we might be, that we might share his glory. And we look forward to that time, and with John of old we would cry, even so, come quickly, Lord Jesus. But while time goes on, while that day that only you know and have sat is not yet, we would pray that as well we might, recognizing our position in Christ, seek to be the servants that you would have us to be. to this needy world in which you have placed us and called us. We pray in Jesus name. The text that I have chosen for the beginning of this presentation is John chapter 18 verse 36.

    Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight that I should not be delivered to the Jews. But now is my kingdom not from hence. This is the toughest lecture. I realize that the ranks have thinned a bit and I expect that in part that’s because a number of the people that have left realized that they couldn’t stay awake after lunch. So I will not be merciless. By that I mean By that I don’t mean I’ll be shorter. I don’t mean I’ll be shorter, but by that I mean if I see you nodding off, I will not point at you and say something.

    Now I concluded the last lecture with a provocative statement, and I realized that. I said the OPC exists for the purpose of recovering in the consciousness of Christ’s church the truth about the other world, and that the OPC’s meaning and mission are intrinsically tied to this issue. And I acknowledge that these statements have the potential of mystifying and even possibly angering some people. Therefore, in this final presentation, I want to fill out these statements a bit and then make some concluding remarks to you.

    But before I get into the substance of the lecture, let me make some comments about Orthodox Presbyterian Church distinctiveness. On the one hand, if she is as I have described her, the OPC is a distinctively Orthodox and Calvinistic Presbyterian body which has become what I have called a Presbyterian anomaly. whose very existence challenges the church-culture alliance that pervades the church’s self-understanding, not only in America, but typically throughout the world. So yes, there is a distinctiveness to the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. On the other hand, the OPC is not unique at all. when held up to the biblical definition of the church. Every church is to be defined by Hebrews 13 verse 14. Here we have no continuing city.

    The whole church is to be able to confess in the words of Philippians 3.20 that our citizenship is in heaven. And every Christian must follow the Savior who confessed the good confession before Pontius Pilate when he said, My kingdom is not of this world.

    Such heavenly mindedness as true Christianity has always acknowledged. does not ruin you for life in the world. Rather, as our God in glory knows, such heavenly mindedness provides the only appropriate and adequate place to stand to be of genuine service in the world. The Son of God, who came from heaven and returned to heaven, had heaven on his mind as he performed his ministry in the world. Obviously, Jesus Christ’s heavenly-mindedness did not ruin him for life in this world.

    His true Church must follow him. And it is my judgment that the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, by her existence, not necessarily by her self-understanding, by the providence and by the mercy of God, has been an eloquent and forceful encouragement for the Church of Jesus Christ as a whole to do just this. to live in keeping with the heavenly mindedness that is observed in Christ and prescribed in the Word.

    In December 1927, J. Gresham Machen said he could not agree with those Presbyterians who had no zeal to see the Presbyterian Church extended through the length and breadth of the world. Machen counted himself among those who hold the faith of the Presbyterian Church, the great Reformed faith that is set forth in the Westminster Confession, to be true. And holding it to be true, we hold that it is intended for the whole world. But what was the faith of the Presbyterian Church? The great Reformed faith set forth in the Westminster Confession.

    Caspar Whistler Hodge, Machen’s colleague at Princeton Theological Seminary and grandson to Charles Hodge, summarized for himself and also for Machen, I judge the Reformed faith, when he wrote these words. Here was that theology that teaches and upholds the majesty and sovereignty of Almighty God, the total inability of fallen man to save himself, and that the whole of salvation is to be ascribed to the power and grace of God. This is simply the pure and consistent form of evangelicalism, which says, with Paul, By grace have ye been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is God’s gift.” This generic Calvinism has been taught under the specific form of covenant theology, so richly developed in the Westminster Confession and grounded in the scripture statement, I will be your God and ye shall be my people. That from Casper Wister Hodge.

    But were there significant differences between this transient definition and what the Reformed faith for so many had become? And just as crucial, if not more so, Were there significant differences between this definition and what the Reformed faith ought to be? Was the Reformed faith here in the 20th century much in need of a retooling for the purpose of bringing out more clearly the essential features of its first impress? Such questions as these raise further questions.

    Was it possible, for instance, for some to grab hold of Hodge’s use of the word evangelical, I’m sure you noticed it, and massage that word in such a way so as to compromise the strength and distinctiveness of the Reformed faith? Was that possible? Is that conceivable? But further, was it possible that Hodge’s definition, as fine as it is, was not adequate and would have to be subjected to a radical reevaluation because of the nature of those events that were transpiring at the end of the last century, the beginning of this century, specifically as they focused upon the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America?

    And if such a re-evaluation was necessary, could the Hodges and the Machens of the Church remain the same in such a re-evaluation? Or would they themselves have to change in order to be true to the genius of the Reformed faith? These crucial questions would be answered in J. Gresham Machen during the remaining years of his life from 1927 to its conclusion. And they would also be answered by the history of that body that has been formed out of his efforts.

    To begin with, There were many problems in the conservative Presbyterianism represented by Princeton theological seminaries. Despite the strong stand for doctrine as such, despite the strong stand for the Westminster standards, Despite the high spiritual view of the Church promoted at Princeton, and the heavy emphasis upon Christian nurture and the ordinary means of grace, the Princeton theology and the so-called old-school Presbyterianism were not without their difficulties. The Princeton theology had an over-inflated view of the human intellect, and an undervalued view of history.

    In fact, that is what got Charles Hodge in trouble with the Mercerburg theology boys, with Philip Schaff and with John Nevin. As strange as it may sound, Charles Hodge got in over his head, and he was not able to maintain his course because it was shown in the arguments with the Mercersburg boys that he did not know his church history as he should.

    It is also true that the Princeton theology had been over-accommodating to the common-sense philosophy of the Scottish realists. I think we all are aware of that problem. The Princeton theology had been somewhat accommodating to certain theological innovations that rose out of the New England theology. Some people question as to whether Samuel Miller should have pursued peace with the New England theology at the point he did in 1817, for instance. Furthermore, as those trained at Westminster Seminary acknowledge, the Princeton theology had a faulty apologetic.

    He had a certain weakness for some forms of piety. Charles Hodge declared that all children dying in infancy were indisputably saved, taking exception to the Westminster standards. Moreover, despite Hodge’s dissent, the old school Presbyterians showed certain new-school habits of mind by allowing post-Civil War political pressures to override their theological convictions. And the stalwart B.B. Warfield contributed to the rise of modern evangelicalism by making the Reformed faith merely the most consistent expression of a broader evangelical theology, and by exalting the individual believer above the corporate character of the people of God. His book, The Plan of Salvation, is quite excellent, but as you read it, you will note that fault.

    In addition, If all this wasn’t bad enough, the charge has been more recently made, voiced by a number of alumni who had lived through the experience, that the faculty at Princeton, at the turn of the century and in the years, the early years of this century, while personally devoted to a rigorous Calvinism, for whatever reason, did not communicate that devotion in the classroom. They wrote it, but apparently, according to the testimony of many, they did not teach it rigorously in the classroom. Now, what was happening, I cannot say at this point. Possibly it had something to do with the Briggs case in the 1890s. The fact that the popularity of Princeton men and Princeton theology had suffered as a consequence of that.

    But by and large, the faculty at Princeton had retrenched, at least in the classroom, away from an aggressive, vigorous, militant Calvinism to the more comfortable position of being the spokesman for a supernatural Christianity over against the outrage of liberalism.

    Now, think about the education of J. Greshamation. He goes to Princeton in 1901. He then is educated in a gentleman’s Presbyterianism. at Princeton during this time. The mood is fairly uniform, and Machen’s experience at Princeton fits in well with the mold. But there was one teacher at Princeton during those days who didn’t fit.

    He was an alien. He was Dutch. He came from the Christian Reformed Church. He was a man in whom nations seemed to have only relative interests. There are not many comments about him in his letters to his mother, for instance. The man I have in mind is Gerhardus Voss. Voss was an odd person, extremely so.

    He was a lonely man as well, an eccentric, on campus. He was a man more often mocked by his students than listened to, and he was generally ignored. I think that all of you who know the halls of academia well recognized the type. And this kind of an individual has probably been the object of your pranks and your caustic remarks as well. As one alumni put it, Voss was a klutz. whose words were so buried beneath his Dutch accent, you couldn’t understand it.

    But it was Vos, who more than anyone else, inconspicuous as he was, it was Vos who would force the issue for a proper assessment of the Reformed faith and build towards its further progress. Now why do I say this? Vos was grabbed hold of by the distinguishing feature of Reformed theology, the doctrine of the covenant, and he would not let it go.

    And Vos it was who, in pressing the case for the primacy, for consideration of the covenant, pulled Reformed theology back to its roots and away from the primacy of the intellect, the primacy of the mind, which now was fairly much entrenched in Princeton thinking.

    The covenantal character of God’s revelation, Vos Saw, establishes the primacy not of the intellect, but of the historical category. In view, then, is the historical unveiling of God’s purpose in covenantal form, mind and evaluation, mind and even definition subordinate to that sovereign activity of God in history. You must lead with the primal biblical category. And the covenant, the reformed doctrine of the covenant, forces you to that conclusion. In other words, the primacy of the act of God, the primacy of the mighty acts of God.

    Voss’s position therefore powerfully challenged the old school Presbyterian position that the reformed faith must refute the primacy of the intellect, as it was held among liberals and others, with its own appeal to the primacy of the intellect. You see the problem that was being addressed. we will confront the liberal’s appeal to the primacy of the intellect with our own appeal to the primacy of the intellect. The Reformed faith instead, said Voss, saw Voss, refutes the primacy of the intellect with the primacy of revelation. and the unfolding story of salvation, the Christian story, as Cornelius Van Til called it. But furthermore, Vos would press his case to the very heart of the He was not going to allow the discussion to live at the level of the mere externals of the covenant itself, the arrangement aspects of the covenant, the legal aspects of the covenant, the documented aspects of the covenant.

    He was going to go to the very heart of the matter. Now, in order to illustrate this, let me get real homey here. Say your wife, you men, asks you, as she is bound to do, honey, do you love me? And you say, well, of course I do. And you show her your marriage certificate. Are you with me here? You dare not define covenant by appeal merely to the legal aspects of the arrangement. You can’t do that.

    Vos saw that you have to press to the very heart of the matter. And in this, he was standing with Calvin, he was standing with the Westminster Divines, He was standing with historic Presbyterianism in its best form. At the center of biblical interest is the believer’s possession of God and God’s possession of the believer. Do you understand what’s going on in the first question and answer of the Catechism? You see it, right? It’s the covenant right there.

    The chief end of man is to glorify God and to enjoy Him forever. What does it mean to glorify God? Do you realize that the first instance for the use of the word glory in Scripture doesn’t have to do with God at all? It has to do with Laban, Genesis 31. sons of Laban were concerned that Jacob would steal their father’s glory. What do they mean?

    His possession, his wealth. To glorify God means to demonstrate that you are his possession. That’s what it means. But you see then how the catechism answer reverses it. And to enjoy him forever. Not only are we God’s possession, but God gives himself to us to be our possession. That’s it. If you then are sons, you are heirs, joint heirs with Christ, heirs of God. You inherit Him. That’s it. This, Voss said, is only in its perfect realization, of course, found in the higher heavenly eternal world.

    It was this which was Adam’s hope in the garden even before sin—to have God and to be in God’s possession. And it is now, in our circumstance, the gift which God presently gives us in Christ, the down payment of which we have received in his Holy Spirit. In its already accomplished truth in Jesus Christ, this becomes the ground, the motivation, the empowerment for all of our behavior. Our ethics flow from this.

    Ross’s contention was, here is the Reformed faith’s fundamental principle and promise of progress. And here is the proper biblical response to all foolhardy worldliness, all millennial fantasies. Here is the proper appropriate response that would also prove to be an appropriate antidote to the vanities of rising nationalism and to the comforts of a gentleman’s Presbyterianism.

    It would not be until the twenties that a group, a very small group of students in the interests of the heart of Calvinism, would begin to move toward Voss. You know their names. Cornelius Van Til, Ned B. Stonehouse, and John Murray. And it would be these men, together with an earlier devoted student of Voss, R.B. Kuyper, under whom Machen himself, after the founding of Westminster Seminary in 1929, an institution that included these gentlemen, would begin his own re-education. His own re-education.

    From them he would learn that the Reformed faith was far more than a gentleman’s Presbyterianism, that Presbyterianism in which he had been raised and trained. In fact, it was far different from even many of its more conservative expressions among American Presbyterians. Now, the struggle in which these matters were worked out struggle in which these matters were worked out during Machen’s lifetime was with American Presbyterian fundamentalists. At the end of his life, Machen, despite the presence of fundamentalists in the newly formed Church, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, Despite the presence of fundamentalists with him, Machen emphatically distanced himself from fundamentals. He stated his case to James E. Bennett, a New York Presbyterian fundamentalist lawyer. Machen, in correspondence with this man, said, I, for my part, am not a fundamentalist at all, but a Presbyterian.

    He went further, saying he found no real commitment to the Westminster standards among the fundamentalists. He found no real proper biblical view of office. He found a tendency towards millennial extremism and towards the heresies of dispensationalism. And he also found an unbiblical legalism that violated the canons of Christian liberty.

    But beneath these very pointed objections was the rabid nationalism that for all the pre-millennial pessimism of the fundamentalists about this world was very much alive in them. As George Marsden has pointed out, American Presbyterian fundamentalism was as much alive with the activist, nationalist, crusading spirit as was American Presbyterian liberalism. After the Third General Assembly, June 1 through 4, 1937, the Fundamentalists would leave the New Church in order to start their own, the Bible Presbyterian Synod.

    They would be led by Carl McIntyre, J. Oliver Buswell, Al McRae, and H. McAllister Griffiths, all men who were convinced that the OPC had come under an un-American influence. At the root of that concern was not just the figures of Kuyper, Stonehouse, Van Til and Murray, but Gerhardtus Voss. Stonehouse and Murray, as well as Kuyper, were arguing their case against the premillennial dispensationalism abroad in the church by an appeal to Voss. The argument was over his influence and the direction he was proposing.

    These then MacIntyre, Buswell, McCrae, Griffiths, and others withdrew in the interests of their version and vision for American Presbyterians. They were unable to see the value and the glory of the New Church in transcending the nationalism and worldliness that had become so much a part of the American Presbyterian scene. Now, it would be in the 1940s, after Machen’s death, that the OPC would face two further challenges that confirmed its identity. The first was with a Presbyterian elitism a residual mainline Presbyterianism that had survived in many moneyed families, including Machen’s own, and in certain individuals who aspired to the cultural standing and influence of the mainline Presbyterian Church.

    The chief figure representing the elitist position was Edwin H. Ryan. Ryan wrote an excellent book, back there on the table, entitled The Presbyterian Conflict. But at the same time, he dreamt of the OPC as a large Presbyterian church with the cultural clout of the mainline church.

    He wanted a church that would recapture a place of power and usefulness in the life of America. Those are his words. He made two major efforts in the 1940s to realize his goal. In 1941, he masterminded at the 8th General Assembly of the OPC, the organization of the so-called Committee of Nine. At the next assembly, this committee expressed its commitment to a program which saw the OPC as a church to meet the needs of this generation, have an increasing area of influence, and make a greater impact on life today.

    But the assembly rejected the committee’s proposals. and the committee was abandoned. Ryan next concentrated his energies on the Christian University Project, an effort by Presbyterian and Reformed people to develop a distinctively Calvinistic university in this country. But Ryan, who served the University Association as General Secretary, was determined to mold the university along elitist lines. And when it became suspected that he was misusing association funds to achieve his goal, he was fired. This happened in the fall of 1946. In the spring of the following year, he left the OPC in disgrace. and return to the PCUSA and to the elitism of that church which he had never actually forsaken.

    The other challenge the OPC would face in the forties that would confirm the church’s identity as a vigorously reformed church, driven at root by a transcendent interest, was from the rising tide of the New Evangelicalism. Now, getting a handle on the neo-evangelical movement is not an easy matter, but let me offer to you a few suggestions. Neo-evangelicalism is a reaction to fundamentalism, wishing to be free from the counterproductive aspects of fundamentalism’s reputation, in the interest of better access to and acceptance in American culture. Neo-evangelicalism is fundamentalism made respectable.

    What it craves is an equal footing, a place of an equal within American society. I cite as an illustration of this the recent statement by Ralph Reed, the leader, the executive director of the Christian Coalition. He captured the sentiment of the neo-evangelical movement well, applying it to his own effort, when he recently said that the coalition had become a significant force in American politics. Quote, we have gained what we have always sought, a place at the table. Unquote. That’s a bit short-sighted. But such adolescent short-sightedness as this has become the calling card of neo-evangelicalism.

    Such an attitude and disposition was sufficiently attracted to many in the OPC in the 1940s for them to make great concessions to it. This is what lay at root in the famous Clark-VanPhil debate. There were many important and profoundly complex doctrinal issues involved in that debate. Issues such as the free offer of the gospel, the fiducial aspect of faith, and most importantly, the incomprehensibility of God. All of these were on the table.

    Some in the OPC who had no real understanding of the theological issues, in fact, they would have been opposed to Clark if they had rightly grasped what he was saying, nevertheless gravitated toward him because he represented to them a means by which they could re-enter American culture and church life. That was the overriding concern.

    The Church was not to be a backwater movement. It was to have the position of prominence in order to make an impact upon the society and the culture. Clark became a figurehead in this movement for many who couldn’t have cared less about the particulars of his position concerning the incomprehensibility of God. Clark was ordained to the OPC ministry in 1944, and his ordination survived an appeal process, even to the General Assembly. So that stood. Clark was ordained. He was a minister in the OPC.

    On many accounts of what went wrong, the Clark supporters felt that they had the support necessary in order to win the election. One account was that Pastor Dean Adair, a Clark supporter, was so distressed by the manners of the Clark party that he switched his vote at the last minute. Others cite the fact that ruling elder Cyrus Ferguson from Kirkwood, Pennsylvania, flew out to the General Assembly meeting at Cedar Grove, Wisconsin, and arrived just in time to cast his vote. At any rate, the Clark Party lost in its bid to gain control of the Foreign Missions Committee, and they lost by one vote. By the next assembly, Clark, and the majority of his supporters had left the Church. A number of them went back into mainline Presbyterianism. The common element in each of these struggles, be it with the Fundamentalists in the 30s or the Elitists or the Neo-Evangelicals in the 40s, is the desire of these groups to offer the OP a way back into the culture, back into a national identity.

    In God’s providence, the OPC has not as yet taken the bait. To this day, the OPC remains a Reformed and Presbyterian church without a cultural bridge That is, without a means back into the American mainstream. The question was asked to me, why is the OPC small? Why doesn’t the OPC grow at a faster rate? Why aren’t there more people in the OPC? Let me tell you something. Given the OPC’s identity, it is amazing that there is anybody in the OPC. Each one of you is a testimony to the grace of God.

    Humanly speaking, this church should not exist. It should not have survived. It should not be here. It is the absence of just such a cultural bridge that accounts in some measure for the smallness of the denomination. Do you realize what happens? People walk into your churches and they perceive, they can’t articulate it, they can’t put it down in writing, they can’t state it even. Something isn’t right. They sense it. There is something here with which they cannot identify.

    And I might add that it is the absence of just this cultural bridge that provides the reason for the breakdown of union talks with other Presbyterian bodies. This is it. It really isn’t those popular issues that were raised. Well, you know, the OPCs don’t really believe in evangelism, and they’re a bunch of theological nitpickers, so we don’t want to get together with them. Smokescreen.

    The real reason for the breakdown in the Union talks with other Presbyterian bodies. is right here. The OPC lacks the cultural bridge. The 1975 attempt at union with the former Reformed Presbyterian Church Evangelical Synod collapsed because the Reformed Presbyterian Church Evangelical Synod was the child of fundamentalism and maintained a cultural vision that could not accept OPC disenfranchisement. Along similar lines, the O.P.’ ‘s attempts at union with the P.C.A. in the eighties collapsed. Much at issue here, although never isolated in the discussion, were the P.C.A.’ ‘s cultural aspirations.

    You don’t talk about these things. It’s the ethos of the Church. These aspirations are very much at the center of the PCA’s identity and rise out of an evangelical social vision of which a large, influential, if not dominant, national church is an indispensable part. That is the PCA’s identity. That is what they are about. My thesis has been Historically, the OPC has not shared this vision. It cannot agree with it. The OPC, as was the case with J. Gresham Machen himself, has been forced to a higher vision.

    She with the patriarchs is forced to desire a better country that is a heavenly one. She has been stamped with an other worldliness that demands further development and progress in her members as to how they, rather than seeking to regain the world they lost, might be of service to their Lord in this world.

    Such service will insist upon the priority of the heavenly consciousness in the pursuit of any task. Such consciousness the fruit of our union with Christ in keeping with the word. This one who even now is in heaven. Beginning here We always begin with and by grace are always in a position of laboring out of what we have not out of what we don’t have. Such labor is progressively informed by God’s gracious provision through his word for expression in the worship of the church in the means of grace in the marks of the church in the ministry and mission of the people of God in the care and counseling of others in the mutual life with fellow believers.

    Think of it. A consciousness that rises above thoughts about securities and rewards in this world. You want to talk about freedom, friends? Let’s talk about freedom. a consciousness that rises above thoughts about security and rewards in this world, that is not held captive by the evening news, or by the political prospects of this party or that, or when it comes to ministry, the prospect of a large, successful enterprise. with statistics you can boast about. Think of it, a consciousness that so stands in the liberty of the sons of God, so confident of God as the true and only reward for God’s people, of heaven as the true and only destination for those who here have no continuing city, that it enables us to be of greatest help to the multitude of churches in this land and in the world. We encouraging them with all humility to look above to the Lord, the Savior of the ends of the earth.

    Thank you. Take a few minutes for a question. John Frayman in his evangelical reunion suggests that the default position I’m not sure. I know he mentioned John frame and he mentioned his book on the evangelical reunion. Yeah. Okay. Well I’m not sure that I can defend all of the argumentation that. went into the JNR situation from the side of those who were opposed to joining and receiving, for instance.

    As far as the ecumenical obligation that is on us, you see, my position is that you always view the imperative in light of the indicative. I mean, okay, what would I say? All right, any command given us by God out of his word must flow from the accomplishment which God himself has worked. And that’s Calvinism, really. Okay, so any obligation that I have must flow from the already accomplished work of God. You’re with me, all right? You understand that much, right?

    But if you take that and you apply that to the whole matter of ecumenicity, for instance, you cannot proceed in ecumenicity if you have already allowed to slip from your hand the reality of the union that is yours in Christ, a consciousness of that truth. And I believe consciousness of that truth, as it’s worked itself out, will force us in the direction that the OPC has gone.

    It will force us to consider more thoroughly our union with Christ, and that is the foundation out of which we then work. It’s not, therefore, talking to this person and talking to that church and endearing by our own wits and by our own imaginations to construct a unified church. in response to the so-called ecumenical imperative. The command laid upon us to work for unity must flow forth from the unity that already exists for the body of Christ in himself. And therefore, such unity that is observed in us is not to our credit. We don’t pat ourselves on the back and say, We’ve got all these differences ironed out, we’re all back together, we’ve got this wonderful thing going, we’ve moved beyond nationalism, we’ve moved beyond ethnicity, we’re now, you know, doing these wonderful things. Any expression of genuine biblical unity for the body of Christ is merely an entering into the unity that already exists in Him. So it is completely and thoroughly of grace.

    Now, from what I, the little I know, and I have tried to work through a little bit of John’s book, I don’t remember that kind of language being brought to the discussion. So in a sense, I’m, you know, I say this isn’t particularly helpful. Now, I think that there are other reasons why John’s approach isn’t particularly helpful and that is that I think that there is a tendency in his writings to be somewhat historically naive or shall I say, do I dare say it?

    Yeah, see the OPC couldn’t win and that’s that’s also what I I I personally take exception to in the analyses that have been offered by some. If we, if they voted not to receive us, it was our fault. If we voted not to go in, it was our fault. We could not win in the minds of some. And that just merely reveals the attitude of mind, you know, the attitude of soul at work in the situation. We could not please. regardless. This doesn’t obviate at all, in any sense, the necessity for us to work towards unity.

    And I could go through the OPC’s ecumenical philosophy, and I agree with it 100%. And that is that, first of all, we view ourselves as a Catholic Church. That’s primary. We view ourselves as a Catholic Church with international interest and concern that we’re not going to be locked up into some sort of provincialism that that basically a wall in because of the boundaries of this country and other we have a worldwide vision. And that that the commitment that I think is is is very important for understanding the O.P.C. in its ecumenical pursuits.

    And that is another reason why we had a great deal of difficulty in working our way through the ecumenical proposals, because we were being asked to choose between two kinds of ecumenicity. It’s getting harder to talk. We had to choose between two forms of ecumenicity. If we go the R.P.C.S. direction, if we go the P.C.A. direction, there is a certain provincialism to which we must submit ourselves.

    But in remaining what we were, we can still cultivate and develop this Catholic interest, which is to see Reformed and Calvinist and Presbyterian churches in fellowship worldwide. helping each other. I think John was first in the back. Yes, there are multiple questions. There are multiple issues involved in that question, and that has to do with the question of whether the cultural bridge had anything to do with those who left the denomination after the failure of Jan R. I definitely think that that is the case. I think that the church growth movement, and to a certain degree, the new life movement, insofar as it was influenced by the church growth movement, had those kinds of convictions.

    They led with the card of evangelism. Now, see, everything I say gets me into trouble. And somebody will walk away, he’s against evangelism. No, no, no, no. But it’s as the OP has been stating all along, evangelism is unto the end of worship. So evangelism can’t be the goal. It is the means to the goal. The goal is the increased worship of God by those who are being gathered in.

    But there was a tendency in the New Life group and in the Church Growth group to move in the direction of the primacy of evangelism. And I think that that moved it away from an OP understanding of things generally. I think that there are other factors. The new, the church growth movement was very much into technique.

    I mean, you know what I mean. They had bought into the technique approach to developing, growing a church. It’s only a matter of the right method. You use the right method, it will succeed. And strangely enough, it would succeed for the JWs, the Mormons, the Buddhists. It didn’t matter who it was. You just plug in. You see? The technology’s neutral. You just plug in.

    But you see there’s an interesting connection between the church growth movement mentality and the new life mentality. What was interesting, what was influencing Jack Miller as the new life movement was taking shape, was John Wesley’s journal. Now he will tell you that. And what was the consequence of John Wesley’s journal and his theology, this turn towards the experiential, this elevation of aspects within the human personality?

    It was Methodism. You get the connection? We’ve got religious Methodism here, we’ve got religious technology over here. There’s a hand in glove or a hand-in-hand kind of relationship between the two. So I think that yes, you see this movement away from what we would consider to be historic classic Calvinism and not much sympathy for the disenfranchisement of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. Yeah, yeah, yeah. As far as I’m concerned, this must be at the forefront of our ecumenical policy with regard to not only churches in this country, but throughout the world. It has to be at the forefront, particularly in our foreign missions efforts. You realize what’s happening to the churches in the third world. You think the forces of nationalism here are rather subtle. They are incredibly, oh, you know, overt. blatant in other places in the world.

    These people are under the gun. You have the case of the church in Indonesia. The church in Indonesia is told, the Reformed Church is told, if they want to be licensed, they must join the WCC. The state is making that determination. What do they do? Well, unfortunately, they joined. But what does the O.P. have to say to that? Not just by sending them a letter or sending them a position paper, but by its very existence. No, you do not have to do that. Make your stand. We’re with you. And to the extent we can, we will enter into the suffering with you. We will bear it with you.

