SERMON

Van Til and the Identity of the OPC

June 1, 1996 · Rev. Charles G. Dennison

Series:

This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered June 1, 1996.

About this sermon

Van Til’s personality shaped how startling his apologetic sounded to its first hearers, including in the dispute between Machen and Buzzwell over how to receive it. Dutch theologians gave Van Til his background, and he reworked what he drew from them. The OPC formed part of its identity by standing outside the American religious establishment.

Browse all sermons

Sermon transcript

My original title for this lecture was Van Till, the Church in the 60s. That was until I found out that Van Till said nothing about the Beatles, LSD, and Timothy Leary. Actually, the title of the lecture is Cornelius Van Till and the identity of the OPC, and it will be an expansion on the article that recently appeared in New Horizons. The minutes of the 6th General Assembly of the OPC, 1939, included this entry.

The vote for moderator of the assembly was taken. The tellers reported that the Reverend Cornelius Van Till, Ph.D., had received a majority. It appeared that Dr. Van Till had not been on the floor when he was nominated, and after election he requested that for definite reasons he be relieved of the office. The request was granted.

Presumably, the definite reasons persisted throughout Dr. Van Til’s long life, since he, although regularly attending GAs, never did serve as moderator. In fact, I don’t believe that he was ever again nominated. Van Til was a brilliant man. He knew that he was not brilliant enough, however, to penetrate the mysteries of Robert’s Rules of Order, or to wield a gavel over an assembly of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

But truly, this incident does provide us some insight into the personality of the man. He was a faithful churchman. He was regular in his worship attendance. He was also always present, but somewhat retiring in the courts of the church. He was important to assembly proceedings at certain points in his career, and we will be talking about some of these.

But even here, he tended to remain in the background and influence more by reputation than by direct involvement in debate. At the same time, He was a very prominent figure in the beginning history of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and played a major part in confirming the identity of the OPC as a distinctively Reformed and Catholic denomination. This lecture in the 60th anniversary year of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church However, unworthy of Dr. Van Til’s high standards and achievements is an effort to honor him and his service to Christ the King within the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

On December 4th, 1936, about six months after the formation of what would come to be known as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, J. Oliver Buswell, president of Wheaton College, minister in the newly formed denomination, and member of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions, wrote J. Gresham Machen for the last time.

Machen would die about a month later before he could finish a response. Always prompt in his correspondence, Machen had trouble with his reply to Buswell’s letter. A draft fragment of a reply, however, does survive and reveals Machen’s frustrations with Buswell. At least three things in Buswell’s letter disturbed him. First, Buswell constantly equivocated on Scofield dispensationalism. A month before, and in other correspondence at the same time, Manchin had not hesitated to identify Scofield dispensationalism as heresy.

Secondly, Buswell had the audacity to suggest that Manchin’s recent ousting by him and others from the position of president in the Independent Board was in the spirit of democracy, since Machen and his followers at Westminster Seminary and in the newly formed denomination had become, quote, dictatorial, unquote.

But thirdly, and most importantly for our purposes this afternoon, Boswell attacked the Westminster apologetic, as he called it, at the center of which was the figure of Cornelius Bentil. Buswell charged that the seminary was moving in a novel direction. He personally supported the historical apologetics and biblical exegesis of such scholars as James Orr, Robert Dick Wilson, and Machen himself, as evidenced in Machen’s works the origin of Paul’s religion and the virgin birth. But now the seminary was promoting a philosophical apologetic that was dangerous and wrong because it weakened the critical capabilities of the students and compromised their practical usefulness. For Buswell, the Westminster apologetic was, quote, substance-less theorizing, unquote.

Where Machen stood on Van Til’s apologetical position continues to be debated. The late Greg Bonson has argued forcefully that Van Til and Machen’s apologetics were, after all, and in the end, quite compatible, if not somewhat the same. But this position, in my own estimation, can be successfully maintained only by ignoring Machen’s continued reliance upon a traditional formulation of the proofs for God’s existence and his continued commitment to a natural theology. Even into the last year of his life, Machen invoked the classical Princeton method, as is shown by his radio talk, How May God Be Known? included in the book The Christian Faith in the Modern World. Where Dr. Bonson has tried to bring Machen and Van Til together on the apologetics question, Alan McRae has endeavored to keep them apart.

