This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered March 2, 1998.
About this sermon
Classical rhetoric cares about ethics and persuasion, and biblical rhetoric exists to proclaim an event more than to illustrate an idea. Fundamentalist and evangelical preaching each fall short of that standard in different ways. Concrete examples of biblical rhetoric close the Lectures series.
Sermon transcript
I’ve been told that he even has a better laugh than I. I’m happy to be here with you and I know a number of you made acquaintance with some of you last year I know some of you better than others. Some of you have been in my congregation in Swickly, Pennsylvania, and it’s really good to see you again, too.
My interest in rhetoric began when I was a seminary student. It began because of my interest in preaching. Now, you’ll note that this is a lecture on biblical literature, and we’re not going to be focusing specifically on preaching, but that’s where my interest began. I was somewhat distressed as a student at Westminster to look at some manuals on homiletics, or theory of preaching, because as I looked at some of the more respected volumes from the last century, I recognized that they had a particular interest in rhetoric.
In fact, they looked at preaching as a baptized form of classical rhetoric. You had such volumes as William G. T. Shedd’s Homiletics and Pastoral Theology and Robert Dabney’s Sacred Rhetoric, volumed by that title, and it was their idea that you merely took the standards of classical rhetoric and you applied them to the pulpit task or to the preaching task.
I abhor that approach. I will tell you right now. And so I was definitely in reaction. through my seminary years to that approach to preaching, and it will probably show in the course of this lecture, but I haven’t really picked up much from the classical rhetoric tradition. I didn’t memorize my lecture, for instance.
Some of you who have had rhetoric know that’s what you’re supposed to do. The other thing that I think is important to say at the beginning is that there has been a resurrection or a renaissance of interest in classical rhetoric. In fact, there are those who are saying now that it is an indispensable part of a proper education, even a Christian education. I’m not too sure about that. unless certain things are understood, certain things are done to the enterprise as a whole.
And I think that that will become apparent this evening. I will make apologies at the beginning of this lecture, and if I have my wits about it at the conclusion, I’ll make the comment again. I only wish that I had the ability, or better yet, the grace from God to be what I say, and for my message to be an exposition of the gospel itself, and my own person a communication to you. And if you will remember this statement as we go through the lecture this evening, I think it will be more intelligible to you.
I’m not interested in simply the science of public communication. And I don’t think the Bible is interested in that either. Okay. You have an outline of the lecture on the back. You will find, I think some, I trust some helpful material on the parables that will be handy for you when we get to that section. Opening up then, rhetoric and biblical literature. First of all, classical rhetoric. Comments about that.
Susan Wardner has described classical rhetoric as that form of communication invented for the specific purpose of persuasion in the public arena. Rhetoric is that form of communication invented for the specific purpose of persuasion in the public arena. As such, classical rhetoric is concerned with what we might call the living voice in public discourse, the living voice in public discourse. This living voice could be, as the art developed, either oral or written.
It was not simply interested in the rational and emotional sides of its presentation, but with the way in which it appeared and sounded. Out of concern for effective communication, classical rhetoric concentrated as much on tone and cadence as it did on cogency.
Classical rhetoric took shape in Sicily and Greece in the 5th century BC. Figures of importance were Corax, Socrates, and by way of extension Plato. together with Isocrates and his school of rhetoric. In the fourth century, Aristotle formalized rhetoric as an art turned to the practical purpose of persuading and impressing.
An art turned to the practical purpose of persuading and impressing. As you can well imagine, such an art drew to the center questions about ethics. Plato had already engaged the sophists on the ethics involved in rhetoric, their abandonment of moral purpose, and their commitment to the goal of winning an argument through any persuasive means, led Plato to attack them for their deceit and insincerity. But since rhetoric concerned itself with persuading and impressing, it invariably drew the attention of those who mastered it as an art for manipulation.
Therefore as the study of rhetoric developed very much at the heart of things had to be the discussion about a communicators ability and His goodness The moral dimension of rhetoric continued to command attention great attention into the Roman era and Both Cicero and Quintilian were preoccupied with it. Quintilian’s desire to equate the great orator with the good man, however, was undermined by the progressive but rapid erosion of Roman culture, an erosion that turned rhetoric into theatrics and entertainment. art form especially employed to debate hypothetical historical and legal questions as Well as to enhance public gatherings such as festivals birthdays marriages and funerals The classical world meets the church The appearance of the Christian Church and the spread of Christianity brought great change to the Greco-Roman world. The rise of Christianity even had a great effect on the revered domain of rhetoric.
