Sermon Series: The Holy Spirit

  • Selling the Spirit Short

    Selling the Spirit Short

    This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The Holy Spirit” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, January 15, 1995.

    About this sermon

    Even the church’s creeds have tended to sell the Holy Spirit short, saying less about him than the Old Testament does. Psalm 51 shows the Spirit and the Trinity already present in the Old Testament. The New Testament adds fullness to a subject already there.

    More sermons from Psalms · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    Tonight we are looking at Psalm 51. Let us pay careful attention to the reading of God’s word. Be gracious to me, O God, according to thy lovingkindness. according to the greatness of thy compassion, blot out my transgressions. Wash me thoroughly from mine iniquity, and cleanse me from my sin.

    For I know my transgressions, and my sin is ever before me. Against thee, the only, I have sinned, and done what is evil in thy sight, so that thou art justified when thou dost speak, and blameless when thou dost judge. Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me. Behold, thou dost desire truth in the innermost being, and in the hidden part thou wilt make me know wisdom.

    Purify me with thyssop, and I shall be cleaned. Wash me, and I shall be whiter than snow. Make me to hear joy and gladness. Let the bones which thou hast broken rejoice. Hide thy face from my sins and blot out all my iniquities. Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a steadfast spirit within me. Do not cast me away from thy presence, and do not take thy Holy Spirit from me. Restore to me the joy of thy salvation, and sustain me with a willing spirit. Then I will teach transgressors thy ways, and sinners will be converted to thee. Deliver me from bloodguiltiness, O God, thou God of my salvation. Then my tongue will joyfully sing of thy righteousness. O Lord, open my lips, that my mouth may declare thy praise.

    For thou dost not delight in sacrifice, otherwise I would give it. Thou art not pleased with burnt offering. The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit, a broken and a contrived heart, O God, thou wilt not despise. By thy favor do good to Zion. Build the walls of Jerusalem. Then thou wilt delight in righteousness, in righteous sacrifices. in burnt offering and full burnt offering, then young bulls will be offered on by an altar.”

    We praise you, O God, for your word, for this word that comes from you gives to us life. O Father, in this life that we now have because of your word, we pray, Lord, that we would be attentive to those matters which you have put before us for our benefit. even the very means of grace. We pray, Lord, that we would avail ourselves of these means and be profited by them. But also, O God, in your word, we ask that we might be submissive to your ordinances and even to your offices which you have established for your church and for her benefit. So, Lord, discipline us. Yes, personally, but also corporately, that we might prove to be a willing people, obedient at every step.

    We ask this, O God, through Christ, in whom perfect obedience and submission is found. Amen. Tonight we are taking up the matter of the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament. The Holy Spirit in the Old Testament. When we take up this issue, there are essentially four matters that come before us for review. The Holy Spirit and the person of God. The Holy Spirit and the person of God.

    2. The Holy Spirit and the diversity of the Holy Spirit’s activities. The Holy Spirit and the diversity of His activities.

    3. The Holy Spirit and office. The Holy Spirit and office. And finally, the Holy Spirit and the history of revelation. Or, if you will, the Holy Spirit and the history of redemption. We begin with the Holy Spirit and the person of God. Now, it must be admitted at the outset that the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament is clothed somewhat in shadows, just as also is the eternal Son of God. However, When left with the Old Testament material, we can say that the Holy Spirit has a much more clearly delineated identity than the Eternal Son.

    For instance, the Son is presented in such a way that even the most devout saints, possessing that Old Testament consciousness, could not put together the puzzle of the divine-human relationship that was to be for God’s coming deliverer. Now, there are hints that the coming Son of God will be fully divine as well as fully human, but the uniform method of Messianic interpretation was, in fact, even by the most devout, to divide the person of the Messiah from the literal appearance of God in his coming.

    This accounts, then, for the surprise, the amazement, of the New Testament witnesses. But the Old Testament repeatedly speaks about the Spirit of God, and that explicitly. The Old Testament repeatedly speaks about the Spirit of God, or the Spirit of the Lord, and that explicitly. The Old Testament mind, therefore, had no difficulty seeing the Holy Spirit intruding into the created order. as God extending himself to his creation and into his world.

    The cloak concealing the Holy Spirit has to do with his Trinitarian identity. Therefore, not specifically as he being God himself, but then in the specific formation of Trinitarian identity, as one with God, but also as a distinct person having individuality. The full revelation of the one true God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, has not been granted as yet in the Old Testament. This is not to say Hints are absent even about this matter of the Trinity.

