This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The Holy Spirit” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, December 17, 1995.
About this sermon
John 7:24 calls for righteous judgment, drawn from Old Testament law and aimed at the Spirit more than at outward appearance. Contentment with earthly custom is exactly the posture this text rules out. Real judgment sees past what a thing looks like to what it is.
Sermon transcript
Tonight we are reading in John 7, and we are beginning in verse 1. John’s Gospel, the seventh chapter, the first verse. Give your attention to the reading of God’s holy word. And after these things, Jesus was walking in Galilee. for he was unwilling to walk in Judea because the Jews were seeking to kill him. Now the feast of the Jews, the Feast of Tabernacles, was at hand. His brothers therefore said to him, Depart from here and go into Judea, that your disciples also may behold your works which you are doing.
For no one does anything in secret when he himself seeks to be known publicly. If you do these things, show yourself to the world, for not even his brothers were believing in him. Jesus therefore said to them, My time is not yet at hand, but your time is always opportune. The world cannot hate you, but it hates me because I testify of it that its deeds are evil. Go up to the feast yourselves. I do not go up to this feast because my time has not yet fully come.’
And having said these things to them, he stayed in Galilee. But when his brothers had gone up to the feast, then he himself also went up, not publicly, but as it were in secret. The Jews, therefore, were seeking him at the feast and were saying, And there was much grumbling among the multitudes concerning him. Some were saying, he is a good man. Others were saying, no, on the contrary, he leads the multitude astray. Yet no one was speaking openly of him for fear of the Jews.
But when it was now the midst of the feast, Jesus went up into the temple and began to teach. The Jews, therefore, were marveling, saying, how has this man become learned? having never been educated. Jesus therefore answered them and said, My teaching is not mine, but his who sent me. If any man is willing to do his will, he shall know of the teaching, whether it is of God or whether I speak from myself. He who speaks from himself seeks his own glory, but he who is seeking the glory of the one who sent him, he is true and there is no unrighteousness in him.
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you carries out the law? Why do you seek to kill me?” The multitude answered, “‘You have a demon. Who seeks to kill you?’ Jesus answered and said to them, “‘I did one deed, and you all marvel. On this account Moses has given you circumcision, not because it is from Moses, but from the fathers, and on the Sabbath you circumcise a man. If a man receives circumcision on the Sabbath, that the law of Moses may not be broken. Are you angry with me because I made an entire man well on the Sabbath? Do not judge according to appearance, but judge with righteous judgment.
And then at verse 37, Now on the last day, the great day of the feast, Jesus stood and cried out, saying, If any man is thirsty, let him come to me and drink. He who believes in me, as the Scripture said, from his innermost being shall flow rivers of living water. But this he spoke of the Spirit, whom those who believed in him were to receive, for the Spirit was not yet given, because Jesus was not yet glorified.
Our Father, we would bow before you in every aspect of the Church’s life, and therefore, Lord, our prayer is that we might more perfectly reflect your will and purpose for us here in this assembly. Lord, may it please you to give to us a full range of gospel proclamation, that your people may be instructed even reminded of the great saving works of our God. But also, Lord, we are praying that the message of the gospel, the gospel of free grants, might in fact be heard here for the sake of those who would be drawn to you, and that you would be pleased to use us and the ministry of this church for the gathering of your elect. Father, we pray, too, that as far as the structure of our Church is concerned, that we would be conscious of your Word and its program for our Church and its life. We pray, Father, for vitality in the leadership of this Church, for the elders and the deacons that serve. We ask also for all in the congregation that we might live aware of one another, that as we are bound together here, O God, so we shall be bound together in glory. We pray this now, looking to you, seeking the ministry of your word to our souls.
For Jesus’ sake, amen. When we consider the gospel of John, many powerful stories as well as powerful verses come to mind. We may even put those stories and verses that we know very well at the center of the gospel and suggest that in them we have found the gospel’s meaning. We may do this, for instance, with the story of Nicodemus, a story very well known to us.