For one thing, the Church registered a renewed moral stability and zeal within a culture facing moral collapse. However, you should understand the church did not achieve this primarily out of her concern to renew moral stability and zeal. You see, Christianity in its apostolic or pristine form had such an impact upon that ancient world, not because it chose to have such an impact, but because it was otherwise directed. For example, Christianity reoriented the rhetorical enterprise within itself. away from the morally suspect political, judicial, and theatrical focus of society, and toward the gospel and the ecclesiastical and evangelistic interests of the believing community.
We could put it like this. In the hands of the church, the rhetorical enterprise was moved in its concern from the enjoyment of life and the hope of a better life in this world to the promise of eternal life in heaven. Such a radically different outlook went a long way in addressing the place of ethics in rhetorical presentations. Since the Church, again in its apostolic and pristine form, has no inherent compulsion to promote itself for its own sake, nor any motivation to use its rhetoric to manipulate its audience in order to ensure its own wealth, privilege, or power in this world. But beyond this reorientation and the reformation it brought, to moral perspective.
Christianity introduced into the classical world more directly and pervasively than Judaism had been able to do the challenge of Hebraic or biblical reality. The challenge of Hebraic or biblical reality. According to this reality, There are not many gods, only one God, who is utterly distinct from his creation, who, in the event of his own sovereign self-disclosure, reveals himself so that his people, by his grace, might participate with him in a transcendent bond of perpetual fellowship. Because the event of God’s self-disclosure is central to biblical or Hebraic reality, rhetoric within the Christian context could never be summarized by the traditional categories of classical rhetoric.
It could not even be synonymous with the logic of judicial, deliberative, or demonstrative persuasion. Rather, biblical reality must first of all be proclamation. proclamation not of an idea, but of an event. Not a thought in someone’s head to be argued for or defended, but an event most certainly having taken place and determinative.
The rhetoric of the Church, if it can even be called rhetoric then, proclaims, preaches, teaches God’s mighty acts, His saving works, and principally, His final sufficient saving work in Jesus Christ. Therefore, the rhetoric of the Church is not the presentation of, or the defense of an idea, it is the announcement at root of the event of God’s self-disclosure, His self-revelation, His saving, mighty act.
Another way the Church brought great change within the classical world was by challenging the canons of rhetorical art with the canon of the Scripture. This meant more than the replacement of one textbook, such as Aristotle’s Rhetoric, with another, namely the Bible. What it meant was this. The living voice was now uniquely, and with unparalleled authority, the divinely inspired written voice. The Bible was a completely different kind of book than the textbooks known to those who were engaged in rhetorical pursuits. By the Church, it was acknowledged to be a living, authoritative word from God, in which and from which the Church and her preachers were compelled to formulate their own words. beneath which they were continuously and rigorously scrutinized.
In its most radical effect, this shift in focus from the rhetorical canons of the Greco-Roman world to the Bible displaced what might be called the rhetorical moment. The rhetorical moment. That moment was no longer the immediate moment in which the speaker presented his case or made his appeal. Instead, that moment was the historical inscripturated moment, the moment assumed or declared in the text to which the speaker and the hearer were related, into which they were drawn in order to believe and obey the one who spoke definitively in his word.
The effect of the Church’s proclamation was to draw the audience into the event. The effect of the living Word of God and the communication of it was to pull the audience into the event, declared and described in the Word. so that you became a participant in it. It is this very truth, namely that the living voice is the written inspired voice which encourages the church to consider seriously then the rhetorical nature of biblical literature.
Part two, modern approaches to rhetoric and the Bible. First of all, what we might call traditional innocence or fundamentalism and rank-and-file evangelicalism. For many, the relationship between biblical literature and rhetoric amounts to no more than a naive awareness of certain fundamental features to the text, such as outline, theme, climax to a given book or passage, This innocent or naive approach to the Bible is often made a blind method of Bible study for those most sincere and devout in their allegiance to the Scriptures. But by leaving matters rest at this superficial level, These often very godly people inadvertently promote ignorance of the Bible’s profound depths. They have also helped to leave higher-level Bible studies a much more open field for those with less than orthodox views on the Bible and the Christian faith.
Enter modern sophistication. When we turn to the modern scientific sophisticated investigations of the Bible, we are often faced with a very disturbing fact. Many of those given to these investigations pursue them with the claim that they are Christian and that they are spokespeople for the church, when in fact their belief system stands quite contrary to the biblical religion and historic Christianity.
J. Gresham Machen called these confused and dishonest people liberals. Others have called them modernists because they have absolutized the modern situation. They see everything from the perspective of the present situation.
