This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered November 1, 1995.
About this sermon
Modern eschatology, from Schweitzer and Bultmann through Dodd and Cullmann, stands against the Reformed alternative of Vos, Stonehouse, and Ridderbos, with its shared sense of two overlapping ages. That eschatology bears directly on how the church understands office, old views against new. Kline’s three stages offer one attempt to work out a proper view of office.
Sermon transcript
We thank you, our God, for your work in us, for your mercy, for how you have blessed us. And Lord, we who fill offices in your church confess that we are unworthy of these offices. We ask, Lord, that we might see ourselves always with your grace. May you bless us, Lord, in our labors. Help us as we consider your word and your church, those that you have given to your church from time to time, even in our present circumstance. May you make profit well from the labors of God in that community. May you help us, Lord, in our service to you. that in that service we be conformed to such services as rendered in heaven above. We ask Lord for your forbearance, Lord may you bring us to that goal to which we press, even resurrection of our bodies in the day of the return of our Savior. We thank you for this time together, Lord, we look to you in it for what Jesus said.
I’d like to get in an advertisement right now. I continue to push this little journal, Carrots, and if you don’t subscribe, you may want to. It is improving over the years and I think the discussion is getting to be raised up a few notches. We want to find out how to get it. Three issues appear. I hope that some of you are still engaged in theological reflection and inquiry. I’m different than Mark Brown. He dresses better than I do. And I’m definitely different than Larry Semmel. He’s nice.
A passage of scripture I’d like to give to you at the very beginning is Isaiah 24, verse 23, Then the moon will be abashed, and the sun ashamed, for the Lord of hosts will reign on Mount Zion and in Jerusalem, and his glory will be before his elders.
Now there are many things that we might say about this verse But one thing that we might say is this, that it seems that the Lord himself desires to reveal his glory before his elders. And we could say that the plan and purpose of God is moving things to that conclusion. to that eventuality.
With that text in mind, we begin our consideration of eschatology and office. At the beginning of my article, Worship and Office, in Mark Brown’s book Order in the Offices, I made mention of Paul Woolley’s comment to his students at the end of the 60s about the future of theological study. He stated that future theological study would concentrate upon the doctrines of the church and eschatology. My article of two years ago was what I called a lesser contribution to the discussion in which I hope for better integration one day of these two great doctrines. What I have to say today is another lesser contribution. In the interests of this grander enterprise, I believe awaits some remarkable individual or individuals the Lord is pleased as yet to raise up.
Let me start my comments about eschatology this way. To say the least, there has been a radical shift in the last century when it comes to the subject of eschatology. Negatively speaking, this redirection has come about because of, one, the modern antipathy towards the supernatural. And secondly, because of the exhaustion and frustration in the Church over the failed schemes of 19th century millennialism and the fantastical schemes of the cults. But more positively, this shift was the result. Some would call this positive. More positively, this shift has been because of a more studied look at the scriptures when the subject of eschatology is considered.
This shift was the result of a growing suspicion about the adequacy of the traditional systematic theological format. with its concentration upon the logical ordering of the categories in the dogmatics. More pressing, however, in the area of sophisticated theological discussion, was the collapse of the liberal view of Jesus and its Pompeian conviction that Christianity, after all, equals the heavens.
Men in the last century like Wilhelm Rehde, Johann Weiss are important in this regard, but in this century also the figure of Albert Schweitzer. These men, Schweitzer included, recognized that the apocalyptic in the biblical record is anything but marginal or superficial. as the liberals had been content. Schweitzer’s consistent eschatology approach to the New Testament, in his estimations, rescued Jesus from liberal misinterpretations, but then delivered him into the apocalyptic eagers of first century Messianism, with its overactive interest in imminent eschatological events. But the question now became, given Schweitzer’s approach, what do you do with this bizarre, apocalyptically informed and dominated Galilean?