    For example, the distinct and individual personality of the Holy Spirit is hinted at in this psalm which we read this evening, Psalm 51, and specifically verse 11, when David pleads that God not remove the Holy Spirit, his Holy Spirit, from him. The text seems to indicate a distinction between God in relationship to David’s appeal and the Holy Spirit in relationship to David’s person.

    Thus, the individuality of the Holy Spirit, the distinct identity of the Holy Spirit, at the same time, of course, related dynamically to God himself. Overarching the text here is the conviction that the loss of the Holy Spirit’s presence is the loss of God’s presence. Therefore, you see, while there is the individuality of the Holy Spirit’s person there is also the identity of the Holy Spirit with the person of God.

    It is a complex way of expression. Still, we are in shadows, and when we come out of those shadows, it will be more clear to us as to what the fullness of the biblical revelation is. The great prophet Joel, moving on, The great prophet Joel, in his prophecy, you recall, at the end of Joel chapter 2, underscores the individual personage of the Holy Spirit. In this text, God promises to pour out his Spirit on all flesh, as God himself distinguishes the Spirit in a special service, a special ministry for his people. At the same time, in that Joel prophecy, that wonderful and familiar Joel prophecy, the impression given by the text is that those receiving the Spirit have, in fact, received God, and that, in a most unique fashion, in fact, in a conclusive fashion. Therefore, the Spirit, in these texts that we have considered thus far, is both individual, that is, able to proceed from God, to use our language from the Confession, able to proceed from God, yet he conveys the very presence of God Himself.

    Moving along this line a little further, we are even able to find Old Testament texts that hint at the Trinity in its fullness. while, of course, falling short of statements that are as expressive and as full as we might find in the New Testament, like at the end of Matthew’s Gospel, where Jesus gives command to his disciples that they are to baptize in the name of the Father and the Son and of the Holy Spirit. But in the Old Testament, you have such hints at the Trinity, a rather full expression or realization of the fullness of the deity.

    One such verse is Psalm 33, verse 6. Psalm 33, verse 6. Here we read, By the word of the Lord the heavens were made. By the word of the Lord the heavens were made. Now, keep in mind that the language of the Old Testament will, in fact, have this shadow quality to it. But yet, looking at what is stated here, we, from our vantage point in the New Testament, are able to perceive something here rather distinct. So, the statement in the psalm is, by the word of the Lord, the heavens were made.

    What persons of the Trinity might be in view in that statement? Think about it. By the word of the Lord, the heavens were made, and by the breath of His mouth, all their host. What person of the Trinity? might be imbued by the conclusion of that statement.

    It is suggested that here, in this psalm, at this particular point, we have, in fact, referenced however veiled to the three Persons of the Trinity. The Word, namely the Eternal Son, the Lord Himself, and by reference through the image of breath, the Spirit, the Spirit of God. The Lord himself, then, together with his word and his breath, his word and breath being figures in which we are able to see the Son and the Spirit. Another text that is suggested to us of the Trinity is the famous prophecy of Isaiah, chapter 61, verse 1.

    You may want to look at that passage. It’s certainly familiar, but it may be helpful to have it in front of you. It reads, the spirit of the Lord God is upon me because the Lord has anointed me to bring good news to the afflicted. He has sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to captives and freedom to prisoners. Isaiah 61 verse 1, in which the Messianic servant figure speaks about his endowment the endowment which he has received, namely the spirit of the Lord God, because the Lord himself has anointed him.”

    Again, it is suggested that in this text there is reference, however veiled, to the triune character of the true God. We, from a Christian standpoint, enable to see that even very clearly. It would seem then that in the Old Testament the Holy Spirit is distinct and distinctively God, bound mysteriously to God in His singular yet diverse activities. But the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament is now presented to us in the diversity of His activities, and that was the second point that we laid out for you as we began the message tonight.

    Right away, in the Bible, we come across the Spirit’s activity. Do you recall in what context, in what connection? Right away, in our Bibles, we come across the Spirit’s activity. Genesis 1, verse 2. Genesis 1, verse 2. And the earth was formless and void, and darkness was over the face of the deep, and the Spirit of God was moving over the surface of the water.”

    Now, I hope by now that you realize the inadequacy of the traditional ecumenical priests. even though we recite those creeds in this church, even though we recite the Apostles’ Creed and also the Nicene Creed on occasion. Both of these creeds boast of a very simple order, as they deal in chronological sequence with the persons of the Godhead. I think that you’ve probably already figured that out in your surveying of those creeds, and there is even a certain redemptive historical logic to these creeds that appeals to me as we progress from the creation to redemption to the sanctified life of the Church of Jesus Christ.