We may do this with the text from that story that we have all committed to memory, John 3.16.
Some might even turn to the story of the blind man of John 9, one of my own favorites. and to its aftermath in John chapter 10, and pick up the wonderful statement of Jesus from that context in the 11th verse of the 10th chapter, where Jesus says, I am the good shepherd, the good shepherd gives his life for his sheep.
Or later, some may even turn to a lighter context, that one in which we find Jesus in his last evening on this earth before his crucifixion, when he had a brief exchange with Thomas and said to Thomas in response, John 14, 6, I am the way, the truth and the life, no man comes to the Father but by me.
Ordinarily, however, when it comes to folks listing central or even favorite chapter and verse from John’s Gospel, not many or any would list John 7. Now, I’m not going to tell you this evening that John 7 is the most important chapter in John’s Gospel. but I am going to argue for the greatness of this chapter and for the exceptional ability or power of one of its verses to pour the gospel of John in its entirety into focus. I have in mind John 7, verse 24.
In this verse, Jesus says this, “‘Do not judge according to appearance, but judge with righteous judgment.’” You might have passed over this text. You might not have considered it very long at all in your reading of this gospel, or in your reading of this chapter, or even possibly in the reading of this chapter this evening. But believe me, it is a great verse, a great text. Let me suggest to you some of why that is.
First of all, it draws its significance in part from the Old Testament law. is the one in whom the law is fulfilled. Jesus is the one who properly exegetes the law. He knows the law, its purpose, its intention, and even its limitation. But this text, John 7.24, does draw from the Old Testament law. Exodus chapter 23 verse 2 is one of the places from which this statement by Jesus may rise.
Here, Exodus 23 verse 2, we find God giving Israel instruction at Sinai, and specifically that they are not to follow a mob in their attitudes, assessments, and judgments. nor are they to pervert justice by giving false evidence. The Jews, as a people, therefore, were to judge, if you will, the righteous judgment. That is, a judgment that stood in the interests of God’s revelation of Himself. in the interests of God’s specific revelation from Sinai, the revelation that is found in his law. This righteous judgment was contrary to the unrighteousness that would wickedly take advantage of someone else’s situation, or adopt to oneself the attitudes and frame of mind of those who were in the land of promise as the Israelites made their way to that land to dispossess them.
In Leviticus 19, verse 5, another text dealing with proper judgment. Here, the emphasis falls upon equity and fairness. You shall not be partial to the poor or defer to the great, but judge the righteous judgment—that is, the fair and equitable judgment. The righteous judgment in this context, then, having to do with equity and fairness.
Deuteronomy 16, verses 18 through 20. These verses change the focus somewhat, as here the directive comes to Israel concerning the kinds of judges and officers that Israel is to have in its communities. These individuals, officers and justices, would be anticipatory of the elders that now we have in our churches. At any rate, these, so identified here in this Deuteronomy passage, are to judge the people with righteous judgment.
The words are there, as if here you find a background and backbone for Jesus’ statement in Deuteronomy. John 7. The officers of Israel must not, therefore, distort justice or be partial. They must not take bribes. Instead, we are told they are to pursue justice and justice alone.
The righteous judgment, then, as we look at the law of God, the righteous judgment is to be impartial, clear-eyed. and uncorrupted. So then, the witness of the law enjoins both people and leaders to make honest assessments and thus render just judgments. But what if the truth is not evident by observation? What if the truth is not evident by the observation of circumstances and the blatant evidence at hand? What if the truth actually lies beyond the obvious, or worse yet, what if one’s own eyes deceive him for whatever reason, be it even a matter of his own Jesus, in his comments in John 7, you might have noted it in verse 19, speaks about the inability of those Jews in his day to keep the law of Moses, they even pursuing his own execution contrary to the law of God. The Prophet Isaiah sees this problem that comes in view at this point, the problem of truth obscured, truth hidden, truth not obvious.
