This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The History of Salvation” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, November 4, 1990.
About this sermon
Jesus’ growing alienation from the crowds comes to a head in his use of the sign of Jonah, worked through carefully in Matthew 16:5-20. Peter’s confession right after marks one of the true hinge points in the whole history of salvation.
Sermon transcript
Tonight we are reading from Matthew’s Gospel, Chapter 16. And we are beginning with verse 1. Hear the word of God. And the Pharisees and Sadducees came up, and testing him, asked him to show them a sign from heaven. But he answered and said to them, When it is evening, you say, it will be fair weather, for the sky is red. And in the morning there will be a storm today, for the sky is red and threatening. Do you know how to discern the appearance of the sky but cannot discern the signs of time? An evil and adulterous generation seeks after a sign, and a sign will not be given it except the sign of Jonah. as he left them and went away.
And the disciples came to the other side and had forgotten to take bread. And Jesus said to them, Watch out and beware of the eleven of the Pharisees and Sadducees. And they began to discuss among themselves, saying, It is because we took no bread. But Jesus, aware of this, said, You men of little faith, why do you discuss among yourselves because you have no bread? Do you not yet understand or remember the five thousands of the five lows of the five thousand and how many large baskets you took up. With the seven lows of the fall 4000 and how many baskets you took up.
How is it that you do not understand that I did not speak to you concerning bread but beware of the love of the Pharisees and Sadducees. Then they understood that He did not say to beware of the leaven of bread, but of the teaching of the Pharisees and Sadducees.
Now when Jesus came into the district of Caesarea Philippi, he began asking his disciples, saying, who do people say that the Son of Man is? And they said, some say John the Baptist, some Elijah, and others Jeremiah or one of the prophets. He said to them, but who do you say that I am?
Simon Peter answered and said, Thou art the Christ, the son of a living God. And Jesus answered and said to him, Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonas, because flesh and blood did not reveal this to you, but my Father who is in heaven. And I also say to you that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades shall not overpower it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you shall bind on earth shall have been bound in heaven, and whatever you shall loose on earth shall have been loosed in heaven.” Then he warned the disciples that they should tell no man that he was the Christ.
Our Father, we rejoice in the foundation that is found in your Word. We rejoice, Lord, in the foundation that Christ’s Word is. May we be wise builders who construct our houses upon the rock of Jesus’ word, may we do those things that he has commanded. And Lord, we pray that it would please you to grant us understanding as well concerning the matter of the confessing Peter, that a foundation, in fact, was laid that day upon which then Jesus promised to build his church. Our God, may we who would be built then upon such a foundation as is in view here, be likewise filled with that faith that exclaims before our Savior that he is, in fact, the Christ, the Son of the living God. May we know for sure, our God, that there is no other foundation laid than that which is laid in Christ Jesus.
We pray, Lord, that you will therefore enable your church to stand strong for that truth, for the confession that is made, and in the spirit of it. And Lord, where that concession is made in truth, may you cause your people to rely well upon you, that they may endure through every circumstance, receiving blessing and even difficult times from you, entrusting themselves to your sovereignty. And may it also please you, our God, to grant faithful stewards for the house that you are establishing in the powerful working of Christ, those to whom have been committed keys for the kingdom, for binding and loosing. And throughout the world, even at this time, Lord, we look to you for those who would be raised up so as to have that authority amongst your people to rule, and may they rule well for your people will thrive under good and proper leadership and will be to the church if she has not that good and fine leadership. To this end, we commit ourselves in prayer, asking you that you will in fact grant such to your church and to this church, even to the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.
And as there are elders in heaven prepared to throw down their crowns before the throne of our God and of the Lamb, may the elders that we have in this world be likewise so disposed. These things now we ask, looking to you, that we might receive good things from the Word at this time. for the sake of Jesus our Savior. Amen.