    But note the Trinitarian ordering of the creeds. Think of it once more. Creation, as it is introduced to you in those creeds, sets before you the Father, and the Father exclusively. Redemption sets before you the Son. The sanctified life of the Church sets before you the Holy Spirit, that’s the very simple and very convenient ordering of these creeds. Now, you realize that this is all a bit stylized.

    Now, that is not to say that the creeds don’t have their value and their use, otherwise we wouldn’t be reciting them. But there is a certain stylized character, compressed character, to the creeds as we have them. After all, the New Testament makes it plain, does it not, and that repeatedly, that the Son was as much present and operative in the creation as the Father. Yet, the Son’s role in creation in these creeds is not even as much as mentioned.

    Think of John chapter 1, for instance. Think of Colossians. Think of Hebrews. Think of texts that specifically speak about the presence and operative power and influence of the Son in creation, that as important as the Father. The same can be said for the Spirit. In fact, in Genesis, this is all the more explicit, since the Spirit is Himself expressly mentioned in Genesis 1 verse 2. Now, the Apostles’ Creed and the Nicene Creed have been the favorite ecumenical creeds for many in the Church.

    We are told, are we not, again and again, that all we need do in Christendom is to get together on the basis of the simple summaries that these creeds present. I object. As fine as these creeds are, they are not adequate. As fine as they are, In fact, I prefer the statement that appears in chapter four, paragraph one of the Westminster Confession of Faith, as it speaks about creation. And maybe if you look at that statement, you will prefer it also. It pleased God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit for the manifestation of the glory of His power, wisdom, and goodness in the beginning to create, or make of nothing, the world and all things therein, whether visible or invisible, in the space of six days, and all very good.” Now that’s a confession. There’s a statement for you.

    The Holy Spirit, yes, the Son as well as the Father. All three are very much present at creation. Now, the Holy Spirit’s presence at creation is specifically tied to the ordering and form brought to a formlessness and an emptiness that characterizes the creation at that point. This gets into the specific character of the Spirit’s operations and ministry, what it is that he is all about. He is bringing order and form. Is it not appropriate, then, that in the New Testament we find out that the Holy Spirit is the person of the Trinity who is bringing order and form to the new creation of God. And that’s specifically as the Church is taking shape.

    But there’s something else here that is very important, and this stated at the outset of biblical revelation. You see, the Holy Spirit is present here not simply for the sake of bringing order and form. He is here also for the sake of connecting his person to spatial considerations. Now, please, I know that this is a little bit deeper than you may be used to going, but I plead with you to hang with me at this point.

    It is not simply the fact that the Holy Spirit here is operative in bringing order and form to the formlessness that the creation is thus thought, but it is the fact that the Holy Spirit in His person is being specifically connected to spatial considerations—environment, atmosphere, whole world.

    It’s preparing you, you see, this revelation out of Genesis for what is coming eventually when the new environment of God will be described as spiritual, or of the Spirit, or in the Spirit. The atmospheric quality of the new world that is brought about by God through the Spirit. This is very important, for you see, our Savior has himself entered the realm of the Spirit. And it is the realm of the Spirit, yes, where the Holy Spirit is specifically in view, that we also shall enter.

    Now, all of this is suggestive of further activity for the Holy Spirit in Old Testament considerations. We find the Holy Spirit much in view in the discussions of building enterprises, you might recall. We find the Holy Spirit very much in view in Old Testament discussions of building enterprises, both for endowment for architectural projects in Israel’s life, but also in the moral project of building character. Desirel, a figure from Bible history we don’t often speak of, Bezalel, Exodus 31, if you don’t know who he is, Bezalel, the craftsman endowed by God in the Spirit for work upon the tabernacle, a building enterprise. He is described in Exodus 31, verse 3, as a man filled with the Spirit of God and wisdom and understanding and knowledge and in all kinds of craftsmanship. So, the Holy Spirit’s operation and activity in building enterprise.

    Again, if we turn to the New Testament, it is not strange that we find the Holy Spirit specifically spoken of in connection with the building of the temple of God. In fact, the Church is the temple of God in which the Spirit dwells, and in that temple we are all to live wisely.

    Wisely. Wisdom’s ministry to the son of the father from Proverbs. Remember that Proverbs is set up as the father endeavors to give instruction to the son. Well, wisdom is personified as you open up those beginning chapters of Proverbs. And wisdom’s ministry promises to build character through the outpouring of the Spirit. Chapter 1 in Proverbs, verse 23. The building of character. Not just the building of building, but the building of character. The building of godliness. We move on.