If eschatology is central to Jesus’ self-consciousness, how do we in the 20th century relate to such extremism? Schweitzer answered that contrary to liberal opinion, we must look to Jesus’ eschatological interest for the timeless and the eternal. That the historical Jesus had expectations of the immediate catastrophic arrival of the kingdom of God, and died in Schweitzer’s estimation, a disappointed man, makes no difference whatsoever. The important thing is the impact of the eschatological habit of mind on Jesus’ behavior and on the behavior of those who would claim to be followers of Jesus.
Only such a habit of mind can appreciate the power of Jesus’ world-negating ethic and its freedom from the world-accepting and self-protective habits of modern theology and the Protestant establishment. Schweitzer’s flight to Africa and his work in medicine there are consistent with his reading of the Gospels and of the life of Jesus. With eschatology redefined and made all the more insistent now in its demands, battles over eschatology erupted in this century.
At the center of those battles stood the imposing figure of Rudolf Bultmann. Bultmann very bluntly said, the mythical eschatology is untenable for the simple reason that the perusy of Christ never took place as the New Testament expected. History did not come to an end, and as every schoolboy knows, it will continue to run its course. The world will come to an end by a natural catastrophe, not by a mythical event as the New Testament expects. But while rejecting the particulars of New Testament eschatology, Bultmann labors as the Schweitzer to salvage the category of eschatology.
He therefore redefines eschatology as an event in which man encounters the truth of his own existence. Such an encounter confronts man with the continual end of an old world and the beginning of a new. There is no future conservation. There is only the existential realization of consummation as man comes to understand that he is placed before a decision for the future every moment of his life. Here, according to Bultmann, is genuine eschatology. And from his point of view, here and only here is found true freedom, true human freedom.
C. H. Dodd accepted Bultmann’s conviction that the world will not end as the Bible describes. And he agreed with Bultmann that eschatology has nothing to do with last things, or with the end of the world.
But while for Bultmann the kingdom in Jesus’ preaching is holy future, according to Dodd it is holy present. God’s famous book, The Parables of the Kingdom, written in 1958, sets forth what he calls realized eschatology. The view that Jesus’ language, while clothed in apocalyptic fantasy, means to call attention to the genuine experience of the eternal in the here and now. What references, therefore, we might find in the Gospels to the future of the kingdom are either interpolations by the first century church to meet its own eschatological crisis, or they are texts that have simply been misunderstood. For Jesus, according to God, the kingdom was wholly spiritual.
A perspective which Herman Ritterboss has pointed out, not far removed from the old liberal point of view. In the middle of this debate, both chronologically and theologically, stands Oscar Kuhlman, whose book, Christ and Time, appeared in 1945. For Kuhlman, Christ is the so-called midpoint of history. There he is. Jesus’ message announces the kingdom’s presence but also anticipates its future appearance in an already not yet tension. We might resonate to that kind of language.
But does this orthodox sounding analysis of Jesus’ message from Kuhlman present a real alternative in the discussions that we have been reviewing thus far? Kuhlman admits that linear time is only background to what is really important, namely the present-future tension, the already-not-yet tension. But consider, if linear time is reduced to background, What about the reality and importance of linear time’s movement to a definitive conclusion? Kuhlman may well be in reaction to modern theology’s removal of the end-of-the-world doctrine from its catalogue of accepted doctrines, but is he any more committed to the end of the world as axiomatic? It appears not.
And when he goes to work on the already and not tension, already not yet tension, and the present future tension of our existence, it becomes a construct just as philosophical as Bultmann’s eschatological moment, eschatological event, and God’s spiritualized pain. You may want to look at what Dr. Van Til has to say about Kuhlmann. In his book, The Great Debate Today, pages 33 through 42, he looks at Kuhlman and Sundell. To summarize, despite the intense debate, those most directly involved in the recent discussions about eschatology are agreed on two things.
First of all, Eschatology is not about last things. It is not about the end of the world. Instead, it is about ultimate things. Those things that are most meaningful. In fact, an eschatology that insists upon talking about a literal end of the world, be it from Jesus or anyone else, is primitive, unscientific, and unacceptable. and as contradictory as it may sound, eschatology is at the center of New Testament consciousness. To be true to this consciousness and to humanity’s greatest interest, because eschatology is about ultimate concerns here, the Church must retranslate the New Testament’s primitive eschatology and place that retranslation at the heart of her life and teaching.