Now, for convenience sake, we will be dealing with two kinds of liberals and their approaches to rhetoric and the Bible. And I am not going to be dealing so much with their methods as I am with their religious direction and intention. First of all, classical liberalism as represented in George Kennedy. The classical liberal position begins with the assumption that the Bible is ancient literature, unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness. Unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness, unique practically because of its sustained usefulness and cultural importance, since it continues to inform the ethical ideas of society. That might be worth repeating for you so that you have that. understanding of liberalism. It approaches the Bible as ancient literature, unique historically because of its sustained testimony to developing religious consciousness, unique practically because of its sustained usefulness and cultural importance since it continues to inform the ethical ideas of society even today. But in order to profit most from the Bible, we must hear it, suggests Kennedy, as did those who originally received it.
Rhetorical analysis helps us to do this effectively, since it alerts us to the rhetorical devices employed in the text to enhance and maximize the effectiveness of a particular piece. Once we have heard the text by way of rhetorical analysis, we are better able to differentiate in it between dismissible culturally specific and universally valid material. This means we are able then to discard what might be called parochial propaganda. Parochial propaganda, including primitive supernaturalisms, and especially the primitive eschatological vision and commitment of the biblical text.
But now, having gone through the rhetorical enterprise or exercise With the universally valid material from the Bible in hand, we having discerned that we are able to translate the scriptures for our modern audience, we are likewise able to generate our own distinctively modern religious rhetoric sensitive to our times.”
Well, that’s classical liberalism. What about radical liberalism? The position of Wilhelm Wellner, While the classical position is interested in society’s moral stability, the radical position concerns itself with the overturning and reinventing of social structures. To put it bluntly, it pursues revolution.
To begin with, the radical position approaches ancient texts, including the Bible, as social discourse. social discourse. This means the text was the product of the dynamic interaction between the author, his intended audience, the community out of which each arose, and the political and ideological environment in which they lived. Becoming quite complex, isn’t it? Rhetorical criticism provides service by peeling back the layers of the text in the interest of uncovering a valid human description obscured by the text’s sociological and political prejudices. But you should understand The radical position connects present society to those in the text’s original setting in a dialogue with the text.
We now in dialogue with the text, we also in dialogue within the text itself. In this ongoing discussion between text, original audience, and present reader, modern culture becomes all the more capable of pursuing life’s true meaning. namely the transformation of society. And you thought rhetoric was harmless. Don’t be so naive. There are many with grand designs when it comes to rhetoric. Upon this basis, the ancient text and modern reader unite in the common goal of empowerment for the oppressed and mutual resistance to all kinds of systemic absolutism, every form of exclusionary politics and religious dogma.
Orthodox response Now we have a time for a full response to these liberal positions however Let me make a few observations for you first of all Neither the classical nor the radical liberal position is committed to a divinely inspired infallible Bible that should be obvious For both, the Bible is a human book testifying to the progress of humanity’s religious quest.
Secondly, both positions assume the supremacy of the present moment. The now of our present circumstance is qualitatively different from the then of the world in which the Bible was written. That is axiomatic. You live in a qualitatively different world. than those who lived in Bible times. Thirdly, both positions assume that the distance between the then and the now is overcome to the extent that that distance can be overcome by the tools of scientific research, such as rhetorical criticism. By use of these tools, they suggest that we are able to reach the levels in and beneath the text helpful for identifying helpful for identifying humanity’s common moral interest. In this context, the Bible is a signpost. The Bible is a signpost.
It is a directional aid, never the product in space and time of the direct action of a God such as the Bible describes, since no such God as the Bible describes does or even can exist. much less is there any such God who can provide definitive instruction in a faith once for all delivered to the saints, as the Bible itself claims.
But it is precisely at this point, namely what the Bible claims for itself, that the greatest problem to the liberal approaches becomes obvious to us. While claiming to stand within the community of faith, those who hold to liberalism are clearly committed to positions plainly at variance with the Bible’s own point of view. In fact, liberalism, both classical and radical, has determined that the biblical record is primitive and even inferior. Worse still, the Scriptures are deceptive, a deceptive witness endorsing not just mythological notions, but oftentimes morally corrupt social and political agendas.
The Bible is not supportive of female ordination. The Bible, therefore, is a morally inferior document. The Bible is repressive when it comes to the homosexual agenda. The Bible is therefore morally primitive and inferior to our enlightened convictions.
You see where this is going. Only modern historical and rhetorical research can make the Bible then useful to improve society through a truly worthwhile view of life. The irony for this type of rhetorical study of the Bible is that it is oblivious to the Bible’s own rhetoric.
That rhetoric presents a God who calls for believing response to his intrusive saving activity. In the Old Testament, the rhetoric centered on the event of the Exodus, the saving event of the Exodus. And it was this event with which the heroes about that event, the audience, were called to interact.