    Another activity of the Spirit is witnessed in the creation of life, the very creation of life, but also, and this necessarily, in the recreation of life, the Holy Spirit’s activity witnessed in the creation of human life and even in its recreation. We turn again to Genesis chapter 2 verse 7. You remember that text, God is forming Adam He forms him out of the dust of the ground, and then he breathes into this being whom he has created the breath of life.

    This is an activity not unaccompanied by the presence of the Holy Spirit, whether or not he is specifically or strictly identified with that breath or not. that the Spirit is somehow imbued, is not only proved by the relationship of the breath to the Spirit and any number of other Old Testament texts, but by the relationship of Genesis 2.7 to John chapter 20, verse 22. You remember that scene? After Christ has been raised from the dead, he visits with his disciples in the upper room, and it is there that the risen Christ breathes upon his disciples and says to them, receive the Holy Spirit.

    Jesus deliberately playing upon Genesis 2-7 as he now is himself standing at the beginning of the new creation and the formation of a new humanity. Recreation, I might add, is also the activity, yes, it’s clear to us, is it not, from that John text, But it is even suggested to us by the activity of the Holy Spirit. Regeneration is there, an activity of the Holy Spirit set before us in the pages of the Old Testament.

    No more striking example of this is given than that found in Ezekiel 37. I think that you all know the story of the Valley of Dry Bones. You might even be able to sing a song about the Valley of Dry Bones. Here the prophet commands the womb, as you might recall, which comes as the spirit to give life to that which was dead. Recreation or regeneration is in view in Ezekiel 37. That which was dead lives. The bones are brought together by the word of the prophet, and then by the word of the prophet together with The breath of God, or His Spirit, life, new life, is given to that which was dead.

    Another activity of the Holy Spirit, moving on, witnessing now the diversity of the activities of the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament. Another activity of the Spirit is the occasional bestowal of power for specific ministry. You remember the book of Judgment. how individuals presented to us there are temporarily equipped for service. One of the most striking examples out of that book of Judges is Samson, one upon whom the Spirit comes. And in the power of the Spirit, he does these mighty deeds. But the Spirit isn’t always with him, as you know the story. Of course, there is also, even in contrast to the temporary equipment, the permanent endowment from the Spirit for those who render continued service in standing office in the Old Testament.

    Specifically in view here are the prophets. seeks the double portion of that spirit that rested upon Elijah. But also, in this regard, the permanency of the spirit’s ministry to certain individuals is prophetic in itself, for it anticipates a permanence that would be given to all of God’s people. I will repeat it tonight. Oh, that all of God’s people were prophets.

    That which the Spirit, that which the prophet receives for his office, the endowment of the Spirit, becomes something in which we can see a permanent endowment to all who are the followers of the prophet. all who have received the word of the prophet and live by that word.

    We wish, do we not, permanent endowment of the Spirit. In fact, are we not told that because of the ministry of Jesus Christ, We all have received the baptism of the Holy Spirit and have been sealed with the Holy Spirit. And that the Holy Spirit is permanently ours if we walk by faith. This then sets before us the Holy Spirit’s activity, which is inclusive of a permanent ministry in the hearts of the faithful.

    David’s prayer, once more, Psalm 51, verse 11, makes this evident. It is not only as king or prophet that David prays his prayer, but as a believer, just as you are a believer. The spirit in the Old Testament is the presence of God to the believer for the purpose of continuing sanctification, for the purpose of further development in godliness.

    Now we can’t go beyond these matters this evening, which we have set before you, there are two other matters that are outstanding yet. We will not be dealing then extensively with the issue of old, with the Old Testament understanding of the Holy Spirit in relationship to office, to the offices that arise in the life of Israel. But suffice it to say this evening, There is reflection of what we have said about the activities of the Spirit in his office, in the activities of those who have received office among the people. I will just make that observation at this point. I will repeat it.

    There is the reflection of what we have said about the activities of the Holy Spirit in his office, in the activities of those who have office amongst the people of God. Those who have office are particularly energized or particularly called to pursue the pattern of activity that is observed in the spirit himself. By the spirit Office-bearers in the Church extend the Spirit into the life of the people of God. They bring to bear the Spirit Himself in the life of the people of God.

    You must remember that yourselves. If you are an office-bearer, you must remember that. If you are not an office bearer, you must remember that, because you will be the objects of ministry by those office bearers, and that for your good. Listen to them. Listen to them. This is very serious business. We are dealing here with holy things. and our souls depend upon them.