It is in this context that a number of figures from within Reformed Orthodoxy, and especially from within the Westminster seminary tradition, have made great contributions. Coming to mind is Gerhardus Voss, who was not teaching at Westminster, he was the teacher of teachers at Westminster. There is also Ned B. Stoneman. There’s Edmund D. Clowney, Meredith Klein, Richard Gamble. And of great significance and related to this constellation is, of course, Herman Ritterbos from the Netherlands.
All of these scholars have been deeply influenced by this 20th century debate and have concluded that eschatology, yes, is at the center of biblical This conclusion has been pursued in the interest of a biblical theological redemptive historical commitment with the result that biblical theology and its eschatological concern have now brought tremendous pressure to bear upon the traditional systematic theological enterprise and its typical discussions on and positioning of eschatology.
For example, Voss’s insight that the historical precedes the theological is something of a bombshell from certain points of view. His insight that eschatology precedes soteriology is equally a bombshell in some sense. insights have become linchpins to this approach, this biblical, theological, and eschatological concern for you.
As a result of these assertions, many have felt the pressure on the traditional scheme, and have responded in uncertainty and even in open hostility. Some have suggested that Voss and company are merely playing off of and into the hands of the modernist agenda. But in all fairness, it is important to acknowledge how hard Voss and these others have fought against the modernist impulse and position. To begin with, they insist on the biblical doctrine of the end of this world order by God’s direct action.
The contrast of Voss’s and Kuhlman’s famous diagrams illustrates the point. And I put them up here so that you can see them. I’m talking about Voss number one and Kuhlman down here. Voss’s diagram anticipates a literal end point. Kuhlman’s does not. There’s no end to this line. Don’t think there’s an end to the line.
Also, the Reformed biblical theologians insist on the present interaction between the present world and the real substantive world to come. As well as, for the saints, a participation in that higher heavenly world now. Again, the contrast between Voss and Pullman is significant. Boss’s vertical interest clearly comes through in his diagram. We are in contact with the higher heavenly world. This is also apparent in Boss 2, or the diagram from the book on Hebrews. The heavenly reality has now intruded into our circumstance and in our New Testament setting.
At the same time, it must not be forgotten that Vos saw himself, speaking of him particularly, these others included, Vos saw himself as defending Reformed Orthodoxy. And although judged innovative by some, as actually reintroducing the genius of Reformed theology into the discussions taking place. Here, Vosk intended that the covenant, the Reformed faith’s contribution to the theological world, has at its center the hope of a higher eternal existence in which permanent communion with God is the greatest blessing, and that this hope belonged to man even in the garden prior to the fall. According to Voss, Reformed theology being covenantal is inherently eschatological in its most basic impulse, and particularly suited to address not only the profound meaning of scripture, but the current crisis over eschatology.
Office. If the past hundred years have witnessed unsettling changes in the area of eschatology, what might we say about us? We’ve already heard about the changes that have come about in post-securitism. But even more extensively, the old view saw office as a unique calling grounded in God himself and especially in Jesus Christ. As God preceded and stood above the man called to fill the office, so the office itself preceded and stood above the man who came to fill it. The man had the office conferred on him. He entered the office. Such language as that reflected of his perspective.
Many things, however, have been at work in the Church to change this point of view. For instance, notions of universal enfranchisement and general endowment have increasingly taken their toll. A few months before his death, J. Gresham Machen complained that fundamentalists held to a democratic view of office. According to Machen, fundamentalists said, any man who was washed in the blood and saved has a right to the office. Recently, Gregory Reynolds has provided a useful analysis of the democratizing trend in the Church with regard to office, and spoken of the denigration of office in connection with the democratizing trend. His study reinforces the conviction expressed by others that the roots of this phenomenon, at least in this country, are found in the emerging evangelical movement, also in the misshapen notions of the relationship of secular government to church polity, and now, most recently, in the convictions of the Charismatics. One result of the democratizing trend, especially among conservatives, has been the trivializing of office. Ordinarily imbued with dignity and commanding respect, office has become common.