    What’s happening in Africa? As these churches start taking shape, the pressures of nationalism on these churches is unbearable. And what does the OP say? What is the OP message? You must not be in a culturated church. You must stand in a transcendent position with us. In a position that then transcends all national barriers and all racial and ethnic barriers. You must stand with us. You must stand in Ephesians 2.

    There’s a lot of work to be done, and I feel that God in his providence is pushing us in these directions in our foreign missions policies and approach. Mark Beale is a wonderful man. He understands much of this. Our ecumenical Committee as well is seeing it more clearly, what kind of help, what kind of service will they be to these struggling, emerging churches in the world. We have a glorious message and a marvelous stand that we can put before them that hopefully will be a blessing.

    Well, it may seem like a contradiction to what I’ve been saying, but I do wish that the OPC did have some men of the stature of Machen and Van Till and Murray and Kuiper today, and we don’t. And the question is, what are we going to do? Well, I know what I’m going to do.

    In my own halting way, I’m going to keep preaching it, and as other men in the churches are going to do, but it’s not altogether a negative. The loss of those stalwart theologians pushes us, we who are ministers, we who are ruling elders in the church, to become extremely proficient in the Word and in our identity. We are forced to it. The strength is not going to come from some central theological clearinghouse, it seems.

    Okay, so what are we going to do? We’re going to be forced to do a lot of work ourselves. And that may mean that our churches have to undergo some bit of a transformation in their own consciousness, they have to encourage their pastors to study, to work, to think these things through clearly and effectively. They have to give them time to do that.

    Churches have to insist on not just passable sermons, but profound sermons. Give me more than I would get down the street at the typical fundamentalist evangelism, certainly more than we would get at the liberal church. You’ve given me more than we would get from an Arminian congregation. It could be an opportunity. The question of a theological seminary continues to be debated in the denomination.

    There are discussions right now about that. The usefulness to our denomination of the Westminster campuses, we all recognize that there has been a change. East and West in relationship to the OPC. And yes, we’re suffering as a result of that. So let’s see what the Lord will do. Yes? There’s probably some truth in that. Yes, the question is, what do I say to those who say that the OPC is exclusivistic and looks down its nose at other sincere, genuine believers? I would say that there is a major major of truth to that but at the same time.

    I really I really do not. I have never run into anyone in my experience for the O.P.C. And that includes my father-in-law. Bob Graham. that believes or believe that the O. P. C. was the only true church of the world. I mean we realize that was a joke when that name was proposed and that certainly in my experience has not been the attitude that I have found amongst O. P. I mean there is there is a great camaraderie there is a sense of fellowship that should be you find that anywhere within a denominator within denomination There is a strength to those connections, but I have not been aware of people who had the attitude that the OPC was the only true church.

    And I have found that the OPs have been very solicitous. They have been very generous. I think that the conviction of OPs has generally been that you don’t have to believe in election to be a lot. Am I am I right. OK. OK. So we can we can graciously and properly. Extend ourselves to others who don’t believe in election. And hopefully we won’t do that in a particularly condescending manner. No, I’m not going to take this is what I’m going to give somebody else. OK, yes, and I hear this. This also gets me into trouble, of course, but the question is, what’s the proper way to take the gospel into the world? Yes, right.

    I think one of the primary things is to recognize, recognize the the place, the role that the church has. The OPC is if not by express statement at least by practice and by parachurch. Counter parachurch. So we have been adamant in in in in the position that this is the church is that we take the Westminster Confession chapter twenty five paragraph three very seriously at least in terms of our practice in the past. which sees that the that the scriptures and the ministry and the and the proclamation of the gospel belong to the church they don’t belong there. So that’s first if we’re settled on that question we move ahead and so if the church is tapped out and now we got the question of of who in the church does this well again now we’re faced with a debate with it in the O.P.C. there are those who say well now you see you have the ordained the ministers of the word who are charged with this responsibility It is their job to preach and proclaim the word. They are the official proclaimers of the gospel. I agree with that position. This is where the official proclamation of the gospel takes place. What does that mean? Does that mean that we who are in the pew then are shackled? We cannot share our faith. We’re somehow indifferent. Heavens, no. But what you are doing is not preaching the gospel. Please understand that.

    It is living the Christian life. And in the Christian life, you are sharing what you are. You are communicating what you are by what you say, what you do. It’s part of the Christian walk. But it isn’t specifically and narrowly defined preaching the gospel that belongs to those who have been ordained in the church for that purpose. So I think that that’s but ministers need to be encouraged to be proclaiming the gospel faithfully and fearlessly. Thinking of ways that they can get their message out into the community. Yet all of that there, and I think that at the same time, the ministry of the word must also be concerned that the people in the pew are are are living their Christian confession and by living that Christian confession, their words and their deeds are communicating the gospel and they’re not giving themselves an excuse for not doing so.

    I might come back to the great reformational recovery of vocation. That has been lost in Reformed consciousness. I think that many of you realize that, where Luther and Calvin saw that our Christian obligation is to do our jobs well, before the Lord and for the Lord. So, if I’m an engineer, if I’m a politician, if I’m a teacher, if I’m an insurance agent, if I’m a housewife, whatever I am, I do this job before the Lord and for the Lord. keeping in mind the heavenly goal and orientation of my existence. And now you see what happens with the evangelical consciousness on this matter and fundamentalist consciousness.

    The only real job you have is evangelizing. The only reason you have a job is to evangelize your fellow workers. Now it’s important that your fellow workers know where you stand. I believe that. conduct yourself in a way that the gospel is communicated. But your primary task is not as an evangelist. Your primary task is as a machinist, or that’s your calling. That’s your responsibility. That’s what God wants you to do. And I think if we can recover something of that, we will again have some pleasure in our work. Thank you, Charlie. We appreciate it.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • History of the OPC I: Prelude

    History of the OPC I: Prelude

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered January 1, 1996.

    About this sermon

    Hebrews 13:14, seeking a city not yet seen, frames a survey of the PCUSA, RCA, and OPC each chasing worldly pursuits in their own ways, beginning with the 1924 PCUSA General Assembly. Nationalism’s quiet compromise of the Westminster Confession gets specific attention. Church discipline, or its absence, is where that compromise eventually shows up.

    More sermons from Hebrews · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    As I kind of indicated a moment ago, I think my first recollection of Charlie was being at a at a General Assembly, and this guy kept standing up saying, got books over here, got a special price for you today. And that was Charlie Dennison. He is a lover of books. He’s a lover of history. And most importantly for us this evening, he’s a lover of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and the Reformed faith, which he preaches. It’s a privilege to have Charlie with us. He is the historian of the denomination, has been for quite a few years now, as long as I’ve been around the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. He is the Bishop of Swickley, Pennsylvania.

    We’ve been looking forward to your time with us, Charlie. The Lord bless you as you speak to us. We’re sorry we don’t have any snow to share with you. Maybe you’d feel more at home if we had some, huh? I’m very grateful for Bill Warren’s contact at last year’s General Assembly and also for the invitation of this session to come and be here with you this weekend.

    There’s two things that I would like to say before we get into the lecture. The first is, as you have already heard, I do love the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, and I want you to remember that, because it may seem that I am saying some very mean things in the course of these lectures. Now, of course, I do not intend them to be mean-spirited, but to be helpful, to be positive actually in building our church. But I do want you to keep in mind as we go through this that I do love the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. I want you also to keep in mind that I do love this country. It’s very important for you to keep that in mind as we go through these lectures and you will find out why. And before you start throwing things and getting up and running down the aisle, I want you to know that I do love this country.

    Now, these lectures have a particular orientation. If you have seen the brochure or seen some advertisement concerning them, if you have seen the title, There is a subtitle to the lecture. That subtitle is the meaning of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. That means that these lectures are not going to be facts and figures.

    If you want the facts and figures Do I have a deal for you? David has books in the back and more than have been mentioned here, and also there is the OPC video. I’m sure that some of you have seen that. I guess there is plans to show that on Sunday morning during the sunny school hours. So if you want the facts and figures, That’s where to go to get the facts and figures.

    I’m not going to be overwhelming you tonight with an avalanche of dates and particular items from the Orthodox Presbyterian Church’s past. The scripture text that I have chosen to give us some orientation, and I know that this presents something of a. Unique approach to the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, but.

    I suggested to you in the title. Hebrews 13 verse 14, if you could keep that in mind here, we have no continuing city, but we seek one which is to come. There are four lectures. They are entitled Prelude, Meaning, Confirmation, and Finale. Tonight’s Prelude. It is Tuesday, November 8th. 1838. 1838. The Reverend Cutting Marsh, that’s right, Cutting, C-U-T-T-I-N-G, don’t ask me.

    A Presbyterian missionary in Stockbridge, Wisconsin, receives two early morning visitors. a young David Palmer and a Delaware tribesman named Big Deer. The reason for their visit? Big Deer’s desire to deliver up his idol, a doll given him by his mother twenty-nine years previously, a doll he had worshipped until he began to hear about Jesus. Now, he stopped worshipping that doll, but at the same time, he kept it by him as a token, a momentum, a reminder of his mother’s love and his ancestral background. But now, on this fall morning, he wished to give up all to follow Christ. The scene changes.

    It is Sunday, October 13, 1991, over 150 years later. The Reverend James Andrews, stated clerk of the Presbyterian Church in the USA, the denomination of Reverend Cutting Marsh, is joined by many others in a ceremony in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Present are Cherokees, Seminoles, and Delawares. The occasion?

    To return to the Delawares a sacred health guardian doll, valued highly among the Delaware’s described as an integral part of the spiritual well-being of their community. The event is marked by religious drum beating and dancing. As part of the U.S. government’s and the mainline church’s effort to support, quote, Native American communities trying to reclaim their cultural heritage and religious dignity. So much for the separation of church and state. The doll in question? The very one Big Deer had delivered up when he decided to follow Jesus.

    In February 1989, those ever so urbane, sophisticated, and culturally alert readers of the now defunct magazine, the Reformed Journal, were treated to a rather sentimental, if not silly editorial written by Richard Mouw. M-O-U-W. Richard Mao was a member of the Reformed Church of America, who at that time was teaching at Calvin College, the college of the Christian Reformed Church. Richard Mao is now president of Fuller Seminary, located in Southern California, nearby Pasadena.

    His editorial served as the means to let the Reformed world know that he had on one occasion prayed to the Virgin Mary, and that he was not the least bit sorry for having done so. It was an act, he felt assured, that achieved its end. My prayer, he said, arrived at the right destination. Indeed. It is the spring of nineteen eighty seven. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church’s Committee on home missions and church extension. Has purchased a full page ad. In another defunct magazine. Eternity. Think of. Eternity is to follow. You must be careful what you name your magazine.

    The whole missions committee had purchased this full page ad for the purpose of soliciting contribution from the general evangelical population and beyond. Hopefully these contributions would replenish the committee severely depleted reserves. That had been nearly exhausted by the committee’s pursuit of the church growth agenda during the decade of the.

    The ad featured a very attractive woman on an exercise machine. To the bold headline, she wants it all. According to the ad, the OPC commended itself to the general Christian public because it used, quote, street smart techniques, unquote, in planting new churches. The criticisms of this ad and the committee. During the subsequent General Assembly very. Some charge that we were guilty of false advertising. I’m not sure. What they had in mind. The woman. Or the byline. I think it was the bylaw. Is that really our fort in home missions and church planning efforts? That we have church smart, we have street smart techniques that we can use in those endeavors.

    Others saw this ad as a violation of the common standards of Christian decency. and outrage. And still others saw it as a flagrant surrender on the part of our denomination to crass commercialism for the purpose of selling the church. A traditionally strong and circumspect denomination like the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, abandoning the heights of its heavenly identity and calling, and descending to the very worldly level of viewing the church and her message as commodities to be bought and sold in the great mass religious marketplace of the world. A Reformed Christian, so-called Richard Mao, with ties to the Christian Reformed world, collapsing into the arms of a romantic superstition in an act his forefathers in the faith would have found indistinguishable from idolatry? A mainline church, the Presbyterian Church USA, dignifying outright paganism by commending in the name of public civil religion, the outrageous religious beliefs which a courageous convert, a hundred and fifty years previously, had surrendered when he decided to give up all to follow Jesus. Each of these instances evidence of the sad, dangerous and precarious state of the Presbyterian and Reformed Church in the twentieth century as we approach the end of this century.

    The question being, how in heaven’s name did we get here? It will be painfully clear, I hope, from these lectures As it is from these three illustrations. That blame cannot. Be assigned solely to the radical and liberal wings of the church. In giving an accounting of the sorry state of affairs we cannot ignore conservative complicity. But even more difficult. We must move even closer to home.

    We must look at ourselves. There is a great scene in John Huston’s version of the classic Moby Dick. Starbucks, the chief mate, is very much aware now of Ahab’s maniacal bent. Says Starbuck to Ahab, let Ahab beware Ahab. Indeed, even given liberalism’s betrayal of the gospel, even given evangelicalism’s present courting of contemporary culture to the point that the gospel itself is in the balance. Let the OPC beware the OPC.

    Now in order to draw into focus the danger we are to ourselves, and to answer the question how in heaven’s name did the Presbyterian and Reformed Church come to such a sad and precarious state of affairs, let me take you back a few years to 1924. twelve years before the founding of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

    My interest in this year is the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church USA. It convened in Grand Rapids, Michigan, interestingly. But not since The PCUSA’s first General Assembly in 1789 had there been a more defining, a more direction-determining assembly for the Church. The 1924 General Assembly of the PCUSA was a watershed assembly. The Church would never be the same afterwards. I say this not simply because of liberalism’s triumph at that assembly, but because of conservative ambivalence and complicity, which became all too painfully apparent.

    There were three major events at that assembly. And these events bring into focus the emerging personality of the once great Presbyterian Church. Setting the stage was the first of these events. The election of the moderator elected was Clarence E. McCartney, a somewhat eccentric, very proud. And yet. To be perfectly honest opportunistic. Man. At the same time, he was a great conservative defender in the P. C. U. S. A. Of Orthodox Calvinism, and he was the pastor of the Arch Street Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia.

    McCartney was the most formidable and popular leader of the conservative cause in the PCUSA at that time, and he had been nominated for the moderatorship of that assembly by another world-famous conservative, William Jennings Bryant, the man who had run for the presidency of the United States. McCartney won the moderatorship over Charles R. Erdmann. a moderate evangelical from Princeton Seminary, where J. Gresham Machen taught, but a favorite among the liberals. McCartney, upon his victory and upon assuming the chair of the moderatorship, placed conservative clergy at the head of every committee in the Assembly. The conservatives at that assembly, because of the tone and strains in the church at that time, the conservatives at that assembly, and as word spread throughout the denomination as a whole, were euphoric.

    But just how hollow conservative elation was would be exposed by the two other major events marking that assembly. Another major event. was the resolution of the so-called positive case. Very briefly. Harry Emerson positive was the bright articulate popular spokesman for liberalism. And an outspoken enemy of McCurdy.

    He was also a Baptist He had come to the nation’s attention as the associate pastor of the First Presbyterian Church in New York City, a church famous for its ecumenical policies, thus the presence of this Baptist in a Presbyterian pulpit. On May 21st, 1922, Fosdick preached his most famous, or shall we say infamous, sermon entitled, Shall the Fundamentalist When, in it, he took exception to the infallibility of the Bible and the historic doctrine of Jesus’ virgin birth. He said the church should be large enough and broad enough to welcome those who hold divergent views on such subjects. When this sermon was distributed widely across the country, an ecclesiastical war broke out. with the conservatives headed by Clarence McCartney. The whole matter came to a head at the 1924 assembly, but a strange thing happened.

    Even though the assembly seemed to be dominated by the conservative rank-and-file, And despite that rank-and-file power having been demonstrated in McCartney’s election, the Assembly pursued Fosdick on a technicality only. He was a misplaced Baptist, and he should decide whether he wanted to become a Presbyterian. here was a piece of political maneuvering all too transparent to the liberals. The fact that the conservative assembly of 1924 failed to pursue Fosdick directly for his public statements and doctrinal deviations built confidence for the liberals Here was an all-too-clear indication of what the PCUSA was becoming. The high ground of doctrine was being abandoned for the more political and practical and pragmatic approach. Although the liberals had lost in the moderatorship vote, and though they themselves were a minority in the assembly, They could not help but think that the Conservatives were cautiously calculating their political options. Raised, therefore, was the question of whether the Conservatives had bought into an administrative view of the Church, and thus severely crippled their commitments to a doctrinal understanding of things. Put quite frankly, Were the doctrinal standards of the PC USA going to play any significant role in the church’s future? A review of the remaining major event of that assembly will conclude the issue. It would be this event that conclusively revealed liberal power and conservative complicity.

    Here, we deal with the Auburn Affirmation. What was the Auburn Affirmation? On December 26, 1923, a group of 150 Presbyterian ministers met at 10 Nelson Street, Auburn, New York. Jointly, they expressed their dissent to actions of General Assembly’s past. the General Assemblies of 1910, 1916, and 1923. By which, in those actions, Presbyterian ministers were declared bound by five essential doctrines, the infallibility of scripture, the virgin birth of Christ, his miracles, his substitutionary death on the cross, and his bodily resurrection.

    These actions in successive assemblies were, as we can say now from our position as Monday morning quarterbacks, unconstitutional and superfluous, even though they were generated by honest conservative folk. They were unconstitutional and superfluous in light of the already orthodox standards of the PCUSA, the Westminster Confession of Faith, and its catechisms. The Auburn group rightly pointed out the unconstitutional character of the Assembly’s actions. It had an advantage.

    But it did so not because these folks, these Auburn affirmationists, had any real deal for the church’s orthodox standards. Instead, their interest ultimately was to declare themselves free from traditional doctrinal restrictions. The Auburn group, therefore, declared the five doctrines in question, but theories over against which other theories could be placed.

    By the time of the 1924 General Assembly, 1,274 Presbyterian ministers had signed the Auburn Affirmation. The 1924 General Assembly, therefore, became a defining moment in the history of the mainline Presbyterian Church. There was an overture from the Presbytery of Cincinnati, calling upon the Church to respond forcefully and quickly. And one would have expected the 1924 Assembly to do just that, given the leadership of McCartney as moderator and the presence of a clear majority for the Conservatives in the Assembly. But even beyond these considerations, the fate of the signers of the Auburn Affirmation seems sealed, since the all-important Bills and Overture Committee of the General Assembly had among its members two of the most famous conservatives of the time, Maitland Alexander, the pastor of the First Presbyterian Church in Pittsburgh, and William Jennings Bryan himself. But what happened?

    First, the Bills and Overtures Committee, despite the presence of these stalwart conservatives, proposed no action be taken in response to the Cincinnati Overture, and thus against the signers of the Auburn Affirmation. There was no dissent in the committee to this decision. There was no minority report submitted. None.

    So the committee brought that recommendation to the floor of the assembly, and one would have expected a fierce debate on the floor. But the assembly voted unanimously to table the entire matter. And interestingly, the motion to table, and thereby dismiss, if you’re aware of the peculiarities of Robert’s rules, the motion to table was made by the famous conservative pastor, Dr. Mark A. Matthews, from Seattle. No one at that assembly recorded a negative vote. No one filed a protest, and in the time proximate to this decision, and therefore within the prescribed statute of limitations, no one filed any charge against any signer of the Auburn Affirmation.

    He’s starting to feel a little uncomfortable. My friends, we’re not talking about liberals. Do you really think that everyone who wears a conservative badge is your ally? It ain’t so. What explanation can be given for the conservative failure of 1924?

    The answer to that question goes a long way in answering the question with which we began tonight. How did we, in heaven’s name, get where we are presently in the Presbyterian and Reformed world? At least this much is clear, is it not? As responsible as liberals are for the ecclesiastical and doctrinal debacle of this century, conservatives have a great deal to answer for themselves.

    The sad fact is, however, that conservative and evangelical and even reformed analysis of the failure of 1924 has been quite disappointing. One typical remark at the time was that the failure was a, quote, grave mistake. I can just see the jowls. Grave mistake.

    Actually, it was the liberal leader. On occasion, you find yourself thanking God for a liberal. Actually, it was the liberal leader, Henry Sloane Coffin of all people, who came closest to the mark. He was at the assembly, he wrote his wife from Grand Rapids, telling her that although the conservatives controlled the assembly, they lacked nerve. They are frightened, he told his wife, and shrink from extreme measures. Coffin’s remarks to his wife signal the coming liberal victory.

    But they also imply the social and cultural dimension to the conservatives reticence to act. The social and cultural dimension of the conservatives reticence to act. His comment to his wife raises the question of conservative motivation. Were the conservatives driven by sincere religious conviction in the interest of the sure and certain biblical faith they confessed, or were they actually controlled by a religion of appearances? whereby they wished to be perceived in the churches and in the public eye as agreeable. Put a bit more crassly, did the conservatives fail to act in 1924 because they judged the stakes too high and the embarrassment and scorn before the watching world and the watching church too potentially damaging? But of course, the reasons for conservative failure go far deeper than I have as yet suggested.

    For example, we must not overlook the fact that the Presbyterian Church in the USA in the early 1900s was an established and yes, highly secularized institutions. Nor should we overlook the fact that the mainline Presbyterian body had achieved this status in large measure because of conservative contribution.

    The PCUSA, the mainline church, was established It was an enfranchised church. It was a church of privilege and prominence. It was a fixture in the American landscape with property, large tracts of real estate, huge buildings, and a great amount of money. It boasted of this position, however, at tremendous cost. Aspects of that cost unperceived even by the most hawk-eyed conservative One area of Uniform blindness in the peace USA Was the rising tide of nationalism I’m setting you up.

    I’m setting you up. That’s why I said to you at the beginning that it’s important for you to know that I love my country. It is important for Orthodox Presbyterians to love their country. But while we love our country, we do not surrender ourselves to nationalism. Let me spell it out. about the political realities of the church’s American environment. There are both conservatives and liberals in the political makeup of this country.

    They all get along well enough without running each other out of the country. Shouldn’t it be the same in the church? You following me? We all live here. We’re all Americans. Some of us are conservatives. Some of us are liberals. But we don’t run each other out of the country. It should be the same way in the church. Do you understand where Fawcett’s getting his theology? He’s looking to the culture. He’s reading the church off the face of the culture. He’s right in sync with the times. It’s up the ante a little bit.

    What about the decretal theology of historic Presbyterianism? You know what I’m talking about? God’s eternal decree, the doctrines precious to historic Presbyterianism, God’s eternal election, His predestination, the working out of His will. How is this going to play? in a nation that is increasingly controlled by the attitude and convictions that rise from free will and a conviction and commitment to equality for all.

    How are you going to be able to make any distinctions among anyone? Historic Calvinism is saying there are the elect here and there are the reprobate over there. The rising tide of nationalism says you cannot make those distinctions. We are all Americans. If there is any salvation, it is ours together. See what’s happening to the consciousness of America. Radical transformation.

    The old Calvinism, therefore, just wasn’t American. so early in, as early as 1903, by additions and deletions, conservatives and liberals embraced within the PCUSA to qualify in some instances and eliminate in others the express Calvinism of the Westminster standards.

    The harsh statements in the judgment of some with regard to double predestination were removed. Chapters were added to the Westminster Confession that were intended to soften the blow that historic Presbyterianism and Calvinism had delivered. In 1906, Again, liberals and conservatives cooperated in drawing the Armenian Cumberland Presbyterian Church into the embrace of the Peace USA. Many conservative Presbyterians, therefore, bore the stamp of American culture above all else, no more committed to Calvinism than were their liberal opponents. Among the conservative clergy, it seemed, the greater commitment was to American independency and individualism than to Presbyterian doctrine and polity.

    Un-Presbyterian and even anti-Calvinistic strains begin to appear in the Church. Dispensationalism, fundamentalistic Arminianism, broad-based evangelicalism and even early forms of Pentecostalism were found in many conservative Presbyterian pulpits in this land.

    Those pulpits, becoming the centers of highly developed personalized ministries, ministerial superstars, all the credentials, all the statistics, huge buildings, Do you think church growth is a modern phenomenon? Recent development? Not so. In some cases, the blending of these forms of ministry with the developing entrepreneurial style of American culture meant the incorporation into ministry of the most tawdry commercialism. Worship became entertainment, preachers became personalities, preaching became a matter of sales, technique, and enterprising, with the gate all important.

    Such interests, noted one Orthodox Presbyterian historian, Paul Woolley, my name, such interests are indistinguishable from American preoccupation. After all, he said, numerical growth is an American enthusiasm. It is a national sport. All of these commitments in what was judged a good cause. a good and just enterprise.

    All of these commitments to the gospel of nationalism left conservative strength compromised, easily exploited by the growing liberal party in the Peace USA. However, no development among the conservatives in the mainline church proved more devastating than the unanimous contempt for church discipline. You could define the Orthodox Presbyterian movement as an attempt to recover church discipline. Somehow, by 1924, sadly, tragically, conservatives in the PCUSA had been convinced that there was only one sin more heinous than signing the Auburn Affirmation, and that was bringing charges against the signer of the Auburn Affirmation. The reasons for this are very complicated. But let me say that they are not unrelated to the emerging, growing national perception of what religion is and should accomplish.

    As far as the conservatives were concerned when it came to the matter of church discipline, they had now come to rely upon revival. Do you understand why some in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church are very hesitant when the issue of revival is raised in our midst? Do you understand why when we see certain revivalist tendencies beginning to gain a foothold that we begin to become very nervous? What was the legacy of the revivalism of the nineteenth century in which many Presbyterians participated enthusiastically, in fact, giving themselves to that with everything they had. The legacy was the disappearance, the evaporation of any substantive, any meaningful church discipline. Why? You just waited for the revival. That would take care of all the sins. You didn’t have to address the man personally. You didn’t have to go to the woman and confront her. You didn’t have to do any of that. Just wait for the revival. It’ll take care of everything.

    That’s not to say that many of us in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church would not welcome strengthening of spiritual life, vibrancy in our churches. But revivalism does bring some baggage, and you have to be aware of that. But there was another factor in the disappearance of discipline. We are a Christian nation. This means that our government and our courts are Christian. We need not discipline our membership because our Christian government will discipline our membership.

    By 1924, the type of church discipline necessary to bring the Auburn affirmationists to justice was non-existent. It seems that within this church, as established and as culturally attuned as was the PCUSA, Discipline was more than impolite, it was an unthinkable and unforgivable breach of ecclesiastical etiquette. You were violating the Presbyterian gentleman’s code by even suggesting such a thing. And so in 1924, no one thought about it. not even J. Aggressive Machen.

    It is a very good thing that you are sitting down. He was a commissioner to the 1924 General Assembly. The previous year he had just finished his tour de force, his great book, Christianity and Liberalism. That book which so eloquently and powerfully stated the truth of the matter. Liberalism was not a variation of Christianity, not even an aberrant form of it. It was an entirely different religion. But at the 1924 assembly, when liberalism so blatantly raised its vile form in the highest court of the church, Machen sat frozen and mute, just like everyone else.

    Two years earlier, That is, two years before he had written his book, three years before the assembly, Machen had visited B. B. Warfield prior to Warfield’s death. In fact, the month before Warfield passed away. Machen asked the ailing Warfield about the state of the PCUSA and about the advisability of a split in the church for the purpose of securing a continuing conservative cause. Warfield’s response was, you can’t split rotten wood. Truly not Machen, possibly not even Warfield himself fully comprehended how rotten the wood was.