One great example of this interaction is found in Exodus 13, verse 8. where the Jewish father tells his son in the context of the Exodus and in the context of the celebration of the Passover, this is what the Lord did for me when he brought me out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. You see, it doesn’t matter how far in time that father is removed from the Exodus event, he still says the same thing. It doesn’t matter whether it’s in the 1400 B.C. period or it’s in the 700s. The Jewish father says the same thing to his child.
This is what the Lord did for me when he brought me out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bodies. But Dad, you weren’t even there. Oh yes, I was. You have a completely different way of thinking. intruding on the consciousness of these Hebrew people. And the rhetoric of Scripture is picking that up in such a way so as to draw the audience, the hearers, into the event. The Father was there.
I can tell you now that it is only covenantal theology, it is only Reformed theology that appreciates that. It is only Reformed theology that can appreciate it. But if that isn’t good enough for you, and you say to yourself, well, that’s the Old Testament. What about the New? I’m getting a little rhetorical here. Paul, being the good Hebrew that he is, better than most, will do the same thing.
Only now, the great intrusive saving act is not the Old Testament exodus, a political and social deliverance for the children of Israel. It is the religious and spiritual deliverance realized through the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. The great intrusive saving act of God now, to which the Old Testament Exodus pointed, is achieved, realized, in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. And keeping in mind what that Hebrew father said back in Exodus 13, Paul expresses participation in this event now in fine covenantal style.
I am crucified with Christ, yet I live. Yet not I, but Christ liveth in me, and the life that I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” Paul, you weren’t even at the crucifixion or the resurrection. Oh, yes, I was. Now, if I were to become sermonic here, I would tell you, so were you.
But why do you hesitate to take those words from Galatians 2.20 and make them your own? To speak about yourself, the first person, singular pronoun in the same way that Paul speaks.
The two modern liberal approaches which I have described to you are incapable, incapable. They talk about the impossibilities for us, let’s talk about the impossibilities for them. I mean, you can’t believe in a God like that. That’s what they were saying, right? The modern liberal approaches which I have described to you are incapable of the covenantal saving confessions that are expressed in Exodus 13 and Galatians 2.
These liberals have thereby severed their connection to the Bible’s rhetorical intention. And sadly, tragically, they are complete strangers to it. Part three. rhetorical analysis, and the scriptures. Having offered a preliminary critique of liberalism’s proposals about rhetoric and the Bible, I don’t mean to discount sincere efforts at higher levels in biblical scholarship to hear more clearly, more carefully, what the text is saying. Let me give you three examples of a more positive approach. Lamentations. Say, wait a minute. Positive? This is going to be the positive approach? Oh yes.
The Old Testament book of Lamentations is generally accepted as the work of the 6th century B.C. prophet Jeremiah, who was a witness to the destruction of Jerusalem and its temple at the hands of the Babylonians in 587 B.C. Of interest to us is the way this book is divided.
It is divided along chapter lines now, composed of five laments. Five laments. A lament per chapter. The last chapter in the form of a prayer. Now, in looking at the book, you will notice the symmetry. chapters 1, 2, 4, and 5, 1, 2, 4, and 5, and thus, laments 1, 2, 4, and 5, each have 22 verses.
While chapter 3, the one we left out, the third lament has 66 verses, a multiple of 22. If you read Hebrew, you would see further what Jeremiah is doing. He is building a repeating acrostic based on the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. A repeating acrostic based on the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Laments 1, 2, and 4 have a verse per letter. Lament 3 has three verses per letter. However, now, further analysis of these laments, one through four, reveals that each has a chiastic pattern.
You know what a chiasm is? It’s the goalpost. You know chiasms, everybody? Shake your head if you know what a chiasm is. A, B, B, A. Okay, you with me? A, B, A, B, C, C, B, A. You can go on one side, back up the other. Okay, that’s chiasm. Each of these laments, one through four, has a chiastic pattern. In other words, and here is what might be, for us, the rhetorical impact. Each lament in this chiastic form is like a verbal whirlpool. a verbal whirlpool, sucking the hearer into its center before throwing that hearer back out to the circumference for the next descent.
You’re going to go down again. The rhetorical impact of this structure for the first four laments registers hard upon a people which has witnessed the total devastation of their nation, capital city, and temple. In fact, you sense something in this structure of the repeating history of Israel as a nation. At the edge, being sucked into the center, thrown out to the edge again, then sucked back down into the center because of her corruption. And it happens again and again and again. But what about the Fifth Lament? Chapter 5. It is neither an acrostic nor a chiasm. You’re with me. It is neither an acrostic or a chiasm.
In other words, the pattern of the previous four laments, rhetorical effect. The first four laments underscore the collapse of the world in which the Jews had come to trust, even to the neglect of their genuine commitment to Jehovah. The breaking of the pattern in the fifth lament serves as a rhetorical statement of hope. The repeated descent into the maelstrom of lament ends now, here in the fifth chapter, in a soulful prayer for restoration.