Often it is viewed as a mere formality, providing title where it is thought necessary to satisfy social and ecclesiastical customs or to provide tax benefits. But unessential for ministry. You don’t have to have office for ministry. After all, everyone has a ministry. After all, we all have ordination.
Many conservatives have rushed to these conclusions because of their interests in greater access to the culture and greater effectiveness in church outreach. At the same time, mainline theology has been doing its part to downgrade office, and that in a way which worked well with the attitudes gaining ground among the conservatives. A growing anti- or supra-denominationalism, for example, did not help but relativize the views of church politics.
This was, in part, Machen’s concern in his battles against the 1920 Plan of Union and against the attitudes of J. Ross Stevenson and Charles Erdmann at Princeton. Machen’s logic was simple. If the Westminster Standards are biblical and therefore true, and if the Westminster Standards teach Presbyterianism, then Presbyterianism is true and meant for the whole world. Polity questions are not up for grabs.
But even apart from the growing anti- and supra-denominationalism, the polity issue has entered a critical phase of its history. Struggles in England in the earlier part of the century illustrate the point. As highly as the Church of England has held the office of bishop, Voices began to be heard within that church calling into question age-old fundamental convictions.
B.H. Streeter challenged established Anglican order with his statement, there is no one form of church order which alone is primitive and which therefore possesses the sanction of apostolic precedent. A.C. Christ left the Church to organize its own form and order.
As these statements become representative of an attitude pervasive within mainline Protestantism, they give us a fair idea of where things presently stand. Not only do Episcopal claims about apostolic succession fall to the ground, But so do any claims about the early Church’s structural uniformity. Also left out of support are those drawing upon the age-old doctrine that God had established in His Word one correct form of polity.
Of interest in this regard, and closer to our own situation, is the statement in the PCUSA’s Confession of 1967. So says the Confession of 67. The Church orders its life as an institution with a constitution, government, officers, finances, and administrative rules.
These are instruments of mission, not ends in themselves. Different orders have served the Gospel and none can claim exclusive belief. This statement is far distant from the commitment of historic Presbyterianism as found, for instance, in the Westminster Confession of Faith. Chapter 30, paragraph 1. The Lord Jesus, as king and head of his church, hath therein appointed a government in the hand of church offices.
Another reason for the downgrade of office within mainline theology, at least from the Orthodox Protestant expression is the rise of existentialist interpretation. The existentialist approach builds upon the critical conclusions of the last century, particularly the views of F.C. Bauer, who died in 1860, whose influence was felt at Tübingen University. This was Bauer’s point of view. He saw the 1st century Church in terms of a collateral development of an austere, petrifying Jewish Christianity, the Thesis, and Paul’s Gentile-directed Gospel of Freedom, Antithesis. In the 2nd century, both the internal pressures from Gnosticism and external pressures from persecution forced reconciliation in the Old Catholic Church. synthesis.
The upshot of this position is that the original liberties of Paul’s view of faith and church life were brought beneath the stifling restrictions of office and order in an emerging early Catholicism. This position has been updated now and powerfully presented in this century by Ernst Casemeyer. who had brought an existential philosophy to bear on the question of church order. Kethamon was convinced that the fact that the world did not end as the early church had hoped threw the church into an organizational crisis. As a result, Paul’s rather free and functional approach to the church’s structure was reassessed in light of the rising strength of an early Catholicist Office and church structure were objectified by that early Catholicism in a new order.
And the spirit, by definition now, was joined to office. Office and spirit were one. Apology became a matter of what was established by an appeal to a permanently settled, definable past. Unity was mandated as an essential expression of organizational strategy.
Over against this early Catholicism stood Paul’s gospel. The enemy of all who look to external guarantees, like order and office, for the inward realities of things. Paul’s gospel loses ground to a church that places its confidence in office, order, and tradition. Needed, says Casimani, is the proclamation of the eschatological event of the turn of the ages, or moving back to Bulgaria. Such proclamation, as takes place in the word and sacraments, calls for a decision on the part of the hearings.