Now we have moved from those early days, the early days of Jesus’ ministry when he ministered in the regions of Judea. You recall the record of which is found in the opening chapters of John’s Gospel. So if you’re looking for those accounts for the early times of Jesus’ ministry, that’s where you will want to turn. But we have moved from those early days now, following that Judean ministry, into this period of the Galilean ministry. You remember the beginning days of that Galilean ministry when Jesus experiences great notoriety. The land is abuzz with the news about Jesus, and everyone is quite excited. We come from those early days in the experience of Jesus in Galilee to the middle phase of that Galilean ministry. And we have noted how Jesus’ popularity has begun to wane. It has begun to erode away. And Jesus has become increasingly a figure attended only by a coterie of close associates.
His position has been carved out by him. Now, his position has been carved out by him. As the popularity begins to wane and erode away, as he is left with this solitary group of men, these close associates, the position he has carved out for himself is arrived at by a series of deliberate acts whereby it seems that he is at work to alienate himself from the crowd, from the Jewish leader, and from his family. The veiled nature of his mission, the ambiguities of his presentations, the deliberate affronts that he places in front of these various groups. These things seem to hide the meaning of his ministry and message. They seem to obscure the kingdom that he has come to bring.
And as far as his own person is concerned, now those who have had an interest in him are forced to come to grips with those prophecies from the Old Testament that would have bearing on any Messiah, anyone making messianic claims. They are forced to come to grips with God’s ways of doing things, and with their own desires and expectations. The Pharisees and Sadducees now, as we move into the 16th chapter, Matthew, feed their own bitter hostility. Every time now they appear, they appear with a purpose in mind, that to entrap That’s to trip up Jesus in things that he says and holds to be true concerning himself. And what is their objective on this occasion?
Show us a sign. And not just any sign. There have been plenty of signs. Show us a sign from heaven. They are taunting. The ridicule of him has in view no ordinary phenomenon. They want an apocalyptic sign, an end-time sign, a sign from heaven, one that would herald the end of the present world order and establish the great kingdom of Jewish supremacy and world dominance. That’s what they’re asking for.
Show us a sign from heaven. Not just any ordinary wonder, not just another miracle, not just healing someone who’s crippled, or casting out a demon, or restoring sight to someone who’s blind. No, we want a sign from heaven. If you are the Messiah, they say, in effect, then do a messianic thing and we will believe.
Sound familiar? At the end, you’ll recall, as Jesus is hanging on a cross, the Pharisees are gathered there, the leaders with them, and they taunt Jesus once more. Come down. Come down from the cross. And we will believe you. But in this instance, in the latter instance, Jesus not responding to them. In this instance, Jesus tried them. They forecast the weather. They forecast the weather. He said, but not the time. They cannot recognize that which is spiritually obvious, for they are spiritually blind.
And now the only sign for them will be the sign of Jonah. Now what’s the sign of Jonah? The sign is to which Jesus has referred. He has spoken of it before in the twelfth chapter of Matthew. You may recall what he says there as he is speaking there against the Pharisees. Verse thirty-eight, there as later they are asking from him a sign Teacher, we want a sign from you,” Jesus tells them.
Verse 39, an evil and adulterous generation craves for a sign, and yet no sign will be given it but the sign of Jonah the prophet. For just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the sea monster, so shall the Son of Man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth. There you have the sign of Jonah laid out for you. But note also in that regard how that sign of Jonah does in fact come about, how it presents itself.
It will be no sign which these men then will see. They will only hear about it. And when they hear about it, they will resolutely, with determination, refuse to believe what is told them. Remember, the news comes back from the tomb, Christ is raised. They refuse to believe it. In the end, the sign of Jonah will be communicated to them in a way in which in a way in which it can be appropriated only by faith, for everything they lack.
But not only is Jesus now dogged by accusing leaders, an example of which here we find at the opening of the 16th chapter of Matthew. Not only is he fawned over by worshipful yet strickle multitude, We’ve heard plenty about them. Not only is he sought out by his non-comprehending family, we have also spoken about them.
But it seems now as we progress in the 16th chapter, at least as far as the next story is concerned, you’re plagued by a group of disciples that at times proves to be so obtuse, so thick, so slow to understand. to believe. In fact, it is difficult to imagine a group being more thick-headed than the disciples prove themselves to be in verses 5 through 12 of the 16th chapter. Now, there may be some hidden meaning to this story that I’m too thick-headed to get.
