This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of “The Holy Spirit” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, October 22, 1995.
About this sermon
In John 3 Christ proclaims the Spirit publicly, and readers have misread the text in two opposite directions, one Arminian and one evidentialist. Against both, the claim stands plain: believers are born from heaven and live only in and from the Spirit. Nicodemus’s confusion is the natural first reaction to that claim.
Sermon transcript
Tonight we will be reading from John Chapter 3, John’s Gospel Chapter 3. We begin at verse 1 and we are reading through verse 17. There was a man of the Pharisees named Nicodemus, a ruler of the Jews. This man came to him by night and said to him, Rabbi, we know that you are come from God as a teacher, for no one can do these signs that you do unless God is with him.
Jesus answered and said to him, Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. Nicodemus said to him, How can a man be born when he is old? He cannot enter a second time into his mother’s womb and be born, can he? Jesus answered, Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.
That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. Do not marvel that I said to you, you must be born again. The wind blows where it wishes, and you hear the sound of it, but do not know where it comes from or where it is going. So is everyone who is born of the Spirit.”
Nicodemus answered and said to him, “‘How can these things be? Jesus answered and said to him, Are you a teacher of Israel and do not understand these things? Truly, truly, I say to you, we speak that which we know, and bear witness of that which we have seen, and you do not receive our witness. If I told you earthly things and you do not believe, how shall you believe if I tell you heavenly things?
No one has ascended into the heavens but he who descended from heaven, even the Son of And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up, that whoever believes may in Him have eternal life. For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish, but have eternal life. For God did not send the Son into the world to judge the world. that the world should be saved through him.
Our Father, we are grateful to you because the Spirit comes for the ordering and for the life of the new creation. We rejoice, Lord, then, in that ordering, and would not set the Spirit over against that order. We plead with you, Lord, that we might be submissive ourselves to that order, and that, Father, it would be apparent to us that just that order breathes out the vitality of the Spirit. Father, we know that this which you have brought about means for us liberty. And Father, we pray that we might then be expressive of our joy in that spiritual freedom by the Spirit that is ours. Even so, Lord, for your church here and throughout the world, may it please you to give us good in keeping with the ministration of the Spirit, that things might be done decently and in order, even as the affairs of this church and all true churches are overseen by Christ through his appointed officers. Lord, we who are officers May we live in keeping with the rule of your word and may we live responsibly as those who are examples to the ones that you have placed under us. Always giving our lives that those who are called to you might be served.
We pray this even through Christ who gave himself for us in that. our study of the person and work of the Holy Spirit now focuses on John’s Gospel. And last week we listed and grouped the references in John’s Gospel to the Holy Spirit, noting that John’s Gospel, because of the number of references and because of that Gospel’s particular slant, is especially, then, the gospel of the Holy Spirit. Our comments last week also dealt with the first grouping of citations, those that were concerned with John the Baptist’s witness concerning the relationship between Christ and the Spirit. Tonight we are moving on to the second grouping, which deals with Jesus’ public proclamations about the Spirit. In view are these texts. John 3, verses 5, 6, and 8, which we have read. verses 23 and 24, John 6 verse 63, and finally John 7 verses 38 and 39. We are turning this evening to the first of these citations within this second group. The citations that we find in John chapter 3, verses 5, 6, and 8.
This, of course, places us right in the center of one of the most familiar of biblical texts, as that text builds to the best-known verse in all Scripture, John 3.16.
Familiarity, however, doesn’t mean comprehension, and it certainly doesn’t preclude misinterpretation. In our effort then to understand this classic passage, Let us work this evening to dismiss two misunderstandings that have arisen with regard to this passage. First of all, as many of you know well, this passage has been employed in the interests of Arminianism. In fact, Arminianism has ridden on the back of this text, by and large. The argument goes something like this.
Jesus tells Nicodemus that he must be born again. He also makes mention or reference to this once more in verse 7. But if I were to ask Jesus now, if I were to ask him how I might be born again, he would invariably answer me with John 3.16, would he not? And its statement, whosoever believes on him should not perish but have everlasting life.
For the Arminian then, the equation is quite simple. Faith precedes Faith leads to, faith causes rebirth. Translate that word, rebirth, regeneration. This means then, in the Arminian estimation, that faith comes before regeneration. That is, before I can be regenerated, before I can be reborn, I must believe. I must exercise faith. I must do something.