    As far as the Holy Spirit, finally, and the history of revelation is concerned, let me say that we are witness, we ourselves are witness to something of the fuller vision of the Spirit’s ministry as the Old Testament revelation progresses. Until that vision, unique to the Old Testament, peaks in the prophecies of Ezekiel and Zechariah, the two prophets in which the ministry of the Holy Spirit is most distinctively set out before us. But while there is this progression and this intensification of the Spirit’s manifestation as we move through the Old Testament and we move towards Ezekiel and Zechariah, at the same time we are compelled to witness the inadequacy and even the emptiness of the Old Testament revelation.

    You must keep that in hand. For the Old Testament’s ministry will not peak in Ezekiel or in Zechariah, it will peak in John the Baptist, the one who says, I can only baptize you with water. That’s the best that the Old Testament can do, redemptively, historically. I can only baptize you with water, but there’s one coming after me who will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire.” John the Baptist awaits that one. He baptizes, then, in the Holy Spirit and with fire. that one who, when he comes and provides such a baptism and such a fullness of the Holy Spirit, makes all that which preceded him to appear as if it were nothing. So glorious is it by comparison.

    We, you say, have received of the Spirit’s fullness and of the conclusiveness and the finality of the Spirit’s ministry. The Holy Spirit, in this ministry to us, in the fullness of it, now blesses us with that spiritual ability to enter into the realm of the Spirit, even though we continue in this world of flesh. Thus we learn, redemptively historically, that the Old Testament, all that we have seen there, Everything that it is set before us with regard to the Holy Spirit is nearly preparatory unto this present time when we have begun to live in the fullness of the Spirit, the world of the Spirit, and the age of the Spirit.

    Our Father, we would not slight the Spirit even though we have been charged with doing just that, slighting the Spirit. There are those in the Church presently who are making claim that the Holy Spirit is their unique possession. and that there are certain signs that accompany the reception of the Holy Spirit personally and individually. And these people would then suggest that we lacking the Spirit must ourselves gain the Spirit through such certification. But we object, Lord. We would give you your due as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, by glorying in what you have accomplished. And that baptism of the Holy Spirit promised in Jesus Christ has come. The fullness of it is that into which

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

  • Pentecost and Its Twentieth-Century Counterfeit

    Pentecost and Its Twentieth-Century Counterfeit

    This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The Holy Spirit” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, January 8, 1995.

    About this sermon

    Modern Pentecostalism’s explosive twentieth-century growth, accelerated by the same restless mentality that shaped the 1960s, claims Acts 2 as its own origin story. The OPC’s own defense of what Pentecost actually was pushes back directly against that claim. Getting Pentecost’s true nature right matters for how the whole rest of the series reads the Holy Spirit.

    More sermons from Acts · Browse all sermons

    Sermon transcript

    We read tonight from Acts 2, beginning with verse 1. Let’s give our full attention to God’s infallible word. Acts 2, verse 1. And when the day of Pentecost had come, they were all together in one place. And suddenly there came from heaven a noise like a violent rushing wind, and it filled the whole house where they were sitting. And there appeared to them tongues as of fire distributing themselves, and they rested on each one of them. And they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak with other tongues as the Spirit was giving them utterance. Now there were Jews living in Jerusalem, devout men. from every nation under heaven. And when the sound occurred, the multitude came together and were bewildered because they were each one hearing them speak in his own language.

    And they were amazed and marveled, saying, Why are not all these who are speaking Galileans? And how is it that we each hear them in our own language to which we were born? Parthians and Medes and Elamites, residents of Mesopotamia, Judea and Cappadocia, Pothos in Asia, Phrygia and Pamphylia, Egypt and the districts of Libya around Cyrene, and visitors from Rome, both Jews and Thessalonians, Cretans and Arabs. We hear them in our own tongues speaking the mighty deeds of God.” And they continued in amazement and great perplexity, saying to one another, What does this mean? But others were mocking and saying, they are full of sweet wine.

    But Peter, taking his stand with the eleven, raised his voice and declared to them, Men of Judea and all you who live in Jerusalem, let this be known to you and give heed to my words. For these men are not drunk, as you suppose, for it is only the third hour of the day. But it is what was spoken through the prophet Joel.

    And it shall be in the last days, God says, that I will pour forth my spirit upon all mankind. And your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams. Even upon my bondslaves, both men and women, I will in those days pour forth my spirit, and they shall prophesy. And I will grant wonders in the sky above and signs on the earth beneath, blood and fire and vaporous smoke. The sun shall be turned into darkness and the moon into blood before the great and glorious day of the Lord shall come.