A soulful prayer for restoration. As to the power of this prayer, if you had it in front of you presently, you would note that it is not a request for the restoration to the land, the city, or the temple, but a prayer for restoration to God Himself. And in this sense, Lamentations becomes profoundly prophetic. and instructive to all of Israel and even to the church presently.
You must move past the land, past the city, past any religious structure to God himself, and that becomes the legacy of Judaism. Rightly understood. God is the inheritance. God is the reward, not the land not the garden, not a restored earth, God himself. Thus Lamentations ends. Turn thou us unto thee, O Lord, and we shall be turned.”
Matthew 13, the parable chapter. You can get a sense of where I’m going with this on the back of the outline. In dealing with Jesus’ rhetoric, we will remember his audience. Matthew helps us in our appreciation of this by his presentation of the parables here in Matthew 13. In this chapter we find two expressed audiences. The multitudes who receive the first four parables, the parables about the sower, the wheat and the tares, the mustard seed and the leaven, taking us through the 35th verse, and then the second audience his disciples who received the last three parables, the parables about the treasure, the pearl, and the dragnet, from verse 36 on.
At the center of the message from the parables is the event, once more underscoring that, the event of God’s self-disclosure through Jesus Christ in the arrival of the kingdom of heaven. Jesus’ parables illustrate the kingdom in its present reality in relationship to its future completion. If you hold on to that, you have a key to unlocking the parables. Jesus’ parables illustrate the kingdom in its present reality in relationship to its future completion.
What can be confusing, however, is the fact that the two audiences, the multitudes and the disciples, approach Jesus and his message about the kingdom with different attitudes and different questions. The multitudes are ambivalent, even skeptical, about Jesus and ask, in effect, this can’t be the kingdom, can it? The first four parables in Matthew 13 address this question. The Jews expected immediate and uniform response to the kingdom. They did not see such response to Jesus.
Jesus tells them in the parable of the sower that the kingdom has indeed come in the sowing of the seed, but the kingdom’s impact is limited and long-term, culminating in a harvest at the end of the age. Each of the following parables directed at the multitudes deals with the same dynamics. Interestingly, the Church, again being drawn into the text and living from it, has precisely the same rhetoric as Jesus had when dealing with multitudes who are ambivalent and skeptical, even to this day. While the disciples are also confused, somewhat like the multitudes, they have a different attitude and question. They trust Jesus, but their question is, what is our life like now that the kingdom has come? What is our life like now that the kingdom has come.
Jesus tells them the parable about the treasure in the field, for the sake of which a man sacrifices everything. The parable about the pearl of great price follows the same end. And finally, the parable about the dragnet sets before the disciples their mission of catching men for the sake of the kingdom until the day when the good are separated from the evil. The church being drawn into the text has precisely the same rhetoric in its message toward the faithful today.
What is the life of the disciple like? What is the life of the church like? The forsaking of everything in the interest of the kingdom. the treasure in the field, the pearl of great price, and the commitment to a mission that sees the faithful gathered out of the world until the end.
Finally, 1 Corinthians 13 and the Apostle Paul. He’s going to miss the best part. You’re still awake, right? Good. All right, here we go. When we come to Paul, we come to a most interesting case in terms of rhetorical analysis. This is because, on the one hand, Paul attacks rhetoric. On the other hand, he seems so adept in its use.
His disclaimer of rhetoric is found in the early chapters of 1st Corinthians. where he sets God’s wisdom in the cross of Christ over against the wisdom of speech. Chapter 1, verse 17. He sets God’s wisdom in the cross of Christ over against the wisdom of speech. What he is describing here as the wisdom of speech is wisdom that belongs to this world and is incapable of bringing people to a knowledge of God.” Verse 21. Chapter 1.
It would seem then, that according to the Apostle Paul, God has His own rhetoric. His own distinctive rhetoric. And that rhetoric isn’t like anything. the Greeks have imagined, or the Romans. That rhetoric, if we can term it such, is in fact the cross. Which Paul is determined to present?
Chapter 123, chapter 2, verse 2. For I am determined to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ and Him crucified.” Paul goes on to say, in effect, to resort to the wisdom of men is to reject the power of God resident in Christ and His cross. Chapter 2, verse 5.
We then watch in amazement as Paul builds his arguments out of the substance of Christ’s cross. And that brings us to 1 Corinthians 13. He will build his arguments out of the substance of Christ’s cross. The cross itself becomes method. It’s not simply message. It becomes method. Now, you know, 1 Corinthians 13, you probably have it memorized. Famous love chapter. It is an excellent example of Paul’s method. Here Paul mocks. Now, I underscore that.
