This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of the “Revelation” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, May 18, 1997.
About this sermon
Signs matter in John’s gospel, and they differ from miracles. The church should not dote on them. A sign from heaven means blessing on the elect, and a sign from the earth means destruction for the wicked.
Sermon transcript
We begin our scripture reading this morning in John’s Gospel, chapter 2. We are beginning at verse 1. This is John’s Gospel, chapter 2, beginning at verse 1, and we will be turning over to Revelation 15 after we conclude our reading here. This is God’s word.
And the third day there was a marriage in Cana of Galilee, and the mother of Jesus was there, and both Jesus was called and his disciples to the marriage. And when they wanted wine, the mother of Jesus said unto him, They have no wine. Jesus saith unto her, Woman, what have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come. His mother saith unto the servants, Whatsoever he saith unto you, do it. And there were set there six waterpots of stone, after the manner of the purifying of the Jews, containing two or three firkins apiece. Jesus saith unto them, Fill the waterpots with water. And they filled them up to the brim.
And he saith unto them, Draw out now, and bear unto the governor of the feast, and they bear it. When the ruler of the feast had tasted the water that was made wine, he knew not once it was, but the servants which drew the water knew. The governor of the feast called the bridegroom, and saith unto him, Every man at the beginning doth set forth good wine, and when men have well drunk, then that which is worse Thou hast kept the good wine until now.”
This beginning of signs did Jesus in Cana of Galilee. He manifested forth his glory, and his disciples believed on him. And then dropping down to the 23rd verse of that chapter, now when he was in Jerusalem at the Passover, In the feast day, many believed in his name when they saw the signs which he did. But Jesus did not commit himself unto them, because he knew all men, and needed not that any should testify of man, for he knew what was in man.”
Turning over to Revelation 15 verse 1, this is what we find. And I saw another sign in heaven, great and marvelous, seven angels having the seven last plagues, for in them is filled up the wrath of God. And I saw, as it were, a sea of glass mingled with fire, and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, and over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass having the harps of God. And they sing the song of Moses, the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb, saying, Great and marvelous are thy works, Lord God Almighty! Just and true are thy ways, thou King of saints! Who shall not fear thee, O Lord, and glorify thy name? For thou only art holy. For all nations shall come and worship before thee, for thy judgments are made manifest. Pray together now.
Do bless us, our God, in our reflections upon your word, that we may be reformed in our thinking. Truly, as your word works in us, there is the correction that comes. And Father, we ask that we would not draw back from that correction, but receive it, and even receive it gladly. Truly, Lord, correction is not without pain. We know this, Father, and we tend to avoid that pain, even the correction which you said. Father, there is the peaceable fruit of that correction that is granted to us even as you build us up in the righteousness that is in Christ. Father, we present ourselves, therefore, to you and for your correcting hand. And may you correct us in our thoughts and in our emotions and in our decisions and actions.
For Lord, we would be conformed to Jesus Christ. even that one into whom we have been introduced by your grace. Lord, work in us in these directions and in keeping with your appointed means so that we would be proven, Lord, and it would be demonstrated that we belong to you. We pray it in Jesus’ name. Amen.
Just a word of explanation to you as we begin this morning. I have decided to introduce some sermons on Revelation, our evening series, as you know, into our morning services. And I have decided to do that because the summer season approaches and is near upon us. And with the disruptions of schedules, including my own, and the possibility that I won’t be preaching as regularly in the evenings, I thought it best that we might continue our reflections on Revelation 15 and 16 occasionally in the morning. This means that I have not abandoned the series on 1 Samuel. However, this morning we are in the book of Revelation, and we will be in this book from time to time during our morning services throughout the summer months.
Now, particularly this morning, I want you to look at Revelation 15.1.
And I want you to consider with me a simple word from this text. The word sign. The word sign. Now, signs in John’s vocabulary are a study in themselves. For instance, if you spend time in John’s Gospel, it’s not too long before you are aware just how important this word sign is in that Gospel. In fact, so laden are the first twelve chapters of John’s Gospel with this word sign, and so laden is the record that John gives us with Jesus’ signs, that these opening chapters of John’s Gospel have been called the Book of the Signs. The wonderful work by Jesus at the wedding of Cana, recorded in John 2, as we have read this morning, is called, you will note, in verse 11, the beginning of Jesus’ signs. The beginning of Jesus’ signs. And the raising of Lazarus in John 11. towards the end of this section in John’s Gospel, is later called, in John 12, verse 18, a sign, it being the culminating sign among the many which Jesus performed as he then drew near to the end of his mission.