Only in the encounter, through that proclamation, is the lordship of Christ established. In fact, there’s a sense in which it is only real in that proclamation. It only exists in that proclamation. True authority only exists in the event of obedient service. And office exists only in ministry. It has no other existence. It exists only in the act of ministry.
To summarize our discussion about office, We take note of the general drift of the Church. Traditional understanding has been subjected to radical reassessment inherent to the democratizing and anti-even supra-denominational attitudes that prevail so widely. Office loses not only its historic definition, but its definitive biblical warrant as the 20th century Church decides that the New Testament provides no settled polity. At the same time, Scripture, or at least certain portions of Scripture, from Casimond’s point of view, are claimed as normative for polity, but only insofar as order and office are juxtaposed with spirit and reinterpreted as event. Clearly, discussions about office have become quitsale. It has been noted, in the traditional Reformed and Presbyterian view, this may be the case even for ourselves in our discussions about 2 and 3 August.
The question thus becomes one about the quest for solid ground. But in this quest, no simple appeal to the Bible will do. Such an appeal to the Bible will also have to have in view a commitment to a wider vision which rises from the Bible. And in light of that, we understand what the scriptures are saying in their totality.
Ironically, Caseman, despite his radical reorientation, may be a felon. His attempt to bring the issues of polity into connection with the overarching eschatological interest of scripture is instructive. Not that we are interested in or believe the particulars of Casiman’s eschatology. However, in his zeal for eschatology, as that which is concerned with ultimate things, Casiman has admitted to eschatology’s pervasive reach and to the fact that it touches upon the entirety of Christian existence, even the matters of office and order. And to that extent, we should be listening. Eschatology enough.
If Case Among is a prod for us in the providence of God, it is to the end that we would appreciate the depths and riches of our Reformed heritage and look again at those whose interest in eschatology lays before us hints of the relationship between eschatology and office. Now I say hints because there has not been as yet a thorough working out of the biblical theological redemptive historical approach to the Church and its offices, keeping in view the Bible’s eschatological interests. Many hints are found in the programmatic work of Voss. Although he does not draw out the implications explicitly for office, his insight into the eschatological character of Christian existence, our foundation.
His work on Pauline eschatology shows that Christ’s work has in view the eschatological goal to which Christ himself is brought by his death and resurrection, and that by the spirit the believer’s union with Christ is not only unto glory with Christ in heaven, but a participation in glory in a provisional way presently. Boss’s work on Hebrews makes similar points, although here he is specifically concerned with the linear progression from the Old to the New Covenant, and to show the heavenly reality’s relationship to both of those administrations. In the Old Covenant, the heavenly reality is shadowed down. In the New, the very substance of that reality has become available or accessible through the ministry of Jesus Christ, our great and final High Priest.
The doctrine of the Church is, of course, implied in the work Voss sets before us in his studies on Paul and on Hebrews. It is expressly considered in his study of the Kingdom of God and the Church. Once again, office does not directly enter the discussion. However, Voss is direct about the relationship of eschatology to the Church. He writes, the Church actually has within herself the powers of the world to come. She is more than the imminent kingdom as it existed before Christ’s exaltation.
She forms an intermediate link between the present life and the life of eternity. Along these lines, Paul, rather, along these lines, Voss stated his position more fully in his biblical theology. When he wrote on Matthew 16 verses 18 through 20 and Jesus’ statement to Peter.
This Matthew pericope, writes Voss, as little as any other New Testament passage gives countenance to the idea of the church as a mere instrument of propaganda or an institute of missions, or whatever goal to which she may stand in vital relations. The Church is all these things, but no one can truly say that these objectives are exhaustive of the purpose of existence of the Church. The conception of the thing as a mere instrument for endlessly reiterated self-reproduction is a hopeless concept in itself. For why should one exist to make others or an organism of others, in perpetuation or extension of what exists at the present time, if this process has no fixed end. This whole view is a virtual denial of the eschatological setting of biblical religion.