According to McRae, Machen privately scoffed at, privately laughed at, Van Til’s position. Whether Machen did so privately, it would seem only McRae can say. However, such a private attitude hardly squares with Machen’s public behavior. Van Til himself recalled his two-day train ride with Machen. Going to and returning from Chicago, Van Til, as he recalled, carefully explained to Machen his approach. Later, Van Til confessed that he didn’t know how much Machen had picked up.

The conversation was quite technical. Still, as much as Machen failed to grasp, and as much as he personally continued in the apologetic position in which he had been schooled, he was publicly committed to Van Til. I believe there were at least two reasons for this. The first, to put it quite bluntly, was political. Machen was very much concerned that Westminster Seminary present a united front before a watching world. He knew this much.

In Van Til he had a man as fiercely loyal to Westminster Seminary and the movement of which it was a part as he was himself. Furthermore, in Van Till, he had someone without traditional American Presbyterian attachments, who, when things got rough, would not always be looking over his shoulder. Here was someone, in other words, Machen could count on. The mention of Van Till’s distance from traditional American Presbyterian attachments introduces the second reason for Machen’s public commitment to Van Till. You see, Machen found himself undergoing a re-education in the latter years of his life. This re-education began formally in 1929 with the organization of Westminster Seminary, in which Machen found himself soon the student to the faculty he had assembled. Machen’s orthodoxy had not left him immovable.

A very, very important point. He was a man open to persuasion. He was not intractable as his enemies contended. Here was a man in his latter years in transition, moving from a sort of provincialism attached to the American Presbyterian scene to the Catholic positions of a more articulate, more thoroughly alert confessional Calvinism. In other words, under the tutelage of the faculty at Westminster, Machen was learning that being reformed meant more than he had dreamt. This re-education for Machen was theological in the deepest sense.

Prior to 1929, for instance, we find very few references to the distinctive reformed doctrines. Only general references to the reformed faith and, yes, reference to Presbyterianism But it seems as if the idea of Presbyterianism is as elevated as the reality itself. After 1929, specifics begin to surface about the covenant, predestination, limited atonement, eschatology, the active obedience of Christ, and even the subject of the Church itself. In fact, Machen begins to speak about the distinctive content of the whole of the Reformed Lossach.

According to Oswald T. Alice, a member of that faculty at Westminster, Machen’s interaction with and response to dispensationalism took place in the last years of his life. It was as if, said Alice, He were learning about dispensationalism for the very first time.

The most difficult area in Machen’s re-education, to be sure, was apologetics. For Van Til was certainly no quick study. Given Machen’s reticence to speak on issues in which he lacked competence, he did not express himself in Van Til’s terms. At the same time, he remained publicly committed to the man, and yes, open to his method. But such commitment and openness would cost Nachen greatly.

Not with liberals in the PCUSA, who could have cared less about increasingly rigorous Calvinist direction of Machen or anyone else, but with the fundamentalists who had attached themselves to Machen and were a part of the movement that brought about the new church.

The fundamentalists in the OPC in those early days were typically Americans before they were Calvinists or Presbyterians. They hailed from that branch of early 20th century Christianity that, despite all of its pre-millennial pessimism about the world, was actually bully on America.

Fundamentalism connected its evangelistic and moral zeal to patriotic ardor. It championed American individualism and democracy, and opposed big government and socialism. Fundamentalists have little difficulty blending their energetic evangelistic enterprising with the commercialism of their day. George Marsden’s comparison between Carl MacIntyre’s brand of fundamentalism and the sales division of a modern corporation is very telling. Much more telling, I think, than George intended. But further, The OP fundamentalists, like fundamentalists generally, generated a strong protectionist spirit, highly suspicious of and downright hostile to foreign influences.