    So rotten was it, in fact, that Machen had not been able to escape the effects of the Machen’s tragic silence at the 1924 Assembly is sobering to all self-assured, if not self-righteous, Orthodox Presbyterians. If someone as great as Machen was not immune to the spirit of complicity, what about us of lesser ability? If Machen need beware of Machen, what about you and me?

    In answering the question, how in heaven’s name did we come to this present situation in the Presbyterian and Reformed Church, we do well to look at ourselves. At the same time, and for the purposes of our encouragement and progress in the faith, we need also to consider what God did to J. Gresson Machen.

    I frame it that way deliberately. It’s not a matter of a man just merely following his ideas, principled and all that. It’s not merely a man being a moral example and living by his will in keeping with his moral attitudes and estimations. History is what God does to us. So, for the purposes of your encouragement and for your progress in the faith, You need to consider what God did to J. Gresson Machen.

    Over the last 13 years of that man’s life, God would force him to face the truth about himself and about the conservatives most closely aligned with him. It was an extremely painful experience. Near the end of his life, he wrote out his own public repentance in the pages of the Presbyterian Guardian. He said, What a fearful sin of omission it was that an effort was not made in 1924 in every single Presbytery in which any of us stood to bring the Auburn Affirmation to trial.

    That confession by nation goes a long way towards reasserting and putting into practice the proper definition of a church. But it also rises from a finer spiritual consciousness. that is being forced to see all the more clearly that here we, the Church of Jesus Christ, have no continuing city.

    Thank you. Charlie, we appreciate so much your being here and quitting our appetites for tomorrow. We trust you’ll all be back tomorrow if at all possible. One other thing I was going to say before we began, but it’s just as good I didn’t, we’ll do it now in a slightly different way.

    As we were sitting at supper, as my want often is, I asked my family, great dessert do we have to go with this great meal? I love dessert. And my wife, somewhat to my utter amazement, said none. I said, oh? And then she said something like, don’t you read the bulletin? I hope you all did read the bulletin and are reminded that now, after this first lecture, dessert is being served in the fellowship hall. So I was told my dessert would come after the lecture. I hope you’ll stay with us and have a moment of fellowship and a little bit of dessert maybe.

    Let us stand for prayer. Father and God, we are reminded again of who you are, of your greatness, of your majesty, that you are indeed the God of history, that you are active in history, not just in biblical history, but you’re active in history today. You’re active in our history. It was you who indeed raised up and formed Dr. Machen, and through him, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. We pray that even again as we hear our own history, that we might be humbled and reminded that you are the God of that history.

    We pray that it might give us a new commitment to be the kind of people that you would have us to be. We might serve you with all of our hearts and soul and mind, that we might glorify you with our words, with our actions as well. But indeed, it might not be merely a shibboleth with us, that our chief end is to glorify God and to enjoy him forever. that it might be truly our desire, our commitment, our longing to glorify you and to enjoy you forever. Thank you for what we’ve heard this evening. Bless us with a good night’s rest. Refresh us in body and spirit. Bring us back tomorrow, we pray, with an eagerness to learn more about who we are and what you’re doing in our history. Amen.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • History of the OPC II: Meaning

    History of the OPC II: Meaning

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered January 1, 1996.

    About this sermon

    Hebrews 11:16’s longing for a better, heavenly country explains Machen’s eschatological theology, against an America in the 1920s eager to put the church to nationalist use. Machen’s biblical orthodoxy resisted that use. His hope rested on heaven, whatever America thought of him.

    More sermons from Hebrews · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    It’s a privilege to have the Rev. Charles Dennison from the OPC Church in Swickly with us, the denominational historian to lecture to us on Here We Have No Continuing City, The Meaning of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. He’s going to take questions after he’s done with each from here on.

    Good morning to you. Again, I’m very glad to be here with you for this opportunity to speak about the history of our church. The passage that I would like to set before you this morning is in Hebrews, as was the one last night. Hebrews 11, verse 16. but now they desire a better country, that is, a heavenly, wherefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for he hath prepared for them a city.”

    Just to remind you of the outline of these lectures, if you didn’t catch it last night, I will go over it again for you this morning. Our first lecture was entitled Prelude. This one is entitled Meaning. The third lecture is Confirmation, and the fourth is Finale.

    Last night we considered the dangerous and even precarious state in which the Presbyterian and Reformed Church found itself in the first part of its century. We were also made aware of the continuing danger we face as part of that Church world, more particularly the danger we as Orthodox Presbyterians face and the danger that we are to ourselves. This morning we look more closely at the cultural setting in which the OPC was formed in hopes of becoming more aware of the dangers confronting us and more aware of the meaning of our denomination, more aware of what it means for us to confess for us to say, here we have no continuing city.

    I will repeat to you what I said last night, because it is very important. First of all, I love the OPC, and as I go through this, even though there are certain things that I criticize about the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, I want you to understand that I love this denomination as you do, you that are a part of it. And secondly, I love my country and even though there will be some very difficult things said about the relationship of the Church to the nation, to the culture in which we find ourselves, It is important to keep that in mind. It will be particularly important to keep that in mind with regard to this lecture.

    On January 28, 1920, J. Gretchen Machen, then A professor of New Testament at Princeton Theological Seminary, an institution in which he had held a position since 1906, wrote a letter to his mother in which he said, I see more clearly than ever before that unless the gospel is true and there is another world Our souls are in prison.”

    Now this remark by itself may seem innocuous, elementary in its religious affirmation, but hardly deserving of special comment. Some, in hearing it, may dismiss it. as a remark from a world-weary nation who momentarily flirted uncharacteristically with an irresponsible world-flight attitude, with notions far removed from the energetic world-involvement customarily associated with nation and admired in him. something smacking of a Protestant monasticism. Others, in hearing this comment from Machen, may conclude that this comment, with its statement about our souls being in prison, is an indication of the stubborn stain of Platonism, which we in the Reformed world have had difficulty removing. no less a figure than Machen having that difficulty too. However, one thing we should be aware of before we attack or dismiss this comment too quickly is that it expresses an essential ingredient in Machen’s theology and to his overall theological vision.

    Machen’s Christianity had always confessed the hope of heaven, and had acknowledged this hope to be indispensable to the gospel. In 1915, early in Machen’s career, he said, The Apostolic Church was intensely otherworldly. The chief gift that the Apostles offered was not a better, more comfortable life in this world, but an entrance into heaven. In 1923, Machen wrote in his classic book, Christianity and Liberalism, In Christian life, there are things that we would like to see removed.

    There are fears within, as well as fighting without. Even within the Christian life, there are sad evidences of sin. But according to the hope which Christ has given us, there will be final victory. The struggles of this world will be followed by the glories of heaven. That hope runs all through Christian life. Christian life is not engrossed by this transitory world that measures all things by the thought of eternity.

    The goal of the Christian life, Machen went on to say, is another world, a heavenly one, in which believers will enjoy eternal communion with God and with his Christ.” Two years later, in his book, What is Faith?, Machen would write these words, “…at the very heart of the Christian religion is the hope of heaven. Man’s chief end is not merely to enjoy God, rather to glorify God and enjoy Him, but it is to glorify God and enjoy Him forever.

    Still, even given this emphatic sincerity expressed in these statements, Their value for Machen remained somewhat abstract and theoretical, and lay at the level of the rhetorical and the systematical. Let me explain this. Even given the emphatic sincerity expressed by Machen in these comments, The doctrine of heaven for him was as yet remote. It was judged essential, and if you read the context in which these quotes appear, it becomes apparent to you, this doctrine was judged essential in the interest of presenting a full-orbed supernatural Christianity over against the anti-supernaturalistic liberals. At the same time, this interest in the hope of heaven was always to be kept within the confines of an equal playing field for all doctrines in the systematical and balanced exposition of Christian theology. In other words, a fair reading of Machen’s comments suggests this. The doctrine of heaven, the hope of heaven, enjoyed in Machen but a momentary rhetorical elevation that it did not have consistently in his life and in his reflection. You understand what I’m saying? Nation’s not alone in this.

    He will be driven under the compulsions of Christian theology and the necessity of standing for a supernatural faith to speak very forcefully about the hope of heaven. But it yet remains somewhat abstract and theoretical, serving a rhetorical purpose. and a systematic theological end where all doctrines are leveled, they stand on an equal footing. But by the end of Nathan’s life, he would know truly that at the very heart of Christianity is the hope of heaven. He would know better than ever before to measure things not just by the thought of eternity, but by its reality, its real and gracious presence with and in the believer. But eternity and heaven in the Orthodox Christian sense of the word even rhetorically and systematically considered, was not much on people’s minds in the 1920s and the 1930s. By and large, they were preoccupied with a worldliness that expressed itself in a spirit of growing nationalism.

    And that made it something that was particularly difficult to deal with, for how do you speak ill of your country? How do you speak ill of your nation? How do you distance yourself from the solid so-called Christian convictions that seem to be now implanted in and seem to be influencing the culture of which you are a part?

    While it is true that the thought of eternity and the heavenly other world had not yet received their full existential power in Machen, he was sufficiently alert in 1920 to recognize just how antithetical the gospel and its promise of glory were to the prevailing mood.

    In the same letter to his mother we quoted earlier, he went on to say, the gospel of Christ is a blessed relief from that sinful state of affairs commonly known as 100% Americanism. See, I warned you. This isn’t going to be easy. Now, it’s one thing to write such things in a private letter to your mother. It’s quite another thing to step into the parlor of one of America’s most venerable institutions and say them.

    But that’s exactly what Machen had done eight months previous, on May 6, 1919, during the graduation ceremonies at Princeton Theological Seminary. He had just returned from France, and from his involvement in the war effort, that’s the First World War, while in the employ of the YMCA. He was then present at Princeton for those graduation ceremonies, to speak to the subject, The Church in the War.

    And in that address, he voiced his extreme grief that the real winner in the war was a very sophisticated, ever-so-polite American paganism, at the center of which stood an uncritical veneration an uncritical veneration of, if not a worship of, the nation itself. Here was a religion commending itself as a, quote, healthy and harmonious and joyous development of human faculties, unquote. A religion preaching a profound satisfaction with human goodness and the inherent merit of one’s own self-sacrifice.

    Rather than singing, there was no other good enough to pay the price of sin, instead of resting in the utterly unique and gracious sacrifice of Christ as the only hope for sinners, 100% Americanism taught that every American, every American as particularly seen in the American troops returning from Europe, could do more than enough to secure his soul against any threat.

    Now please understand, Machen meant no disrespect to the returning soldiers. He meant no disrespect to those who had given their lives in World War I. He considered himself a patriot, a man who loved his country with binding obligations to this nation. Otherwise, he would not have volunteered for service during the war. and he was convinced that the Allies must win that conflict. At the same time, Manchin was no supporter of what he called 100% Americanism and its tidal wave of post-World War I American euphoria. that found the United States puffing and blowing with ecstatic self-confidence.

    In this setting, as Machen knew, the biblical gospel of broken-hearted sinners saved by grace through faith in Jesus Christ would be at best only tolerated and at worst judged impertinent, not just by American society. but by the American Church held firmly within the grip of that society. This point has been proven true. Despite America and America’s religious establishment’s seemingly insatiable appetite for religion, and for religious success stories, and for the sentimental, moralistic Christianity of headliner evangelists. American society knows, after all, that such things as these cannot really challenge it at its root. They are no threat. They are absolutely no threat. After all, following World War I, all real Americans were agreed.

    The USA was undoubtedly the dominant world power. Our ingenuity, our industry, our practical scientific aptitude, our collective heroism had beaten the Huns, bringing to an end European insanity, something that they could not bring to an end themselves. And now we, we, were responsible for making the world safe for democracy. If German and English historians like Spengler and Toynbee wanted to talk about the decline or the end of the West, they obviously hadn’t looked West far enough. One thing was certain, Americans would never again bow and scrape before European pretensions. We were free now, yes, free at last, from our dependence upon the old world. In fact, now the old world, the European world, depended on us. They couldn’t bring the conflict to an end by themselves. We had to do it.

    True superiority, therefore, was not to be found in age-old museums, mausoleums, and cathedrals, in finery and manors preserved under glass, all which had been corrupted, we knew, by generations of inbreeding among profligate royalty, effete artists, and effeminate clergymen.

    The United States was a nation of robust, efficient common sense, fresh and unencumbered in its pursuits. Backed by its unparalleled wealth and its appropriately pragmatic civic-minded religion, the United States had become the measure for humanity. Here was the world’s best hope, a hope effectively reinforced in the American populace through catechizing in the standards of American life by governmental agencies and by other genuine American institutions, such as the Church.

    Fill in the blank there, please. The Church. After all, the Church now knew its true role. The Church was the priest of culture, sanctifying and reinforcing community and national values. Thus it is that our nation would be prepared. Don’t stop at this. This is what was being said. Our nation was prepared to accomplish its mandated moral mission.

    The realization of not just the better life, but of the best life, the veritable kingdom of God on Earth. And who but we could bring the best life to the world since we already had the best government in our democratic organization and system, the best economics in our respect for nature’s control over monetary matters, and the best moral fiber as proved by the fact that we now had the 18th Amendment.

    You’re thinking, what was the 18th Amendment? Prohibition! Prohibition. The Prohibition Party, interestingly organized in 1869, the date upon which, or the year in which, the old school and the new school got back together in Presbyterianism. That party was triumphant in 1919, and in 1920, the Wallstead Act was enacted. The 18th Amendment, Prohibition.

    Could there be any question about it? The best moral fiber in the world. Certainly not tainted. In fact, our task in bringing the best life to the world is made all the easier. Because all of the nations will naturally envy us. Certainly they will want to be just like us. And if they don’t, they ought to.

    Well, as you can well imagine, not everyone was standing to salute this expression of 100% Americanism. Least of all, J. Grissom Mitchell. But it’s at this point that things become very, very complex. Because it is imperative that we be very careful in deciding why Machen would not stand to salute 100% Americanism. There have been many people who have interpreted Machen along a particular line that is particularly useful to them. So. Buckle up for the ride here we go. Why was it that nation could not stand and salute one hundred percent American. Well it certainly was not because he stood for the cause of the so-called non enfranchised. Now I mean no disrespect here. It was not because he stood. For the cause of the immigrant laboring class. May disturb you that I talk like that. that there is a certain class consciousness that was very much at play in the last century and in the early parts of this century in America.

    These were the displaced people, in effect, spokesmen for whom were by and large the crusading trade unions. To be sure, Machen would vote for the Roman Catholic and Democrat Al Smith in 1928. Herbert Hoover, just like many of those displaced people.

    And he would not only oppose, but he would outrightly attack Prohibition, just as many of those more recent arrivals from Europe did. He would even champion bilingual education in ethnic communities where these displaced people settled, and that in the interest of keeping the government off their backs.

    But despite these intersections, Machen could not identify with the class struggle, collective, even socialist consciousness of these people. Nor did he have any sympathy with that wing of the church that promoted a brand of Christianity particularly tailored to these people, their needs, and their desires. He therefore rejected the social gospel. He recognized the social gospel’s this-world eschatology, and repudiated that gospel’s agenda for the realization of its hopes through government-mandated social transformation. away from the non-enfranchised. But very importantly, neither was Machen a friend of the arrogant, anti-establishment crowd of the upper crust.

    You know who I’m talking about. It is true that many of these people came from the same social circles in which Machen himself He had been raised in the best of Baltimore society, that was his hometown. At the time, Baltimore was considered the cultural gem of America. And it is true, as historian Gerald Hart has pointed out, that Machen grew up a scamp, a mischievous prankster. devoted to his personal freedom and to having one royal good time.

    That’s why you have to take some of Stonehouse’s biography with a grain of salt. Nietzsche was, of course, brilliant. He was even a genius. who was able to breeze through the most advanced education and never compromise his basic commitment to fun. At the same time, there was even a more basic commitment for him in the Christianity revered by his family, especially by his mother, for he had been schooled in the scriptures and in the Westminster catechism from his youth.

    And although this instruction was filtered through a very broad social, even societal and cultural, and upper-crust vision, and although this instruction was tried and tested By Machen’s frequent flippancy, Machen himself was constantly monitored by that gospel that stood at the center of this instruction which he had received from his home and by the gospel’s true doctrine of liberty.

    But those who were nation’s social equals, those members of the arrogant anti-establishment crowd, loved license, not liberty. They took advantage of their parents, their own, and the nation’s wealth. and the general pursuit of the better life to promote the high life and the most decadent, self-centered, irresponsible social behavior. They were possessed of a hardened cynicism and expressed contempt for what they judged America’s hypocritical, residual Puritan morality. They sneered at the outlandish claims of American Christianity or Even better, they sneered at the outlandish claims of historic Christianity, since the irrefutable certainties of modern science had disproved such nonsense, even though they had never seriously investigated either historic Christianity or modern science. They had developed a remarkable strain of adolescent self-pity which they carried with them into adulthood, blaming, of course, the First World War or anything else that was convenient, in the way in which these things had introduced them to the brevity of life and the injustice of human existence.

    If you see something of the lives of Ernest Hemingway and F. Scott Fitzgerald and the characters in their novels and short stories in all of this, you have not misunderstood. These people, more than any others, would contribute to the destruction of things during this period of time.

    They would contradict the sense and sensibility and the imagined stability of 100% Americanism in the 1920s. Because of them, the 20s became the roaring 20s. And in the words of a temporarily sobered F. Scott Fitzgerald, the wasted decade of wasted youth. It was a time ruled by a tragically offbeat and lost generation, drunk on jazz, gin, and easy sex, caught up in the gaudiest spree in history.

    And when it was over, for all the nation’s vanity, all the nation’s sanctimonious breast-thumping, all the nation’s hundred percent Americanism. This country was left with an epidemic of venereal disease, a record number of broken families, and addictions of various kinds, all sorts of untreatable neuroses, a collapsed economy, abandoned estates, and enough collective guilt to make this nation easy pickings for the social self-righteousness of FDR’s New Deal.

    Now, believe it or not, many who have wished to discredit Jay Aggressive Nation have charged that he had his roots in the morally disreputable rich upper class. Some charged him with being a drunkard, not just an anti-prohibitionist, but a drunkard. Some went even to this extent. They charged him with bisexuality. They even charged him with being a homosexual.

    But he, in actual fact, lived far from the decadence of these people. He could not be identified with the decadent rich. He was, despite all of his commitment to fun and to a good time, a trophy of God’s grace in the midst of such wickedness. but of all the groups of dissenters to 100% Americanism, Machen had the most in common not with the non-established, not with the anti-established, but with the dis-established. At the center of this group was the larger-than-life figure of H. L. Machen.

    M. E. N. C. K. E. N. The provocative journalist and editor of the Baltimore Sun.

    Mencken was a social libertarian, a rebel who waged a lifelong war of protest on behalf of the lost southern culture. He held accountable for this loss the monstrously evil northern establishment which, through the Civil War, had delivered up southern life to the ravages of Plutocrats and Protestant barbarians. particularly those barbarians that held forth in Dayton, Tennessee, and at the trial of J.T. Scope, over the issue of evolution, if I need to fill in that for you. But at this time, in the 20s and in the early 30s, the voice of the disestablished was also being heard from a group of young writers, the most famous of which was Robert Penn. It’s a smug, ugly, urban, industrialist, imperialist, bureaucratic world in life view. how much has been made of Nathan’s connection with the Southern disestablishment.

    To be sure, he was raised the fair-haired boy in Baltimore, southern town, and that within a family that felt deeply the cause of the defeated South. He carried with him the imprint of his mother’s ancestry from the state of Georgia. and was undoubtedly marked by her contempt. For all things. Yankee. She dreaded at one point making a trip to Washington D.C. because. It had statues on every corner of those Yankees.

    Machen even defended the South’s segregation position in an argument with B. B. Warfield over whether or not a black student would be admitted to Princeton Theological Seminary. Furthermore, Machen’s libertarian views in politics and in social matters have been interpreted by some as dominant in the man. Dominant in the man. and evidence that he was committed to the state’s right position of the confederacy and that was actually what he was all about.

    But it’s true as these connections. To the southern disestablishment maybe. As true as the point of contact with the non established and even the anti established tradition of the American populist may have been, the reasons why Machen did not rise and salute the flag of 100% Americanism ran much deeper than those we have just discussed. They run, in fact, as deep as the word of God. And here would be the man’s commitment in the end. Devoted to the scriptures, to the word of God, above everything else. But so deep and so profound were these reasons that they in actuality stood beyond nation’s immediate ability to grasp them.

    Nor would the reasons for the comprehensive consideration of the reasons for his refusal to stand and salute be opened up for him by way of his rational penetration of them. Such penetration would come only because of the events of his last years and his last days.

    Those events would find Machen far removed from the life of the upper class, life of the encultured Presbyterianism he knew in Baltimore, in Princeton, New Jersey, and even in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. that city to which he had come in 1929 for the purposes of opening up Westminster Theological Seminary.

    Now, in his later days, he would be defrocked from the ministry of the Peace USA, this taking place in early June 1936, and that for his failure to remove himself from the independent board of Presbyterian foreign missions, an organization that he had founded and headed in 1933 as a protest against the PCUSA’s refusal to ensure the purity of the preaching and teaching of its foreign missionaries. But further, Nathan would be betrayed by those who were closest to him, by fundamentalists within his ranks, those in the independent board and within the newly formed denomination. For in 1936, in November, he would be removed from the presidency of that independent board by a coup overseen by fundamentalist opponents who believed that he was power-hungry and getting much too much power. Interestingly, that charge came from Carl McIntyre.

    So it was that this man increasingly distressed and even despondent as he came to grips more and more with the significance of his life. and where it was that he particularly stood, and why it was he could not stand and salute 100% Americanism. Finally, he finds himself on the Dakota Plains in the dead of winter, keeping a long-standing commitment to small, struggling congregations, endeavoring to maintain their orthodoxy.

    In this setting, Machen seemed the alien, the true pilgrim. isolated from such cultural figures and forces judged prominent in the American and the American Church’s deem. And here, in a Bismarck hospital on New Year’s Day 1937, Machen died, virtually stripped of all peripheral interests and concerns. But it would be in this setting that his spirits, ironically, would rebound. and the hope of heaven would consume him. So real was heaven to Machen that he imagined himself already there.

    When Sam Allen, his friend and minister to some of those small churches in the Dakotas, came to call on him before his death, Machen said about heaven, Sam, it was glorious, it was glorious. And later, as many as you know, he dictated his telegram to John Murray. That telegram said, I’m so thankful for active obedience of Christ. No hope without it. No hope? No hope of what?

    A better or even the best world? Here? world dominance for America, the success of the cause of the South, and the triumph of an agrarian family-based society, hope for Christianity’s conquest of the globe, or even the success and survival in this world for the Orthodox Presbyterian Church? Of course not. The hope of which most nations spoke has now been divested of its theoretical, rhetorical, and systematical restraint. The heart of Christianity, the hope of heaven, the reality of eternity, had become the measure of all things. Do you see it? Do you get it?

    Nathan was being taught at the end of his life what it means to begin with the end of all things. To begin with, to start with the truth about that other world. You start with the conclusion that of grace because it is given to you. And all of this is working itself out in this man so that you might begin in the very same way.

    The Orthodox Presbyterian Church begins where Machen ended, and that is her calling and her meaning. Essentially, she has been stamped with another worldliness that transcends her cultural setting And in this position, she can hardly seek to regain the world she has lost. But in the interest of the city above, and as citizens of that city, she confesses herself to be a sojourner and Christ’s servant in and to this world. For God’s glory. Thank you. I think I’m supposed to take questions. Not that I want to. Oh, good. I’ve convinced you all. Great. All right. I should know better than to try to string this out. Did I bring that? by revivalism? Oh boy. OK, yes, I will.

    The question concerns last night’s lecture and comments that I made about revivalism. Essentially, what is revivalism? It seems that revivalism is a particularly Protestant phenomenon, not that there aren’t renewal movements in Catholicism and in Eastern Orthodoxy, but it seems that revivalism is particularly Protestant phenomenon. Generally, revivalism is traced to the 18th century and movements on the continent with within the German Lutheran state church and other places within Europe. Pockets of it, of course, rising within the Netherlands.

    The influences that came to the established church through sort of non-established forms of Christianity. So in that, there was a certain movement away from the particulars of doctrine and dogmatics, and a movement towards the experiential side of Christianity. Now, I think that Presbyterians historically have contended that proper religion is always a matter of heartfelt devotion to Christ and a passion for God. I would judge that the Puritans themselves get A pluses when it comes to the essential religious impulse. And that essential religious impulse, and we’ll be speaking about this a little bit later, is the desire for God and the delight in God himself. Now, we’re not speaking here in general religious terms. We have in mind specifically the God of the Bible, the triune God of historic Christian confession. So there was this movement, though, that of felt that the experiential side of our faith was getting short shrift.

    And there was an explosion, as you probably know, in this country in the 18th century called the Great Awakening. And basically, when Americans start talking about revival or revivalism, they have in mind something that issues forth from the Great Awakening. Now, I think that those of you who know that history pretty well realize that the Great Awakening had was something of a mixed bag, and Edwards himself recognized that.

    As far as it involved the Presbyterians, you had the extreme statements made by people like Gilbert Tenet, who was basically writing a number of ministers out of the church because of his interest in revival, and he couldn’t find the spark of spiritual life, at least in his estimation, in these people and in their congregations, so he, in effect, wrote them off. That led to the old side-new side split in the Presbyterian Church in the 1700s. The revivalism or the revival of the 18th century, many have contended, was essentially Calvinistic, influenced by the figures of Edwards and Whitfield.

    So they feel confident with the theology, at least with the soteriology of these gentlemen. There was another side, of course, to the revival, and that was John Wesley. And that was decidedly, at least on paper, at least in the expressions of Wesley, anti-Calvinist.

    So you have this mixture. And historically, Presbyterians have not been unanimous in their support even of Edwards and Whitfield. That’s also true I would be on it would be unfair to say that you know all Presbyterians are solid behind Edwards and Whitfield in fact there were questions raised at Princeton Seminary in the next century about the legacy of the Great Awakening and Edwards owned theology. There were questions they didn’t dismiss him but there were questions.

    Now, out of this grows a particular way of looking at the church. For instance, your tried and true Presbyterians, they certainly don’t have the names like those who were so instrumental in the great awakening of the 18th century. Your tried and true Presbyterians were going in the direction of nurture. Revivalism was going in the direction of special occasion. You see what’s happening?

    In the solid, you know, these are sort of pejorative terms, I realize that. In the solid historic Presbyterian movement, there was the concern and the interest for a solid, biblically based Christian education. which was always there, which was constant, which was always beating at you, or encouraging you, or nurturing you, or building you up in the fellowship of the Church. In that environment, there was always an assumption that was being made, and not an ill-founded assumption. The ministers in the Church along those lines would look at their congregations and they would say, the best of them now, the best of them, not being presumptuous, they would say, I am bound by the word of God to treat these people as the people of God. I have to address them as Christians.

    Now the revivalist mentality comes in and it is taking exception. It is taking exception to the nurture framework, what some in the Presbyterian world would have called the covenantal structure of things. And so now the appeal is made to the occasional intrusion of the Spirit of God. See the difference? One is the constant nurturing, the other now begins to rely upon the sudden intrusion of the Spirit into the affairs of the Church, into the affairs of the community, into the affairs of the world.

    So, then you move that from the camp meeting, or out on the hillside where the revival is taking place, back into the pulpit. And you have The minister standing in the pulpit now, like Kenneth and others, who are suggesting that no, these people in front of me are not Christians and they must be converted. They are objects then of the evangel in its most preliminary expression. They must be brought to faith. they must be converted.