The Church was born in and stands in the sign of consummation and rest, as well as of motion. She consists not of mere doing, but likewise of fruition. And this fruition pertains not exclusively to the future. It is the most blessed part of the present life. And the best proof for the Church as an end in itself lies in the inclusion of the Church in the eschatological world. For that world is not the world of things aimed at, but of things attained unto.
Drawing from these sources, Porbos’ view of eschatology we are able to summarize his position under two rubrics. First, the category of motion, which would be inclusive of the redemptive historical movement from promise to fulfillment and from the Old Testament to the New, and the consummating movement from this world to the next. The second heading is the category of the consummate world itself, or better, the heavenly reality. which intrudes upon the present life of the Church from the future, but also provides the pattern and substance from that heavenly world for the Church’s enjoyment and well-being present.
It has remained to others besides Voss to work with these categories when it comes to the relationship of office and eschatology and the bearing that they have on the Church’s life as a whole. Edmund P. Clowney. has written extensively on the doctrine of the Church from a Biblical theological point of view. He has stressed the eschatological character of the Church as the assembly of the Lord, the body of Christ, the fellowship of the Spirit. And he is very much aware of how the Church, through the work of Christ and the blessing of the Spirit, comes into possession of heavenly realities and is made heir of God.
Thus far, Clowney’s position builds well on that second category that we mentioned above, that of the consummate world and the heavenly reality. But when it comes to office, the emphasis shifts for Clowney. It will fall on the first category, that of motion, as the Church moves toward her goal in ministry. To be sure, Clowney sees all the offices grounded in Christ. But his interest is as these offices are effective for the ministry of the Church in the areas of worship, edification, and evangelization. In other words, if they are useful for the Church in making progress toward her goals in this world.
Clowney’s labors have been greatly beneficial. He has self-consciously built upon Voss for the purpose of bringing the biblical, theological, and eschatological structure of revelation to bear upon the matters of the Church, its life, and its offices. But as yet, Clowney has not related these matters fully to the second category which we cited earlier, namely, the category of the Consonant World and the Heavenly Reality. The individual who has begun to move us in this direction, his narrative Klein lays out the intratestimental development in his book, The Structure of Biblical Forging, written in 1972. Klein observes that each testament develops along a similar line.
Looking at the Old Testament, we see first the people of God constituted under a mediator during the days of the redemption from Egypt. the wilderness wanderings, and the transjordan conquests. Next, we see the people temporarily under charismatic leadership in the period of Joshua and the Judges. The third stage finds the people established in the land as the administration of the Old Testament kingdom takes on a sense of finality and permanence. The temple and the institutions of the kingdom speak of permanence, They speak of a settledness, and as such, they speak to us about eternity. They bear the stamp of eternity. These three stages anticipate what comes in the New Testament.
Here we witness again the formative stage in the Gospel narratives in which Jesus Christ is the final mediator, and he appears as God’s great work of redemption is consummated in him. Next comes the period of charismatic leadership, which is temporary, a period of church expansion under the apostles when the Spirit’s special gifts abound. This period is covered in the Acts of the Apostles and evidenced in certain of Paul’s letters. Finally, there takes shape the stable, permanent stage of church order, which is reflected in a number of bridge documents as you move from apostolic to post-apostolic. Not that The pastoral epistles are post-apostolic, but they are anticipating the transition.
Made all the more obvious to us from Klein’s presentation should be the interconnectedness of the Old and New Testaments. Increasingly clear should be the validity of those arguments that insist upon Old Testament roots to New Testament authors. Our Presbyterian forebears, the Westminster Divines, lacked the finely developed big biblical theological sensitivities of Dr. Klein, but they hardly missed the point when they, without embarrassment or hesitation, grounded the office of the New Testament ministry in the Old Testament priesthood. And also look to the Old Testament elder as the precursor to the New Testament church government. but more to the point of our argument.
The development marked out by Klein carries us toward that which is permanent, and in its New Testament expression, that which uniquely conveys the substance of the heavenly eschatological order. However, the question now becomes, has not the heavenly eschatological order always been there? preceding and even providing pattern and in the end supplying substance to things here on earth. Particularly now the church in its redemptive historical contest. Klein moves us towards this consideration in his book Images of the Spirit, 1980. His thesis is this.