H. McAllister Griffiths, for instance, one time confidant of Machen, who because of his fundamentalist convictions turned on Machen charged that those who dominated Westminster Seminary and the OPC, quote, were not of American Presbyterian background, unquote. He had in mind John Murray, who was from Scotland, and also Professors R. B. Kuyper, Ned B. Stonehouse, and Cornelius Van Till, whom he identified as of, quote, Holland Dutch extraction.

It’s really bad. Alan McRae, another fundamentalist of the OPC, would give as his reason for resigning from the faculty at Westminster Seminary in April 1937, the fact that the seminary had come under the control of, quote, a small alien group without American Presbyterian background, unquote.

Later, he indicated he meant no offense to Murray. Only the Dutchman. And among the Dutchman, he singled out Van Til and said, the effect of Van Til’s teaching upon the students had more to do with my resignation from the seminary than anything else. From McCrae’s perspective, Van Til’s apologetic was as alien as the man himself. Both were pushing the church and the seminary in directions foreign to the American fundamentalist vision. The battle between the fundamentalists and the confessionally reformed aliens came to a head at the Third General Assembly in June 1937.

The issue on the table, or rather the issues on the table, were the future of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions and Temperance. The Fundamentalists favored continued support of the Independent Board. The Aliens favored a denominational committee on missions. The fundamentalists favored abstinence from alcoholic beverages. The aliens favored liberty of conscience, where the Bible itself did not prescribe. While the aliens won on both of these counts, the real victory was for a more Catholic, more theologically aware, more Calvinistic identity for the OPC.

Fourteen ministers and three elders subsequently withdrew from the Church and in the next year helped to organize the Bible Presbyterian Synod. But it was becoming apparent that fundamentalism would not define the new church. But this being true, a very startling thought suggests itself. Although The OPC had advertised itself as the continuation of the Old Church, the mainline PCUSA, and although Machen had used this very line of argument, it now appeared that the OPC was not a continuation. The fundamentalists, who were at one time comfortable in the Old Church, were not comfortable at all in the New. This thought would go even deeper, for the new church would prove to be at odds with the old church in a far more significant sense than is ordinarily recognized. Here, after the loss of Machen, the figure increasingly taking center stage in the consciousness of the church was Van Til. Bantill has been rightly known for his impact in the area of Christian apologetics. His apologetic is startling in many ways. I will cite three.

First, he did not see the task of apologetics as that of establishing the validity of first principles upon the basis of neutral reason and in the interest of a natural theology. as had been the classical position expressed at Old Princeton and, by and large, in the old church. For Van Til, apologetics was the defense of the faith, not the defense of the possibility of believing this, that, or something else. Apologetics presupposes, then, the truth of the biblical revelation about the ontological Trinity, and about the Bible’s own self-confessed center, the self-attesting cross.

This means that Van Til’s apologetic is essentially redemptive historical in character. As Van Til was to say, Quote, logic and fact have meaning only in terms of the Christian story, unquote. That is the story of salvation found in the Bible. But further and secondly, the faith which Van Til sought to defend was that of the Reformed church as expressed in the Reformed creeds. Therefore, Van Til’s apologetic was self-consciously ecclesiastical.

This leads into his understanding of the separateness of the Church. But along these lines, his apologetic was also decidedly and militantly antithetical. Van Til would speak of this antithetical and militant posture in a letter to a friend late in his career. being quite critical of a speaker he had recently heard, he wrote, there was very little of Augustine’s picture of the struggle between the city of God and the city of man, there was little of Kuiper’s idea of the antithesis between regenerate and non-regenerate mankind, and there was nothing of Machen, who wanted to put the flag on the top of the highest peak and do it, if necessary, alone. That captures it. But thirdly, Van Til’s apologetic had a deliberate philosophical interest, and this because he was very much aware of and understood the deep undercurrents of theological discussion.