This perspective led a world-famous Arminian evangelist, whose name I won’t mention, but his initials are BG, a few years ago to write the ultimate how-to book. That book was entitled, How to be Born Again. In that book, this evangelist presented to his readers what I have just presented to you. The issue in John 3, and in Jesus’ exchange with Nicodemus, is how we might be reborn.
A question answered by John 3.16, and the faith specifically mentioned in it. We are reborn, we are regenerated as a result of our faith. Our faith causes our rebirth.
But as strange as it may seem to this evangelist and those who agree with him, Such an interpretation of John 3 flies in the face of this passage’s clear teaching. The Arminian position posits power and possibility, potential with the individual. And that, too, believes. You see, it lies within the sinner’s ability to believe, and that ability is located in a world that is free and, in some measure, uncorrupted. Isn’t that what the Arminian is bound to say when forced to the wall with regard to his that there is an aspect of the human personality that is uncorrupted by the fall, by sin. It lies within the sinner’s ability to believe. That ability, located in a world that is free and in some measure uncorrupted, which can of itself then move towards God.
But I ask you, how except by extreme prejudice can anyone glean such teaching from John 3? Jesus begins by presenting his message not in the language of possibility, but in the language of impossibility. Jesus’ language here in John 3 doesn’t as much as leave room for the Arminian position.
And you know what? Nicodemus, as Act 2 says he is, gets the point. in that he concludes in verse 4 that Jesus must be speaking absurdities. He understands what Jesus is talking about, even though the Arminian can’t seem to get it. Jesus is speaking absurdities. Jesus repeats himself, once isn’t enough, I’ll tell you again, this time mentioning the fact that those who are to see the kingdom of God, who are to enter it, must be born of water and the Spirit.
In this, Jesus thus separates natural birth, even an absurd second natural birth such as Nicodemus proposes, from the supernatural birth that he has in mind. We are speaking here, then, about two orders of existence. One of the flesh, says Jesus, and the other of the spirit, verse 6. The effort of the flesh does not, cannot yield birth in the spirit. In fact, Jesus goes on to say, rebirth, birth in the spirit, belong completely to the sovereign disposition and operation of the Spirit.”
All that Jesus then has to say tells us about human and natural inability. but at the same time about a heavenly and supernatural power in and through the Holy Spirit. And this then being the case, the faith of which Jesus speaks later, that is, the faith spoken of in verse 16, must be the fruit of regeneration. the consequence of rebirth, not its cause. John, early on in his gospel, established this tone and direction for his message. In chapter 1, verses 12 and 13, John wrote these words, but as many as received him, then he gave the right to become children of God, even those who believe in his name, who were born not of blood, nor of the wool of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. I told you that John’s gospel was the manifestly anti-charismatic gospel. I also told you that it was the manifestly anti-sacramentalist gospel. Tonight, I am telling you that this gospel is the manifestly anti-Arminian gospel.
You see, all of the struggles that we are compelled to endure presently in the Church have already been addressed in the Scriptures. Thus, the sufficiency of the Scriptures. Thus, the permanent relevance of the Scriptures. We don’t make the Bible relevant. The Bible is, of itself, relevant. And it behooves us all to understand the nature of the Bible’s relevance.
Well, the second misunderstanding of this text rises off the first. I’m still wielding the sword. The second misunderstanding has to do with a romanticized and corollary intellectualized reading of this passage. Let me say it another way that may catch the interest of those of you who have experience with Reformed theology. This second misunderstanding has to do with the evidentialist reading of this text.
According to this approach, Nicodemus is a sincere inquirer, an honest intellectual, who, for fear of the Jewish authorities, of whose number he is one, seeks out Jesus under the cover of night. Nicodemus, therefore, at this point, is good, is essentially good, but like others, hesitant and fearful. His statement in verse 2 is meant in good faith, and must be interpreted as genuine and honest as far as it goes. That’s the opening statement by Nicodemus, verse 2, “…Rabbi, we know that you have come from God as a teacher, for no one can do these signs that you do unless God is with you.”
Verse 2, therefore, is cited as evidence of an essentially good theology from a Jewish leader who is himself on the right road. making progress, moving in the right direction. This theology, which this Jewish leader has, can be twisted in as far as it goes.
It says that the signs, the evidences, prove the man, prove the case for the man. No man can do these signs, the signs which you do, Jesus, unless God is with him. Therefore, we know God is with you because of the signs you do. The evidences that we see prove the case, evidentially.
Nicodemus, therefore, has what we call a good apologetic. And this apologetic, though it needs a little maturing here and a little massaging by Jesus, provides the basis upon which Jesus then can build his own place. Moving from the signs to the fact that God is with Jesus, then leads Nicodemus to the place of even greater confidence in Jesus. who will then identify himself as the Son of God. That’s neat, compact, and very clean.