And the Prophet Isaiah sees as well the resolution of this problem, as he speaks through the inspiration of the Spirit. concerning the coming of the Messiah. I have a text from that book of Emanuel in view, Isaiah chapter 11, and its famous statement concerning the coming of the Messiah and the Messianic age. That text talks about the Messiah as shoot and branch from the vine of Jesse, verse 1 in that eleventh chapter. upon whom the Spirit of the Lord will rest,” verse 2. But the verse I want you to notice is the third verse of that eleventh chapter, where the Messiah is described as that one who delights in the fear of the Lord.
And because he fears the Lord, He is one, then, who judges with righteous judgment, and notice what is said about him. He will not judge, says the prophecy, by what his eyes see, nor make a decision by what his ears hear. He is gone beyond the obvious, beyond the evident, beyond that which is plain and clear. In other words, the Messiah, in judging the righteous judgment, is carried beyond the canons of the mere external and sensory discernment. For the Messiah, judging with righteous judgment, means then making determination on more than the obvious, more than the apparent.
But of course, even with this, as we come out of the Old Testament law and the prophets, the possibility exists that we will think that the Messiah himself merely has the advantage of getting beneath the surface, of dealing with and seeing into the heart and to the heart of any issue.
But all of that, at the level of life lived in this world, and on the surface plane of this creation, and in the interests of such life as that. In fact, with the law and the prophets in hand, It is possible of giving the appearance of judging with righteous judgment. The Jews of Jesus’ day have the law, and they also have the prophets, and they are brimming over, are they not, with messianic hope and expectation, John 7 being witness to that. So it is possible, even with all this advantage, of giving the appearance of judging with righteous judgment, when in fact such judgment is actually a judgment according to appearance.
This is why John 7, 24 is such a great text, and why I suggested to you that it has the capability of drawing us to the very center of what John, in his gospel, is endeavoring to communicate throughout the entirety of that gospel. Now, this text is set both broadly and narrowly in the context of prescribed behavior for the Jewish people. Broadly, the setting is, as you note at the beginning of the chapter, the Feast of Tabernacles. While narrowly, as Jesus introduces the subject himself through the development of the chapter, while narrowly, the context seems to be now a dispute specifically over the Sabbath, and a healing which Jesus performed on the Sabbath. Now, admittedly, with the broad context, the issue is a clear matter concerning God’s law, for the Feast of Tabernacles was a commanded feast, one which all the males of Israel from a certain age were commanded by the law to attend. While the issue at stake in the narrow consideration, specifically the Sabbath, seems to have to do with the traditions that have developed around the Sabbath from those teachers and instructors within Israel.
But even given the difference as you move from the broader context to the more narrow context, Jesus’ words here in John 7.24 are meant to drive home a singular point. And that singular point is this. The world of appearance—in fact, this world, with its judgments, observations, and even laws—is one thing. The world of righteous judgment is a completely different thing. Let me pull this out for you a little bit. better from a parallel text that appears a chapter later in John.
I have in mind here John 8.15, where Jesus seemingly repeats himself, at least in part. For here he says, you people judge according to the flesh. and he sets his judgment, then, in the conclusion of that verse, over against theirs.
If we join John 7.24 with John 8.15, it would seem that Jesus, then, is equating judgment according to appearance with judgment according to the flesh.
And that being the case, As we think of the implications of this, we might then say that judging with righteous judgment, in the sense in which John 7.24 means it, can only mean judging in the Spirit over against the flesh. But what does that mean? What does it mean to judge according to the Spirit? The sense of this in John’s Gospel must be a judgment in keeping with the reality. that Jesus Christ brings about through his finished work.
