This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of the “Revelation” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, April 13, 1997.
About this sermon
Premillennial, postmillennial, and amillennial readers each hear the song of Moses in 15:3 differently. The pre- and postmillennial positions are right in a way. William Hendriksen’s version of amillennialism falls short, and the text points to a better one.
Sermon transcript
This evening we are reading again Revelation 15, beginning at verse 1. Then I saw another sign in heaven, great and marvelous, seven angels who had seven flags, which are the last, because in them the wrath of God is finished. And I saw something like a sea of glass mixed with fire, and those who had been victorious over the beast and his image and the number of his name, standing on the sea of glass, holding harps of God.
And they sang the song of Moses, the bondservant of God and the song of the Lamb, saying, Great and marvelous are your works, O Lord God, the Almighty. Righteous and true are your ways, King of the nations. Who will not fear, O Lord, and glorify your name? For you alone are holy, for all the nations will come and worship before you, for your righteous acts have been revealed.’
After these things I looked, and the temple of the Tabernacle of Testimony in heaven was opened, and the seven angels who had the seven plagues, came out of the temple clothed in linen, clean and bright, and girded around their chests with golden sashes. And then one of the four living creatures gave to the seven angels seven golden bowls full of the wrath of God, who lives forever and ever. And the temple was filled with smoke from the glory of God and from his power, and no one was able to enter the temple until the seven plagues of the seven angels were finished.
Our Father, by your word the world was created, and you have established the world in wisdom. And in keeping, O God, with your word and the pattern of things in heaven, you have established your people a church and a habitation for yourself. Again, O God, your wisdom is operative in the establishment of this structure in which your glory dwells.
Grant us mercy even as we living stones are placed one upon another, and we are built up as a holy habitation of our God in the Spirit. and grant us a proper spirit of mind and soul so that we would be submissive to the reality that is now evident before us and with us from heaven itself, the pattern of the assembly and glory manifesting itself in the reality of the body of Christ in this world. Grant us a proper disposition as we would submit to your rule, and as the rule of the word is prescribed for your people and abided in, even as we fear our God and tremble before him. We ask, Lord, that as this is mediated to us in the Spirit, blessed as it is by Christ himself, that we, your people, would be strong And Lord, do this in the strength of the Spirit that is of help to your children throughout the world.
We have prayed this day, O Lord, for the Church beyond our own boundaries. We would pray again this evening for the same. And ask, God, that you would be gracious to your Church throughout the world as she pursues her proper mission. This we ask in Jesus’ name. Amen. George Elton Ladd says of this Song of Moses and of the Lamb, it is one of the most moving expressions of faith in the entire biblical literature. high praise.
Ladd speaks this way out of his premillennial frame of reference. He places the song in the setting of the Great Tribulation, that darkest hour of human history, as he calls it. that time immediately prior to Christ’s return to set up his earthly millennial reign.
That time, as Ladd describes it, when it truly seems that Satan is the god of this age. Ladd chooses to read the second verse of this first fifteenth chapter of Revelation, and its comment about those who have triumphed over the beast, his image, and the number of his name, as a reference to the experience of the martyrs who have suffered in the Great Tribulation. The reason why the song has its extraordinary power, according to Ladd, is because it is sung in praise of God directly in that great tribulation which the martyrs endure. The martyrs exalt the name of God because, contrary to outward appearances, He is indeed the King of all the ages, including the time of the martyrs and the time of their martyrdom. Noting the remarkable pathos resident in such a setting, Ladd makes his conclusion.
This is one of the most moving expressions of faith in the entire biblical literature. But if the premillennialist Ladd sees this song and its praise in the setting of suffering, and thus exceptional and compelling, David Chilton, the postmillennialist, along with his mentor R. J. Rusduni, sees this song as a victory hymn to which God’s saints march presently. In it, they proclaim that the salvation God provides in his victory in this world over the heathen of this world.
The issue of suffering, on this view, is utterly and completely peripheral, and essentially a matter of the past. That is, the saints move through the suffering of their early history or any other restricted period of their history to enjoy the more characteristic mood of Christian triumph. This triumph exalts God in a jubilant anthem of Christian optimism.
However, such an anthem was never meant nearly, so say the post-millennialists, as the marching music for the missionary movement. The earth, so says this position, is the arena of Christ’s conquest. Jesus, the incarnation of God in this world, did not live in history in order to surrender history. He redeems his elect in order to assert his crown rights, bring to light the implications of his victory, and then to recreate all things in terms of his sovereign will.
Ladd says, the power of the song rests in its reflection of a heroic faith in the midst of tribulation. Chilton says, the power of the song rests in its expression of triumph after suffering, but before and in the Christian’s conquest of this world. Well, we’ve heard from the Post Mill and the Pre-Mill, what about the Army Mill? William Henderson says the song is indeed a song of triumph, sung by no less than the church triumphant after the last day, after the end of the world.
