This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The Holy Spirit” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, March 10, 1996.
About this sermon
Christ breathes on the disciples in John 20:22, echoing God’s breath of life into Adam in Genesis 2:7, and the moment stands close to the Spirit’s coming in Acts 2. That breath, in 20:22-23, is more than a symbolic gesture. Church, Christ, and Spirit belong together, and no one can pull them apart.
Sermon transcript
Tonight we are reading from John’s Gospel, Chapter 20. And we are reading at verse 19 to the end of the chapter. John chapter 20 verse 19, this is God’s fully inspired and inerrant word. And therefore it was evening on that day, the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in their midst and said to them, peace be with you.
And when he had said this, he showed them both his hands and his side. The disciples, therefore, rejoiced when they saw the Lord. Jesus, therefore, said to them again, Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, I also send you. And when he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them. If you retain the sins of any, they have been retained. Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came.
The other disciples, therefore, were saying to him, we have seen the Lord. But he said to them, unless I shall see in his hands the imprint of the nails and put my finger into the place of the nails and put my hand into his side, I will not believe. And after eight days, again, his disciples were inside and Thomas with them. Jesus came, the doors having been shut and stood in their midst and said, Peace be with you. Then he said to Thomas, Reach here your finger and see my hands. Reach here your hand and put it into my side and be not unbelieving, but believing. Thomas answered and said to him, my Lord and my God. Jesus said to him, Because you have seen me, have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see and yet believed. Many other signs, therefore, Jesus also performed in the presence of the disciples, which are not written in this book. These have been written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name.
Then, turning back to Genesis chapter two, verse seven, then the Lord God formed man of dust from the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became a living soul. May your word minister to us, O God, in its healing power that we and all of our ills may be cured. So, Lord, your word is set for life. and that we, in Jesus Christ, might have the abundant life, even that life that belongs to the realms of eternity. Father, in that realm there is no measure to the provision that is granted us. Even as you give yourself to your people in your fullness, so also, O God, all the benefits of the blessings in the kingdom are granted to us. Fathers, strengthen us even as we walk in this world by the provision which you have supplied us out of your heavenly habitation. That habitation, Lord, of which we have been made citizens and to which we shall come eventually. even through the resurrection of our bodies. We pray this in Jesus’ name. Amen.
There are four distinct presentations of the person and work of the Holy Spirit in John’s Gospel. We have moved at this point through the first three, the first three presentations of the person and work of the Holy Spirit. First of all, there was John the Baptist’s witness. where we heard, through John’s witness, about the Holy Spirit’s coming and abiding upon the Christ. Chapter 1, verses 32 and 33. And also, later on, about the Christ giving the Holy Spirit to the Church without measure. So, the testimony of the Baptist, in Chapter 3, This testimony and witness by John the Baptist is wonderful.
It is marvelous. For now there stands before the people of God that one upon whom the Spirit abides perpetually. That means that the Spirit will not come and go. Rather, the Spirit remains. But furthermore, according to this witness from John the Baptist, the Spirit has now been given to Christ without measure. Even the double portion of the Spirit that came upon Elisha was measured. It was the double portion. But here is the portion without measure.
Of interest to us in this regard is the fact that we shall share in the blessings that come to the cross. We, too, then, in and through Christ, have the perpetual abiding presence of the Holy Spirit with us. That means that we have the perpetual abiding presence of God himself with us. And furthermore, we have received in and through Christ the Spirit without measure.
There is then no partial deposit. There is no partial deposit of the Spirit to those who truly believe. We do not move then from an incomplete reception of the Spirit to a fuller reception still. That is foreign to the testimony of John the Baptist concerning Christ, and that is foreign to the New Testament’s declaration with respect to the church as a whole.
Secondly, we have the presentation of the Holy Spirit in Jesus’ public proclamation, which we found particularly in chapters four through seven in this gospel. This public proclamation by Jesus of the Holy Spirit anticipates the coming of the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit comes to bless the church with new life. That’s what’s in view in chapter three, as we look at the promise there, the mention made of the spirit and life in context with the discussion between Jesus and Nicodemus. But also, we have here the anticipation of the coming of the Holy Spirit for the sake of the Church in the new day of worship. God is spirit, and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.
Thus Jesus says to the Samaritan woman in chapter 4, verses 23 and 24. There is a whole new environment, so the Declaration goes. a whole new environment established for the people of God, in which only the spirit profits because the flesh profits nothing. Thus, we have Jesus’ statement in John 6, verse 63. And even religious punctiliousness and performance and precision are a hindrance to humanity’s genuine thirst, which is only answered by faith in Christ and in the rushing torrents of the Holy Spirit flowing from the believer’s innermost being. So Jesus testifies on the great day of the Feast of Tabernacles in John 7, verses 38 and 39.
Jesus’ proclamation of the Spirit in this section in John’s Gospel is both declaratory and evangelistic. Declaratory of the certainty of the Spirit and of the world the spirit invites. Evangelistic in setting out the superlative characteristics and qualities of that world and the incomparable beatitude of the spirit and his heavenly domain.