Particularly, he recognized in mainline Protestantism and the old mainline Presbyterian Church, the streams of philosophical thought in variance with the genius of biblical religion. Especially, he recognized the streams of Enlightenment thought. In fact, these streams were no quiet tributaries. Instead, they had become a raging flood.

Historian Henry Steele Cominger has confirmed Van Til’s position on American society in general. That society was, from the 18th century, thoroughly informed by the Enlightenment ideal. Mark Noll has confirmed Van Til’s position with respect to American Presbyterianism with his analysis of John Witherspoon. And the way in which Witherspoon, while using the common sense philosophy of the Scottish realists, also promoted, however unwittingly, the Enlightenment’s ideal. The end result was a gentleman’s Presbyterianism.

Combining a church religion that retained the language of salvation by the triune God of the Bible, and a public civil religion that had no room for the Trinitarian declarations and confessions of the Church whatsoever. The difficulty for a Church population still holding to the salvific religion of Scriptures would be the situation in which the Church’s religion became more like the public civil religion. more like religion in keeping with the Enlightenment ideal. What happens, for instance, when mainline Presbyterians, who have banked on the alliance of church religion and civil religion, in the interest of the common cultural vision of the establishment, find the alliance broken, and the generic, naturalistic, non-Trinitarian, anti-Salvific religion of the public square now the religion of the pulpit.

What do Presbyterians do when they discover the establishmentarian and cultural positioning that has historically defined them as Presbyterians demands that they now surrender the gospel? Do they hold on to their precious establishmentarian Presbyterianism and let the gospel go? Or do they, like Machen and others with him, hold to that gospel and let goods and kindred go, even though they find themselves not only outside of the establishmentarian church, but outside of the establishment altogether? You see, when Machen was defrocked, he was disenfranchised from the Presbyterian establishment. And when he was disenfranchised, the movement identified with him was as well.

But this very painful experience actually becomes the opportunity for the reassessment of Presbyterianism. The OPC, therefore, is not simply the continuation of the old established Presbyterian Church beholden to a deadly alliance with the Enlightenment ideal or the primacy of the intellect. much less the national and cultural credentials held dear by fundamentalists. Something of the pilgrim identity of Christ’s true church has intruded upon this denomination, as she, for the sake of her true reward, God himself, is being prepared to lose everything for him.

Here is the crucial issue in the question about OPC identity. For the OPC, the place within the establishment has been lost. The one time defining tie to American culture, inherent to American Presbyterianism itself, has been severed. And it is this fact as much as anything else, namely the fact that the OPC is a Presbyterian anomaly, and she has no cultural bridge, no establishment, dependence, or aspiration that defines her.

Van Til’s identity as an alien he being of Holland-Dutch extraction, and his philosophical apologetic would speak effectively to and for the new church. His message about the antithetical nature of the faith was ready-made for the church’s stand in the world. But his message also helps the church appreciate why she cannot be a mere continuation of the old church. For the old church, even at its best, was critically flawed, and he pointed that out time and again in his writings.

It would not do, therefore, to long to return to the establishmentarianism of the American Presbyterian model. But the great struggle for OPC identity, in which the figure of Van Til would play such an important part, was not the battle with Presbyterian fundamentalism in the 30s, but with the growing New Evangelicalism and a residual Presbyterian elitism in the 40s.

This struggle played itself out in two episodes. The first involved the Committee of Nine, erected by the Eighth General Assembly in 1941. The purpose of this committee was, quote, to study the relationship of the OPC to society and to other ecclesiastical bodies, unquote, in order to make recommendations about how the OP might, quote, meet the needs of this generation, and have an increasing area of influence and make a greater impact on life today.” The thriving force behind this committee was Edwin H. Ryan, a Presbyterian elitist, who although he wrote the fine book, The Presbyterian Conflict, dreamed of the OPC as a large Presbyterian body with the cultural clout of the PCUSA.