Here, then, is the victorious multitude of the redeemed, the great company of victors who, after all the bowls of wrath have been poured out and all the saints have entered glory, let loose in praise of God’s conclusive triumph at the end of the age. The sense of this perspective has been caught in the famous Reformed hymn, By the Sea of Crystal. By the sea of crystal, saints in glory stand, Myriads in number, drawn from every land, Robed in white apparel, washed in Jesus’ blood, They now reign in heaven with the Lamb of God. It could, of course, be argued that this hymn is not time-specific.
That is, that it could pertain to the present resurrection of believers at their death, as well as to the final resurrection of the body at the last day. Still, the later or latter application, even in keeping with Hendrickson’s interpretation, remains and offers fitting illustration. of what is in view in the hymn. At any rate, Envision is the end of labors in this world for the saints, whether by the first resurrection or the last, according to the Amillennial position as Hendrickson has presented it.
We have then these three positions—Amill, postmill and pre-mill. We might summarize them along these lines. The pre-mill sees the song sung by the martyred saints in heaven, their song sung in the tribulation or in the midst of itself, and in that tribulation giving expression to their great faith in which they have endured specifically during the time of the seven last plagues. The Post Mill sees the songs sung by the church in the world, their song one of militant triumph as they move on from suffering and after the plagues into the ever-widening arena of Christ’s realized reign on the earth. The Aumil, at least as Hendrickson has it, is representative then, and sees the song sung by saints in glory after the last day, and after the completion of the seven plagues spoken of here. We could list similarities and dissimilarities of these positions, both the Premil and the see the songs sung by saints in glory, post-mills on earth. Both the post-mill and the aw-mill see the songs sung after sufferings, the pre-mill during. Both the aw-mill and the pre-mill see the songs sung in the future, post-mill now.
Post-mill and the aw-mill see the songs sung in triumph, the pre-mill essentially in the arena of anguish. For the postmill, the plagues are essentially past. For the premill, future. For the armill, present. For the armill, the song is a glorious hymn of eternity. For the premill, a moving hymn of faith and endurance in the midst of the coming great tribulation. For the postmill, a martial anthem of Christian conquest accompanying the march to universal world dominion. three views, providing a window through which we might view the respective theological positions.
What can we say? Here we are faced with the age-old questions, those issues over which so many have debated so fiercely. Would I make you upset If I told you that I believe each view has touched upon something of vital significance, would you judge me the master equivocator if I told you that in my judgment each position, at least as we have heard them here this evening, also misses the mark in some regard? Would you think me to have finally surrendered to theological relativity, or become the advocate of that hideous enemy of genuine biblical religion, the balanced point of view, or the theology of the other hand, on the one hand we have this, on the other hand we have that, if I told you each position sees, yes, part of the picture, would you think me, the amillennialist, If I started saying nice things about premills and postmills, will I trust in what I have to offer to you?
I am no traitor, coward, or equivocator when it comes to the true interests of our biblical faith. First of all, let me address the pre-mill. I hope this is not too much of a shock for you, but I believe that Ladd, to a degree, is right on the mark. He is right to set before us the superlative pathos at work in the scene.
Truly, this song is to be understood as sung in the face of all that seems to be so contrary to what it itself communicates. We are in fact here dealing with that which is truly heroic, a faith that sees the invisible A faith that sees the triumph despite the testimony to defeat. There is something here of the genuine interest of the gospel that we live by faith.
In the midst of tribulation then, the saints sing. in the midst of suffering, the saints sing. Paul and Silas are in prison in Philippi, and at midnight they sing to God. They praise their Savior. Despite the circumstances, the song issues forth from the people of God. Indeed, maybe not precisely now, as Ladd has conceived of it, in the specific Great Tribulation of the premillennial scheme. But nevertheless, in the midst of tribulation, the saints sing to the glory of God. They sing a hymn of triumph. in the sure and certain knowledge that because God has revealed his righteous acts, he will complete all of his purposes, and in that they rest. Where Ladd is mistaken is in restricting this expression of piety and devotion to the time of the so-called Great Tribulation.
And in reading too literally the martyr language from the passage, Scripture teaches us that we are living presently in the tribulation. In this world, you will have tribulation. And that the martyr is the one in whom all we who believe are, in fact, included. The martyr to the faith defines you in your Christian experience and existence.
You live to die. If you have not settled that question, I plead with you, listen to the message of the book of Revelation and to the whole of Scripture, and be informed and instructed with regard to the nature of your faith. You have believed to die.”