We are driven by this proclamation even as we are compelled and entreated. Listen to what Christ says then. in this portion of John’s Gospel concerning the Holy Spirit. Look at these texts one more time for your own benefit, that you might profit from them immensely. Thirdly, we have the promise of the Holy Spirit to the disciples specifically.
This is set before us in chapters fourteen through sixteen of John’s Gospel, and here This promise makes explicit the spirit, the attitude for the church, as the spirit communicates heavenly eternal comfort from the regions of truth, such as the world cannot receive or even. John fourteen verses sixteen and seventy. This spirit teaches the church, the church, so Jesus promises as he brings to the church remembrance remembrance of all that he has said, and that through the apostolic witness.
Chapter fourteen, verse twenty six. The spirit has no greater task than to bear witness to Christ himself. His witness being that into which the church then enters. Chapter fifteen, verse twenty six. Since the spirit is the one who can get the world concerning sin, righteousness and judgment. Chapter sixteen. verses seven through eleven, and confirms the church in the truth about the future.
So wonderfully full and exhilarating and comforting is Jesus’ promise of the spirit in chapters fourteen through sixteen in John, that the actual appearance of the spirit is meant to be in John’s gospel a truly conclusive, comprehensive, and culminating event, fulfilling the promise and even exceeding in reality the description that has been given in the past.
Thus we come to John twenty verse twenty two and our message. Jesus gives the Holy Spirit. Now right away. We must say a word about the relationship between John twenty verse twenty two and Acts chapter two. John twenty verse twenty two has Jesus breathing on the disciples and saying receive the Holy Spirit.
Chapter two which you know records the coming of the Holy Spirit upon the Christians gathered in the upper room on the day of Pentecost after Jesus had ascended into heaven. With these two records with these two accounts are there actually two bestowals of the Holy Spirit are there. two comings of the Holy Spirit, one in John, the other in Acts. Are John and Luke disagreeing? Are they at odds? Do they represent different traditions? Do they come from different communities? Not at all.
What we find in John 20, 22, is in fact symbolic action by Jesus. an action intended to establish the meaning of the gift of the Spirit. It also intended to reinforce certain truths about the relationship that Jesus himself bears to the Holy Spirit. For example, John records this story of a time before Christ’s ascension in order to capitalize on Christ’s presence and significance his presence and significance for the Holy Spirit’s appearance, which is coming. What makes this all the more remarkable is the fact that Jesus himself, in this very gospel, has told his disciples before his crucifixion that he must go away in order that the Holy Spirit must come.
Check once more, chapter sixteen, verse seven. Now Jesus has not finally receded into heaven by way of the ascension, but nevertheless, the Holy Spirit, as it were, arrives. What is the point? What is the point that John is making by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit here? Obviously, John wishes to make much of this very point. Otherwise, he would not have such a stark contradiction, apparently, in his gospel, namely, the Holy Spirit is given, but Jesus is still here. Jesus had said earlier, I have to go away, that the Holy Spirit may come, but here in John 20, Jesus is still here, and the Spirit is represented as coming, appearing.
The point, then, is underscored. It is emphasized in a literary and doctrinal manner. And that, through the force of the apparent contradiction, is set there in order to catch our attention, to stop us in our tracks, that we might consider, that we might think, that we might understand. In other words, attention is drawn to John 20, verse 22, because of the incongruity in the tension that it creates within the gospel itself.
It forces us to reflect. John means here by his method to underscore what Jesus directly does in giving the Holy Spirit to his church. The Holy Spirit proceeds from the living Christ. The Holy Spirit proceeds from the living Christ. He is particularly and truly time is the spirit is particularly and truly tied to the living Christ. But what’s all the fuss? Don’t we all know that? Well, if you look at the next verse, verse 23, you begin to understand what all the fuss is about.
For here, Jesus says, If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them. If you retain the sins of any, they have been retained. These words then deliberately draw into view the church and her ministry through the proclamation of and the instruction in the gospel, and that also reinforced by the proper exercise of discipline within the church.
This means that in these two verses we have then the risen living Christ, the Holy Spirit, and the Church and her ministry brought into closest connection. So close is the connection that the three cannot be separated. That’s the point. The three cannot be separated. That is the intention of the evangelist John, as he, by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, writes down these words.
The living, risen Christ, the Holy Spirit, and the Church and her ministry cannot be separated. That is to say, the living Christ is not to be separated from the Spirit, and neither Christ nor the Spirit are to be separated from the Church. its preaching of the gospel, its instruction in the same, and its exercise of proper church discipline, the forgiving of sins and the retaining of sins.