No, no, no. It is not simply judgment by an appeal to something ethereal, something immaterial. It’s not just judgment in terms of what we might consider to be the finer things of existence, something that speaks to us about the aesthetic qualities of life, Something inherently capable for us because we have the potentiality of the Spirit. Yes, beyond the flesh, there is the Spirit, and there is the Spirit in us all, and we can appeal to that. Something that is native to our constitution.
Besides, Jesus isn’t even making appeal to that which is there as it were, from the beginning of the story of salvation. He has in mind something specifically new, something radical. He has in mind that reality which comes as a result of his finished work, the spirit over against the flesh. the flesh being the old, and the Spirit being the new.
Judgment in keeping, then, with the coming of the Spirit and the world which the Spirit brings with him—the new atmosphere, the new environment. into which Jesus Christ enters in the Spirit and we after him. Yes, all of this in keeping with what Jesus then declares later on in the great day of the feast, spoken of in verses 37-39. Another way to say it is that the righteous judgment of which Jesus speaks here is the heavenly, transcendent judgment, providing us vantage point then to make assessment, and to make assessment in truth with judgments and assessments that are eternal, that belong to the environment of eternity.
So you see, it is not just honest, impartial, uncorrupted judgment. Even though that is preached by the law and reinforced by the law, it just doesn’t make it. It can’t cut it in the end. It is inadequate, nor just superb. sublime, penetrating analysis and assessment that always goes right to the heart of matter.
Rather, such judgment as Jesus has in mind here is judgment that comes forth from the heart of heaven, from the very heart of God. which now asserts itself in the world through Jesus Christ because of his finished work and because of the gift of the Spirit. It is precisely such a judgment as this that scrutinizes Old Testament law itself, and all Jewish custom and tradition build upon it. even be they such things as sublime as the Feast of Tabernacles and the Sabbath itself.”
The Son of Man is Lord of the Sabbath. And I dare say, if you are following along now with me, as with Israel, so with the new Israel, as with the Jews, so with you Christians. It is precisely such judgment as Jesus speaks of here that scrutinizes your observance and your involvement with your customs and traditions. Be they as wonderful as sacraments and sabbaths and holiday celebrations Might Jesus speak the same way to you in the context of your celebration of Christmas as he spoke to the Jews in the context of the Feast of Tabernacles? Jesus in this gospel then John, driving home the point, propels you past the appearance of all of these things, be they sacraments or Sabbaths or special holiday celebrations, lest you ever content yourself that by paying your respects to any one of them, even meticulously observing them, you are inherently satisfying God. At the beginning of the seventh chapter, Jesus said that he would not go up to the Feast of Tabernacles with his brothers.
In verse 10, he says, we are told that he did go up after all. He does the same today. He refuses to go up insofar as what we go up to as an observance fit for mere appearance. He refuses to go up today in order to confound judgment made according to appearance, according to the flesh. But he does go out, albeit secretly, in stealth, in the interests of the righteous, heavenly, spiritual judgment which he executes. You are being scrutinized right now by Him. He is here by stealth.
In our feasts, our sacraments, our Sabbaths, our Savior still goes up secretly, that is, in the Spirit, that he might challenge all our attitudes about life lived at the mere level of appearance. And he does so in order to beckon us all to the full life in the eternal realm of the Spirit, out of which we are enabled to judge the righteous judgment in and through Him. Lord, as we think about it, we are frightened because it may well be that we sit here for appearance sake. But Lord, you come up to our service of worship, and you are here secretly. in the interests that we might discern you and judge the righteous judgment. That is, the judgment which is in keeping with the spirit and the world that he brings with him. Forgive us, O God, for our practice may be an insult to you.
But in our prayer this evening, we plead the righteousness of our Savior, whose performance in every circumstance is in keeping with that world which the Spirit brings. Bless us in all of our observations and observances. May our celebrations be pure, as we are always alert to Christ in secret, hidden among us. We pray this, that we in fact, Lord, might live worthy of the calling that we have received in Him. unto the end, that we might see, in fact, that world which we believe exists.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