You may not pick that up from your reading of the text, nor from the way in which 1 Corinthians 13 is invariably read. You know, it’s always in a serious tone, and we seem to be trying Here in the 13th chapter, Paul mocks the spiritually vain within the Corinthian church. He does this through a presentation of Christ and Christ’s cross.
But you, in calling 1 Corinthians to mind now, or maybe you even have it open in front of you, can’t remember in it, can’t pick up any reference in it, of either Christ or his cross. Now, even though you’re right, as you scan through the verses of 1 Corinthians 13, or as you think in your mind, calling to mind that chapter, that there are no mentions of Christ or His cross in it, be assured, Paul means here to communicate both Christ and His cross.
In the first place, Paul intends here no presentation of an abstract definition of love. 1 Corinthians 13 is not a general philosophical or ethical discourse. This should be apparent to us from verses 4 through 7, where Paul tells us love is patient, kind, free of jealousy, boasting, arrogance, and the like. That’s my paraphrase.
Now, it is a particular kind of hermeneutical obtuseness that has refused to see Jesus Christ at root in this description. Paul here is not expounding an idea, the idea of love, or a feeling, the feeling of love, or even an attribute of character, he is expounding Jesus Christ.
Specifically, he is expounding the cross. After all, in the cross of Christ, Christ himself refuses to seek his own advantage or glory. It is in the cross that he shows himself unprovoked, It is in the cross that Christ does not take into account a wrong suffered. In the cross, Christ bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, and endures all things. He is working off of Christ. But Christ and his cross do more than lie beneath the surface of Paul’s words. They form, as well, the very substance to his method in argumentation. The very substance in his method of argumentation. This takes place in two ways.
First, Paul is fighting spiritual pride among those at Corinth who boast in their particular gifts in the Spirit. At the opening of 1 Corinthians 13, Paul subtly mocks these people. He subtly mocks these people. He means what he writes here to be a humorous, though controlled, attack. He mocks these people by taking their gifts and heightening them to such a level that they are placed beyond the realms of actual reality or even possibility.
Beginning with the tongues of men and of angels, verse 1, he goes on to an understanding of all mysteries and all knowledge, the possession of all faith, and an absolute demonstration of charity, so-called, through immolation. I’ll burn my body. You get to that third verse and you wonder where in the world is this guy coming from? Just come out of the Bible, come out of the background of our understanding of what it means to serve God, you’re going to burn your body. Who does not?
Pagans, I get it. It’s certainly an understatement. By the time we get to the part about him burning his body, we should have perceived the twinkle in his eye. Paul is saying sarcastically here, is sarcasm a proper pious rhetorical device? Yes. Paul is saying sarcastically Even if I had these gifts, and I don’t, nor does anyone else, and had not love, I’m nothing. But you will notice now how he tempers his barb. He tempers them by his use of the first person singular pronoun, I. Though I speak, though I have, though I bestow, he rhetorically controls his sarcasm by placing himself in the middle of the humorous assault by making himself look ridiculous. He says, though I, not though you.
This is nothing less than the effect of Christ and his cross expressing itself in his approach. Paul labors to humble himself even in his most barbed communication. But then later, in verse 9, Paul says, For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. Here, the expression of Christ and His cross deepens.
He uses now the first person plural pronoun, we. This pronoun is as deliberate as it is inclusive. You see, everyone gifted and non-gifted is included in the we. Everyone gifted and non-gifted is included in the we. In fact, Paul himself is included in the we. And Paul has the greatest gift.
He’s the apostle. He’s included himself amongst those who know in part and prophesy in part. The effect of Paul’s language is not merely the recognition of the uniform limitation under which all in the church serve, but equally the uniform level to which even the least gifted, even the ungifted, are exalted so as to participate with one as distinct as an apostle in the body. He literally takes those who are considered to be nothing in Corinth, and with the inclusive we, he exalts them to a level which he has as apostle. Is that not the operation of Christ in his cross? Whereby he humbles himself to our level, he having the greatest gift He being the most gifted, He being the most exalted, and by that action in the cross, He elevates us to share in His Sonship.
The manner, the method of Paul’s argumentation in itself is the preaching of Christ and the event of his cross. As Paul places himself as a prime example of the absurd folly to which some of the Corinthians have fallen prey, in this imitating Christ on his cross, but as well exalting all to the level of his own extraordinary gift, thus reproducing in his argumentation the glorious effect of Christ on the cross. So much is Paul bound up in Christ, so much does he find his life in Christ, that even his method of argumentation, his rhetorical method, preaches Christ.