Now, in truth, the book of the Acts has no different message than this. However, with the run of the historical narrative in the book of the Acts, with the record of the eruptions of the Holy Spirit’s presence spotted throughout that narrative, with the freshness and what might appear to be the spontaneity of the Spirit’s visitation, you might be tempted to think of the Holy Spirit as capricious, detached, and His actions as unstructured and individualistic. You may be tempted to think that. Of course, such a reading of the Book of Acts would be a misreading. Still, with precisely this misreading, in hand and dominating the mind, so many have rushed off in the direction of personal possession of the Spirit, and that in such a way that they claim Christ and the Holy Spirit in utter disregard of the Church.
They couldn’t care less. According to them, theirs is an acts situation. Theirs is a Pentecostal environment. They are the vanguard. They are on the frontier of spiritual advance and relevance. Therefore, they say, don’t you dare hold me back with details about church life and practice, about church protocol and such matters as structure and discipline, don’t suggest that I am somehow bound to the organizational manifestation and the institution of the Church. Such things are a drag upon my own personal progress and upon the personal importance of my own ministry. I’ve got the spirit, I’m convinced of it, I feel it, and that is all I need, and as far as I’m concerned, that settles the matter.
Hogwash. Utter, unadulterated hogwash. If you haven’t run into these exact words, you have at least run into the attitude. God’s revelation through John 20, verses 22 and 23, stands diametrically opposed to such words and such attitudes. In proper proportion and in the measure the Lord intends, You do not have the living risen Christ or the Holy Spirit apart from the church. With its gospel of forgiveness, its message about the seriousness of sin, and even its retention. through the administration of the authority which God has established. I will put it plainly.
In other words, reject the true Church of Christ and you lose Christ and the Holy Spirit. Specifically, reject the true Church of Christ that is the church defined for us in the Word of God, and you lose Christ and the Holy Spirit. Let me say something to you young people. You may not understand your parents strong attachment to the church.
But in its very best light, this is what that attachment is all about. For your parents have learned, they have come to believe that they can’t have Christ and the Spirit without having the church. That’s why they come week after week. That’s why they insist that you come with them. Because they know this to be the truth.
I might also say something about the process of discipline in this regard. I have dealt with many discipline cases in my time as a pastor. Those that have turned out well and beneficial. have been those in which the individual in view has not been able to give up the church. They stood and they took it because they could not imagine themselves cut off from the assembly. There have been others. To put it very frankly, Charlotte, they just didn’t give a damn. One other thing impresses itself upon us from these verses.
Not only do we not have Christ and the Holy Spirit apart from the Church, we do not have the Church apart from Christ and the gift of the Holy Spirit. Therefore, we dare not distance the Church in its formal structure from Christ and the Holy Spirit. But just who are Christ and the Holy Spirit? They are none other than the Christ and the Holy Spirit revealed in the Word. This means that the abandonment of the biblical Christ and the biblical revelation of the Holy Spirit signals forfeiture of the title through church.
Although the form of the church with its institutional nature is essential, The gospel of Jesus is no friend of formalism and the preservation of the institution of the Church for its own sake, as if it stood in its own right. There is one final thing that also arises from these verses. As I intimated at the beginning of our message, they are intended to carry a sense of comprehensiveness In other words, these statements by Jesus set before us the apex and the content in something of an exhaustive manner for the work of the living Christ in relationship to the gift of the Spirit. That apex and content had everything to do with the Church’s proclamation of the gospel and her exercise of Church discipline, and the crowning issue of the forgiveness and the retaining of sins. They have nothing to do with the visitation of the physically stupendous and miraculous.
The ongoing ministry of the Church is here described, left behind as foundational, are the temporary signs and wonders of Jesus’ miracles and the miracles of the apostles. Jesus’ words in John 20, 22, and 23 are indicative of the ongoing eternal order of his Church, and for that reason they are reminiscent of the Lord God’s action in Genesis 2, verse 7. The old creation began with God breathing into the lifeless body of Adam the breath of life. The new creation begins with Christ breathing the breath of life into his disciples. representative of the Church.
My prayer is that you belong to the new creation, the ongoing eternal order of the Church, the true Church set for the proclamation of the gospel, the forgiveness of sins, the retention of the same when it is required, the true Church ingraved by Christ, which has not just the Holy Spirit’s presence, but in the Holy Spirit’s presence, the presence of the living Christ. Our God in heaven, we ask that we might, in looking at texts like this, alert to what you have to say concerning your son, your spirit, and your church. Father, we ask that we would not then ignore the import of your church and thus lose from sight the significance of the living Christ and the Holy Spirit. We pray, our Father, that we might abide in the assembly which you have established, even as we submit ourselves to the rule which you have established in and for that church. We pray, our God, that it would please you also to bless the church in her ministry, even as the word is proclaimed faithfully throughout the world. You grant us each that strength that is requisite to our standing in place within the assembly, that we might prove to be fully participant in those activities that are proper and appropriate for us. We ask, Lord, that we might then be ever mindful of how we, as the Church, have been blessed with your very presence, with the presence of your Son, even through the presence of the Holy Spirit.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