The majority in the committee stood with Ryan, two dissented, of whom one was Van Till. The minority feared the establishment out of this committee of a permanent bureaucratic fixture that would dominate the church’s future. But more importantly, it feared the loss of the vigorous proclamation of the OPC’s distinctive faith. The minority sensed that the Committee would be the means to return to the lost Presbyterian heritage, a move which, under the leadership of someone like Ryan, spelled disaster. The Assembly was persuaded by the minority, and the Committee was dissolved.

But this defeat signaled for Ryan a breach between him and many in the denomination, including many at Westminster Seminary, where he served as President of the Board of Trustees. Things came to a head when he and some at Westminster, such as Van Til, became involved in the Christian University Project. Ryan thought this university should stand in the interests of the American cultural line. Van Til and others disagreed. Because of this disagreement and the suspicion that Ryan, as General Secretary of the University Association, had misused funds, the Association removed Ryan from office in the fall of 1946.

And upon being informed that the Presbytery of Philadelphia was preparing to move against him, judicially, he withdrew from the OPC. Later he returned to the PCUSA claiming that he had re-read the fourth book of Calvin’s Institutes and had become convinced that Nathan and the OPC had been schismatic all along. In actual fact, Ryan was merely returning to the cultural identity of the church that he had never really left.

The second episode the struggle during the 40s in which the figure of Van Til was so important involved those who were of a more evangelical point of view. The rise of the broad and modern evangelical movement is a study in itself. But let me mention a few of its features. First, It has redefined the word evangelical, so that it no longer carries the sense it had for Luther and for Calvin. The Reformers used the word evangelical to describe the Church. The modern evangelical uses it to describe personal commitments. that have as much to do with devotion to the autonomy of the individual conscience and voluntarism as they do to any distinctive Christian doctrine. It is not without reason, therefore, that Van Til saw evangelicalism as inherently Arminian. Secondly, modern evangelicalism has tended to be dominated by personality cults and the parachurch.

As a result, the visible church has been pushed into the background. In fact, the visible church, in order to justify itself, must be redefined as an evangelical institution, no longer unique and offering an absolute obligation, The visible church sits at the level of other evangelical institutions, forced to compete for the believer’s interests and money. Thirdly, modern evangelicalism aspires to cultural parity, the position of an equal.

It aspires to acceptance. It is not schizophrenic about the culture as are the fundamentalists. It is not controlled by the aristocratic notion of privilege, as was Ryan. It craves acceptance. Ralph Reed, executive director of the Christian Coalition, recently spoke about his organization having arrived at the apex of evangelical aspiration.

We now have, he said, what we have always wanted, a place at the table. Paul Woolley spoke more to the point in assessing such an attitude. These people, said Woolley, like to read about themselves in the newspaper. Woolley made that statement in 1944 specifically addressing evangelical discontent within the OPC.

Now, it would be unfair to say that those who in the 1940s represented the evangelical cause in the OPC lacked Reformed convictions and specific commitments to a Reformed understanding of the Church. At the same time, they had been influenced by the broad and rapidly developing evangelical movement at many points. What they perceived as OPC isolation and even contrariness provided opportunity for certain features of evangelical thinking to dominate their minds.

As you probably know, the struggle in the 40s between the evangelical mind and orthodox Presbyterianism centered on the theological positions of Gordon Clark and Cornelius Van Till. The theological issues are treated in many places, including in fighting the good fight. I do not mean to reduce in any way the magnitude and the importance of those theological issues. However, my purpose here is to draw your attention to the wide cultural and ecclesiastical dynamics.

In a certain sense, both Van Til and Clark were front men. for the groups that lined up behind their positions and personalities. The Van Til group, whether consciously or not, pursued a course in line with OPC disenfranchisement and the antithetical posture of a rigorous Calvinism.

Those lining up behind Clark were much more of the mind of Ryan’s failed Committee of Nine, but not for elitist reasons. Instead, for evangelical reasons. Specifically, behind Clark stood a group devoted to a, quote, program for action, unquote, that would move the OPC into alliance with fundamentalists and evangelicals for greater impact upon American society. Once more, as in the earlier debate with the fundamentalists, the cry went up that the OPC was under the thumb of men from, quote, other lands, unquote. Men without American evangelical Presbyterian background or roots.