I hope you have been able to see that the Bible affects, even rejects, but always subordinates rhetoric to greater concerns. Actually, it co-ops rhetoric and transforms it into an extension of the biblically declared saving work of God, where the event of God’s accomplishment dominates all ideas about that event. The Bible, therefore, intends its presentation to bring the hearer into direct and spiritual contact with God’s saving act, whether the destruction of Jerusalem and its temple in the case of Jeremiah, or the tension of the already not yet of the kingdom in the case of Jesus, or the cross of Christ in the case of Paul. The message and the method in the Bible’s rhetoric are so intertwined that in the end, the method itself communicates the message. The world’s rhetoric, for all its artistry and scientific precision, in the end, by contrast, too often comes off only transparently contrived, but anemic, if not vacuous.
And that’s it. Now we’re going to do a question and answer session now and we’re going to pass this around right now. Do you want to stop this and then start it up again? Okay, now we’re going to enter the question-answer section of the lecture series, The Bible and Rhetoric. Take one. Uh-oh, I see a hand.
I think it’s got to be something more than just making us feel accepted. It seems like there’s an existential link there between Paul and Christ. I can see that between Paul and Christ, or the believer in Christ, but what about the believer in the other section of the text? I think one of the things that we should keep in mind is that the Scriptures are sufficient, and the intention of God is to make it plain to us that not only has he provided for us completely within the text, but he’s thought of everything. And so the pull which is affecting us is always toward the Word and into the Word, that we might see in the Word its treasures, its riches, and the way in which it opens up the greatness of God and the fact that He has thought of everything. So, the history of the world is in the Bible. the life of the Christian or the church to the end of the age is in the Bible. It’s there. It is the task of the church through her preachers and teachers to make that apparent to the congregants, the faithful, the community of faith, the body.
And invariably we become confused and we become disoriented when that’s not as clear to us. Where we begin self-consciously to walk off in other directions. Now the crisis of our time is that now it is being accepted as an axiom both for liberalism and for evangelicalism generally.
I might say that there is a qualitative difference between the now and the then. So you live in a completely different world. And the advances scientifically confirm that. Or the advances socially, in the minds of many politically, confirm that. We live in a qualitatively different world.
And I just do not believe that that’s the Bible’s point of view. You have, for instance, volumes that are being produced now about preaching, for instance. You have Gray Donnis’ book, The Modern Preacher in the Ancient Text. which unfortunately is assuming that distinction between the then and the now. You have John Stott’s book, Between Two Worlds, and the two worlds he has in mind is the biblical world and the world of today, not this world and the next. So there are problems that have now intruded upon the church and its consciousness, which makes it increasingly difficult for the church to live in and from the text. In fact, Scripture becomes an appendage to life. It becomes a volume for proof texts. It’s not a place to dwell. It’s not a habitation. It becomes a place to go in order to get various texts to prop yourself up or to apply. I don’t… So, God wanted to do that. He gave us this truth that we are to be identified with the Scriptures and with the Word. Well, what about the corruption of man’s mind? I mean, unless he gives us a sufficient word, where are we going to turn? Well, I’ll turn to my own mind. That’s where I’ll turn. I’ll think it up on my own. Or, you know, I’ll just build on the the building blocks that God’s given me here, and I’ll be content with the structures and the forms that I come up with.
Does not our doctrine of total depravity and the threat to us from our own sin drive us back to the Word and its sufficiency? I think he’s putting us in our place. I think that’s for sure. He’s trying to, you know, cut off all roads of escape. I mean, you’re going to stand at the Red Sea and you’re going to see the salvation of the Lord. And the only way for you to live is to go through that sea.
Now you might say, you know, I’m being poetic, I’m being, you know, metaphorical, you know. How is this helpful for the day-to-day detail of life and all of the things that you face in your problems? And I’m telling you that the answer to those issues are found in the text and they don’t minimize your life presently at all. They maximize it. Because the effect of it is to, after you’ve lost your life, to the Word. You see, that’s a religious act. You’re actually giving up your life now to live in the text. You see what you’re doing? It is a religious act. It is an extension of the cross itself. See?
If you sacrifice your life, and what’s the consequence of that? What’s the result of that? The result of that is that your life is given back to you. To what end? so that you can get the things that you lost when you gave the world up? No, that you might be a servant, self-consciously aware of your relationship to the world as you live in your present circumstance. You are given back to the world in service. For the sake of what? Well, for the sake of preserving the planet, right? No. For the sake of God Himself. You do it for God. That’s your motivation.
One technical sense seems like often times in the gospel narrative Jesus presents some counter-arguments due to the Pharisees’ interpretation, you know, they’re always asking him things that he’s always saying something that he’s not saying. So, is Jesus a Galenicist in the classical sense? If he is, what does that do to your thesis? If he isn’t, then what’s his intention in confounding them, if it’s not, to persuade them?