But it does appear to me that its inclusion in the canon is for the purpose that we ourselves might be encouraged. That is to say, if Jesus our Lord can be patient and loving towards this group of blockheads, And I mean this respectfully, please understand me. He can certainly be patient and loving towards us. This scene comes off as a compact comedy of errors.
From Don comprehending the point of Jesus’ words And then sort of going into counsel, you see, going into a huddle and discussing the whole matter. Well, do you think he meant this? Do you think he meant that? And being so thoroughly wrong, missing the point altogether. And then Jesus appears in exasperation, saying, Oh, you men of little faith. Jesus has warned them against the teachings of the Pharisees. He’s done so in a comment about leaven.
You know how leaven works? Leaven works itself out into the entire lump of dough. Well, if the disciples are a lump of dough, they’re certainly acting like lumps. If the disciples are a lump of dough, well then the teachings of the Pharisees will work themselves out into them fully and completely in unbelief will triumph.”
Jesus is telling them, beware of the leaven in that respect. But because he’s mentioned the leaven, they think he’s talking about bread and conclude that he is upset because they forgot to bring any. And then you have Jesus’ response, even if I am talking about bread. Does it really matter? Didn’t we just feed 5,000? And most recently, haven’t we fed 4,000? What are you worried about bread for? Well, it’s an incident in which the disciples’ lack of faith is utterly transparent. But just as much, they’re ignorant. their ignorance.
Now it’s not to say that the disciples are faithless and ignorant, and we are not. But Jesus, who has proved to be so kind and patient with these men, is proving himself patient with us too. But won’t you grasp hold of the lessons Jesus has here for his own. That your own struggles with faith would be resolved and you would no longer make excuses for your ignorance. Surely Jesus’ intention is not to leave the disciples in this position where they are called men of little faith, in this position where they are so manifestly ignorant, his intention is to bring them on so that they would be filled with faith, filled with certainty, and well-informed, no longer ignorant at all. understanding Him and what He’s about. Now, as we’ve said, the disciples’ lack of faith here is thoroughly transparent, as is their lack of understanding. And Jesus is intent upon resolving both their unbelief and their ignorance, and he is determined to do the same in all of his elect. Are you not among his elect? And is he not working on you to strengthen your faith and to resolve your ignorance?
Now, it is especially fitting that the next story appear in this setting. The disciples are leveled to a man, are they not? They are leveled to a man. It is so appropriate that the following story appear in this setting. The stage is set for that marvelous event at Caesarea Philippi. The stage is set by the attack of Jewish leaders by the ignorance and unbelief of disciples. So now Jesus takes his disciples into Philip’s territory. Do you remember where Philip’s territory was? It lies to the northeast of the Sea of Galilee.
It is a region especially associated with Gentile presence. One, now, the region particularly in view here, the region of Caesarea Philippi, it is one inscribed with the name of the Gentile Lord, Caesar. Caesarea, Caesar. And simultaneously, joined to that, the name of the Palestinian ruler, the half-Jew, the part Idiomenean, the part Edomite, Philip, his name too inscribed with Caesars, demarcating this place. In this remarkable setting, Against a background of hostility, ignorance and unbelief, Jesus asks his question.
Who do men say the Son of Man is? Now at first glance, this question seems to be a general one about the Son of Man, a theoretical discussion. We’re going to have a theological discussion here. Gentlemen, about the Son of Man. That figure that appears in prophecy, out of the pages of the Old Testament, Daniel chapter 7, you remember? A name that Jesus has used with respect to himself through his ministry thus far, but at this point it doesn’t seem that he’s specifically applying it to himself. It’s a general question.
Who do men say that the Son of Man is? Or, he asks the general question about the Son of Man, whoever he might be. And there are the responses, given by the disciples now. And from these responses, it may seem apparent that they’re not connecting the Son of Man with Jesus. John the Baptist. It’s obvious that Jesus isn’t John the Baptist. Elijah. and others. Jeremiah, one of the prophets. So come the speculative answers of the disciples. But then Jesus, in order to set things straight, is quite direct when he asks now, again, about the Son of Man, putting himself in the place of that title. Verse 15, but who do you say that I am? First, who do you say the Son of Man is? Now, who do you say I am? Thus identifying himself with the expected Son of Man.