This second episode in which the figure of Van Till was so prominent came to a head at the 14th General Assembly in 1947. The Clark party determined to make an effort to gain control of the denomination’s foreign missions committee. After extensive discussion and debate, the Clark party lost in their quest by the margin of one vote. The effect of that loss was much greater than the margin in the vote. Before the next assembly, Clark and many who stood behind him had left the church many of these individuals for enculturated Presbyterian bodies.

As sad as these departures were, and as devastating as was their effect, the OPC, not irrespective of the figure of Cornelius Van Till, was confirmed and furthered in its identity as a Presbyterian anomaly, resistant to efforts that pushed it back into the American mainstream or endeavored to make it an extension of American Presbyterian provincialism.

Instead, because of the influence of Van Til and others, the OPC was moved in Catholic and more rigorously more insistent reformed directions. This is not to say that Van Til triumphed in every respect in the OPC. His commitment to Kuiper’s program for the reformation of culture would not win the day. The OPC’s antithetical posture has proved itself no more comfortable with the ethnic Dutch perspective of neo-Calvinism than the ethnic American perspectives from which it had distanced itself.

But where then does this leave the Orthodox Presbyterian Church? If it stands in some regard beyond its American environment, and even beyond Van Till in the full analysis of his perspective, where then does the OPC stand? Could it be that the OPC stands in an alien and disestablished position, furthered by Nathan’s experience and Van Til’s articulately antithetical theology in the interest of the identity of God’s true church as a pilgrim people without nationalist or ethnic portfolio? Could it be that the OPC, by her existence, stands as a very helpful reminder that Christ’s Church is stamped with an essential and proper other-worldliness?

She is to exhibit a heavenly-mindedness that does not seek to regain the world that has been forsaken, but rather seeks how to be of service to the Lord in that world until the Lord returns. Indeed, the true Church of Jesus Christ must always confess, here have we no continuing city, but we seek one to come. Our citizenship is in heaven, is it not? Our life is hid with Christ. in God.

I answered all the questions. Yes. So that’s what she said. She talked about the possibility that Chertab, if any, would have ultimately gone to the plaintiff. And secondly, what was contemplated in Chertab, who is a member of something I later proved to be true, was that she was involved in a joint project with the EPA. Yes, the question is with regard to responsibility that Christians have to society and to culture and within the society and culture as a whole. Is that the scope of the question?

That is that we can never abandon our identity as citizens of heaven as we are in this world. We take that with us. That is who we are. And therefore our lives are the implementing of that heavenly perspective at heavenly life. If I could put it like this, by our union with Christ, we are exalted into the heavens, and we participate in his life in glory. But having been joined to him by faith, we see the one who bears the wound marks of his own humiliation, and we likewise therefore make ourselves as it were of no reputation, and we choose service in the world in imitation to our Savior, in imitation of our Savior, even being given over to conformity, such conformity that may lead us to death.

That is the agenda. You start there. You must start with what has been given you already by grace. What has been given you is heaven. You are now living out of that reality. To do anything else is to allow works to intrude. And that is what is happening. Under the banner of being relevant, we are witnessing the triumph of moralism.

So whatever the answer to the question is, it must start from that biblical point of view. I dare say that the life of the church looks like the life of Jesus. And that’s what the Gospels are about. The Gospels are not written just simply to give us biographies of Jesus. They are written to give us the life of the church in the life of the Savior. That’s what it means to be covenantal in your approach to the Gospels. So if you want to know how to live, Look to Jesus. Let me press that question a little further.

Does there remain a cultural mandate for Christians? Do Christians have any task in politics? You pointed out that the OPC has rejected the sort of Hyperionism of Vance Hill. What would you say about Christians’ obligations in politics, in the arts, in science, and so on?