    So you begin to make your assumptions from that point of view, and you begin to treat the people as if they are not in the faith. So this is not to discount, please understand, this is not to discount the sincerity, the integrity, of the genuineness of those who were involved with the Great Awakening and the great spiritual concern that they had for those who were about them. And it is not to question the integrity of their faith in any way, it’s not to question even the validity of the conversions, some of the conversions that took place under them. But I think that some of you know that Edwards had to distance himself from some of that before his death, just so deliberately.

    But that gets you, hey, this is a complete, this is another lecturer. You’ll learn to ask questions of me. We haven’t gotten to the 19th century, but of course, it’s in the 19th century. Just to finish up, just to cap the thing a bit. Many of you are aware of what happened in the 19th century with revivalism and with the second Great Awakening. things are fairly desperate because you have at the center of this movement a figure like Charles Finney, who repudiates his Calvinism, repudiates his Presbyterianism, and looks upon them as a drag upon his effectiveness, and launches out into his program, which is not just spiritual revival, it is national and cultural revival. It is the transformation of society. That is what Finney is interested in. Out of that comes the subsequent movements where you have the revivalists at the end of the century, Dwight L. Moody, you move into the Billy Sunday era, you move into the Billy Graham era.

    Now it is, as Ian Murray has rightly pointed out, you’re dealing with contrivance now. You’re dealing with things that are manufactured. This is a science, Ren. The Holy Spirit is actually now bound to technology. And he cannot move without it. In fact, it’s probably impossible for the spirit to move without a particular pulpit that is measured. Most of us who are reformed conviction are distancing ourselves now from the aftermath. But many of us are very sincere in endeavoring to hold on to what we see as genuine religious and Christian impulse in the 18th century. And I respect that. I want you to know that. What do you guys act like a team or something. What is the tag team. Did she touch you. Yeah OK.

    Well it certainly isn’t the case to me and Murray. And Ian Murray has just written this book, and he’s fighting a good fight for how he understands genuine revival. And you must see that that is very much at the heart of the Banner of Truth Trust. I’ve subscribed to Banner of Truth. I have for years. I want you to know. Some of my best friends are. And I love Ian Murray, don’t get me wrong, he’s a great tree office man.

    But the difficulty is with the revival interest as it is with the other, what I call the other R’s. The whole list of R’s. You have revival amongst typically evangelical Protestants. You have renewal among Episcopalians. You have reformation with some Calvinistically informed individuals. You have reconstruction. You see all the list of orders.

    Isn’t it interesting that all of them come See, the difficulty for the R’s is this, the danger in the R’s is that you set for yourself a remedy for all of our ills that come short of the real R, the return of Christ. And all the years now I’ve been reading Banner of Truth and Of course, I’ve written some letters to Ian Murray to talk a little bit through the mails, not directly, but through the mails. But the interest seems to be in revival in some sense as an end in itself.

    And that cannot be. It plays itself out, I think, unfortunately, when it comes to the matter of a serious approach to church discipline, which works very well with the nurture idea of the church. Well, you know how it goes. I mean, churches that are into nurture are boring. They’re boring. My church is boring.

    I’m being facetious, but I think that you know what I mean. I mean, people look at it as if with this constant, continual, level approach to things that nothing’s happening. When in fact, a very great deal is happening. Taking care of people, being involved with their lives, overseeing them, helping them, kindly, graciously correcting them. You’re there when the revivalist leaves. You continue. You pick up the pieces. You continue to minister. I think that’s where a real church and the church’s real work is to be found. Now does anyone want to fight? The time for us to take our coffee break now, we have a table full of these guys.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Eschatology and the Shape of Office

    Eschatology and the Shape of Office

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered November 1, 1995.

    About this sermon

    Modern eschatology, from Schweitzer and Bultmann through Dodd and Cullmann, stands against the Reformed alternative of Vos, Stonehouse, and Ridderbos, with its shared sense of two overlapping ages. That eschatology bears directly on how the church understands office, old views against new. Kline’s three stages offer one attempt to work out a proper view of office.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    We thank you, our God, for your work in us, for your mercy, for how you have blessed us. And Lord, we who fill offices in your church confess that we are unworthy of these offices. We ask, Lord, that we might see ourselves always with your grace. May you bless us, Lord, in our labors. Help us as we consider your word and your church, those that you have given to your church from time to time, even in our present circumstance. May you make profit well from the labors of God in that community. May you help us, Lord, in our service to you. that in that service we be conformed to such services as rendered in heaven above. We ask Lord for your forbearance, Lord may you bring us to that goal to which we press, even resurrection of our bodies in the day of the return of our Savior. We thank you for this time together, Lord, we look to you in it for what Jesus said.

    I’d like to get in an advertisement right now. I continue to push this little journal, Carrots, and if you don’t subscribe, you may want to. It is improving over the years and I think the discussion is getting to be raised up a few notches. We want to find out how to get it. Three issues appear. I hope that some of you are still engaged in theological reflection and inquiry. I’m different than Mark Brown. He dresses better than I do. And I’m definitely different than Larry Semmel. He’s nice.

    A passage of scripture I’d like to give to you at the very beginning is Isaiah 24, verse 23, Then the moon will be abashed, and the sun ashamed, for the Lord of hosts will reign on Mount Zion and in Jerusalem, and his glory will be before his elders.

    Now there are many things that we might say about this verse But one thing that we might say is this, that it seems that the Lord himself desires to reveal his glory before his elders. And we could say that the plan and purpose of God is moving things to that conclusion. to that eventuality.

    With that text in mind, we begin our consideration of eschatology and office. At the beginning of my article, Worship and Office, in Mark Brown’s book Order in the Offices, I made mention of Paul Woolley’s comment to his students at the end of the 60s about the future of theological study. He stated that future theological study would concentrate upon the doctrines of the church and eschatology. My article of two years ago was what I called a lesser contribution to the discussion in which I hope for better integration one day of these two great doctrines. What I have to say today is another lesser contribution. In the interests of this grander enterprise, I believe awaits some remarkable individual or individuals the Lord is pleased as yet to raise up.

    Let me start my comments about eschatology this way. To say the least, there has been a radical shift in the last century when it comes to the subject of eschatology. Negatively speaking, this redirection has come about because of, one, the modern antipathy towards the supernatural. And secondly, because of the exhaustion and frustration in the Church over the failed schemes of 19th century millennialism and the fantastical schemes of the cults. But more positively, this shift was the result. Some would call this positive. More positively, this shift has been because of a more studied look at the scriptures when the subject of eschatology is considered.

    This shift was the result of a growing suspicion about the adequacy of the traditional systematic theological format. with its concentration upon the logical ordering of the categories in the dogmatics. More pressing, however, in the area of sophisticated theological discussion, was the collapse of the liberal view of Jesus and its Pompeian conviction that Christianity, after all, equals the heavens.

    Men in the last century like Wilhelm Rehde, Johann Weiss are important in this regard, but in this century also the figure of Albert Schweitzer. These men, Schweitzer included, recognized that the apocalyptic in the biblical record is anything but marginal or superficial. as the liberals had been content. Schweitzer’s consistent eschatology approach to the New Testament, in his estimations, rescued Jesus from liberal misinterpretations, but then delivered him into the apocalyptic eagers of first century Messianism, with its overactive interest in imminent eschatological events. But the question now became, given Schweitzer’s approach, what do you do with this bizarre, apocalyptically informed and dominated Galilean?

    If eschatology is central to Jesus’ self-consciousness, how do we in the 20th century relate to such extremism? Schweitzer answered that contrary to liberal opinion, we must look to Jesus’ eschatological interest for the timeless and the eternal. That the historical Jesus had expectations of the immediate catastrophic arrival of the kingdom of God, and died in Schweitzer’s estimation, a disappointed man, makes no difference whatsoever. The important thing is the impact of the eschatological habit of mind on Jesus’ behavior and on the behavior of those who would claim to be followers of Jesus.

    Only such a habit of mind can appreciate the power of Jesus’ world-negating ethic and its freedom from the world-accepting and self-protective habits of modern theology and the Protestant establishment. Schweitzer’s flight to Africa and his work in medicine there are consistent with his reading of the Gospels and of the life of Jesus. With eschatology redefined and made all the more insistent now in its demands, battles over eschatology erupted in this century.

    At the center of those battles stood the imposing figure of Rudolf Bultmann. Bultmann very bluntly said, the mythical eschatology is untenable for the simple reason that the perusy of Christ never took place as the New Testament expected. History did not come to an end, and as every schoolboy knows, it will continue to run its course. The world will come to an end by a natural catastrophe, not by a mythical event as the New Testament expects. But while rejecting the particulars of New Testament eschatology, Bultmann labors as the Schweitzer to salvage the category of eschatology.

    He therefore redefines eschatology as an event in which man encounters the truth of his own existence. Such an encounter confronts man with the continual end of an old world and the beginning of a new. There is no future conservation. There is only the existential realization of consummation as man comes to understand that he is placed before a decision for the future every moment of his life. Here, according to Bultmann, is genuine eschatology. And from his point of view, here and only here is found true freedom, true human freedom.

    C. H. Dodd accepted Bultmann’s conviction that the world will not end as the Bible describes. And he agreed with Bultmann that eschatology has nothing to do with last things, or with the end of the world.

    But while for Bultmann the kingdom in Jesus’ preaching is holy future, according to Dodd it is holy present. God’s famous book, The Parables of the Kingdom, written in 1958, sets forth what he calls realized eschatology. The view that Jesus’ language, while clothed in apocalyptic fantasy, means to call attention to the genuine experience of the eternal in the here and now. What references, therefore, we might find in the Gospels to the future of the kingdom are either interpolations by the first century church to meet its own eschatological crisis, or they are texts that have simply been misunderstood. For Jesus, according to God, the kingdom was wholly spiritual.

    A perspective which Herman Ritterboss has pointed out, not far removed from the old liberal point of view. In the middle of this debate, both chronologically and theologically, stands Oscar Kuhlman, whose book, Christ and Time, appeared in 1945. For Kuhlman, Christ is the so-called midpoint of history. There he is. Jesus’ message announces the kingdom’s presence but also anticipates its future appearance in an already not yet tension. We might resonate to that kind of language.

    But does this orthodox sounding analysis of Jesus’ message from Kuhlman present a real alternative in the discussions that we have been reviewing thus far? Kuhlman admits that linear time is only background to what is really important, namely the present-future tension, the already-not-yet tension. But consider, if linear time is reduced to background, What about the reality and importance of linear time’s movement to a definitive conclusion? Kuhlman may well be in reaction to modern theology’s removal of the end-of-the-world doctrine from its catalogue of accepted doctrines, but is he any more committed to the end of the world as axiomatic? It appears not.

    And when he goes to work on the already and not tension, already not yet tension, and the present future tension of our existence, it becomes a construct just as philosophical as Bultmann’s eschatological moment, eschatological event, and God’s spiritualized pain. You may want to look at what Dr. Van Til has to say about Kuhlmann. In his book, The Great Debate Today, pages 33 through 42, he looks at Kuhlman and Sundell. To summarize, despite the intense debate, those most directly involved in the recent discussions about eschatology are agreed on two things.

    First of all, Eschatology is not about last things. It is not about the end of the world. Instead, it is about ultimate things. Those things that are most meaningful. In fact, an eschatology that insists upon talking about a literal end of the world, be it from Jesus or anyone else, is primitive, unscientific, and unacceptable. and as contradictory as it may sound, eschatology is at the center of New Testament consciousness. To be true to this consciousness and to humanity’s greatest interest, because eschatology is about ultimate concerns here, the Church must retranslate the New Testament’s primitive eschatology and place that retranslation at the heart of her life and teaching.

    It is in this context that a number of figures from within Reformed Orthodoxy, and especially from within the Westminster seminary tradition, have made great contributions. Coming to mind is Gerhardus Voss, who was not teaching at Westminster, he was the teacher of teachers at Westminster. There is also Ned B. Stoneman. There’s Edmund D. Clowney, Meredith Klein, Richard Gamble. And of great significance and related to this constellation is, of course, Herman Ritterbos from the Netherlands.

    All of these scholars have been deeply influenced by this 20th century debate and have concluded that eschatology, yes, is at the center of biblical This conclusion has been pursued in the interest of a biblical theological redemptive historical commitment with the result that biblical theology and its eschatological concern have now brought tremendous pressure to bear upon the traditional systematic theological enterprise and its typical discussions on and positioning of eschatology.

    For example, Voss’s insight that the historical precedes the theological is something of a bombshell from certain points of view. His insight that eschatology precedes soteriology is equally a bombshell in some sense. insights have become linchpins to this approach, this biblical, theological, and eschatological concern for you.

    As a result of these assertions, many have felt the pressure on the traditional scheme, and have responded in uncertainty and even in open hostility. Some have suggested that Voss and company are merely playing off of and into the hands of the modernist agenda. But in all fairness, it is important to acknowledge how hard Voss and these others have fought against the modernist impulse and position. To begin with, they insist on the biblical doctrine of the end of this world order by God’s direct action.

    The contrast of Voss’s and Kuhlman’s famous diagrams illustrates the point. And I put them up here so that you can see them. I’m talking about Voss number one and Kuhlman down here. Voss’s diagram anticipates a literal end point. Kuhlman’s does not. There’s no end to this line. Don’t think there’s an end to the line.

    Also, the Reformed biblical theologians insist on the present interaction between the present world and the real substantive world to come. As well as, for the saints, a participation in that higher heavenly world now. Again, the contrast between Voss and Pullman is significant. Boss’s vertical interest clearly comes through in his diagram. We are in contact with the higher heavenly world. This is also apparent in Boss 2, or the diagram from the book on Hebrews. The heavenly reality has now intruded into our circumstance and in our New Testament setting.

    At the same time, it must not be forgotten that Vos saw himself, speaking of him particularly, these others included, Vos saw himself as defending Reformed Orthodoxy. And although judged innovative by some, as actually reintroducing the genius of Reformed theology into the discussions taking place. Here, Vosk intended that the covenant, the Reformed faith’s contribution to the theological world, has at its center the hope of a higher eternal existence in which permanent communion with God is the greatest blessing, and that this hope belonged to man even in the garden prior to the fall. According to Voss, Reformed theology being covenantal is inherently eschatological in its most basic impulse, and particularly suited to address not only the profound meaning of scripture, but the current crisis over eschatology.

    Office. If the past hundred years have witnessed unsettling changes in the area of eschatology, what might we say about us? We’ve already heard about the changes that have come about in post-securitism. But even more extensively, the old view saw office as a unique calling grounded in God himself and especially in Jesus Christ. As God preceded and stood above the man called to fill the office, so the office itself preceded and stood above the man who came to fill it. The man had the office conferred on him. He entered the office. Such language as that reflected of his perspective.

    Many things, however, have been at work in the Church to change this point of view. For instance, notions of universal enfranchisement and general endowment have increasingly taken their toll. A few months before his death, J. Gresham Machen complained that fundamentalists held to a democratic view of office. According to Machen, fundamentalists said, any man who was washed in the blood and saved has a right to the office. Recently, Gregory Reynolds has provided a useful analysis of the democratizing trend in the Church with regard to office, and spoken of the denigration of office in connection with the democratizing trend. His study reinforces the conviction expressed by others that the roots of this phenomenon, at least in this country, are found in the emerging evangelical movement, also in the misshapen notions of the relationship of secular government to church polity, and now, most recently, in the convictions of the Charismatics. One result of the democratizing trend, especially among conservatives, has been the trivializing of office. Ordinarily imbued with dignity and commanding respect, office has become common.

    Often it is viewed as a mere formality, providing title where it is thought necessary to satisfy social and ecclesiastical customs or to provide tax benefits. But unessential for ministry. You don’t have to have office for ministry. After all, everyone has a ministry. After all, we all have ordination.

    Many conservatives have rushed to these conclusions because of their interests in greater access to the culture and greater effectiveness in church outreach. At the same time, mainline theology has been doing its part to downgrade office, and that in a way which worked well with the attitudes gaining ground among the conservatives. A growing anti- or supra-denominationalism, for example, did not help but relativize the views of church politics.

    This was, in part, Machen’s concern in his battles against the 1920 Plan of Union and against the attitudes of J. Ross Stevenson and Charles Erdmann at Princeton. Machen’s logic was simple. If the Westminster Standards are biblical and therefore true, and if the Westminster Standards teach Presbyterianism, then Presbyterianism is true and meant for the whole world. Polity questions are not up for grabs.

    But even apart from the growing anti- and supra-denominationalism, the polity issue has entered a critical phase of its history. Struggles in England in the earlier part of the century illustrate the point. As highly as the Church of England has held the office of bishop, Voices began to be heard within that church calling into question age-old fundamental convictions.

    B.H. Streeter challenged established Anglican order with his statement, there is no one form of church order which alone is primitive and which therefore possesses the sanction of apostolic precedent. A.C. Christ left the Church to organize its own form and order.

    As these statements become representative of an attitude pervasive within mainline Protestantism, they give us a fair idea of where things presently stand. Not only do Episcopal claims about apostolic succession fall to the ground, But so do any claims about the early Church’s structural uniformity. Also left out of support are those drawing upon the age-old doctrine that God had established in His Word one correct form of polity.

    Of interest in this regard, and closer to our own situation, is the statement in the PCUSA’s Confession of 1967. So says the Confession of 67. The Church orders its life as an institution with a constitution, government, officers, finances, and administrative rules.

    These are instruments of mission, not ends in themselves. Different orders have served the Gospel and none can claim exclusive belief. This statement is far distant from the commitment of historic Presbyterianism as found, for instance, in the Westminster Confession of Faith. Chapter 30, paragraph 1. The Lord Jesus, as king and head of his church, hath therein appointed a government in the hand of church offices.

    Another reason for the downgrade of office within mainline theology, at least from the Orthodox Protestant expression is the rise of existentialist interpretation. The existentialist approach builds upon the critical conclusions of the last century, particularly the views of F.C. Bauer, who died in 1860, whose influence was felt at Tübingen University. This was Bauer’s point of view. He saw the 1st century Church in terms of a collateral development of an austere, petrifying Jewish Christianity, the Thesis, and Paul’s Gentile-directed Gospel of Freedom, Antithesis. In the 2nd century, both the internal pressures from Gnosticism and external pressures from persecution forced reconciliation in the Old Catholic Church. synthesis.

    The upshot of this position is that the original liberties of Paul’s view of faith and church life were brought beneath the stifling restrictions of office and order in an emerging early Catholicism. This position has been updated now and powerfully presented in this century by Ernst Casemeyer. who had brought an existential philosophy to bear on the question of church order. Kethamon was convinced that the fact that the world did not end as the early church had hoped threw the church into an organizational crisis. As a result, Paul’s rather free and functional approach to the church’s structure was reassessed in light of the rising strength of an early Catholicist Office and church structure were objectified by that early Catholicism in a new order.

    And the spirit, by definition now, was joined to office. Office and spirit were one. Apology became a matter of what was established by an appeal to a permanently settled, definable past. Unity was mandated as an essential expression of organizational strategy.

    Over against this early Catholicism stood Paul’s gospel. The enemy of all who look to external guarantees, like order and office, for the inward realities of things. Paul’s gospel loses ground to a church that places its confidence in office, order, and tradition. Needed, says Casimani, is the proclamation of the eschatological event of the turn of the ages, or moving back to Bulgaria. Such proclamation, as takes place in the word and sacraments, calls for a decision on the part of the hearings.

    Only in the encounter, through that proclamation, is the lordship of Christ established. In fact, there’s a sense in which it is only real in that proclamation. It only exists in that proclamation. True authority only exists in the event of obedient service. And office exists only in ministry. It has no other existence. It exists only in the act of ministry.

    To summarize our discussion about office, We take note of the general drift of the Church. Traditional understanding has been subjected to radical reassessment inherent to the democratizing and anti-even supra-denominational attitudes that prevail so widely. Office loses not only its historic definition, but its definitive biblical warrant as the 20th century Church decides that the New Testament provides no settled polity. At the same time, Scripture, or at least certain portions of Scripture, from Casimond’s point of view, are claimed as normative for polity, but only insofar as order and office are juxtaposed with spirit and reinterpreted as event. Clearly, discussions about office have become quitsale. It has been noted, in the traditional Reformed and Presbyterian view, this may be the case even for ourselves in our discussions about 2 and 3 August.

    The question thus becomes one about the quest for solid ground. But in this quest, no simple appeal to the Bible will do. Such an appeal to the Bible will also have to have in view a commitment to a wider vision which rises from the Bible. And in light of that, we understand what the scriptures are saying in their totality.

    Ironically, Caseman, despite his radical reorientation, may be a felon. His attempt to bring the issues of polity into connection with the overarching eschatological interest of scripture is instructive. Not that we are interested in or believe the particulars of Casiman’s eschatology. However, in his zeal for eschatology, as that which is concerned with ultimate things, Casiman has admitted to eschatology’s pervasive reach and to the fact that it touches upon the entirety of Christian existence, even the matters of office and order. And to that extent, we should be listening. Eschatology enough.

    If Case Among is a prod for us in the providence of God, it is to the end that we would appreciate the depths and riches of our Reformed heritage and look again at those whose interest in eschatology lays before us hints of the relationship between eschatology and office. Now I say hints because there has not been as yet a thorough working out of the biblical theological redemptive historical approach to the Church and its offices, keeping in view the Bible’s eschatological interests. Many hints are found in the programmatic work of Voss. Although he does not draw out the implications explicitly for office, his insight into the eschatological character of Christian existence, our foundation.

    His work on Pauline eschatology shows that Christ’s work has in view the eschatological goal to which Christ himself is brought by his death and resurrection, and that by the spirit the believer’s union with Christ is not only unto glory with Christ in heaven, but a participation in glory in a provisional way presently. Boss’s work on Hebrews makes similar points, although here he is specifically concerned with the linear progression from the Old to the New Covenant, and to show the heavenly reality’s relationship to both of those administrations. In the Old Covenant, the heavenly reality is shadowed down. In the New, the very substance of that reality has become available or accessible through the ministry of Jesus Christ, our great and final High Priest.

    The doctrine of the Church is, of course, implied in the work Voss sets before us in his studies on Paul and on Hebrews. It is expressly considered in his study of the Kingdom of God and the Church. Once again, office does not directly enter the discussion. However, Voss is direct about the relationship of eschatology to the Church. He writes, the Church actually has within herself the powers of the world to come. She is more than the imminent kingdom as it existed before Christ’s exaltation.

    She forms an intermediate link between the present life and the life of eternity. Along these lines, Paul, rather, along these lines, Voss stated his position more fully in his biblical theology. When he wrote on Matthew 16 verses 18 through 20 and Jesus’ statement to Peter.

    This Matthew pericope, writes Voss, as little as any other New Testament passage gives countenance to the idea of the church as a mere instrument of propaganda or an institute of missions, or whatever goal to which she may stand in vital relations. The Church is all these things, but no one can truly say that these objectives are exhaustive of the purpose of existence of the Church. The conception of the thing as a mere instrument for endlessly reiterated self-reproduction is a hopeless concept in itself. For why should one exist to make others or an organism of others, in perpetuation or extension of what exists at the present time, if this process has no fixed end. This whole view is a virtual denial of the eschatological setting of biblical religion.

    The Church was born in and stands in the sign of consummation and rest, as well as of motion. She consists not of mere doing, but likewise of fruition. And this fruition pertains not exclusively to the future. It is the most blessed part of the present life. And the best proof for the Church as an end in itself lies in the inclusion of the Church in the eschatological world. For that world is not the world of things aimed at, but of things attained unto.

    Drawing from these sources, Porbos’ view of eschatology we are able to summarize his position under two rubrics. First, the category of motion, which would be inclusive of the redemptive historical movement from promise to fulfillment and from the Old Testament to the New, and the consummating movement from this world to the next. The second heading is the category of the consummate world itself, or better, the heavenly reality. which intrudes upon the present life of the Church from the future, but also provides the pattern and substance from that heavenly world for the Church’s enjoyment and well-being present.

    It has remained to others besides Voss to work with these categories when it comes to the relationship of office and eschatology and the bearing that they have on the Church’s life as a whole. Edmund P. Clowney. has written extensively on the doctrine of the Church from a Biblical theological point of view. He has stressed the eschatological character of the Church as the assembly of the Lord, the body of Christ, the fellowship of the Spirit. And he is very much aware of how the Church, through the work of Christ and the blessing of the Spirit, comes into possession of heavenly realities and is made heir of God.

    Thus far, Clowney’s position builds well on that second category that we mentioned above, that of the consummate world and the heavenly reality. But when it comes to office, the emphasis shifts for Clowney. It will fall on the first category, that of motion, as the Church moves toward her goal in ministry. To be sure, Clowney sees all the offices grounded in Christ. But his interest is as these offices are effective for the ministry of the Church in the areas of worship, edification, and evangelization. In other words, if they are useful for the Church in making progress toward her goals in this world.

    Clowney’s labors have been greatly beneficial. He has self-consciously built upon Voss for the purpose of bringing the biblical, theological, and eschatological structure of revelation to bear upon the matters of the Church, its life, and its offices. But as yet, Clowney has not related these matters fully to the second category which we cited earlier, namely, the category of the Consonant World and the Heavenly Reality. The individual who has begun to move us in this direction, his narrative Klein lays out the intratestimental development in his book, The Structure of Biblical Forging, written in 1972. Klein observes that each testament develops along a similar line.

    Looking at the Old Testament, we see first the people of God constituted under a mediator during the days of the redemption from Egypt. the wilderness wanderings, and the transjordan conquests. Next, we see the people temporarily under charismatic leadership in the period of Joshua and the Judges. The third stage finds the people established in the land as the administration of the Old Testament kingdom takes on a sense of finality and permanence. The temple and the institutions of the kingdom speak of permanence, They speak of a settledness, and as such, they speak to us about eternity. They bear the stamp of eternity. These three stages anticipate what comes in the New Testament.

    Here we witness again the formative stage in the Gospel narratives in which Jesus Christ is the final mediator, and he appears as God’s great work of redemption is consummated in him. Next comes the period of charismatic leadership, which is temporary, a period of church expansion under the apostles when the Spirit’s special gifts abound. This period is covered in the Acts of the Apostles and evidenced in certain of Paul’s letters. Finally, there takes shape the stable, permanent stage of church order, which is reflected in a number of bridge documents as you move from apostolic to post-apostolic. Not that The pastoral epistles are post-apostolic, but they are anticipating the transition.

    Made all the more obvious to us from Klein’s presentation should be the interconnectedness of the Old and New Testaments. Increasingly clear should be the validity of those arguments that insist upon Old Testament roots to New Testament authors. Our Presbyterian forebears, the Westminster Divines, lacked the finely developed big biblical theological sensitivities of Dr. Klein, but they hardly missed the point when they, without embarrassment or hesitation, grounded the office of the New Testament ministry in the Old Testament priesthood. And also look to the Old Testament elder as the precursor to the New Testament church government. but more to the point of our argument.

    The development marked out by Klein carries us toward that which is permanent, and in its New Testament expression, that which uniquely conveys the substance of the heavenly eschatological order. However, the question now becomes, has not the heavenly eschatological order always been there? preceding and even providing pattern and in the end supplying substance to things here on earth. Particularly now the church in its redemptive historical contest. Klein moves us towards this consideration in his book Images of the Spirit, 1980. His thesis is this.

    Genesis 1-2 introduces the theophonic glory cloud into the creational account with the words, the Spirit of God hovered over the face of the waters. The spirit glory cloud provides the heavenly paradigm for the creation itself and also for the creation of man, thus linking them and creation to the heavenly archetype.