Well, I don’t know what rhetorical method or polemical method would be involved when he, you know, looks Nicodemus in the eyes and says, you know, you must be born again. What kind of an argument is that? That was exactly Nicodemus’ response. What kind of an argument is that? Doesn’t it become obvious that Jesus is operating on a completely different matrix?
I mean, he is seeing heaven, he’s seeing God, he’s seeing everything clearly. And you’ve got people down here that want to debate, want to argue, want to be clever. We know that you’re a teacher come from God. We know. That’ll put him off his guard. Nicodemus comes as the sort of classical polemicist, doesn’t he? He wants to argue about this stuff. He’s not coming as the innocent inquirer. Don’t think that. That’s one of the ways in which he’s invariably interpreted. That’s what’s going on in John 3. I mean, he’s coming for the deliberate purpose of laying Jesus low, of besting Jesus in the argument. And he points out the absurdity of Jesus’ statement. You know, it’s ridiculous. How can a man be bored again? And for the second time in his mother’s womb? It’s quite humorous. should go through there.
So, I mean, whether you’re saying that Jesus, of course, has mastered the polemical arts, He’s beyond them. And you see, He’s not talking about here an exchange of ideas. Well, of course, Nicodemus, you have an idea, I have an idea, and we’re going to have a nice discussion here, or a debate, or an argument about whose ideas are best. Jesus is going to declare to him the reality of which the Bible speaks, and the fact that now the rebirth of which he is speaking is available. It’s event-centered. You know, Van Til’s point is that the Jews of Jesus’ day have been Hellenized.
They want to polemicize it in the sense of a classical rhetorical argument. Okay, let’s get into debate. We love it, don’t we? It’s just a way to make a living. And Jesus is not here fooling around with ideas. He is declaring to them the reality of God’s coming and the availability now of new birth. from above, from heaven. Impossibilities to a Hellenistic mind.
It seems like your main point is more about a philosophy of history or of the nature of sociology in that it is historical, event-centered, than it is about rhetoric. Like, for instance, if you were dealing with liberalism, particularly, I think, radical liberalism, your focus is on the falsity of their philosophy of history. I thought more than any particular rhetorical philosophy or perspective. And so I was wondering if that’s the case and why you’re couching the, or why it’s called rhetoric and Bible as opposed to the Bible and history.
Well, what I’m going to do, of course, is to subordinate language to history. And as far as I’m concerned, that’s irrefutable. I realize that there are those who are contending for an abstract consideration of language and logic in relationship to language structures. But to me, for me, that is a completely indefensible position, and that is a completely unbiblical position.
The priority of history is established in Genesis 1.1, in the beginning. It’s a time statement. It’s a historical statement. Language for us, language as God communicates to his world, is placed in a time-space frame. It is an historical context. It can’t be avoided. You can’t get out of it. You can’t go anywhere to escape it. And to assert such stuff, in my judgment, is absurd, is nonsense.
So if we’re going to talk about rhetoric in relationship to the Bible, it is going to be subordinated to the Gospel, to what is central to the Scriptures, the events of God’s activity. That’s why I couched it the way I did, that the Hellenistic world was confronted with Hebraic reality. Not Hebraic ideas, but Hebraic reality. Oh, I wish I could say that.
I was asked, is there a theme that connects all these lectures together? And I said, No. The next two nights are similar in that they deal with Jay Dressen Nation and the history of somewhat of the OPC. But, you know, tonight, this is this is Yeah, this is this. We’re in and out on this one. Oh, oh, yeah. I mean, it’s Of course, you’re going to see the connections as we go through the three lectures. I mean, it’s going to be obvious. Yeah. Yes.
But that still leaves a wide open matter of style, I guess you could call it. The modern equivalent of classical rhetoric is advertising of many forms. So we have biblical rhetoric or whatever you want to call it. overriding purpose or goal, like the proclamation of the gospel, and that’s going to give us some ethical bounds within which to work. But that doesn’t say anything about, you know, can we be sarcastic, or, well, as you were talking about, what Paul was doing. It seems like there’s still a wide field of questions about homiletics. That is central and that to me and I don’t think that we’ve done or that I’ve done a very good job of living in and from the proclamation itself so that in my demeanor, in my posture I become a means by which the message itself is communicated.
The man becomes an extension of the message. You perceive the cross in him. You perceive Christ in him, as well as in the method and, of course, in the message. It’s the total thing. Such is the life in Christ that Paul is trying to advocate, and he says as much. You might recall in 2 Corinthians 2 and 3 where he’s taking on those who are.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