Now, I have made that connection in another regard. that hasn’t proved to be very popular. I have suggested to Christian educators and to Christian school personnel that the task of Christian education is to teach our children to die. Now, how do you put that in a brochure? But I dare say, somehow we need to communicate that. For too often what we hear is, from Christian educators, we’re training our children how to take over the world. They might even work it into their mission statement.
Oh, a little recognition down here in the front row. You see what I mean? I truly then believe that Ladd has latched on to something that not even Hendrickson in his amillennial position has properly grasped. I do, as I said before, recognize the difficulties with Ladd’s position. I’ve tried to spell those out for you.
But, nevertheless, there is a wonderful, sublime pathos operative in this text. We sing our hymn of triumph directly in the face of everything that testifies to the contrary. That’s what faith does. But, pressing on, would it surprise you too much if I were to say that David Chilton is when he stresses so forcibly the present truth of this text, that what is described is presently enforced and is presently engaged in by believers. Yes, a hymn of triumph! It doesn’t really take, though, a post-millennialist to tell us that. A hymn of triumph! How we hear those hymns sung here.
But Chilton is wrong in missing the essential, and I underscore that word essential. the essential ironic and paradoxical character of the kingdom and its manifestation for advance in the world. It advances in weakness. That’s the prescribed method of advancement. It advances specifically in and through suffering. The reason why this is true is because it is mobilized under the banner and in the sign of the cross. Here is the Church’s life, conformity to Christ and His cross, conformity to Him in His death.
The kingdom, then, does not advance, as some have thought, by the deliberate mobilization for, expressly, dominion. I choose dominion, and that’s what I’m after. You have to choose against it. Rather, the power of God is displayed in the faith of those whose power is nothing.
I might appeal to Hannah in this regard. Finally, then, as you might well expect from what I have been saying thus far, Would you be alarmed too much if I were to tell you that Hendrickson is wrong? Ladd is right, Hilton is right, Hendrickson is wrong. What’s going on here?
He is wrong when he sets the scene of this text at the end of the world and beyond, and exclusively in heavenly glory. Such a commitment from Hendrickson forces him to change the ordering of the text. And he says, the song actually belongs, chronologically, after the plants. You see the order of the text? The song is sung before the plants. Hendrickson has to reverse it. Because, you see, the song can only be sung, according to Hendrickson, at the end of the world, after the plagues are all complete.
No, the song is sung in the face of the plagues, and even before the plagues, as the saints are positioned by grace, or seen according to the gospel, in heaven. Not because they had been finally gathered to heaven, but because heaven is the arena of their life. And they live there as if having already gone there with the martyrs, and they live from there in all of their dealings in this world. But as it is with heaven now, so also the nature of their life. Heaven is hidden.
The only way you see it, the only way you perceive it, is by faith. And the only way you can sing this song as a hymn of triumph, I tell you, presently, as you look out upon the world, as you read the daily newspaper, as you turn on the evening news, as you even consider your own life by faith. And now you are compelled. Now you are compelled. You’re compelled by what you see here and by what you hear. You’re compelled, despite the circumstances, and even the circumstances of your own life, to sing this hymn of glory. Now, some of you have asked me about application. I think, I could be wrong, I think this is application. I hope it is useful and helpful.
Therefore, the proper view is that we, the Church of Jesus Christ, presently are bound to and shaped by martyrs and those who have preceded us to glory, so that we live as if already there, secure from the ravages and judgments of this world. While joined to heavenly life, we sing the song of Moses and the song of the Lamb in glad chorus. And we’ve determined faith even in the face of opposition, even in the face of the threat of death. For we in our faith have been privileged to witness the great and marvelous works of our God, our Redeemer, the One who is Almighty, whose ways are righteous and true, the King of the Ages.
There is no one like Him. There is none but Him. He only is God. and all the world and its inhabitants are his. This is the one who has revealed his righteous actions to Moses and Jesus Christ, the Lamb of God, particularly now Jesus Christ, the one by whom we are blessed. Yes, indeed. Lad, the premillennialist is correct. This is one of the most moving expressions of faith in the entire biblical literature. Amen.
Father, as you would help us in our singing, you will help us in our living. And Lord, we know that you are the one who renews us and grants us strength in the inner man, even though the outer man is wasting away and is destroyed in this world. And as with us, O God, so with the Church as a whole. For we, O God, are being conformed to the image of our Savior, even as we, through the mystery of faith, triumph through suffering. And even, O God, give glory to you through our lack of power and in our weakness. You please to work by these measures to bring glory to yourself and the triumph of all of your graces.
We pray, our Father, that we might be then a people who are obedient to you, even as we see our life joined to that of the martyrs, even as we see our souls united and now singing the songs of Zion in glory and rejoicing in you, O Lord, despite the plagues that rage in the world. Hear us, O Father, for Jesus…
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