    In the fallen world, the glory cloud revisits the earth in the exodus again bringing order to God’s redeemed people and restoring the image, provisionally now, typically, in the glowing face of Moses, the investiture of Aaron, and subsequently in the exaltation of the king and the commissioning of the prophets. With the New Testament, what has been anticipated in the Old Testament is realized in Christ, who is himself the spirit glory cloud incarnate.

    He becomes, in his service and by his death and resurrection, the fulfillment of Old Testament types seen in the Old Testament temple and sacrifices, the realization of all of the offices that preceded and the center of God’s new creation. The client’s position moves us toward equally profound conclusions when we look at the Church specifically, and ask the question, is there a session in heaven? rooted in God, rooted in his triune nature, but also coming to expression in the divine counsel of the Lord which he convenes with his angelic hosts. Is not the earthly gathering of church rulers derivative of and correspondent to a heavenly gathering? will not the earthly assembly, created in the spirit, in its order and offices, find its origin and counterpart in heaven. The parallel of Old Testament and New Testament order, therefore, is because they derive from the same heavenly source, with the New Testament order more glorious because it is, as Vos has said, the heavenly reality actually manifesting itself in the earth. the Old Testament order being merely shouted.

    How exalted, then, the Church, even her order and her officers, become by the grace of God. Christ declares His Church to be with Him of the eternal order. It is His Church, He tells us, And he also tells us that the gates of hell shall not prevail against him. And in its authoritative use of the keys of the kingdom of heaven, the Church finds the bond between its earthly decisions and the decisions of the heavenly consorts. But even more glorious is the Church, its order, and its offices.

    For it seems that the Church is more dear to God than the angelic assembly and its council that is convened above. When Moses, Aaron, and the elders of Israel in Exodus 24 climb that mountain, and there behold God with the cavemen of Sapphire beneath his feet, and there eat and drink in his presence, it is as if a displacement has occurred. The earthly order with its offices is derived from the heavenly pattern to be sure, but it is destined to be brought to a position higher than the angelic assembly with its elements. Indeed, he did not subject to angels a world to come.

    And do you not know, you shall judge Thank you. We come to the end of our study. It has been preliminary. It has been suggested. It is hardly satisfying. But hopefully we have learned and have been reminded of our reformed faith. That it is wonderfully able to address the present day struggles of our Prescottology. In fact, it is especially equipped to elevate the discussion.

    With a firm grip on the biblical view of history and on heaven to which history answers, we know that eschatology is about, yes, ultimate things, but it’s also about last things, and the last things that are first things. But with our reformed faith and our convictions, we are prepared to deal with the relationship of ultimate things, life’s purpose. As far as office is concerned, we know better than to oppose order to order, office to spirit. Also in the quest to find solid ground in the discussions about office and refine We most certainly know to look to the scriptures. We are not so naive to think that consideration of scripture can be pursued apart from commitment to the scripture’s own overarching structure and principle.

    In this, we are also engaged in and elevating our discussion. Therefore, finally, it is my hope that in taking stock of the Bible’s overarching structure and interest even its eschatological concern, we would keep in mind that heavenly end to which we press, and that that heavenly end to which we press, by grace, is already given to us as the means by which we make our journey to our glorious end. This is the way it is, in order that it might be all of grace. Particularly when applied to the Church and to Church order, there stands above us the heavenly original, by which we are brought to our exalted position, yes, touching it already, and in time into glory.

    Knowing that, in glory, we who are in and with the twenty-four elders will fall down before God and before the Lamb, cast our crowns before him, having led all creation in this consummate course, blessing and honor, glory and power be unto him that sitteth upon the throne and unto the Lamb forever and ever. In that day, we also will know how much God has desired to display His glory in its full and perfect radiance before His elders in the heavenly Zion and in the heavenly Jerusalem.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Machen and Tragedy

    Machen and Tragedy

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered November 1, 1995.

    About this sermon

    J. Gresham Machen’s genuine admiration for the Christian Reformed Church sits alongside the OPC’s own early, difficult years between 1936 and 1962, caught between fundamentalism and a Kuyperian alternative represented by the clash of McIntyre and Kuyper’s own heirs. Secularism’s advance forms the pressure both movements were reacting against. Machen’s own end is read as tragedy in the full sense, more than an unfortunate ending.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    I’m not sure it would be correct to describe these as our annual lectures. We have these lectures on a more ad hoc basis, but I’m glad to see among those who are here this afternoon not only our students and faculty, but some ministers from the area and other interested friends. I trust that the time that we spend together will be profitable, and the lecture that will be given will be helpful to us as well in learning something of the history of Christ’s particular, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church in the twentieth century.

    Before I say anything further by way of introduction and description of the lectures, I believe it would be good for us to pause and ask the Lord’s blessing in prayer. Let us pray. Our Father in Heaven, we thank you, Father, that as we have assembled together, we may assemble in the confidence that Jesus Christ has been seated upon your right hand, that he who is the head and king of the Church, who rules over all things for the sake of the Church, watches over us even now as we’ve gathered here. We thank you that as we’ve come, we may hear this afternoon from one of your servants, Reverend Dennison, as he speaks to us about the history and developments within that part of Christ’s Church known as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church in the 20th century in North America. We pray, Father, that the instruction we receive through him may be helpful to us may give us a better understanding of the progress and developments and the life of your Church so that we may take to heart and learn how we may be faithful in our time in the ministry of your word among your people and among the Churches. We pray then that in all things what we do here this afternoon may bring praise and glory to your name, that it may be helpful to us and better equip us for the work of the ministry in and among the Churches of which we are members. keep sin from us in the thoughts of our hearts, the words that we speak. May all that we do bring praise to your name. We ask this in Jesus’ name, amen.

    Before I introduce Rev. Denison to you this afternoon, I think it would be good for me to say a little bit about the format for the lectures this year. Rev. Denison will be giving three as we term the more academic lectures, the first of which he is giving this afternoon, now at two, and two additional lectures tomorrow. The first one will be at 830, and the second one will be at 10 o’clock. Those lectures, the one this afternoon as well, will be addressed specifically to the history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church in North America. He will also be giving this evening in the First Christian Reformed Church of Sheldon a more popular lecture. to which you are all, of course, encouraged and warmly invited to come. It will be at 7.30 at the First Christian Reformed Church, and that lecture will be addressed with the theme, What is the Gospel? His lecture this afternoon is entitled, Tragedy, the OPC Struggle with Fundamentalism in the 1930s.

    So he is going to trace out for us something of the origins, the beginnings of the Orthodox I won’t say anything more about the precise content of what he has to say. He knows that much better than I, and I don’t wish to steal from him anything that he might have to say.

    I don’t know Reverend Dennison that well personally, and so I can only introduce him in a somewhat formal way, but I hope that through his lectures and the time that he spends among us, we may also get to know him as well as a brother in the Lord and a pastor in the Church. is a pastor-historian. He is a graduate of Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia. He is also presently the pastor of an Orthodox Presbyterian Church at Sewickley, Pennsylvania. Reverend Dennison is not only a pastor, he happens also to be the, and I’m not sure what that means exactly in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church circles, but he’s the official church historian, I’m told, of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. And it’s in that capacity in part that he edited two books on the history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, the first of which is entitled The Orthodox Presbyterian Church, 1936-1986, and another volume, Pressing Toward the Mark.

    And so I believe it’s a privilege of ours to have him with us to speak on this subject that is close to him and one concerning which he knows, I think, a great deal, and I hope and trust that we will be profited and assisted by his I think it would be well for me to just put some dates in front of you and make a few comments at the beginning.

    One is 1881, and that would be the birth year of J. Gresson Machen, 1881. Another, 1929, the date of the founding of Westminster Seminary in Philadelphia under Machen and others. 1933, the date for the founding of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions, one of the interesting chapters in church history in the twentieth century. So those three dates.

    Also an explanation of some acronyms. You have OPC, Orthodox Presbyterian Church. I think that some of you are aware that that has not always been the name of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. You see, we were the original PCA. but nonetheless the PCA, the Presbyterian Church of America from 1936 to 1939 before the courts of the land forced us to change our name. I’ll be using OPC throughout the lectures just so that you understand that in those years in which we weren’t really the OPC, we were the OPC. You might also want to take note of the PCUSA.

    Those are the letters that are used to describe the large mainline Presbyterian denomination. I think you’re all aware of the difference structure-wise as we move from the Reformed to a Presbyterian context. General Assembly, Synod, Classes, Presbytery. We have Session, Consistory. Okay, you understand that those are sort of equivalent categories. I want to thank the board and faculty at MidAmerica here for their gracious invitation to me.

    I am Annalisa Ross Presbyterian and I am present here with you with a deep sense of humility. knowing the great debt the Orthodox Presbyterian Church owes to the Continental Reformed tradition, and most particularly to the Christian Reformed Church. The names Gerhardus Voss, Harvey Kuyper, Cornelius Van Till, Ned Stonehouse, all one-time members of the Christian Reformed Church, have meant much for the development of a Reformed and Presbyterian consciousness in the denomination I represent.

    It goes without saying that these are harrowing times for the world of Protestant orthodoxy. The Christian Reformed Church, traditionally strong with an exemplary history, now itself shows evidences of the extremities of our times. In many ways, the present circumstances for the CRC remind us of the fundamentalist modernist storm and stress period in American Protestantism earlier in the century. It will be remembered that the OPC, organized on June 11, 1936, was born in this earlier struggle. Nor can it be forgotten by us in the OPC how the CRC seemed the special servant of God’s Spirit to comfort and advise us.

    J. Gresham Machen, the central figure in the OPC’s founding, believed the CRC the most blessed ally the newly formed Church had. He reflected on the greetings sent by the CRC to the OPC at its first General Assembly. he said, no other ecclesiastical body in the whole world could have sent greetings more welcome. The happiness of nation at those greetings could not have been greater, since they meant that the CRC recognized the OPC as a true Church. Correct in its separation from the Presbyterian Church in the The OPC then was not a schismatic sect in the judgment of the CRC.

    But Machen went further in his remarks. He looked upon the CRC as the model of a truly Reformed Church. Separatist in the very best sense of the word, standing apart in the interests of true unity and the purity of the Church. He said the CRC was theologically consistent, never vaguely evangelical or conservative or fundamentalist, but always endeavoring to be reformed. To Machen, this meant that the CRC was not content with some partial or piecemeal presentation of the truth that the Bible contained. held firmly to that glorious system of revealed truth summarized in the great Reformed confessions of the faith.

    Machen admired the tradition of catechetical preaching in the CRC, by which he said the laity were soundly and systematically trained in doctrine. He admired the exercise of Church discipline, and he admired the CRC’s commitment to make the education of its children Christian throughout. Now Machen’s high praise for the CRC was politely reciprocated by H. J. Kuyper in his December 25, 1936 editorial in the Banner. He identified the establishment of the OPC as one of the outstanding events of 1936 in the religious and ecclesiastical world.

    Progress of this church, he said, will mean much for the preservation and propagation of our Calvinistic doctrines and traditions. Piper noted how carefully the banner had monitored the formation of the OPC and its early months, and concluded with these words.

    Let us add that if we have been an inspiration to the leaders of the New Presbyterian Church, they have no less been an inspiration to us. We have often asked ourselves the question whether we would have been willing to suffer the hardship and calumny for our faith which they have endured the past few years. Let us not forget that our contacts with these men who have stepped out or been cast out of the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. have served us as a constant warning against the perils of modernism.” Despite Kuyper’s kind words at that time, the OPC stood more immediately, more obviously, in the CRC’s debt. His words did, however, hold out the prospect for valuable service the OPC could render the CRC if times of suffering and hardship came in which the CRC was in fact face-to-face with the perils of modernism.” Subsequent history has brought great change in both denominations, and even to the once strong relationship they sustained to each other.

    However, the story of the OPC’s formation and past history, both in its testimony to Christian courage and to human weakness, seems especially appropriate for CRC audiences these days. It is in the interests of discharging an old debt, then, that I am with you for these lectures. My prayer is for your profit, as we of the OPC profited from the sacrifice and service of an earlier generation that stood in the tradition represented by this institution. Let me set the stage for these lectures. I may bear the title. tragedy, hope and ambivalence, the history of the OPC, 1936-1962.

    The dates mentioned take us from the year of the OPC’s birth, which I have already mentioned, to the year of Dr. Ned B. Stonehouse’s death. Stonehouse died November 18, 1962. Stonehouse is the last of three significant figures around whom these lectures are organized, the others being J. Gresson Machen and Cornelius Van Til. Each of these figures matches up to one of the words in the title. Machen matches up to the word tragedy, Van Til to the word hope, Stonehouse to the word ambivalence. These words call to mind specific crises in which each figure played a leading part.

    Before we close today, we will consider Machen’s battle with fundamentalists in the OPC at the close of his life, a battle more devastating for him than the struggle he had against modernism, believe it or not. The second lecture reviews Van Til’s remarkable but narrow victory in the forties over the visions of cultural Protestantism, championed by figures like Edwin H. Ryan, that’s R-I-A-N, and Gordon H. Clark. This struggle in the 40s revealed the fragile nature of the Reformed consciousness within the OPC, but also the fact that Van Til’s theological and apologetical stand could not easily be disassociated from the Church. from the newly formed Presbyterian Church. There is hope rising from that controversy in the 40s, but this hope is qualified by a lingering ambivalence that demands careful study and scrutiny. Our third lecture looks at Ned B. Stonehouse, a fierce promoter of nation and truly an extraordinary scholar, New Testament scholar, with a worldwide reputation, and a man who proved ambivalent.

    They, at least in the beginnings of an agonizing war with subjectivism, represented in the Peniel movement. That’s P-E-N-I-E-L, a movement I will explain to you later. here only noting that it consumed OPC energies directly for about 14 years and indirectly for about 21, carrying us through the period in which Dr. Stonehouse died in 1962. In setting these lectures for you, we would do well, moving on from the consideration of the title and surveying somewhat the content of each, we would do well to give more than a nod in a more cosmopolitan direction. Without conceding that the larger sociological movements are the key to understanding the particular features of a church’s history, we do not want to be ignorant of the world around us, neither its potential influence, and fret nor the pressures that providentially arise within our context encouraging us to take a better look at ourselves.

    The years 1936 to 1962 saw principally a collapse of Europe and the beginning stages of Europe’s redefinition. This period ends with Europe divided by a newly built wall between an economically attractive West and an intractable, determined, although increasingly scientifically sophisticated, East.

    American isolationism was a thing of the past. Old-world colonialism was dead. Asian and African interests could not be ignored and pushed their concerns and agendas upon the world. In many respects, this period is one in which a brave new world takes shape, brimming over with hostilities born from the clash of fundamentally distinct ideologies and the residual impact of nationalism and racial conflict. But in its more profound expressions, 1936 to 1962, for all its diversity and discord, signals the triumph of an immanentistic world consciousness.

    The dynamics of history are now understood as at no point previously so pervasively or so consistently from within. No substantial appeal is being made to divine power or design. World War II itself and subsequent conflicts are fought without any serious theological analysis as to their apocalyptic dimensions by the traditionally Christian West. And in the East, militarist mythologies lie in ruins. The world now will be interpreted from within. But mankind is discovering a new religion. one beyond, but also the natural descendant of theological liberalism, one in which the fatherhood of God now disappears in the interests of the brotherhood of man.

    In America, John Steinbeck’s 1939 novel The Grapes of Wrath spells out the new religion. The Jode family has lived through Egypt-like feast and famine days on the Oklahoma plains. But now the plagues of the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl, together with the oppression of the modern-day pharaohs, those machine-owning, land-grabbing syndicates, finds the Jodes looking to the promised land, California. The Job family is led on this pilgrimage by an itinerant ex-preacher named Cayce, who is himself in search of a replacement for his forsaken fundamentalism.

    In Steinbeck’s recasting of the biblical Exodus story, Cayce becomes the new Moses, the prophet of a religion devoid of Jehovah. Before his death, Cayce passes on the new faith to his Joshua Tom Joad, the oldest of the Joad boys, who then confesses that man has no soul of his own, but only a piece of a big one.

    This one great big soul, however, is no testimony to a higher transcendent reality to a heavenly world, to the God of Orthodoxy. Instead, this one great big soul testifies to a greater collective individuality found only in the common lot of humanity. See how we are not going to get outside of ourselves. There can be no appeal to anything beyond ourselves and our world.

    Steinbeck’s novel therefore proclaims a new gospel devoid of God, devoid of Jesus Christ, in which faith in mankind promises ultimate triumph over adversity, whatever that adversity might be. This is the stuff with which you are to meet the Depression, the Dust Bowl and World War from even the most monumental setbacks with confidence that it is winning the battle for control over existence and over itself.

    But with this confidence has come a new view of government in which the world of politics absorbs everything in sight. The media is drawn into the picture as it draws together technology and politics for the catechizing of humanity in the modern immunotistic world of consciousness.

    Abandoned is the Reformation commitment to service for the sake of God and his transcendent kingdom in its present and coming glory. What remains is propaganda for the sake of political advantage and one’s supposed idea of proof, all in the name of the most eminently worthy causes. But one thing we must realize is that in all of this, religion has not lost its place in the world. It’s not as if religion itself has been abandoned. That is a misinterpretation of what is transpiring. Secularization has not meant the destruction of religion, but rather its transformation, so that religion itself is translated into the interests of political hope, in that there is, in fact, no other reality.

    This radical change has been forecast by the social upheaval of the 19th century, but now became complete and the ecclesiastical reactions to the world wars, the depression, and the corollary and subsequent social crises. Therefore, the modern Church, in its boldest and most consistent expression, finds itself quite at home within the emerging order and at odds with the stubborn resistance it finds, the pocket resistance it finds, to this twentieth-century Enlightenment movement. A book appears in the sixties that summarizes the theological consensus that congealed during this time, covered by our lectures. That book, Harvey Cox’s The Secular City, was published in 1965.

    It set out with powerful lucidity radical reading of Bonhoeffer’s quote world come of age unquote and quote religionless Christianity unquote Now you have to understand something about Cox at this point He does not see himself primarily as Prophetic or prescriptive as if he’s trying to establish what ought to be a as if his interest is, I have a message, I’m going to preach my message, and with this message will transform the world.

    His interest, then, is not prophetic or prescriptive. His interest is primarily descriptive. He is describing what has already transpired. It’s already taken place. that the facts are undeniable. The world no longer understands itself religiously or in terms of the metaphysics attendant to a God who stands apart from the world or is to be understood in any orthodox sense. But get this, even though this has taken place now as far as the world is concerned, and the religious understanding of things has been dismissed We are not to view this state of affairs negatively. It is rather inevitable and necessary. That’s what it means for the world to come of age.

    A religionless Christianity is, in fact, the point to which we were pressing all along. He says then, that this is even the inevitable and necessary conclusion to the dynamic of the biblical record, even the dynamic of the biblical record in its doctrine of creation. Creation itself pushes us to this conclusion. Secularization is the conclusion of the Scripture’s position on creation.

    In the secular city, Christianity becomes the process of social change and political action in keeping with the program of reconciliation observed in Jesus of Nazareth.” Christianity becomes the process of social change and political action in keeping with the program of reconciliation observed in Jesus of Nazareth. Should anybody be surprised by the theological lay of the land since the The sociopolitical reading of the Bible has become a deluge. Jesus has been recast as the champion of a new embodiment of the kingdom of God, who was determined to overthrow Jerusalem’s priestly temple system that stood for the Roman Jewish elitists and oppressed the majority of Palestinian Jews.

    I’m quoting from a representative voice. We can go even a step further in what radical hermeneutics is saying with respect to the scriptural message. The early New Testament Church now appears as a primal equality movement that was squelched by a chauvinistic male power play. leading female church leaders branded as heretics, and women viewed generally as unimportant or as a threat.” Are you surprised?

    You have to remember, of course, that the Bible itself is party. party to the misrepresentation of Jesus and the early Church, which we in our naivete have embraced. We must remember that the Bible itself is party to the suppression of Jesus’ true mission, to the suppression of the early New Testament Church’s politically correct agenda. That’s why you can’t trust your Bible completely and wholly.

    The Bible actually gives comfort to those who would hide in obsolete ethical directives. It gives comfort to those who would oppress women. The Bible actually gives comfort to those who would oppress homosexuals and other minority groups. Therefore, if the Bible is to remain authoritative, and we, of course, want it to remain authoritative, If we want the Bible to remain authoritative for us, something more than incidental to our present secular circumstance, this Bible must speak to us about an overarching theology of hope. We must discern in the Bible, so says J. Christian Becker of Princeton Seminary, an apocalyptic thrust that will only find its fulfillment when the triumph of God will make an end to all evil, suffering and injustice, and bring about the joy of a world at peace.” That’s our hope. It might be thought that the world of Neo-Orthodoxy would offer us some relief from this. After all, the neo-Orthodox wanted to talk about salvation and history in the interests of the Holy Other God who acts in space and time.

    But the neo-Orthodox message has now been upstaged by those who have favored secularization, and they have been upstaged because they have lacked the ability to speak definitively about God’s essential transcendence. They have refused to speak concretely about the essential ontological deity of God’s Son, and they have refused to speak about the substantive nature of the resurrection of Jesus Christ and of the world to come. And this refusal on their part has left them victims in a conflict in which they have been co-conspirators. Ironically, neo-Orthodoxy has generated its own irrelevance.

    This then is the situation as it has taken shape over the course of this century and gained focus from the mid-30s to the early 60s. A radical cultural and religious shift has occurred, signaling the triumph of an eminentistic world consciousness. Here is the context for the formulation of the OPC, the context for the significance of her early leaders.

    Men like Machen, Van Til and Stonehouse do not deserve our attention in themselves, but as they together with the OPC and other faithful churches have given response to the societal ecclesiastical demagoguery and deceit of our time. They also commend themselves for our consideration because of the costly stand they took in reviewing their own constituency and heritage. But neither are these men themselves, much less the OPC, shielded from that all-seeing, scrutinizing gaze that is capable of detecting in them whatever log might be in their own eyes. Tragedy and J. Gresson Machen The time remaining, my purpose is not to recite history to you. You can get accounts of Meichen and the formation of the OPC from various places. My concern is to draw together for you material that is either little known or ignored in the retelling of the OPC’s early history.

    Sometime during November 12-14, 1936, a young pastor named Robert H. Graham stepped into an elevator in the Manufacturers and Bankers Club at Broad and Walnut Streets, Philadelphia. Stepping in at the same time was the Rev. Carl McIntyre, the flamboyant editor of the Christian Beacon and the pastor of the Presbyterian Church in Collingswood, New Jersey.

    These two men were headed for the second floor and the second General Assembly of the OPC. They first met in June. This was the second Assembly meeting in November. The bond between these men went beyond their common denomination. They were both members of the new Church.

    On this occasion, MacIntyre took Graham into his confidence. As Graham, now in his 87th year, remembers it, MacIntyre said, this fellow nation is getting too much power. With that statement, MacIntyre expressed the growing distrust of Nachen felt within the OPC’s fundamentalist wing. Such distrust forecast the break by fundamentalism from Nachen and his movement. That break eventually catapulted MacIntyre into the role of a fundamentalist luminary at the head of a vast empire, including the Bible Presbyterian Church. Although Machen himself died before the break where the Fundamentalists came, it occurred in May of the following year, he was able to read all the signs and carried the weight of those signs to his grave. The crisis with the Fundamentalists in the OPC broke in. nation had been prepared for the earlier crises of his career.

    In fact, he seemed to rise to them. It was almost as if he enjoyed them. He faced the moderates, those he called the indifferentists. And even in facing them, no amount of humiliation that could heap upon him distracted him. They had, as you know, come after him. They came after him in 1926 in Baltimore, Maryland, the General Assembly. They attacked him in full view of the city in which he had been raised, in which he was well known, in which his family was well respected. Can you think of a greater humiliation for the man?

    He had been nominated to the chair of apologetics at Princeton Seminary, an appointment that had to be confirmed by the General Assembly, but the Assembly was moved by J. Ross Stevenson, president of Princeton Seminary, who identified Machen as the spokesman for intolerance. Charles R. Erdmann, Machen’s colleague, also opposed Machen, calling him thoroughly controversial. For moderates like Stevenson and Erdmann, Machen possessed temperamental idiosyncrasies He was a man hampered by serious limitations.

    Although Machen lost the battle for the position at Princeton and even saw the seminary remade in 1929, and that in the modernist direction, he was still resilient, determined, and positive in his fight for orthodoxy. Late September 1929, Westminster Seminary opened its doors in Philadelphia. Nachen gave the address. He said in that address that though Princeton Seminary is dead, the noble tradition of Princeton is alive. He was still buoyant.

    And he remained buoyant throughout the long, drawn-out battle with liberalism. He stood his ground against the PCUSA hierarchy and its defense of its own Board of Foreign which harbored modernist liberals, including Pearl Buck, the famous novelist. He threw himself into an emergency organization, the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions, which he, with others, formed in 1933 in protest to the denomination’s Board of Foreign Missions. For this action, he was deposed. by the PCUSA in a case that ran its course at the 1936 General Assembly in Syracuse, New York.

    Then on June 11, 1936, a new church convened its first General Assembly, and about this event, Machen wrote in the Presbyterian Guardian, We became members at last of a true Presbyterian Church. We recovered at last true Christian fellowship. What a joyous moment it was. how the long years of struggle seemed to sink into nothingness compared with the peace and joy that filled our hearts. Now, that was Machen writing in June. Machen in November was a completely different man. Many remember him as a fellow much more restrained and somber. Stonehouse spoke about how much he had aged since that 1936 opening assembly for the OPC.

    The first blow came to him in the revelation during the summer months that his right-hand man, H. McAllister Griffiths, had sexually compromised himself. Griffiths had been Nation’s counsel throughout his ecclesiastical trials. He had also been the editor of the Presbyterian Guardian, and now his reputation, at least as far as Nation and the close circles around Nation, were concerned, was ruined. Griffiths withdrew from most of his Church duties, but interestingly there is no evidence of Church discipline. and Griffiths retains his position in the Independent Board. So that was the first blow from H.M. in the summer months of 1936.

    The next blow came in the October-November row over R.B. Kuyper’s report in the Banner on the OPC’s first General Assembly. This is what Kuyper had written. He said, the CRC would have been delighted that candidates for the ministry in the OPC were examined so closely about the anti-reformed heresies so extremely prevalent among American fundamentalists, Arminianism and the dispensationalism of the Scofield Bible.

    You might well imagine Carl MacIntyre’s response. MacIntyre took Kuyper to task on two accounts. First of all, he said he was inaccurate in his recollection of what happened at that first assembly, implying that Kuyper was a liar. And secondly, he took him to task for what he considered to be his anti-premillennialism. Kuyper, in other words, was a bigot. When Kuyper responded to MacIntyre’s October 1 Christian Beacon editorial, MacIntyre refused to publish his letter. The response from Kuyper’s friend, J. Gresham Machen, was immediate.

    He charged MacIntyre with deliberate sabotage. Machen was a pro when it came to recognizing power plays. He could spot it a mile away, and he recognized its insidiousness. So much so that he seriously now contemplated bringing charges against MacIntyre. He wrote to J. Oliver Buswell, president of Wheaton College, I am afraid it is my duty to take the preliminary steps to bring some kind of disciplinary action against MacIntyre. When Boswell suggested the private conference for the resolution of the problem, Machen responded that the conference he had in mind would take place within the courts of the church. It was as if Machen sensed that he and the OPC were being purposely pushed to the wall by the Fundamentalists, publicly embarrassed by them.

    He sensed that the confrontation was going to come. Even after the First Assembly, during the summer months, he had confided in Kuyper, our struggles are not over. A serious conflict with the Fundamentalists is in the offing. That is what he said to Kuyper.