    And it shall be that everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved. Let’s pray together. Dear Lord, we cannot estimate the value of your word to us. And Father, it is true that we become dull at times. And we ask, Lord, that you will help us we will shake ourselves free of this dullness of spirit, and that your spirit, in all of his strength and might, would be evident in us and to us. So then, O God, may we hear your word and receive it, and may it profit us, Lord, immensely. We ask this for the sake of Christ. the One who gives the Spirit to us. Amen. Now, I want you to know that I was inspired to preach this message to you tonight. As proof, I offer that in my excitement while writing this message out, I broke my pencil at least 43 times.

    It has been said that the 20th century is unique in church history. Our century, so it is claimed, has brought to the fore the person and the work of the Holy Spirit as never before in the history of the Church. The fourth and fifth centuries may have had their debates about the Trinity, about the relationship of the persons of the Trinity to one another. particularly the relationship of the natures of Christ in his one person, the 16th century can lay claim to a Christian revolution over the question of the nature of saving faith and the question of how sinners are made right before God. But the 20th century, so we are told, and yes, to a degree this is accurate, has witnessed an explosion.

    According to some, this is an explosion brought about by the rediscovery of the individuality of the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit’s direct workings in the lives of believers. Not since Pentecost, not since the days of the early Church, has the Holy Spirit received His due.

    The specific beginnings of this explosion, if you will, if you can have the beginning of an explosion, occurred at least, say, some, when in early January 1901, under the tutelage of Charles F. Parham, students of his at his Topeka, Kansas Bible College, along with Parham himself, the gift of the Spirit, at least in their estimation, that is what they perceived, they were enabled by their claim to speak in tongues. Agnes Osmond was reportedly the first to receive this dissertation on January 1, 1901. The beginnings of this distinctive century in Christian history. But the little tongue of fire in Topeka in 1901 became a wildfire by 1906, and that specifically at Azusa Street in Los Angeles, California.

    This was the great groundswell of interest in and for the so-called Pentecostal movement. By the mid-1960s, the explosion of religious zeal could claim, according to some estimates, more than 10 million adherents worldwide. What could the Orthodox Presbyterian Church say before such a throng? over 10 million adherents. And by the 60s, this movement came to claim the support of many Protestant mainliners. No, not just those humble, fundamentalist type, holiness type, that had attached themselves to Parham that had been present at Azusa Street in Los Angeles, by the 1960s, many prominent figures in mainline Protestantism had lent their support to the movement.

    In the 50s and early 60s, the movement had gained greater credibility then, and its support was coming from a diverse group of people. including John McCaw, president of Princeton Theological Seminary, including Henry Van Dusen, president of Union Theological Seminary in New York City, but also notably the Episcopalian Samuel Shoemaker, famous for his contributions right here in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, as well as Anglican’s Leslie Newbigin, and of all people, Philip Edgecombe Hughes, who later came to teach at Westminster Theological Seminary. Van Dusen is of particular interest. Remember, he is the president of Union Theological Seminary in New York City. He said in an article for Life magazine, the Pentecostal movement is a revolution. It is a revolution comparable in importance with the original apostolic church and with the Protestant Reformation.

    Now, not that these mainline leaders of Protestantism had experienced the Pentecostal visitation themselves, not that they had spoken in tongues or received other charismatic endowments. At the same time, their openness toward and their acceptance and promotion of the new Holy Spirit hysteria worked its own miracles in the respectable corridors of Christendom. 1967 brought what some would judge an official involvement of the Roman Catholic Church here in the United States, and that through the organization of the Holy Spirit conferences, beginning in no other place but at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh. fueled by a great desire on the part of the laity within the Roman Church for direct involvement in their faith, and a wave of interest in folk religion on the part of the religious, that is, those who had received orders in the Church, nuns, priests, monks, the charismatic movement swept through the Roman Church in some places like a mighty rushing As Vatican II ended, many in Mother Church were exchanging one unknown tongue, Latin, for another, Rossellalia. Out of this, a whole new vision for ecumenicity was emerging. A favorite even among evangelicals had already announced in 1957 the addition of another chair at the ecumenical table. He said that there are three principal streams of life in the Christian Church. First, the Catholic, then the Protestant, and now the Pentecostal.

    20th century has indeed witnessed a remarkable phenomenon. A movement claiming biblistically New Testament roots—here’s the republication of the exact phenomenon that you see occurring on the pages of the Book of Acts and at other places in the New Testament—a movement then claiming New Testament roots, beginning among poorer class Protestants of a fundamentalist and holiness stripe, but by mid-century gaining the applause of Roman Catholicism and of the Protestant establishment elite, particularly the applause of even those of a neo-Orthodox Barthian stripe, as in the case of Newbigin and Mackay, but also the applause of an out-and-out liberal, such as Henry Van Dusen. But this is only a third of the story. We have a ways to go.