Genesis 1-2 introduces the theophonic glory cloud into the creational account with the words, the Spirit of God hovered over the face of the waters. The spirit glory cloud provides the heavenly paradigm for the creation itself and also for the creation of man, thus linking them and creation to the heavenly archetype.
In the fallen world, the glory cloud revisits the earth in the exodus again bringing order to God’s redeemed people and restoring the image, provisionally now, typically, in the glowing face of Moses, the investiture of Aaron, and subsequently in the exaltation of the king and the commissioning of the prophets. With the New Testament, what has been anticipated in the Old Testament is realized in Christ, who is himself the spirit glory cloud incarnate.
He becomes, in his service and by his death and resurrection, the fulfillment of Old Testament types seen in the Old Testament temple and sacrifices, the realization of all of the offices that preceded and the center of God’s new creation. The client’s position moves us toward equally profound conclusions when we look at the Church specifically, and ask the question, is there a session in heaven? rooted in God, rooted in his triune nature, but also coming to expression in the divine counsel of the Lord which he convenes with his angelic hosts. Is not the earthly gathering of church rulers derivative of and correspondent to a heavenly gathering? will not the earthly assembly, created in the spirit, in its order and offices, find its origin and counterpart in heaven. The parallel of Old Testament and New Testament order, therefore, is because they derive from the same heavenly source, with the New Testament order more glorious because it is, as Vos has said, the heavenly reality actually manifesting itself in the earth. the Old Testament order being merely shouted.
How exalted, then, the Church, even her order and her officers, become by the grace of God. Christ declares His Church to be with Him of the eternal order. It is His Church, He tells us, And he also tells us that the gates of hell shall not prevail against him. And in its authoritative use of the keys of the kingdom of heaven, the Church finds the bond between its earthly decisions and the decisions of the heavenly consorts. But even more glorious is the Church, its order, and its offices.
For it seems that the Church is more dear to God than the angelic assembly and its council that is convened above. When Moses, Aaron, and the elders of Israel in Exodus 24 climb that mountain, and there behold God with the cavemen of Sapphire beneath his feet, and there eat and drink in his presence, it is as if a displacement has occurred. The earthly order with its offices is derived from the heavenly pattern to be sure, but it is destined to be brought to a position higher than the angelic assembly with its elements. Indeed, he did not subject to angels a world to come.
And do you not know, you shall judge Thank you. We come to the end of our study. It has been preliminary. It has been suggested. It is hardly satisfying. But hopefully we have learned and have been reminded of our reformed faith. That it is wonderfully able to address the present day struggles of our Prescottology. In fact, it is especially equipped to elevate the discussion.
With a firm grip on the biblical view of history and on heaven to which history answers, we know that eschatology is about, yes, ultimate things, but it’s also about last things, and the last things that are first things. But with our reformed faith and our convictions, we are prepared to deal with the relationship of ultimate things, life’s purpose. As far as office is concerned, we know better than to oppose order to order, office to spirit. Also in the quest to find solid ground in the discussions about office and refine We most certainly know to look to the scriptures. We are not so naive to think that consideration of scripture can be pursued apart from commitment to the scripture’s own overarching structure and principle.
In this, we are also engaged in and elevating our discussion. Therefore, finally, it is my hope that in taking stock of the Bible’s overarching structure and interest even its eschatological concern, we would keep in mind that heavenly end to which we press, and that that heavenly end to which we press, by grace, is already given to us as the means by which we make our journey to our glorious end. This is the way it is, in order that it might be all of grace. Particularly when applied to the Church and to Church order, there stands above us the heavenly original, by which we are brought to our exalted position, yes, touching it already, and in time into glory.
Knowing that, in glory, we who are in and with the twenty-four elders will fall down before God and before the Lamb, cast our crowns before him, having led all creation in this consummate course, blessing and honor, glory and power be unto him that sitteth upon the throne and unto the Lamb forever and ever. In that day, we also will know how much God has desired to display His glory in its full and perfect radiance before His elders in the heavenly Zion and in the heavenly Jerusalem.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