    But where earlier in his career, Machen had himself been willing to be identified as a fundamentalist, now he rejected the term emphatically. Writing to the New York fundamentalist lawyer James E. Bennett, he said, I, for my part, am not a fundamentalist at all. He added the words, at all. And then he went on to say that I am a persecution. Machen was very critical of the Fundamentalists as things were developing here through the summer months and into the fall.

    In his letter to Bennett, he implied that Fundamentalists had no real commitment to the Westminster standards. He implied an Arminianism. He suspected that their view of office essentially laid office open to any man who is washed in the blood of Christ and saved. He, with Kuyper and the rest of the Westminster faculty, with the exception of Alan McRae, believed the fundamentalist Scofield Bible dispensationalism to be terribly heretical. He also had no sympathy for the fundamentalist view of the separated life, since he saw it as a denial of the Presbyterian doctrines of Christian liberty of conscience and the regulative principle.

    This then was the second blow, the October-November lull. The third blow came two days after the second General Assembly. You might recall that that Assembly ends on November 14 and places us on November 16. On that day, the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions met in Philadelphia. Machin was up for re-election as president of the Independent Board, a position that he had held since 1933, when the board had been organized.

    He lost the presidency that day to an independent clergyman named Harold S. Laird, L-A-I-R-D. But more, Machen knew the Board had been captured by fundamentalism and could no longer operate honestly in terms of its constitutional commitment to Presbyterianism. The coup within the Board had been engineered by the fundamentalist lawyer James Bennett, who had no regard for Machen’s Presbyterianism, and together with MacIntyre, who was himself a member of the board, believed Machen to be vested with too much, if not papal, power. According to Mary Gresham Machen, J. Gresham Machen’s niece, the deciding vote in that election was cast by H. McAllister, who had turned on Machen after being morally discredited and had now thrown his weight to the fundamentalist Fundamentalists side before a meteoric rise in McIntyre’s movement Are all the enemies on the left Are all the enemies on the left Nation was devastated Nothing that he’d experienced from the liberals, even the moderates, affected him as much as this. He told Kuyper that the loss of the board for the cause of the Reformed faith was the greatest shock of his life. After his defeat, that very day, he phoned his sister-in-law in Baltimore, Helen Woods Machen. Her record of that conversation goes like this.

    Machen said to her, they kicked me out as president. It is the hardest blow I’ve had yet. I’m done for now. I feel I’ve been driven to the final humiliation of my life. I actually pleaded for myself. pleaded that I be returned to office. My back was against the wall and the whole life of the board was at stake. And I loved it so. And now it’s gone. Absolutely wrecked. Lost to everything it stood for. Everything I stand for and the man who stand with me. Now everything is in the hands of men who haven’t the slightest notion of the issues at stake.

    Everything I’ve worked for loved and suffered for has been kicked out too. I feel it’s the end for me. This time they’ve finished me.” Nothing in the remaining weeks of Nachen’s life contradicts Helen Nachen’s recollections. Nachen was not himself at the Christmas break. He was pensive, humorless, reclusive.

    It seems that what the moderates and the modernists in the PCUSA had not been able to do, the fundamentalists within the OPC and the Independent Board were successful in doing. Obviously, what wounded Maychin most was the betrayal, both doctrinal and personal. Of those he had taught, of those he had been wonderfully close to, In this, something of the experience of his Savior was intruding upon him in a way that he would have never asked for in an unexpected way. So also unexpectedly, the great issues were becoming crystal clear.

    And now, as the year ended, stricken with pneumonia and dying in Bismarck, North Dakota, Matron spoke of a reformed faith. He said to Sam Allen, an O.P. pastor at his bedside, isn’t it grand? And he spoke of Christ’s active obedience, sending a telegram to John Murray. He wrote to Murray about that act of obedience of Christ, no hope without it. And what of the hope? He spoke of his vision of heaven, he said it was glorious, and he died at about 7.30 p.m. January 1, 1937.

    Thank you, Reverend Dennison. We had agreed beforehand, I didn’t mention that at the outset, but we would allow any who wish to ask Reverend Dennison any questions that may have arisen that you thought of during the course of his presentation. Now we will limit ourselves in asking these questions and answering them for roughly, I would say, 10 minutes. So if there are questions at this time, I’ll turn things over again to Reverend Dennison. and you may address them to him. Yes.

    I would like to ask Reverend Jonathan, how do you define fundamentalism? Well, the definitions have certainly been traded about over the last 30 years, I would say. I have tended to approach fundamentalism a little bit more culturally. Yes, there are the theological convictions in Aaron’s scripture, opposition to evolution by and large, premillennial tendency towards dispensationalism. overt Arminian to covert. You have an attitude that rises above the Church, sees things in what it would consider broader categories. Pension for independency within it. But as I said, I tend to think of it more in terms, as much in terms of a cultural position than a theological position.

    And so I think that the attitude of fundamentalism is socially isolationist, provincial. I think that It is individualistic by and large, supportive of public and political programs to that end. It has a very active social and political conscience, although at the same time it says that this world is going to hell in a handbasket. I think we’re all aware of the contradiction and the hypocrisy of fundamentalism.

    It is militant in its approach to the culture and to the church. We’ll deal with evangelicalism in the next lecture, but I think that you can work out some nice contrasts between the fundamentalist approach and the evangelical approach along that social line. The evangelical traditionally is not militant. He’s adept at getting along. Where the fundamentalist wants all the time, the evangelical just wants equal time.

    Mason was concerned about that from the right wing going forward fundamentally. You’re somewhat of an expert on Mason in that context. Mason realized today, make an educated guess, do you think he would see in the OPC or in the conservative movement in the CRC some fundamentalism? that the fundamentalists in the OPC were soundly thrashed in the next lecture.

    It was a costly fight, but I don’t think that fundamentalism by and large has survived in the OPC. I think the OPC is more fighting the problems of a residual evangelicalism. I think that’s their struggle presently, so I think those folks would match up with the moderates or the indifferentists of Nations Day. Now, I’m not that conversant with what’s happening in CRC circles in great detail.

    I’ve certainly had some exposure since I’m a member of the Presidentiary of Ohio and the OCC, and Dan Moss happens to serve on our session. So we had been deeply involved in the issue of the fate of the Washington congregation. So I’m a little bit familiar with that. I’ve also had to deal with Daryl Molina. I am a little bit aware of tabloid journalism, even in the church.

    So the sensationalism of Carl MacIntyre and Christian Beacon may be abroad in places in the Christian Reformed Church. I don’t know whether I’m stepping on anybody’s toes. Uh-oh, there’s a member of the board back there. I’m not a member of the board or anything like that.

    I just wondered why the fundamentalism gets that negative connotation. I mean, the fundamentals were the same as Mason was fighting against war against the liberals, right? Somehow or other, the term fundamentalist, that is to say, I want to hold to the fundamentals of Scripture, the main issues and teachings of Scripture, It’s something we’re also about to turn. Now, why in the history of the Church did people who tended to be narrow and to be like MacIntyre, did they captivate?

    Now, they’re the bad guys. And so today, in the Christian Front Church, I think maybe that’s the point there, those of us who really want to maintain nothing more than the heart, But what the Christian farm church has always been for, don’t worry about the non-sensual for the real, the sensual, they very quickly label you as a fundamentalist. As a non-homonym, I give it some character ways, but it serves the purpose. Well, Craig, he overwatched it all.

    Now, Nathan was fighting for the fundamentalist. So in a sense, he was a genuine fundamentalist. There was a period in his life, I’d say in the early to the mid-twenties, where Mayking would not shy away from being called a fundamentalist in a certain context. But he would always add, you see, I’m not going to reduce the faith to a few fundamentals. What I stand for is the full-orged, reformed faith. That’s what I stand for.

    And as that increasingly began to play itself out in his consciousness, he became increasingly uneasy with the term fundamentalist and fundamentalism, because he could see that what these individuals were doing was that they were trafficking with Reformed confessionalism.

    And that was what was in the balance. The fundamentalists were only going to give the tip of the hat to the confession in the end. He could see that. That was clear to him. They really weren’t concerned about chapters beyond chapter one of the Confession of Faith, the Westminster Confession of Faith. The first chapter deals with the doctrine of Scripture. So the inerrancy of Scripture was very important to them, but they couldn’t be bothered with the doctrine of the Covenant, for instance, chapter seven, or statements with regard to the law of God, or other things that were part of this comprehensive Reformed view. as that became more and more clear to Nathan, and it became clear to him, I feel, because of his contact with that original faculty at Westminster. I’m getting ahead of myself here, but that’s the next lecture.

    He is really going to be going to school, as it were, under Murray and Vantill and Kuyper and Stonehouse in learning about the breadth and the comprehensiveness of the Reformed position. So he backs off. And don’t be naïve and don’t be deceived. Those who were standing for the fundamentalist position weren’t Reformed. They simply weren’t Reformed. They had no real commitment to the comprehensive statement of Reformed faith.

    That’s why. That’s why the difference comes, you see. You mentioned earlier in your lecture that Mason was often accused of being stubborn and difficult to get along with, and therefore the modesty and indifference stood in his way and lost its place in the chair of apologetics. How much of that same kind of personal dynamic plays itself out with Karl McIntyre? Fair enough. Fair enough.

    Again, we’re getting a little bit ahead of the story, and I want to work on that in my second lecture. Of course, MacIntyre organizes the beacon at the beginning of 1936. Here is this young firebrand. This guy has energy that will run him. I don’t know, he may have slept. He was a phenom, and Dr. Van Tilghman, when I was at Westminster Center in the late 60s, was guilty of anything, but not himself. He was his best student. So he was a phenom. And he has a magazine, The Christian Beacon, that has three times the circulation than the Christian magazine.

    We might not just have a meteorological war going on here. Here’s this young Turk who doesn’t really understand the way of the land. Now, I can’t say that there wasn’t some of that there, but I can’t imagine anything more obnoxious to you than that. It was pressing to take. I mean, what I said in the lecture is correct. Nature recognized the signs of the power of what it saw. He realized, even if there were indiscretions on the other side, he realized that MacIntyre’s objective was to discredit him and the Guardian and his descendants. That was the objective. Can you talk a bit about what you see as the motivations of MacIntyre?

    He did not believe his training. Yes, I think that’s correct. He came in a pre-Millennialist. He went out a pre-Millennialist. He came in, I think, convinced of Schofieldism. I think he left convinced of Schofieldism. He was adamantly in favor of the 1903 amendments to the Left-Lintern Convention of Freedom. And that wasn’t just because he wanted to have claim to the property.

    I’m convinced that the man actually believed some of the stuff that was in those amendments to the confessional. Most particularly, the items that were retained in the Bible fit onto the confessional statement. All infants dying in infancy are saved. Categorically, unequivocally. He had to hold on to that statement.

    So I think the motivation for MacIntyre was, look, premillennialism is right, I’m going to prosecute the case. Separated Wives is right, right, I’m going to prosecute the case. We’re going to return to the ministry, we’re going to arrest the church and the control over us, the ministry, the seminary, from making himself, and this denomination is not going to merely have Eschatological liberty, it’s going to have a premillennial preponderance. We will be the majority position.

    To follow up on that, was it, I mean, I think in retrospect, it’s pretty obviously a terrible mistake for the Reformed elements to make common cause with the front-liners, thinking that somehow we could win them over or somehow this would not come back to haunt us.

    Yes, that was Mason just said. That was the reflection on Mason’s attitude. I don’t know who he said it to. But Mason too has said to someone who was raising the objection of having these individuals in such positions, well, they’re a little naive, we have to give them time. Very uninformed. Well, of course, it turns out that they’re very much informed. Do we have a question yet?

    I just wanted to ask what was it about Nathan’s perspective of his not being retained as president that brought him to such despondency and that Jacob’s all things are against me. It wasn’t that they were kicking him out of the seminary. It was just that they were kicking him off his position as president of the Independent Board of Missions. I’m missing something that, in his mind, made that so vital. Did he not have his fingers on how much support he really had?

    He had been victimized, and we’ll have the people say more about that in the second lecture, but he was convinced that as long as he or the men that stood with him most intimately were retained in power, that they could move the Independent Board away from its emergency features.

    It had been created to handle the emergency situation in the large Presbyterian Church. So he looked at it as something that would eventually play out its usefulness. And the more the Presbyterians in the Board were able to prosecute that case within the Board, he knew that the future of the board would go in the direction of its own dissolution. But once the fundamentalist rattled, there was no hope of reversing that direction in his mind. And he realized that he’d lost. And that it would spell, then, a break.

    He could see it coming, not just with the independent board, but the break would come in the church. And we saw the break As good as Don in that meeting, he broke in and convinced everybody. You could see it. You could see what happened. The church itself was going to splinter and break. What was the percentage of people? I didn’t say that, did I? The deciding vote was passed by August 3rd.

    You know, the 4th one. Oh yes, well, actually… How many left with MacIntyre? Yes, yes, at the next assembly, the third assembly, fourteen ministries and three elders leave, so it doesn’t look like as much as anything, but you see it mushrooms then, and because MacIntyre has this vehicle, the Christian beacon, it has this wide circulation, The OPC is not now just being discredited by the large name on the nomination.

    They’re being attacked from the other side, and mercilessly attacked from the other side. It just crippled him. I mean, you could see it just disintegrate before his eyes. You could see the fight that was going to come as a result of this whole thing.

    Our Father in Heaven, we thank you for your superintendence over the Church’s history, particularly these episodes that we have learned about this afternoon. We acknowledge and confess to you our own sinfulness and our own inability to, even for a moment, direct the course of the Church that it rests with its sovereign Heavenly King, Jesus Christ. We thank you that we have this privilege and this opportunity to reflect together on a period of history in a body of believers who are so close and so interdependent with us on the truth of the Gospel as contained in the Confession.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Van Til and Hope

    Van Til and Hope

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered November 1, 1995.

    About this sermon

    Machen’s Reformed doctrine and his relationship with Cornelius Van Til belong together, against the background of a pre-1903 Westminster Confession not yet marked by a certain Americanism creeping into doctrine. Van Til’s apologetic grew directly out of the battles both men fought. Their hope survived those battles, and it never avoided them.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    like to once again welcome those who are with us. We always have the students, of course, to acknowledge your goodness to us and your faithfulness over all your works, that you have given to us a night’s rest and that in this day we have a gift from your hand.

    This beautiful day we may see the sunshine and the power and wisdom of your hand in creation and providence. We may also be before you as those who are clothed with the righteousness of Jesus Christ, whereby we can find acceptance and access to your throne of grace.

    We thank you, Father, that again this day we may reflect for a few moments through the instruction of Rev. Dennison upon the life and the history of the Church that Christ is gathering by his Spirit and word. We pray that as we reflect together with him on the history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, that you would give to us eyes of faith to see how you are through your providence and in fulfillment of your counsel gathering that Church, that people chosen unto everlasting life, whom you have purposed to give to your Son. and whom he purchased with his own precious blood, that in all of the fragility and all of the growth as well as weakness of the Church, we may be able to see beyond those whom you used in your grace to build that Church, see the hand of your mercy and your faithfulness, that we may see the glory of your redemptive work in history. Father, we pray as well that we may also be taught to see our own weakness to see the sinfulness of your people, to see how much we need to humble ourselves before you and look alone to the Lord who reigns over all, to build his church and to establish his kingdom. So we pray as well for your blessing upon Reverend Dennison as he speaks to us. Empower him and strengthen him, give him clarity of expression so that through this we may be well instructed and your name may be praised. Keep sin from us, we ask, and cleanse us of all our unrighteousness. So we pray these things in Jesus’ name, amen.

    I will not this morning introduce Rev. Dennison again in terms of who he is and things of that sort, but I will say this, he is presenting now at this hour the second of three lectures on the history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. Yesterday he addressed the topic, Tragedy, the OPC’s struggle with fundamentalism in the 1930s, the beginnings of the OPC. In this hour, his address is entitled Hope, the Influence of Cornelius Fentill and the Rejection of a Cultured Protestantism, promoted by Gordon Clark and Edwin Ryan.

    Just a note yet about our schedule. This lecture is scheduled for 8.30. The second lecture this morning is scheduled for 10.30. I’m not sure exactly when we’ll be finished with this first hour, but we should at the very latest be done at 10 o’clock so we can have a time of fellowship and a break together at ten o’clock.

    So there will be time again, as was true yesterday, for some questions at the end, I believe, of Reverend Dennison’s presentation. Welcome again, Reverend Dennison. It’s good to do these mornings. Early morning things are better than after lunch. Everybody’s falling asleep. Here are a few more women in here.

    On December 4th, 1936, J. Oliver Buswell, president of Wheaton College, member of the OPC and of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions, wrote to J. Gresham Machin for the last time. Machin was usually prompt with his responses, especially to Buswell, But this time he left the letter unanswered, at least temporarily, intending to reply during the upcoming Christmas break. Once at his brother’s home in Baltimore, over the Christmas break, Machen began an answer to that letter, but never finished. As I indicated yesterday, Machen died on New Year’s Day, 1937. A hint as to why Machen found it so difficult to respond to Buswell appears in a draft fragment that has survived. Machen’s tone in that fragment is abrupt.

    He seems to be grieved about the persistent intractability and obtuseness of his fundamentalist opponents. He had already concluded in his November 27 letter to Boswell that the fundamentalism represented by James E. Bennett was unethical and sub-Christian. Not only had Bennett’s victory, he was the New York lawyer, the fundamentalist New York lawyer, Not only had Bennett’s victory in the independent board meant the impossibility for the board to be true to its charter, that is to Presbyterianism, but Bennett himself had engaged in a smear campaign against Machen to achieve his goal. Adding this to an already well-developed contempt for MacIntyre’s underhandedness, and for the mean-spiritedness of H. McAllister Griffiths, Machen had no patience for Buswell’s attempt to massage Schofield dispensationalism. As Machen said in the draft fragment, quote, The use of the Schofield Bible is a very terrible evil that is doing untold harm doctrinally and morally to the souls of men. In short, from Machen’s point of view, dispensationalism is heresy. Two further elements in Boswell’s letter undoubtedly annoyed Machen. The first was the veiled charge that Machen and his friends at the Presbyterian Guardian and at Westminster Seminary were, quote, undemocratic and dictatorial, unquote.

    That they were envious of MacIntyre’s ability to start the magazine, The Christian Beacon, and to conduct it with such a degree of success. As I indicated yesterday in the question and answer period, The Beacon had a circulation three times as large as The Guardians, and that within the space of a few months.

    Machen’s unseating as president of the independent board was therefore, according to Buswell, in the interests of the spirit of democracy. And although he never said so openly, Buswell was certainly implying that the action of the board in unseating Machen was an indirect form of discipline.

    The other thing that had to annoy Machen was Buswell’s attack upon the Westminster apologetic, at the center of which, although he is never named by Buswell, was the figure of Cornelius Van Til. Buswell first observed that Machen may not be in agreement with what has been taking place at Westminster in that area of apologetics.

    Nevertheless, the position of the seminary, said Buswell, has shifted over the past five years. Buswell supported what he called historical apologetics and biblical exegesis, the type represented by figures like James Orr, Robert Dick Wilson, and Machen himself in Machen’s works on the origin of Paul’s religion and the virgin birth. But now, Boswell observed, the tendency at Westminster was to substitute what the faculty was calling a theological apologetic with what Boswell called a philosophical apologetic. Westminster said Boswell was headed in the wrong direction. Its new position was dangerous, weakening the critical position of its graduates and their practical usefulness. Interestingly, Buswell linked the new Westminster apologetic with our millennialism.

    As if in his mind, the two were joined inseparably as if they had bled into each other. Buzwell does not explain himself here, but what he may have had in mind was the fact that fundamentalists found evidentialism more conducive to their own system. In the insistence upon the priority of proofs, that in fact being essential to the evidentialist position and the primary to the evidentialist position, They were laying groundwork even for their eschatological schemes, which could be said to depend upon evidences. While it is incorrect to say that presuppositionalists dismiss or ignore proofs, they most certainly assign them a limited and subordinate position. As a result, Their position appeared to evidentialist fundamentalists like Buswell as substance-less theorizing, and their view of the future as dabbling in the regions of ether and abstraction. Buswell preferred the demonstrably concrete, earthy reality. such as were consistent with his interest in an earthly millennium.

    Where Machen stood on the apologetical question continues to be debated into our present day. Maybe some of you are aware of Greg Monson’s argument in the book Pressing Toward the Mark, his article Machen, Van Til and the Apologetical Tradition of the OPC. Bonson’s argument is that Machen and Van Til’s apologetics are actually compatible, if not one. I think that an honest assessment of the facts must drive us to a different conclusion. There was the argument, however, coming from the other side, from that which Bonson presents.

    That side is represented by Alan McRae, a professor early on at Westminster Seminary, himself a premillennialist and evidentialist. Alan McRae states that Machen privately scoffed at Van Til’s position, but this seems inconsistent with the testimony of others, including Van Til himself.

    The truth of the matter most likely has to do with Machen’s re-education, and also with his loyalty to the seminary and to its faculty. Regarding Machen’s re-education, he had in many ways become the student of the faculty that he had assembled. Now, I know that that is something that causes a great deal of discussion when it is raised in OP circles. Machen is usually looked upon as a person who came into the situations at Westminster full-blown and fully matured theologically. But in actuality, Machen was a man in motion.

    He was a man in transition, moving from and evangelical Presbyterianism to a confessional-reformed Presbyterianism. He was learning what it meant to be reformed in the strictest sense of that word, and his education seems to have commenced with the organization of Westminster in 1929. His re-education was theological in the deepest sense, no longer generalities about Presbyterianism, or if you look at Machen’s works prior to 1929, you will see that there are very few references to distinctive Reformed doctrines, or exposition of them. There are general references to the Reformed faith and to Presbyterianism, but very few specific treatments of detailed doctrines. So no longer generalities about Presbyterianism and the Reformed faith, but particularities. Interest in the covenant, interest in eschatology, interest in the active obedience of Christ, something that he was learning about from John Murray, that documentable.

    And according to Oswald T. Ellis, Manchin’s interaction with and response to dispensationalism took place in the last years of his life. virtually ignorant of the movement prior to the 30s. It was as if he were learning about it for the very first time as the debates begin to develop in the early 30s. But admittedly the most difficult area was apologetics. Frenation was devoted to the Princeton apologetic of B.B. Warfield.

    There are many examples of this. There’s an article that he wrote for the Woman’s Home Companion in 1925 entitled My Idea of God, which has been republished a number of times. See, Machen got around. Woman’s Home Companion, he was widely recognized as a popular writer on the religious scene in the 20s and 30s.

    But Van Til’s apologetic position was no quick study. So Machen, much like yourselves, was in the position of listening. But while he was listening, he had to continue to preach and teach. And when he preached and when he taught, at least along the lines apologetics, his message was clearly, unmistakably, evidentialist, and an expression of his past commitment to natural theology. If you need proof of this, I invite you to look at the book, The Christian Faith in the Modern World, and Machen’s article in that book, actually a radio talk that he gave in the last year of his life, entitled, How May We Know God? But even though this is true now, Machen is continuing in this evidentialist line, committed to natural theology, and as contrary as it may sound, he is completely committed personally to Bantils. On an intellectual level, we have a confused state. On a personal level, it’s not confused at all.

    He is personally committed to Vantill. This was undoubtedly because of Machen’s personal fondness for the man. Vantill was magnetic. He was incredibly winsome. He was tremendously popular. He was great to be around, just as Machen was great to be around.

    There are the stories of Machen and Van Til’s train trip to Chicago. They spent a couple of days on the train together talking about these very things. That often used as evidence that Machen at least was willing to tolerate Van Til’s position. There was a great bond between them. But Machen also respected loyalty. And there wasn’t anyone as loyal as Van Til. to the movement. He could see the broad picture. He had no narrow myopic view. So there was Vantill’s loyalty to the cause. But there was also Machen’s conviction that the seminary must present a united front against all attacks. Vantill is our man. We will defend him. We will stand behind as far as the public attacks of a public interest in our case is concerned.

    So because of these things, Buswell’s attack in his letter certainly left Machen deeply annoyed. As a secondary aspect of this whole thing, Machen’s response to Buswell It could be very well that Machen didn’t know what to say on the matter. So he delayed. But at least he could see this much as he reflected about the situation.

    If Van Til was right, the critics’ razor was about to be applied to the Princeton apologetic and to Machen’s own view of American Presbyterians. he could see the consequences. Machen had been banking on his message that Westminster Seminary and the OPC were the true spiritual descendants of Princeton Seminary and the Presbyterian Church USA. Thus he hoped to avoid the charge of schism. We are the continuing Church. They left us, we didn’t need them. You know how the argument goes. And by root of that argument, appeal to a general Presbyterian population for support. Maybe even appealing to them that they come over and join the OPC.

    Machen’s position drove him to fight tenaciously at the OPC’s second General Assembly. That’s November 12 through 14, 1936. to fight tenaciously at that Second Assembly for the adoption of the Westminster Standards in their pre-1903 form. The additions in 1903 to the Westminster Standards, to the Confession, had severely crippled the Calvinism of the Confession and had sent the Church in an Arminian direction, and away from the original commitments of the PCUSA. Thus, the PCUSA had forfeited its right to the heritage it claimed. And Machen and the OPC, in Machen’s mind, were laying claims to the original intention and commitment of the PCUSA. By going back to the pre-1903 forms, the OPC through Mason was then laying claim to this heritage.

    However, MacIntyre and other fundamentalists argued for the retention of the 1903 editions. MacIntyre spoke in favor of an overture from the Presbytery of New Jersey, his own presbytery I might add, to delay the question of the adoption of the Confessions form until the next General Assembly. And in the meanwhile, MacIntyre intended to solicit support through his magazine, the Christian Beacon, in the Presbyteries and among the Church’s membership for the adoption of the Standards in their post-1903 form. According to MacIntyre, the continuing Church could lay claim to true spiritual succession with the fullest possible leverage in pending property settlement cases only if the 1903 amendments were retained, only if the doctrinal standards at the point of making the suit, only if those doctrinal standards and statements were identical.

    But Nathan saw a delay, a calamity beyond words. And it was in this context that Van Til rose to his feet. and spoke on Machen’s defense and in defense of his position. And as a result of that, this Machen-Vantill alliance soundly defeated the Tending Motion. Machen and Vantill stood together, therefore, against the perceived threat of Arminianism within the 1903 edition. the threat of Arminianism, which they considered to be veiled even within the fundamentalist gospel.

    They spoke on behalf of a deeper Presbyterianism, a full-orbed confessional Calvinism that they felt undergirded Old Princeton and the Old Church, regardless of what the problems would be between them and their assessments of Old Princeton and the Old Church.

    What Vantow and the other members of Westminster’s young faculty knew and what now had become clear to Machen was the significant difference between the Presbyterianism they loved and the so-called, quote, American Presbyterianism, unquote, promoted by Presbyterian fundamentalism. By Buzwell and MacIntyre.

    The fundamentalist version of Presbyterianism placed great stock in its vision for America. Despite their premillennialism, these people, for all their pessimism about this world, were truly bully on America. Their evangelistic and moral zeal was connected to their patriotic ardor. By and large, politically, they opposed big government and anything that smacked of socialism. These things, rising to the level of those things that they opposed within theology and within the Church. Here were the champions of American individualism and democracy as they understood it. Features they felt had to be reflected in the church as well as in society.

    In their missions enterprises, they saw themselves as exporting American values as much as exporting the gospel. They blended their energetic, evangelistic enterprising with the commercialism of their day. George Marsden, the historian, has compared MacIntyre fundamentalism to the sales division of a modern corporation. But that insight carries much more sting than Marsden ever imagined. As we might expect, Presbyterian fundamentalists generated a strong protectionist spirit, highly suspicious of and downright hostile to foreign influences.