    For the Pentecostal movement has received both direct and indirect support through other developments in the religious scene during this century. Now, by way of introduction to this second third, I turn once more to the 60s. At the end of that decade, the youth fetish had grabbed hold of the throat of the evangelical church. By the end of the sixties, the youth fetish, the worship of youth, had grabbed hold of the throat of the evangelical church.

    A subculture already in deep distrust of the establishment, including the establishment church, clued into its own music, its own meaning, its own world, discovered Jesus. I’ll repeat that, lest at the beginning of that sentence you didn’t know where I was going. A subculture already into deep distrust of the establishment, including the organized clued into its own music, its own meaning, its own world, discovered Jesus. Now, what was born, generated out of that, was a complex sociological phenomenon, generally impatient with structure and theological precision, but heavily into feelings, so-called Christian music and relevance.

    Above all, relevance. Because you see, the only sin worth worrying about is the sin of being boring. You wouldn’t want to be boring. And you wouldn’t want to live a boring life. What we need is youthful excitement. I said this is a complex sociological phenomenon. And I say that because of four things. First, the Jesus movement. You knew what I was talking about, didn’t you?

    The Jesus movement proved, in the end, to be thoroughly establishmentarian itself, and that in a very clever way. That is, it proved to be just as interested in popularity, power, and control as the establishment to which it objected. And in this regard, the Jesus movement proved itself to be fairly commercial in the end. This movement is now mainstream. Have you not noticed? It is now mainstream and quite profitable, having successfully replaced the Word of God with its music and God’s ordained ministers and office-bearers with entertainers, or ministers and office-bearers who are entertainers.

    It has displaced solid biblical theology and orthodoxy. together with decent, solid Christian nurture, with religious mush, noxious sentimentality, adolescent banality, and hormonal theology. Now, maybe you don’t know what hormonal theology is. Think about it. Have you noticed the covers on Christian music CDs? And I ask you, for many of those covers to those CDs, is it not obvious to you that the intent is to sell Christ with Seth? That’s what I mean by hormonal theology. Well, here’s good news for everybody. Christianity is not only fun, it’s sexy. Now, the next reason that this phenomenon is so complex is because Protestantism already had in place its own subculture, ready to set up to the new Jesus counterculture.

    Here was my experience. with Campus Crusade, I remember 1965. The only people they had in their magazines were young men with crew cuts, young ladies smartly dressed, campus leaders to be sure. By 1969, Campus Crusades periodicals were filled with pictures of people with long hair, males, and females without any shoes. How easy it was. How easy it was.

    Constantism already had in place a subculture ready to side up to the new Jesus counterculture. I have specifically in mind the evangelical paraplegiastical network. Outside of the church, making a lot of points, scoring a lot of points at the expense of the church. Hey, hey fella, your parents don’t understand you, but we do. Yes, sir, they don’t understand you, but we are your friends.” Here was a paraplesiastical network, a subculture already in existence, that had perfected had perfected its ability to rob the Church of the support that the Church owed to its own proper ministries.

    This network had already subordinated doctrine to pragmatics. It had already subordinated its doctrine to access to the masses. It had already bought a theological position that saw in humanity a common emotional link. Those of you who went through it, I ask you to go back and review. The appeal was always to the emotions. This network had already bought a theological position that saw in humanity a common emotional link to which it could appeal, in terms of which it could bring pressure upon an audience.

    The evangelical para-ecclesiastical network never did have any problems with the Pentecostal movement. And why would it? The final reason why this phenomenon is such a complex sociological reality is the reaction of the church generally to it. What churches, as churches, have had the courage to stand up against it. I’m not talking here about individual congregations. I’m talking about denominations.

    Terrified. Terrified by the threat of their own irrelevance. Frightened to death that they would lose their chance. feeling guilty that they had failed to show their emotions adequately, or adequately develop a social conscience, especially where the youth were concerned.

    The Church virtually has handed over title to building land, copyrights, standards, and bank accounts, and transformed the Church of Christ into a perpetual summer camp. This lunacy has now worked to grant support to the Pentecostal takeover of our time. And that from those that we would never have expected it.

    The appeal is to informality, spontaneity, subjectivism. Get in touch with your feelings. Don’t be afraid of expressing your feelings. Break through those old inhibitions. Dance a little bit in the aisle. Wave your hands. Warm the spirit. Laugh! By the Holy Spirit.