So that by the time we get to verse 16, it is the most logical, the most natural thing for Nicodemus to believe in the full message of Jesus’ divine identity. And John, in this chapter, has then provided us, the Church, with the classic textbook case for the evidentialist apologetic, as it has been brought to maturity by Jesus building on the base which Nicodemus has brought to him.
But this approach gets it all wrong. Nicodemus is not the sincere seeker. In John’s gospel, he is not the honest intellectual. He is an agent of the Sanhedrin. He is sent by them in the night, not to cover his tracks in order to avoid possible persecution, but because the night fits his character. He is an agent of darkness. And in the end, if in fact Nicodemus is transformed by the gospel of Jesus Christ, he will be the proof of the very things that John is saying in this chapter. A man for whom it is utterly impossible for him to change himself. Lost. Utterly.
Nicodemus’ statement to Christ in verse 2 is not an invitation to Jesus to sincere dialogue. It is not an invitation to Jesus to instruct him, Nicodemus, upon a commonly agreed upon base in the consideration of evidences within the boundaries of the dictates of neutral logic.
Nicodemus’s words, we know, are framed out of an assured superiority. They are framed out of a contrived flattery. They are words that are an intended trap for Jesus. If Jesus acquiesces to Nicodemus’s first thrust, this means that Jesus then will be brought onto a common turf with Nicodemus. And on that talk, on that turf, Nicodemus is king. He rules. And the walls of argumentation are established by him. You will note that Jesus does not directly respond to Nicodemus’ statement. Why would that be? He doesn’t accept the flattery, he doesn’t walk into the trap.
He redirects the discussion altogether. for he knows that these words are intended to place him at the mercy of Nicodemus. But even more than that, they are meant to place him at the mercy of those things that are observed and seen, at the mercy and beneath the authority of that which is natural and necessary. according to the dictates of human logic, unavoidable. Even faith on this scheme becomes natural and necessary. And it forfeits that character that makes it truly faith in the estimations of Jesus and this apostle who writes this gospel.
Jesus’ response, then, is not to build on the common ground with Nicodemus, but to challenge that common ground. Placed over against Nicodemus and his natural order is Jesus himself the Spirit and the supernatural heavenly order. Jesus’ interest, therefore, is not to build on a view of the world that conveniently makes room for science. That’s the world of Nicodemus. Rather, his purpose is to declare the reality of, and the priority of, an entirely different sphere, realm, order altogether. Faith, according to Jesus, is not of the natural, necessary order.
It is not the necessary and natural conclusion of the natural process. arrived at by logical sequence that moves from the observation of signs to further conclusions. Rather, it is a divine gift. It is an intrusion upon that order from another world altogether, the world of the Spirit.
A gift that enables you to see and to properly grasp the significance of the signs that are performed. John’s gospel is not only, then, the manifestly anti-Charismatic gospel, the manifestly anti-Sacramentalist gospel, the manifestly anti-Arminian gospel, it is the manifestly anti-Evidentialist gospel. And that, you see, building once more upon the irony of the case, that this gospel spends more time dealing with the signs that Jesus performs than anyone. that don’t just then leave with the antics. Rather, leave this evening with the grand and eloquent message of this gospel in the positive.
It is the magnificent gospel of birth from heaven. What are we talking about here? Birth from heaven. That’s what Jesus’ words mean in John 3. It’s not just being born again, it’s born from above, it’s born from heaven. This is the magnificent gospel of birth from heaven, by which We grasp well and live well in the light of the full meaning of the Spirit and the order over which he presides, the right and proper meaning of the sacraments, the true character of our faith, and the right appropriation of the signs which Jesus has performed.
The Holy Spirit’s ministry through the Apostle is wonderful in the sublime. And while we are moving away from these things that this gospel invades against, may we be sure to live in the fullness of what this gospel declares. Again, our Father, we bow before you, realizing, Father, that we are your humble servants, there is a grand and wonderful heritage that is ours in the Reformed faith, but it would be with meekness and with the humility of our Savior that we would hold to that faith. We preach strong here, but help us all as we have opportunity to be kind and helpful to those who are much in need of the full blessing from your word. And may our lives, the way in which we conduct ourselves, not refute, or at least appear to refute, our message. We pray this with the request that your Spirit might bless us wonderfully in our service of you. We pray through Christ, Amen.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