    H. McAllister Griffiths expressed himself on this issue in this way. Those who came to dominate the policies of Westminster Seminary and the OPC were not of American Presbyterian background. He had in mind John Murray, the Scot from the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and professors Kuyper, Stonehouse, and Van Til, all of whom he identified as being of, quote, Holland Dutch extraction. Griffiths charged these men with deliberately plotting an attack on modern dispensationalism.

    But it was an attack that got out of hand and got away from them. And in the course of it, they inadvertently destroyed the heritage which biblical democracy revered in American Presbyterianism. Pre-millennialists no longer felt welcome, they said, said Griffiths rather. As a result of this attack, pre-millennialists no longer felt welcome in the OPC.

    Alan McRae, that’s M-A-C-R-A-E, Alan McRae stood on similar ground, but was more specific. When he resigned from Westminster Seminary in May 1937, McCrae complained that, quote, control of the faculty has passed into the hands of a small alien group without American Presbyterian background.

    Later on, he indicated that he meant no offense to Murray. We know who’s left. He had in mind, indeed, the Dutchman, and among the Dutchman he singled out one in particular, whom he held responsible for the mess things were in, Van Till. So Cray said, quote, The effect of Van Till’s teaching upon the students had more to do with my resignation than anything else.”

    The apologetics question therefore equaled, if not exceeded, in importance in the mind of McRae the eschatological question he was himself a premillennial. In this, McRae echoed Buswell and all the fundamentalists saw the new seminary and church headed in directions foreign to those for their vision of American Presbyterianism.

    The whole matter came to a head in the Third General Assembly, June 1 through June 4, 1937. Now, the mood of that assembly was set early on when the assembly voted overwhelmingly to organize its own committee on foreign missions. And thus the denomination abandoned the independent board that in the previous November had unseated Machen from the presidency of that board. The Assembly then proceeded to reject overtures calling for the endorsement of total abstinence, these coming from the Fundamentalists, this being a plank in the Fundamentalists’ platform.

    When those overtures were rejected and the Assembly concluded, the fourteen ministers and three elders withdrew from the Church, and the following year the Bible Presbyterian Synod was organized Justifying its action on the ground that the OPC had departed quote from the historic position of American Presbyterianism unquote So the OPC was not the continuation of the old church There were differences you see the OPC was not the continuation of the old church and In that, the OPC now stood publicly opposite American Presbyterian fundamentalism, in addition to being intolerant of theological liberalism within the old church.

    But as Machen himself perceived before his death The OPC was turning out to be at odds with the old Church in a far deeper sense, and here the figure increasingly taking center stage at Westminster and in the consciousness of the Church was Van Til, a man who was virtually turning the study of apologetics head over heels. Van Til’s apologetic was revolutionary in two ways.

    Van Til did not see the task of apologetics as that of establishing the validity of first principles for the doing of theology or of thinking theologically. He did not see the task of apologetics as that of establishing the validity of first principles upon the basis of natural reason and in the interests of a natural theology. as had been the case in the classical position represented in Princeton. For Van Til, apologetics was the defense of the faith, not the defense of the possibility of the faith, or not the defense of the possibility of faith.

    It was the defense of the faith. And as such, Van Til concluded, apologetics presupposes the faith. The Bible’s truth in its revelation of the ontological trinity, and in its redemptive historical center, the self-attesting Christ. But further, the faith Vantill sought to defend was that of the Reformed churches expressed in their creeds. And therefore, Vantill’s apologetic was self-consciously biblical, theological, and ecclesiastical. In the second place, Vantill’s apologetic was philosophical.

    It was so overtly a sin for which the Boswells of the Church could not forgive him. But this had even greater significance to the wider currents of mainline Presbyterianism, American Presbyterianism considered in its widest sense. Provencial recognized within mainline Presbyterianism, as he did within mainline Protestantism generally, the streams of enlightenment thought at work. These streams had become a mighty river.

    Confirmation for Van Til’s assessment comes from a strange place. In 1977, Henry Steele Comminger, he’s not a member of the OPC, published The Empire of Reason. His thesis is simple. The enlightenment of the 18th century, with its boast in human autonomy and natural reason, did not fare as well in Europe as is ordinarily thought. actually faltering and sputtering in Europe, the Enlightenment crossed the Atlantic and found a home in the developing colonies. Now we may not buy all of Comminger’s thesis, but at least this much seems clear. He does make a good case for how well the Enlightenment did in this country.

    Moving the discussion into Presbyterian circles, Dr. Mark Knoll, N-O-L-L, wrote on the influences upon James Madison in the December 1987 issue of Pro Rega. Noel finds a central influence on Madison in John Witherspoon, Presbyterian president at the College of New Jersey, eventually Princeton University, and Madison’s teacher. Witherspoon was a Scottish immigrant and a clergyman who emerged quite the spokesman for the Enlightenment version of public religion. His roots were in the common-sense philosophy of the Scottish realists, but in the end his view of man in so many ways was indistinguishable from the Enlightenment idea.

    Man could, it seems, with a mind unaided by revelation, determine truth and could progress in that truth for the sake of the betterment of society, a worthy goal seemingly in itself. From Witherspoon to the 1930s, the Presbyterian steamroller had been on the move.

    It may have espoused an evangelical theology, even a robust Calvinism within the walls of the Church in various places at various times. But it struck common cause with Enlightenment ideology under the banner of autonomous reason in the public realm. In time, however, Enlightenment ideology moved into the Church and overshadowed the Church’s message. There were a few brave souls holding out in the back room for the old theology, but even they had hardly grasped what had gone wrong, since in their own way they had capitulated to autonomous reason and the cultural vision of the establishment and what that meant for American Presbyterianism.

    A place in the establishment, you see. Now, this scenario added to the tragedy of J. Russell Machen. His outspoken, intelligent, militant stand for orthodoxy earned him a one-way ticket out of the Church, but also out of the culture of which that Church was an integral part. Machen had himself become an alien. in a culture that he knew better than any other person around him.

    He was born and bred in the best of Baltimore society. He was speaking French as a child around the dinner table. His parents were reading to him the classics. His father in his eightieth years was teaching himself Italian. I mean, this is the kind of culture that this man grew up in.

    Machen knew that cultured Presbyterianism at its best, but his stand for orthodoxy placed him outside the church, but also outside of the culture of which that church was an integral part. He had become an alien. He had become a counter-cultural figure in the best sense of that word.

    And the movement that he had fathered was, from its beginnings, disenfranchised. without establishment credentials, the OPC was nothing less than a Presbyterian anomaly. Presbyterians are always establishmentarian. They are so by definition. That’s what it means to be a Presbyterian. So the OPC was now cast in the role of a Presbyterian anomaly. It simply did not fit the form in a nation where the Presbyterian Church is the establishment.

    It was Van Til’s philosophical apologetic that enabled him to see these things better than even Machen. Better than most, even who were or have been a part of the OPC. But this much is clear. The OPC was not a mere continuation of the old church. since that old church, even at its best, was infected with the viruses of the Enlightenment.

    Van Til knew it simply would not do to return to the establishmentarianism of American Presbyterianism. Here, beyond the millennial issue, the temperance question, debates with modernism per se, was the crucial issue. for the OPC, the tie to American culture inherent to American Presbyterianism, had been severed. They had a route of appeal to the general populace, not through their theology, but through their politics, economics, and sociology.

    And when they saw, not able to articulate it possibly this way, when they saw the deconstruction of that bridge going on in the early days of the OPC, they had to get out. They had to leave. because it was an attack upon their essential identity. Of course, the establishment Presbyterians did not need a bridge at all, since they were very well integrated into the culture. Their response was contempt.

    Contempt for the OPC and for Van Til, particularly. contempt for Van Til, especially, for telling them that the world that they had helped to make, the world in which they believed in, was, in fact, rotten. Van Til’s greatest struggle would not be with the fundamentalists in the 30s, however. Instead, in the 40s, he battled a residual evangelicalism and a tangential Presbyterian elitism. A residual evangelicalism and a tangential Presbyterian elitism.

    The first chapter of this struggle was the battle over the Committee of Nine, directed at the 8th General Assembly in 1941. The motion to establish this committee reads like this, that a committee of nine, six ministers and three elders be elected by the General Assembly to study the relationship of the OPC to society in general, and to other ecclesiastical bodies in particular, with a view to bringing into the next General Assembly recommendations suggesting ways and means whereby the message and methods of our Church may be better implemented to meet the needs of this generation, and the OPC may have an increasing area of influence and make a greater impact on life today. Now, to tell you just how important the church perceived this issue at the time, the motion, the establishment of this committee of nine, it took six ballots to elect a full slate of members. Van Til was not elected until the fifth ballot. The other members of the committee of nine were the ministers, Edwin Ryan, R-I-A-N.

    R.D. Kuyper, interestingly. Robert Strong, Burton Goddard of Gordon College. Clifford Smith. The elders were C.A. Freitag, Murray Forst Thompson. and Gordon Clark. According to the Reverend Lawrence Ayers, the driving force behind the idea for this committee was none other than Edwin Wyatt, who was himself a Presbyterian elitist.

    And who, although he wrote a very fine, excellent book, and I’ll be happy to sell you a copy, entitled The Presbyterian Conflict. We have recently republished that book. The best account, in fact, in short treatment of the struggles of the 20s and 30s, I might add. So although he did write this fine book, there being some evidence that Nietzsche actually stood behind that work.

    Ryan was working off of Machen’s materials since Machen was working on a document the last summer of his life entitled The Conflict. No one knows where those notes went after Machen’s death. It’s tough for me to put in good words for Ryan. You’ll see why eventually.

    Despite the book, the book itself is excellent. I like to see the figure of Machen standing behind it. But although he did write this very fine book, he dreamt about the OPC. I’d be willing to bet that he spent some sleepless nights over this too. He dreamt about the OPC as a very, very large Presbyterian body with the cultural clout of the PCUSA. Now Ryan dominated the committee. and he had six others agreeing with him.

    That meant the two, if my math is correct, descended. The elder, Mary Forrest Thompson and Dan Till. It would be interesting to investigate R.B. Kuyper’s attitude in this, but I don’t have any clues about that presently. The public debate at the assembly focused on the fear that if the majority got its way, a super committee was in the offing that would become a permanent bureaucratic feature in the Church’s future. Remember the objective? They were going to investigate ways that they could make more impact upon public life. have a super committee established that would be virtually determining their posture towards society and culture in general. You see, that was what was in the battle.

    In actual fact, the point was whether the OPC was to reclaim a lost American Presbyterian heritage. But a return to that heritage under the leadership of a man like Ryan would mean an uncritical acceptance of the Presbyterian Cultural Synthesis. Van Til and Thompson’s minority report won the assembly and the committee was dissolved. Minority won. This loss for Ryan signaled a breach between him and Van Til and a breach between him and the other members of the faculty at Westminster Seminary. the institution where he was the president of the board of trustees.

    Still, when the suggestion arose in the mid-forties for the organization of a Christian university, strangely enough, this man who was seemingly the odd man out now, this man Ryan became the general secretary for the association responsible for managing this whole affair.

    Ryan had definite ideas about the shape and form the Christian university should take, ideas that were of variance with the seminary men and others who had been brought into the enterprise from outside, from the Christian Reformed Church, for instance. Ryan thought the university should stand in the interests of the American Presbyterian cultural line, and it was at that time that William B. Erdmann, gave a great deal of money to the Association. Instead of using that money to take care of property matters, Ryan diverted those funds to purchase gratis memberships in the Association for the Right People. By stacking the Association with those of like mind, Ryan planned to redirect the university movement.

    The plot was discovered, however, by the board and Ryan was fired. Subsequently, members of the Presbytery of Philadelphia from the OPC visited Ryan early 1947 to prefer charges against him for breach of trust. It was at that point that Ryan fled the OPC.

    He fled claiming that he had re-read the fourth book of Calvin’s Institutes and had been convinced that Machen and the OPC had been schismatic all along. That’s what found its way into the press. But of course, if Machen and the OPC had been schismatic all along, he was guilty also of schism, so he had to repent, which is what he did. He repented and returned to the PCUSA, the church whose cultural elitism he had never left.

    I might say that Brian did very well for himself. Subsequently, he rose to the position of assistant to the president at Princeton Seminary, the last position he held in his public life. I might also add that Brian is still alive, living in San Diego.

    The second chapter in Van Til’s struggle during the forties involved some of those who had been a part of the Committee of Nine, Robert Strong, Clifford Smith, and Gordon Clark. Ryan was involved also, but not as directly, since the interests of these men, Strong, Smith, and Clark, the interests of these men were more evangelical and less elitist.

    Events had been put in motion in 1940 when J. Oliver Buswell had been removed as president of Wheaton College because of his involvement in the Presbyterian controversy. That removal of Buswell led to a chain of events, and by 1943, Gordon Clark, a Buswell appointee, a very gifted Christian philosopher who was teaching at Wheaton, found little sympathy for his Calvinism within the new administration. So without a job, Clark became the interest of a congregation in Philadelphia who wished him to become its pastor. Since Clark was a layman without seminary training, he had to secure certain requirement waivers before the General Assembly, which he did at the 1944 assembly. Prior to that assembly in 1944, four ministers, some of whom had been a part of a committee of nine majority, caucused for two days on the State of the Church.

    They drafted a plan for action in the OPC and distributed it to a selected group of men on May 11, five days before the Assembly convened. The plan pleaded for a return to the theme of true spiritual succession to the PCUSA. It also pleaded for a strong program of evangelism. It opposed the narrowness of Westminster Seminary and the Presbyterian Guardian. in favor of church-controlled seminaries and magazines, and in favor of greater cooperation in the fundamentalist evangelical world. It listed as a specific objective the ordination of Gordon Clark, a figure those responsible for this plan felt greatly important for the realization of their greater goals.

    The fight was on. Clark was ordained August 9, 1944, but a complaint was filed and found its way to the General Assembly in 1945. The complaint argued many things, but chief was the question of Clark’s orthodoxy on the matter of the incomprehensibility of God. Clark defended the primacy of the intellect in a way directly at variance with Van Til’s formulation of the principle of analogy.

    Simply put, according to Van Til, God’s knowledge is an extension of his ontological difference from man, or creator-creature distinction. Therefore, there is a qualitative difference between God’s knowledge and man’s knowledge. Man’s knowledge is like God’s knowledge. It is analogous to God’s knowledge, but it is not the same as God’s knowledge. For Van Til, Clark’s position destroyed the creator-creature distinction, and was guilty of a gross rationalism. Clark, on the other hand, believed God’s knowledge incomprehensible in a quantitative sense, that is, God knows infinitely more than man can ever know. However, God’s and man’s knowledge are of the same kind. Any other physician, said Clark, ends in skepticism, if not mysticism.

    Still, the larger issue in this whole debate was whether the OPC would maintain a course that moved it away from the unfortunate features of American Presbyterianism, even in its evangelical expression and toward a more reformed and antithetical identity. Clark had become the front man for a fight to bring the Church back to the American tradition. Once more, the cry went up that the OPC was under the thumb of men who represented reformed traditions from other lands.

    But for these, with the ever so powerful thumb, such as Van Til, alliance with the fundamentalists and evangelicals in the interests of recapturing American society employed suspicious means to gain suspect ends. It would land the church right back in the soup out of which it had come.

    The third and final chapter in Van Til’s struggle involved the figure of Floyd E. Hamilton. Floyd E. Hamilton. Although the General Assembly failed to find for the complainants on the doctrinal issue in the Clark case, It did find the procedures of the Presbyterian of Philadelphia irregular. Still, Gordon Clark’s ordination stood, but the mood in the church was tense. The plan for action did, after all, call for the recapture of the denomination in the cause of American Presbyterianism. Now comes to center stage the figure of Floyd Hamilton. Hamilton was an able man, but a fierce defender of Clark and an even fiercer evidentialist. So in that respect, he was not of a mind with Clark, interestingly.

    His appointment to a seminary post in Korea was under review by the Foreign Missions Committee. While the committee was willing to send Hamilton to Korea as a missionary, it would not approve his appointment to a seminary position because of his theological position.

    Those who had favored the Committee of Nine majority and the plan for action decided to make their stand, their all-out stand, over the issue of Hamilton’s appointment. As a result, two entirely different slate of candidates were put up before the Assembly for consideration for positions in the Board for Foreign Missions. After a day’s debate, the Assembly sustained the Foreign Missions Committee by returning to office a majority of those who opposed Hamilton.

    The margin of difference in the Assembly was one vote. But the defeat was far greater than the margin of difference. Many who favored Hamilton, who stood for the plan of action, who supported Gordon Clark and his position, who represented the broad evangelical cause, resigned from their General Assembly Committee assignments before the end of that assembly. And within a year and a half, most of those men had left the OPC, including Gordon Clark.

    As sad as these departures were, the hope of the OPC had been preserved. Van Til had been the central figure, the representative figure, in the further development of this Presbyterian anomaly that resisted all efforts to make it an extension of American provincialism. Instead, this church’s interests would be Catholic. that is worldwide and reformed, not simply American.

    Well, thank you, Reverend Dennison. I think there should be time for some questions, and so we’ll do as we did yesterday. I’ll give it back over to Reverend Dennison. We should break no later than 10 o’clock. Are there any questions? The kinds of tensions and struggles you’re describing within the OPC, do you see those same kinds of tensions within the PCA today? No. Well, I certainly don’t see anybody in print picking up on the dynamics that I’ve gone over.

    As far as I can see, the PCA has made its decision. It’s made its choice. It has determined, and I believe that from the outset, that it will be an American Presbyterian body, even though it has congregations in Canada. It will be basically a United States American, in that narrow sense, phenomenon.

    Oh yes, and I think if any of you have traveled in the South and you’ve visited some PCA churches, You know what I’m talking about. It’s nothing for a PCA congregation during the election season to be treated to a political candidate stepping into the pulpit and making his political pitch to the congregation. That’s routine in some places. I don’t see any evidence in the PCA that the dynamics have been sorted out.

    I think also that in addition to that, I think they’ve proven themselves ecumenically. They are really throwing their weight towards the NAE and towards the World Evangelical Fellowship. Now Horton’s an interesting phenomenon, right? He’s definitely an anomaly in the PCA. Is there much of a movement there? I’m not quite sure where Greenville is going to come down.

    It seems to me that they wish to be representative of an old school Southern Presbyterianism. Now if the PCA is broad enough to think of themselves in terms of Hey, the borders of the USA, the good old US of A, has Morton narrowed things even more, in a sense, by drawing it into a regional context. Southern Presbyterianism is what we’re interested in, and I think he’s quite upfront about that, if I’m not mistaken. They want to be seen as the defenders of southern, old school, southern Presbyterianism.

    I don’t see much future for that. I mean, there’s certain cultural buttons that that pushes, you know, local control, away from bureaucracy, empowerment to the ruling elders, those kinds of things that do get a response. But I have to believe that the that the push for us, for God’s people, has to be beyond these either regional or ethnic or national boundaries. You’ve got to push beyond those things. One more on that.

    What about the folks who are leaving the OPC to join the PTA? Are they conscious of what they’re doing? I think that beneath… Yes, I think that there’s always… I think that there is… People suspect it, but they can’t articulate it. You know what I mean? It’s running through their veins, but they can’t put it down on paper. It’s like what was happening during the debates between the RPC-ES, the OPC, the PCA on merger. Why is it that the RPC-ES is so attracted to the PCA, but the OPC is not? How do you account for that? Is it just the matters that get front page?

    Oh, you know, those OPs are nothing but a bunch of theological nitpickers. They don’t really have any philosophy of growth. They want to be small. They boast about being small. You know, that kind of thing. You know, we don’t want those kind of people around.

    They’re negative. That’s front page. That’s front page. But what’s really, I think, sticking in the craw is the fact that the OP simply is not to be swallowed or digested by the broad American evangelical point of view. It’s not going to happen. They recognize that there’s something that resists. For instance, you see, the OPC has no cultural bridge. Fundamentalism does, and it’s militant in its approach. Evangelicalism does. It’s the velvet glove approach. I’m quite gentlemanly about it, but as I said yesterday, the fundamentalists want all the time and the evangelicals just won’t equal time.

    I think that it’s just something that won’t go down, and I think that as these men leave the OPC, they are realizing increasingly that there’s something that doesn’t fit for them in the OPC. There’s something in the air. There’s something in the water. It just doesn’t fit.

    So they leave, and I think it’s in the interest of broader issues of a cultural Presbyterianism, of an evangelical variety. I can say, you know, you get the old picture of the relationship of the Reformed Church to the Evangelical Church, where you have the two blocks, you know, I mean you’ve probably done that, where you have the two squares that, you know, you have the Reformed Church, you have the Evangelical Church, and there’s an overlapping down here in the corner. between the two. Then there’s the other approach which sees one square, one large square, called the Evangelical Church, and in the corner of the large square there’s this little square called the Reformed Church. I think the people who have left the OPC have opted for that latter approach. Probably not as much as McCrae feared. I think that in many ways McCrae’s fears were personal.

    He was facing students were coming in from Van Til’s classes, and McCray was interested in using a great deal of archaeological evidence to prove his case for the validity of scripture. Not that these things aren’t useful, you see, and interesting, but Van Til was saying, no, the issue is deeper than that. How do you view evidence? What’s the philosophy behind it? Your approach to these evidences, that kind of thing.

    And McCrae was very interested personally in maintaining the loyalty of the students. And he was losing his following. And so therefore it threw him in a crisis position. He was a very astute person. He saw that he was going to be a marginal individual in the future of Westminster. He saw that clearly. And there just wasn’t going to be any prospects for him professionally there.

    In addition to the theological matters, they were important, and the apologetical issue, which was very important to him, there were personal matters too. But I think that, as I said, the fears of McCrae were probably greater than have actually been realized in the OPC, and I’ll say that for this reason. It’s not that individuals coming out of Westminster, going into the OPC, haven’t embraced the apologetics of Vantel. But sadly, as is the case in many pastors, that isn’t a front-burner issue for them once they hit the pavement. They had a very difficult time working out that apologetics in relationship to the details of pastoral life. McCrae’s criticism, or Buswell’s criticism, was correct. Unfortunately, Van Til’s perspective ended up being somewhat theoretical to many of the individuals, and they embraced it somewhat naively. Van Til’s apologetic is a learned language.

    And if you don’t keep practicing the learned language, you lose it. You might claim that you still know it. And that’s what most, I think, OP ministers have done. They claim that they still know the stand to apologetics. They’re committed to it. And I think they’re committed to the idea, possibly in the interest of what they consider to be a consistent reform position, you see. And so the apologetics stance becomes somewhat tangential. to what’s really moving and motivating them. So, as I say, the band-took apologetic is a learned language and unless you keep involved with it, your ability to handle it and to use it and to profit from it is greatly diminished.

    Yes. Was the split between Van Till and Clark necessary? They certainly thought so. If it was necessary in your mind, could their disagreement over that, could they still have stayed in the bounds of the Westminster Concession Estate and still have a disagreement? The OPC said they could. See, Clark was never disciplined.

    None of the complaints were ever sustained except the one that there had been certain improprieties in the way they went about licensing him and ordaining him. They conducted his exams for licensure and ordination at the same time. General Assembly saw that as an irregularity and sustained a complaint in that respect. But there was no other complaint or dimension of the complaint sustained by the General Assembly.

    So the Assembly voted that Clark’s position was legitimate. It was within the bounds of the confession. And that’s the judgment of the Church. As to whether the discussion was substantive, I believe it was tremendously substantive. There were more issues involved, as you know. The free offer of the gospel was involved. The nature of faith in the believer, that was involved, too. All of these questions were pertinent.

    But as Michael Hackenberg in Pressing Toward the Mark, I think, has successfully demonstrated, even beyond these theological and even philosophical issues, was that broad question of whether the OPC was going to be reformed in an international sense, or American Presbyterian in a narrow sense. Providentially, as things worked out through the Floyd Hamilton instance, the church was moved in that international reform direction.

    I don’t happen to believe I agree with John Frame. I don’t happen to believe that the debate was near foolishness and virtually substanceless. I mean, I almost get the impression that John is saying, if I were there, things would have been different. That’s a little hard to take. I haven’t read the book, I know Gary.

    I think that even beyond the theonomic critiques that there are those who have generally felt that the Westminster apologetic is in a state of decline at the seminary and in the OTC. I think that that’s probably accurate. Now I think that at the same time Westminster East would be adamant in saying that that is not correct.

    And you have Dr. Knutson, Robert Knutson, as the head of the department now in apologetics. And you have Bill Edgar, who’s come into the department. And I’ll tell you, I have the greatest respect for Dr. Knutson. And even though I know he’s been very supportive of the Dewey-Viridian point of view, and even stood opposite of Van Tillen in some respects. I have a great deal of respect for Knudsen, and I think that his interest is to maintain a Van Tillen perspective, but not without critique.

    I think Bill Edgar is probably the nicest guy you ever want to meet. He’s just a marvelously generous individual. But Bill’s training is not specifically in philosophy. as was Van Til’s, is more in the arts and in culture generally. So there’s a different edge to Edgar’s apologetic than there had been previously.

    Now some would say that possibly that’s a weakening of it and I think the jury’s still out on that. I think that there’s been a turn. I think that the interest, at least the general feel of things, and I can’t say this is true for Knudsen or for Edgar, so it’s not really fair. to say that about them. But as far as Frayn is concerned, and the influence that he has, and as far as Verne Poitras is concerned, there has been a turn, and that turn involves a certain enamorment with linguistic analysis, language philosophy. And there are those who contend that this does in fact mean a turning away from the Vantillian Insights. So, there’s a new direction.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Stonehouse and Ambivalence

    Stonehouse and Ambivalence

    This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered November 1, 1995.

    About this sermon

    The young OPC’s struggle with ecumenism met a test case in the Peniel Movement and the disputed errors of Beers, with Ned Stonehouse and Sloyer on opposite sides. The Penielists claimed a deeper spirituality, and their claims fall short. Modern evangelicalism shows the same ambivalence toward similar movements.

    Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    You may have your attention. We’re at that point where we’re here, the third of Reverend Dennison’s lectures. The third, the last of the lectures will follow the format we’ve been following. After he’s given his address, we’ll allow some time for questions, at which time, no later than 12, we will make that our outer limit. No later than 12, we will adjourn. Reverend Dennison’s third lecture is entitled Ambivalence. the ecumenical struggles of the OPC, especially as they included a struggle with the question of divine guidance. and in the way in which the OP handles its problems at the end of the 40s is overshadowed by two clouds.

    The one cloud was the continuation in the church of those who were essentially in disagreement with the direction the church was going. So with Clark’s departure, With the departure of others who were associated with him, not everyone who was in agreement with Clark left the denomination. There was a continuing element that was present and exerted quite an influence. I would say that I would judge that the chief figure in this respect would be Edmund P. Clowney, who was a supporter of Clark. and eventually then became president of Westminster Seminary. Their vision continued to be an indigenous, large-scale, national Presbyterian church with very definite, strong ties to the evangelical community.

    The other cloud was the particularly dark thunderhead of criticism directed against the OPC for its doctrinally intense theological nitpicking stance. This second cloud posed a great threat because beneath its shadow, those who stood with the greatest theological integrity may in fact begin to relax their guard in the name of Christian charity and cordiality.

    The pressure is extreme. I think that everybody who has been a part of the life of the church in some official capacity can testify to the pressures that come upon you. If you’ve taken a particularly strong stand, it seems imperative that you somehow prove that you’re human in reflex to that strong stand. Their efforts to communicate warmth and an appropriately tolerant spirit in response to the severe criticisms could leave them somewhat slow-witted in the face of certain challenges. And, of course, pressure multiplies when those certain challenges come, and especially warm, gracious, solicitous people who excel in the qualities of what seem to be a sincere and genuine spirituality, backing down before those who seem to overwhelm you with their graciousness.