Is Simon Peter one of those obtuse? ignorant, unbelieving disciples who respond. You see the power of it now? Against the background of the disciples’ confusion, their ignorance and unbelief, now Peter, one of those ignorant, unbelieving, obtuse disciples responds, you are the Christ, the Son of the living God. How do you get from the earlier part of that 16th chapter to this point? How do we move from this ignorant, stumbling disciple to a disciple now who has upon his lips, as if without a moment’s hesitation, a confession of this nature? You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.
What an amazing confession it is. And Jesus here is saying, in his response to Peter now, that this confession is not because of Peter’s impetuousness. It’s not because he’s given over to spontaneous outbursts, or it was a flashing, fleeting, momentary insight of genius. What Jesus is saying is, that confession is utterly impossible, given the man from whom it comes. It is a supernatural confession. It comes from God, it doesn’t come from the man.
Flesh and blood haven’t revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven. So amazing is this confession, so climactic, so conclusive that Jesus launches into an extended blessing And in that blessing he acknowledges the supernatural origins of Simon Peter’s words.
But he continues in his blessing, he continues in Jehovah-like style to change officially Simon’s name to Peter. Do you remember those instances in the Old Testament where there’s a name change brought about by none other than the Lord himself? Think of an instance. from Abram to Abraham, from Jacob to Israel. Do you remember those Jehovah-like instances where there is a change of name and now Jesus as Jesus, in Jehovah-like style, changes Simon’s name to Peter, which means rock, and declares that on the foundation of the confessing Peter—that’s very important—upon the foundation of the confessing Peter, in a short while he will be the stumbling block Peter, the denying Peter, Upon the foundation of the confessing Peter, Jesus will build his unassailable church.
Verse 8. He then tells this confessing Peter that he, Peter, is not only the foundation but the steward of the house Jesus shall build. We translate this in general terms to the confessing and appointed servant then. As we see, all confessing and appointed servants is committed the rule in Christ’s Church. The hell with me now. so that the force and the power of this scene, this remarkable scene, settle in upon you. The context of these words from Christ is utterly most remarkable.
So let me ask you now, what chance is there for this enterprise to succeed? What chance, humanly, in earthly terms, is there for this enterprise laid out here by Jesus, this enterprise, to succeed? We’ve got a bunch of stumbling, ignorant, faltering, non-comprehending, blockhead disciples. What chance is there for this enterprise to succeed? Jesus has deliberately alienated himself from leadership. People in Palestine, he has distanced himself from the multitude, he’s cut himself off from Jewish institutions, even the Jewish institution of the family. What hope is there for this enterprise to succeed?
But not only will Christ and his Church prevail over hatred from enemies, ignorance and unbelief from would-be disciples, it will triumph over all, over everything that opposes it. Even an alliance of the Gentile Lord and the Palestinian rulers. It will triumph over alliances of Rome and Jewry. and it will triumph over the very councils of hell. This unspectacular, this ordinary, this ridiculous group of people destined for glory. part and parcel of that which Christ himself establishes. And the promise goes out, the gates of hell shall not prevail against her.
Jesus’ ministry therefore has reached an end point. It’s almost as if everything is concluded now. With that confession from Peter, it’s almost as if everything is concluded. It’s as if we can hear in Peter himself the confession of the entire Church of Jesus as Lord. No, even more, as if we are brought to the very end of all things. And in that confession we hear the resolution of all matters. every tongue acknowledging, every knee bowing, a picture of the coming glory that belongs to him on the very last day.
Yet at this point, the picture is incomplete. The Messiah’s person and ministry remain vain. his kingdom obscure. And there remains for him yet that horrible, that ignominious goal of the cross, to which he even now reaches forward. And his mission is not finished until he arrives there. For the Son of Man has come not to be ministered unto, but to minister, and to give his life a ransom for many. So having reached a concluding point, we press on. And thus we shall do in the weeks to come. Amen.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