That all is going to have to rise exegetically. It’s all going to have to rise out of Scripture. Do we believe the Bible is sufficient or don’t we? Is the answer in Scripture or is it not? If it is, then it behooves us to to ferret that out, to see it in scripture.

Where might we look with regard to the question of the Christian in politics? It seems to me that in an alien environment, one of the places you might look is to the exile and how believers and God functioned within that situation. It seems to me that if you’re thinking about Christians in politics, you might do well to consider Theophilus. The title that he bears is most excellent. very suggestive of office, privilege within the society. What is the nature of Luke’s address to Theophilus, both in the Gospel and the Book of Acts?

It’s going to arise out of that. And I contend that it will be there that you will find the implementation of the heavenly point of view. The alien character, the stranger character of the people of God It doesn’t exclude the people of God from pursuing political tasks, political position, political responsibility. But they must go into that with this eschatological self-consciousness, or this epistemological self-consciousness, never forgetting who they are, never being deluded as to what this is all about.

Is it really the improvement of society, the betterment of the world? We might all live longer. These are nice advantages, but is that the true perspective of the gospel? The better life? Lawrence? I have a question. Can you tell me your destination? Is that still a priority? The question is whether or not the perspective of Van Til is, or of course, his contribution to OP identity is being kept alive or whether it is diminishing. I don’t know how to answer that question. I will say this. There is something strange about the OPC. That’s why I call the OPC a Presbyterian anomaly. There is something strange and peculiar about this church. And I think it’s as strange and peculiar as Nathan’s own pilgrimage.

I really don’t believe that Machen would choose the route of disenfranchisement. He’s forced to it. That’s merely to say that God is at work in history. He forces us to conclusions that we wouldn’t choose. I think the women at the end of the Gospel of Mark are going to be forced to conclusions that they don’t arrive at on their own. History itself is forcing us in directions we wouldn’t choose. In other words, it’s not our ideas that control history. It’s not because I make a decision that we end up going in this direction. It’s because I have such fine theology. And I’m so true to it. I’m such a stalwart for the reformed faith.

That’s not why history is moving the direction it is. That’s not why we’re here today. It’s because God has overcome our pretentiousness and our own self-importance, the estimations that we have of our own value, and he pulls us where we don’t want to go. He does that at the end of John’s Gospel too. The figure is Peter. He’s not going to want to be crucified or die in a death honoring to me, but that’s how it’s going to work out. So as I say about the OPC, we are a strange, peculiar people, and we are an anomaly. And we are being forced in directions that we don’t choose. We voted ourselves out of existence twice.

Consider that, gentlemen. Consider that. So, with regard to the influence of Dan Till, Dan Till is himself being sanctified by this history, as we all are, and it is the history of Christ that is at work in us, pulling us on to glory and our conformity to Him. We don’t worship nature, we don’t worship Dan Till. They would be the first to tell us that. So if there is an ongoing impact of Van Til, I judge in this peculiar church to this point in our history that it’s going to be in ways that maybe Van Til would not have chosen.

Nor would we ourselves. And maybe even in ways we don’t even recognize. Our isolation, for instance. Is it choice? Or is it providence? Well… Any other questions? You can see if you ask me a question, I get wound up, so you probably don’t want to ask any more. The front row down here is getting worried. Yes, key frame?

The New Testament of American politics. I find it very good that the American people, in the form of Christian and the whole faith, American culture, the way it was developed before, it was such a wonderful, wonderful and beautiful country. War and The question is to what degree do we see the OPC actually living out a countercultural position?

And I think we fight against that at every point. Again, it doesn’t seem to be our choice, naturally. We’re driven into corners. We’re forced to make decisions. And our identity is confirmed upon us. Our meaning becomes more our existence than our self-understanding. So yes, I think that the struggle with American culture and our identity in it continues to be an ongoing battle. But to this point, I’m confident of the Lord’s leading of this denomination. That’s it. So on behalf of the committee of historians, we are thankful that you attended.

The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.