    Informality, spontaneity, subjectivism run rampant now, as assault is brought to bear upon even those citadels of strength within orthodoxy. Now, as it is, we have only covered two-thirds of the picture this evening. And we don’t have time to go into adequately the third piece of the puzzle. But I will mention it to you and say a word about it. And I want to do that because, you see, it is the one that is most ordinarily overlooked.

    In addition to Pentecostalism proper and its roots, in addition to the youth cult and the para-ecclesiastical subculture of evangelicalism, is the power of a residual Victorian Romantic religion.

    Victorian Romantic You see, we ordinarily think of the latter days of the 19th century, the beginning of the 20th century, as exhibiting some marks of strength within orthodoxy, as if there were a virulent orthodoxy still at work in some meaningful way, even within the mainline churches, committed to the objective truth of the biblical gospel. and this gospel, the biblical gospel, as the sure and certain ground for Christian confidence, specifically a faith that has the ability to take you out of yourself, even out of your time, and place you in another, and specifically place you in relationship to events that happened 1900 years ago, with a conviction that it was the events that took place then in Christ’s life, in his death, in his resurrection and ascension, the event that takes place at Pentecost in the gift of the Spirit, and that definitively, that these events are determinative for Christian life and that they always have the priority, and that my experience by itself means nothing. Means nothing. But what we find instead claiming the churches and the pulpits in this Victorian Romantic religion is not some sort of commitment to a biblical orthodoxy that has at its center the exposition of biblical text and doctrine, to the end that the hearer will be brought into a whole new world and in that new world have their emotions and their intellect subordinated to the glory, the absolute glory and sovereignty of God.

    Instead, the purpose of Victorian Romantic religion was to exalt your own personal experience, and to produce in you through an appeal to your emotions and your sensitivities, a spiritual swoon. The greatest goal of the Victorian preacher was to have you weeping in the pew before you wept.

    And not necessarily because of your sins, but because he had told you a sweet story that broke your heart. I used to listen to Bruce Teelman. Bruce Teelman Pastor of First Presbyterian Church, now departed, was one of the great masters of Victorian Romantic religion. And I can tell you, if I had to listen one more time to the story about his friend dying from leukemia, you conjure up stories for the purpose of breaking your hearer’s hearts. You break their hearts because you know if you can make them cry, they’ll love you.

    I used to preach like that. I learned to preach like that. That’s how I was taught to preach, even when I was in high school. I shouldn’t have been preaching when I was in high school, but I did. I was a product of that parenthesiastical network amongst evangelicals. That’s how I used to preach at Geneva College. Westminster Seminary ruined me. I don’t think I can construct a sermon like that anymore.

    The purpose of Victorian Romantic religion is to exalt you and your story and to appeal to you through the means of other stories, the telling of religious tales, the sharing of evangelical folklore. You can’t even verify whether the stories are true. It doesn’t matter. They make you cry, don’t they? They have their impact, they have their effect. What difference does it make whether they’re true? For that matter, what difference does it make whether the gospel stories are true? If I can relate them to you in some way so as to break your heart, that’s all that matters.

    So it is, you see, that preaching is reduced to pulpiteering. That proclamation is reduced to theatrics. That’s the heritage with which we enter. We Protestants in America enter the 20th century. And not even J. Gresson Machen was immune. All of these strains then, in this very complex constellation of things, contribute to Pentecostalism’s triumph, as if it were a great conspiracy. each aspect reinforcing the other. So.

    Subtle is it in its complexity that it makes its assault upon those institutions and churches that have formally stood unwavering for the truth of biblical orthodoxy. The OTC has fought during her history against all of this. It hasn’t done it at all times intelligently. It hasn’t done it, at all times, well. But the bottom line is that the OPC is one of the few churches that has done it at all. And it has pursued this course, ironically enough, and I do not hesitate to add this, in the true interest of the original Pentecost.

    My concern in the weeks ahead is to deal then with the Holy Spirit, his person, and his ministry. Yes, as we reflect upon scripture and its proclamation, but also as we reflect upon our church’s stand in this centering and are reminded of our need to resist all of the temptations that come at us from whatever source. Our Father in Heaven, help us, O God, to give you that which is your rightful due. May we ascribe glory to you and all of your perfections, your righteousness, your holiness, your power. and your beauty. May we stand, O God, in amazement of you. And, Lord, guard our hearts and minds, even as you guard our church, lest we profane you. And that, by wrongly reading your word, and even wrongly reading our experiences. This we pray, that you may be glorified, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Amen.

    The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.