    There is, at the same time, a deeper and more perplexing level to this matter that takes us right into the heart of the age-old doctrine-like problem. It has been contended, simplifying things a great deal now, to be sure that there are two sides to the church, one emphasizing doctrine and the other life. In observing the dynamics of the interaction of these two sides, the observation has been made that each side, in the interests of wholeness, tends to compensate for its deficiency in efforts to incorporate the other side into it. The end result, however, is weakness results as, for instance, on the doctrinal side, it reduces the importance of doctrine in order to appeal to those who, despite their doctrinal handicap, show evidence of genuine spiritual health. Likewise, the pro-life side weakens itself when it reaches out to doctrine for the sake of establishing its own credibility.

    And this brings to mind questions about sincerity. We reach the ground floor to this doctrine-like difficulty when we realize that both sides carry within themselves what is perceived to stand opposite to them. We reach the ground floor to this doctrine-like difficulty when we realize that both sides carry within themselves what is perceived to stand opposite to them.

    If, in fact, these sides do stand respectively as distinct temperaments for an approach to Christian life, they stand holistically as systems complete in themselves. Therefore, the doctrine side, in its best expressions, has its own perspective on Christian life. It has the doctrine life components within itself. and the life side is not devoid of doctrine as is often imagined, but possessed of a doctrine inherent to it.

    Confusion about and ignorance of the ground floor to the doctrine-like debate has placed the Church repeatedly in hot water. The case in point is the rise and reign of the modern practical theological movement. Taking a chapter out of the more recent history of the OPC, I call your attention to the struggle the OPC experienced in the 80s over the Church Growth School of Thought. Repeatedly, the Church Growth Group assured the Assembly that it embraced and assumed the Church’s Calvinism. that its interest was in the practical matters of church development and dynamic Christian witness. Many, however, sensed that these practical interests actually expressed a theology inherent to them, one at variance with the Reformed confessionalism subscribed to by the denomination.

    In the debates, neither side seemed to be able to get to the theological ground floor. Possibly the church growth group had no real interest in doing that. Some on the doctrinal side seemed to accept the other side’s explanation. The church growth group was orthodox, but confused about the place and value of Methodism. But others were convinced that the problem was more severe. However, they did not press on to a thorough, more penetrating analysis.

    And their refusal to do so keeps in place the ambivalence that lives beneath the cloud that has hung over the Church at least since the late 40s. This cloud unless it is dealt with, is due, well let’s put it this way, the ambivalence that lives beneath that cloud is destined to be a source of contention and great controversy in the church. A great storm lets loose. on the church at the close of the Clark controversy.

    It is the battle over Peniel. P-E-N-I-E-L. This issue disturbs the church directly for 14 years, and indirectly much longer. In fact, to 1969 and possibly even into the 70s with the Arnie Kress case. But in line with our argument, the denial issue is a monument to OPC ambivalence. and ambivalence expressed even by the Church’s strongest and most orthodox personalities.

    Peniel bears the name given by Jacob to the place where he wrestled with the angel, Genesis 32 verse 30. Peniel means, of course, the face of God. Jacob having given this explanation, I have seen God face to face, yet my life has been The penile movement in its name sets as its objective life before the face of God. The roots of penile are debated, to say the least. Historically, the roots, so say the adherents of penile, go no further back than to the early thirties.

    Liberalism prevailed in the upstate New York churches. Young people from some of those liberal churches in and around Schenectady began meeting for Bible studies. When it became evident that they needed help, they turned to the nearby Albany Bible Institute.

    Two teachers, Susan Beers and Rhoda Armstrong, interestingly women, came to their aid and joined a young engineering student named Ray Miners, M-E-I-N-E-R-S, a member of the group. And these three virtually were the teachers of those young people in those days. In 1933, after Miners left to pursue further studies, the group took advantage of an offer from one of its members to use the family cottage on Lake Luzerne for a week-long retreat. Miss Beers and Miss Armstrong again were involved in the teaching.

    Before too long, however, the loan of a family cottage turned into rental of many cottages, and then the purchase of property, and the Penile Bible Conference was born, an organization that continues to this present day. To the group’s credit, it recognized that it could not content itself with a mere Bible conference. There had to be some expression ecclesiastically. The churches were in deplorable state, and Ray Miners had gone off to secure education necessary to do something about the church situation.

    He studied at Westminster. He graduated from Westminster in 1938. And he returned to Schenectady and to this group, which was now ready and willing to organize a church under him. Minor’s training at Westminster Seminary determined his course and the course of the group.

    So on November 4, 1938, Calvary Orthodox Presbyterian Church was received into the Presbytery of New York, New England. Both the congregation and the Bible Conference flourished. Many, many people throughout New England and even beyond were influenced. The Bible Conference became famous as a magnet for young people, especially young men who had their eye on Christian ministry and service. A number of those men, of course, then were off to seminary, and the seminary of choice at that time was Westminster Seminary. Two men deeply affected were Herman Peterson, that’s P-E-T-E-R-S-E-N, a 1941 graduate from Westminster Seminary who pastored the newly organized Covenant OPC of Albany, New York from 1943 to 1949. And also, and a little later, Grover Travers Sloyer. S-L-O-Y-E-R. Sloyer graduated from Westminster in 1950. He served as stated supply at Redeemer OPC in Philadelphia from 1950 to 1954. That length of time demands some explanation, and we’ll get to that, and as a pastor from 1954 to 1959 in the same congregation. Essentially, around these two men, the penile controversy turned. But as we said earlier, the origins of the penile movement are debated.

    We don’t want to lose our grip on that question. Questions rise as to what particular influence came upon the movement in its early days. No one’s arguing the fact that it seemed to just grow up ad hoc in the upstate New York area. But the question is, what particular influences came upon that movement in its early days?

    In order to get a better fix on this, we need to know about the distinctive features of penile. One advocate for penile claims that, quote, if any theological construction prevailed in the early years, it was the reformed faith brought into penile by Ray Miners straight out of Westminster Seminary and Reformation. So if you have problems with denial, you know who to blame. It may well be that the Reformed faith did play a significant part in those early days. But it must be remembered that minors did not arrive at Westminster until 1935. What were the influences prior to Minor’s Westminster days, or even his arrival back in the Penile area.

    It might be judged that, yes, Machen was one of those influences since Machen, in part, drew Minors to Westminster Seminary. But did Machen have an influence generally upon the group beyond Minors? This, of course, is plausible. since Machen was recognized as a fundamentalist leader in his day. But if Machen was such a great influence, was it at all because of his reformed positions? This is most certainly not the case, since Machen’s strengths as the champion for the reformed cause are not seen until nearly the end of his life. Further, it is highly doubtful that the interest in Machen at the Albany Bible Institute, the institute from which much of the early instruction came, was because of Machen’s ardent Calvinism. We can say that Fundamentalism most definitely influenced Peniel in its formative years. But what form did Fundamentalism take? Was it the straight-up American fundamentalism?

    Many features of the movement of Peniel, as it developed, weigh against this conclusion. There are general features that distinguish Peniel from the garden-variety American fundamentalism. For instance, there is no evidence that Peniel was much exercised about the usual fundamentalist concerns, such as the millennium. social moral questions of the day, the separated life, the threat of world communism, the incursion of foreigners and their influence.

    The Nihilists were more interested in other things, as we shall see. For now, let me say, they were more meditative, more studious, more mystical than fundamentalism. Even beyond this, penile held to an interdenominationalism. Now it could be said that fundamentalism does the same in that it transcends confessions, tries to get beyond the strictures of confessional identity, but the penilists did this with a difference. The penilist version of interdenominationalism granted to its para-ecclesiastical identity more autonomy and importance than even fundamentalism would be comfortable with.

    One adherent of Peniel wrote, Peniel has a far greater and more spiritual understanding of the importance of the Church as Christ’s body and the harbinger of his kingdom than even the OPC does, having not succumbed to the notion that we are the only true Church constantly purifying ourselves from contact with all the rest of the body. Now the accuracy of this portrayal of the OPC aside, the writer seems to be setting the parachurch in its expression at Peniel above the church with pride of place, because Peniel better reflects the true nature of the body of Christ by including in it those the church excludes. So while we can say that fundamentalism most definitely influences Peniel, and that undoubtedly through Peniel’s dependence upon the Albany Bible Institute, Peniel had a distinctive identity. Also, according to what we have seen, and its own testimony, Peniel was influenced, yes, in addition to Fundamentalism, by the Reformed theology of Westminster Seminary and the OPC.

    But yet, even in this regard, it had its own distinctive twist. That distinctive identity for Peniel comes to expression in doctrines that gave occasion for the OPC’s judgment. We mention two major areas. First of all, Peniel was committed to a secondary work by the Spirit for the attainment of full Christian maturity. Peniel was committed to a secondary work by the Spirit for the attainment of a full Christian maturity.

    It is reported by Arthur Kuschke, librarian at Westminster Seminary, directly involved in the Peniel controversy, that Miss Susan Dears, early teacher at Pennile and great influence in the Pennile movement throughout, made much of the word then in Romans 6.1. What shall we say then? According to Miss Dears, Paul intends his reader to move on from the experience of justification to the experience of sanctification which is then,” this experience of sanctification, which is then subsumed in verse 6 of Romans 6, under the words, knowing this, that our old man is crucified.

    The experience of knowing that our old man is crucified is called by Nisbeer’s, quote, She went from Romans 6.6 to Romans 8.4 and the statement about walking after the Spirit, the connection being that those who have met the cross in this secondary experience are those who are in fact walking in the Spirit.

    From here, Miss Deer’s theology carries tones of perfectionism. since in her mind, Romans 6.12 implied for her that it was possible, in what seems to be an absolute way, not to let sin reign in your mortal body.

    But even more to the point, and the crucial point in the debate, walking in the Spirit meant such an awareness of God’s immediate presence, God’s immediate presence, that the Christian could be assured of the Holy Spirit’s direct involvement in all the decisions of life.

    The direct, immediate involvement of the Spirit in all the decisions of life. In fact, the Spirit was to be consulted through the methods of penile, for ascertaining. what one should do in the various circumstances of life. There are ways in which to come to what seem to be infallible assurances with regard to what one should do, even to the point of whether you should put the left shoe on before the right shoe when you get up in the morning. And such matters as serious as who your life’s partner will be, whether they are agreeable or not. You have a certain amount of leverage if you’re able to come to them and say, Guidance from the Holy Spirit in a direct and immediate way, and apart from the scriptures, was at the disposal of those who had met the cross.

    As a result of the penile doctrine of guidance, the movement would seem to be on a direct collision course with the OPC over the questions of the closing of the canon and the sufficiency of scripture. Commitments such as those expressed by Ms. Beers drive us to sources other than American fundamentalism and certainly most definitely beyond Reformed orthodoxy. Undoubtedly, as Arthur Kushti has pointed out, the source of much of Peniel’s distinctive terminology arose from none other source than Susan Beers herself. I might say in this regard, noting the movement’s independency, its novelty, and the prominence of female leadership, it seems to have some of the distinctive features of a cult. We do have, then, these direct lines to various traditions. We have also the fact that these traditions are subjected to the twists that Peniel then brings to bear upon the traditions. We have Susan Beers herself, but then we have the correspondence within Peniel to various movements that In fact, take us far beyond these considerations that we’ve listed so far. For instance, some have suggested a link between Susan Beers and Jesse Penn Lewis. That’s a hyphenated last name. Jesse Penn Lewis, a key figure in the 1904-1905 Welsh revival. We have a link then with revivalism.

    But most certainly the correspondence is evident between Peniel and the methods, because you see, Peniel was deeply involved in a methodical program for discovering the Holy Spirit’s will. The correspondence between Peniel and the methods of Wesley, as well as later holiness movements emanating from Finney, who had a great influence, you might recall, in upstate New York, and also the Keswick movement in England, and rounding out things, the second blessing-ism of Pentecostalism. Still, Peniel, while having affinity with all these various strains, has never accepted direct linkage with any of them. Peniel saw itself more broadly still in a way that transcended movements, and these movements particularly, just as it transcended the limitations of denominations and confessions. Peniel, therefore, had tied on to something more universal, something that ran through all of these movements, something it found expressed according to its own analysis Even in the Calvinism of Westminster and the OPC, Peniel represented and was a special instance of the so-called spirituality movement, broadly conceived. I want to talk to you about Richard Lovelace. Richard Lovelace is a teacher at Gordon Conwell Seminary. He is a devotee of Peniel. He is a graduate also of Westminster Seminary.

    And he has set out the evangelical defense for the universal significance of the spirituality category in his 1979 book, Dynamics of Spiritual Life and Evangelical Theology of Renewal. In this book, Lovelace writes in the interests of what he calls a, quote, unified field theory of spirituality, unquote. A unified field theory of spirituality. The burden of which is to bring out the common thread that runs through the various groups of genuine believers. Namely, the experience of newness of life in Christ. experiences and claims of renewal are the common bond between Arminians, Calvinists, Charismatics, Catholics, Thomas Merton, Thomas Aquinas, John Calvin, John Wesley, at least from Wobley’s reading of things. There is this supercategory, then, you see, that is above everything else. It is the category of spirituality, defined as the experience of newness of life in Christ.

    As you can see, this unified field theory of spirituality enjoys the advantage, the rather imperious advantage, of identifying with all movements, yet hovering over them all. It’s sort of like the Christian version of Hare Krishna. Did you ever run into those people at the airport? Did you ever try to talk to them and they tried to convince you that they were Christians too?

    Along with everything else. In the doctrine-life dichotomy that we spoke of earlier, Lovelace’s spirituality position comes down on the side of life, while claiming to have a doctrinal position amenable to the many that he considers legitimate, including the reformed position. But what most people miss is that the spirituality position has a doctrinal commitment inherent to itself that stands in direct counter-variance, especially to the Reformed point of view. By the way, Lovelace dedicated his book to Susan Beers. Take a drink here. In 1948, during the OPC’s 15th General Assembly in Wildwood, New Jersey, Arthur Krischke was invited to go to dinner with John Rankin and Herman Peterson. Remember the name Herman Peterson. 1948. The Clark case is just concluded. The subject of discussion is Peniel, now about 16 years old. Rankin has a little congregation in Worcester, New York, and he has been disturbed by the influx of young people from Peniel.

    Peterson’s congregation in Albany is divided presently over the issue. Making matters worse for Peterson is the fact that he has been a Penielist, but now finds himself a victim of its excesses and at odds with it. The advice these two men received that night from Arthur Kuschke is to stand their ground and to bring the matter to the Presbytery’s attention. Matters did come to a head in September of that year at a meeting of the Presbytery of New York, New England. The Presbytery set before it not only the growing concern of these two pastors, but the consideration of the recent vote at the church in Albany. The church had voted 13 to 12 in favor of Peterson’s removal, as Peterson says, because of my repudiation of penile teaching. The Presidetary conducted an extensive investigation found in favor of Peterson and subsequently passed several resolutions on the subject of penile, warning against its dangers.

    As far as the Albany congregation was concerned, however, the damage was done. The penilists left, but by December of 1949, Peterson had left also. The church limped along for twelve more years, sometimes without a pastor, and finally dissolved in 1962. By and large now, the situation is under control in New York, New England.

    The debate, however, will move to the Presbytery of Philadelphia. The transition figure is the man we mentioned earlier, G. Travers Slawyer. Sloyer is a Philadelphia native who graduated from Westminster in 1950. However, he comes out of Westminster a devoted disciple of Peniel. Soon after his graduation, he has a license to preach from the Presbytery of New York, New England. but still living in the Philadelphia area following his graduation, he became the stated supply at Redeemer OPC in Philadelphia, a small work that had been without a pastor for seven years, but a favorite place of worship among many students. To say the least, Sloyer’s tenure at Redeemer is rocky. His license was received by the Presbytery of Philadelphia in January January 1951.

    Many in the presbytery, including especially Arthur Kuschke, were alert to the threat of penile, and so discussions with Slawyer began between him and the Candidates and Credentials Committee of that presbytery. After a year of talks, Slawyer’s license was recalled. Over the next two years, the debate raged hot and heavy over Slawyer.

    Many sought to retain him, not in small measure because he was generating visual evidences of effectiveness in ministry at Redeemer Church, a congregation that had struggled since its organization in 1936. One of Slawyer’s most ardent supporters was the talented, internationally recognized New Testament scholar from Westminster Seminary, Ned B. Stonehouse. As Stonehouse himself later said, I took a firm position in support of Slawyer’s orthodoxy. Through the efforts of Stonehouse and others in the Presbytery of Philadelphia, Slawyer’s license was restored.

    And in July 1954, he was ordained and installed as pastor of Redeemer Church, all of this through a cloud of formal complaints lodged within the presbytery. As things turned out, Sawyer’s ministry was as tumultuous as his licensure. Within three years, sharp division developed in the church, and in August 1957, 13 members at Redeemer Church filed a complaint against Schloyer and the elders for failure to protect the congregation against false doctrines of guidance and sanctification, which are now being circulated in the congregation.

    They cited separation in the church because of a practice of distinct spiritual fellowship among adherents of Peniel. because of the penile practice of directly challenging Satan, because of the penile teaching about choosing death to the old man, about experiencing the victory of the cross, about receiving the guidance of the Holy Spirit for the details of daily life, including a life partner. The complainants, in support of their position had gathered testimony not only from within their own circle, but from former adherents to Peniel, including Herman Peterson. The case against Schloyer was overwhelming, so much so that Stonehouse reversed himself and became the most adamant opponent of Schloyer and the movement. Stonehouse led the charge in calling the session into account and demanding of it that the erroneous practices cease.

    When the penalists refused, the Presbytery intervened and severed the pastoral relationship in January 1958. Schleuer and his group withdrew temporarily to independency while they pursued redress at the General Assembly level. The 1958 Assembly agreed that the Presbytery had the right to issue directives to Redeemer’s session, but it disagreed with the action of severing the pastoral relationship with the Church without formal discipline and ordered Schloyer to be reinstated.

    This man at one time had lost his licensure, was re-licensed, this man had lost his credentials, or rather he had been removed from his church and then reinstated into that congregation. The Presbytery did this, they reinstated him, but when the Presbytery realized that there would be no change, they were very hesitant.

    When they realized that there would be no change, they realized that they were in for quite a fight. Let me start that again. Presbytery reinstated Schloyer but When it realized that there would be no change in Slawyer’s attitude, it made plans to bring formal charges against him and his elders. Again, with Stonehouse leading the charge. Slawyer withdrew from the OPC in January 1959 and was received into the RCA one year later.

    To this day, the question still asked is, how was it possible for the OPC to fool around with this thing for so long? As we reflected on things, we have seen the obvious bizarre features of the penile movement. Why was penile not dealt with quickly and summarily?

    How is it possible for figures like Stonehouse to be taken in even temporarily? These two questions are not unrelated. We will try to deal with them separately and bring them together. First of all, then, the Slownest Act. The OPC was suffering from the opprobrium of the Clark controversy. The Church was battle-weary and very hesitant to enter into another fray. Furthermore, it was very slow to see the issues involved.

    As Kushti says, the penile side led with experience and was not accustomed to speak with the kind of theological alertness the OPC had come to expect. When Peniel did speak, it seemed to have no problem expressing itself in the language of Calvinism, in the language of the Confession and the Catechism. Kushti says this had nothing to do with the question of integrity. It wasn’t as if these people were trying to be dubious. What happened was the two groups then were passing each other as ships in the night. But this merely points out what we have said earlier.

    The major difficulty was the inability of the doctrine side to penetrate to the ground floor of the issue with an incisive critique of the life side in terms of the overarching theological commitment inherent to the life side itself. Therefore, the doctrine side is left waiting for obvious aberrations sufficient to convict. Sadly, however, in waiting for evidence, the doctrine side nearly deals eventually and finally with external difficulty, not with the root issue, thus leaving even the doctrine side with a deep sense of dissatisfaction. with the criticisms that are offered, this itself leading to further delay.

    Stonehouse is the epitome of all of this. Early in the discussion, Stonehouse hears the confession and the catechism quoted by the penalists. Initially, he is content to take the responses at face value. The panheilists show vitality, great spiritual zeal. Stonehouse confessed how impressed he was with this.

    But he finally does come to his senses, as far as he is capable, when he becomes convinced that there is a theological gibbet on which to hang the panheilists, namely their inability to understand the distinction between inspiration and illumination.

    Certainly this is a crucial issue, but it stands short of the comprehensive category of spirituality that lay at the foundation of the penile movement. It stops short of delivering a devastating critique of Richard Lovelace. In the end, according to Stonehouse, the penile movement is off-beam on a particular doctrine but the deeper level remains untouched. Thus, the Church lacks the thorough rejoinder it needs to face the continuing threat, and that threat will continue to rise and plague the Church.

    The denial movement, then, is indicative of the continual struggle Presbyterianism has had with spirituality. And although the OPC won the battle with denial, it has not won the larger war with evangelical spirituality that continues in the church to this day, and particularly asserts itself in the areas of evangelism and worship.

    In the days ahead, there is a meeting of the minds between Orthodox Presbyterians and others of Reformed conviction, they would do well to put their heads together on this question of evangelical spirituality and address it at its most fundamental level.

    Thank you once again, Reverend Dennison. Your presentations always have a way of provoking, at least in my mind, lots of questions, the way you bring them to an end. Are there questions that will take 15 minutes? We’ll be finished then at quarter to 12 if there are questions. Are there questions that you would like at this point to address to Reverend Dennison? Well, you see, the problem doesn’t go away. You handle the question on a narrow theological point. and you don’t handle the root issue and the problem doesn’t go away.

    Now eventually the OPC, as a result of the Penile Controversy, brings in a report on guidance. They do that in 1969. And many have looked at that report on guidance as being the definitive statement. And Bob Knutson was the chair of that committee. And he certainly knew what he was talking about because he grew up in Methodism. He could see the connection, you see. The problem doesn’t go away. You have the problem continuing into the 70s. One of the products of Peniel was Arnold Press.

    He becomes a very, very popular preacher in western Pennsylvania. The Nashua OPC in Edinburgh, Pennsylvania. From there, he goes to a foreign mission service to Japan. But while in Japan, he is engaging in activities that take him even, from what penilists say, beyond being a penilist. He becomes a charismatic. He becomes overt. So he is brought to trial in 1976. And then, as a result of that, he retreats into the RCA and from there to the CRC, becomes a missionary of the CRC to Japan.

    So it’s obvious that other denominations are not dealing with this problem. It’s out there and now we’re reaping the consequences of our refusal to deal with it in any substantive fashion. And I would say that the interest in contemporary worship is also a part of this mindset. So as far as I know, there has been no effort on the part of Westminster subsequently.

    And I think the real telling tale is Jack Miller, is a professor at Westminster. And I think that despite the fact that there are differences between Jack Miller and Peniel, we are dealing here with this general category of spirituality in the New Life movement that rises out of Jack Miller. And as Jack Miller is developing his program and his approach to things, no one at Westminster that I know of is taking him to task or sitting him down So the New Life Movement comes into existence in 1973 in the OPC and it wreaks havoc on the church until recently when most of its congregations left for the PCA.

    That brings you up to date. The growth of the OPC has been modest but steady. We had reached the 19,000 mark prior to the exodus of the New Life people. We are in the mid-18,000s now, but growing again. So the growth has been steady but modest from the beginning of the church. There have been periods of intense growth.

    Some of them have been related to matters in the general ecclesiastical world. For instance, the 1958 union between the old United Presbyterian Church and the PCUSA, the rise of political conservatism in California in the late 50s and early 60s saw great influx into the OPC in that area. I would say that during the church growth years, the 80s, there was growth, but it wasn’t beyond what had been experienced in previous years. Of course that was basically reversed by the Exodus. Yes, it is, and the Presbytery of Southern California is trying to face this problem where there is a concentration of theonomists.

    Greg Bonson, for instance, is there, Roger Wagner, and others who are very strong theonomic voices in the denomination. But I would say that Most men in the OPC would distance themselves from theonomy, but the pressure is on them for other reasons. The pressure is on them to come to theonomic conclusions. Let’s put it that way.

    Although they would not identify themselves as being theonomic. And that’s because of the increased confrontation between the church and the culture. For instance, in the state of New Jersey right now, we have a situation there where the presbytery of New Jersey has brought suit against the state of New Jersey and its governor because he has signed into legislation an act that, in the judgment of many, would open up public assemblies of whatever kind to whomever, since you could not restrict your public assemblies And you could not in fact say certain things in public assemblies with respect to particular minority groups such as homosexuals, etc. So there are many who read that kind of reaction by the Presbytery of New Jersey as something of a theonomic reaction.

    But those people are not I wouldn’t say that they would identify themselves as being theonomic. So, I don’t think that the theonomic movement has, in itself, a tremendous amount of influence in the OPC. There are individuals, G.I. Williamson, for instance, Leonard Koppus, these individuals have identified themselves on occasion as theonomists. I would judge that both of those individuals have a little different approach than Greg Monson, for instance, or some of the other theonolists.

    If there are no further questions, I would like Reverend Dennison to take this occasion to thank you on behalf of the faculty, the students, And our guests, I’m sure I can speak for all of us when I say you have done what we hoped when we invited you here you would do, and that is instruct us capably in the history of the OPC.

    And that is for us a very important thing because we believe that we are members together of one holy Catholic and apostolic church. We may be in different congregations of that church, but we are together and we are very interested in the developments in the OPC. And I believe that I can speak for the faculty. And this school, when I say we wish in the future also to continue to retain and, in fact, increase and cultivate relations with you in the OPC, because we believe we stand together on the same Word of God and in the same great confessional tradition.

    We need to, as much as is possible, work together in the work to which the Lord has called us. And so I do want to express our thankfulness to you and our gratitude for what you’ve done and the help that you’ve given to us. When you’re serving as a pastor in a congregation and you have many duties and responsibilities, there was some expectation on our part when we asked you to come and you did a great deal of work, and for that we’re also very thankful. I’d like to ask Reverend Grossman if he would lead us in a closing prayer.

    And Heavenly Father, we do thank you for your manifold and rich blessings to us as your people. It means you have endowed your church with many things, and especially spiritual blessings, not only of salvation and eternal life, but joy and peace, which are paramount. But also with a great deal of understanding of the world in which you have placed us, and the work that we have to do, and the joy that we receive from that work. So thank you for Reverend Benenson and for his lectures here, for his insights and his theological acumen. We thank you that he has been willing to share those with us.

    And we pray that as we have listened and learned, that you will also cause us to be more discerning and our understanding, not only of our brothers and sisters in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and in other churches, but also of our own work and of our own churches, and of the work that we do in studying the history, but also the theology and the movements and streams of thought in the churches, so that, O Heavenly Father, we may more and more seek to shape our ideas, our thinking, after the truths of your Word. We thank you for those giants of the faith who have gone before us. And even though they show weaknesses at times, yet we recognize, O Heavenly Father, that we are indebted to them for so much of what we have and are today in the churches of the reformed nation. We thank you, O Heavenly Father, especially for your word and prayer that we continue to be the foundation and the touchstone of truth. for all those who hold to the Resurrection.

    Heavenly Father, we thank you for this day and for the opportunities that have been presented to you and each of us as we go about the work and the activities which are left to us in this day. To all those who must travel, we would like to thank Mr. Guy for his congregation, bless him and his family, and grant your blessing upon the work that he’s done in the churches across this continent and to the end of the year.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.