Now, we often call these signs miracles, and if you have the King James Version in front of you, you realize that I changed the translation at that very point. The King James does in fact have miracles, but I read it as signs. The habit of mind is to treat these terms as if they were synonymous. Signs equals miracles. But the word miracle hardly captures what John’s word, sign, has in mind.
For the word miracle, as we have assimilated it, in the manner in which we have become accustomed to using it, lends itself too quickly to a philosophical interpretation. A philosophical interpretation in which the miracle is understood to be a mere interruption or suspension of the laws of nature, invariably thought to establish proof for the existence of God and evidence for the reality of a supernatural realm. A miracle, then, in common parlance, is an inexplicable wonder thought to demonstrate the reality of a divine being and the existence of a supernatural world. This is, in fact, the approach of C.S. Lewis in his very popular book on miracles—a book bearing the title, Miracles.
But the signs in John’s writings are quite differently directed. They do not have in view a proof for God’s existence. nor are they concerned with a demonstration of the role of the supernatural. Such an approach is much too general, too nonspecific, even too abstract, to interest John under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. The signs in John’s writings have to do not with the broad question of God’s existence, but with Jesus’ specific redemptive historical claims to be the long-expected Messiah of biblical promise. No, even more. As John’s gospel makes plain, the signs in his writings have to do with Jesus’ specific redemptive historical claims to be the God of Israel come in the flesh. By the same token, The signs in John’s writings have to do not with the question about the reality of a supernatural realm, but with the specific truth about another world tied to the God of the Bible, who gives his people entrance to that world and eternal life in it through faith in Jesus Christ.
The Bible, John included, has no interest in miracles. The Bible, John included, has no interest in miracles. In other words, the Bible, inclusive of John, has no interest in the question, does God exist? Nor does it have interest in the supernatural, for the sake of the supernatural.
The Bible is not into proving to you either God or the supernatural. The Bible, rather, is into declaring to you, preaching to you, who the true God is, and declaring to you the specific reality of the world over which He, through His eternal Son, presides. What the Bible is interested in is the specifics of the religion that it declares, and all of its particulars. This God, no other God, not a God, not a supposition for God, or the possibility that he might exist, some divine being, nondescribed. being stripped down in his attributes, being retarded in his actions, and restrained in all of his glory.
So, I say again to you, that in keeping with the popular interest or even the philosophical interest in the question of miracle, the Bible, inclusive of John, has no interest in miracle along those lines. In John’s Gospel, the signs concern the Messiah’s identity and the content of his redemptive power and intention.
At Cana, Jesus turns water into wine as a sign of his coming ministry in the Spirit. The abundance of the new wine, together with its qualities, speak of the approaching hour, when Christ will bless his church with the superabundance of the best wine. But such wine as this belongs to the realm of eternity. It is the transcendent, superlative wine of glory, and it belongs to the life of the world of eternity, in which Jesus Christ is the center.
The sign at Cana, therefore, is a pointer. It is a signpost within this world to another world altogether, the reality of which is being declared to those who hear. So it is with the other signs in John’s Gospel. The bread and the fish, inexplicably multiplied in the hills along the eastern shores of the Sea of Galilee in John 6, speak about wonderful provision, heavenly bread. They speak about eternal, inexhaustible storehouses over which God is the master. The sight granted to a man born blind in John 9 points to a world where none are blind, just as the raising of Lazarus in John 11 points to a world where no one dies.
All of this is content-specific, not general. All of this is content-specific. These signs which Jesus performs are pointers. In fact, that is why they are called signs. They point. Road signs are pointers to the realities beyond themselves. They are not that reality to which they point. The sign beside the road warning you of an upcoming curve is not the curve. It is a signpost. It is a pointer to something beyond itself. So also are all of Jesus’ signs.
This means, then, that as such these signs are not ends in themselves, they are not, I underscore this, the reality to which they point. Unfortunately, there were those in Jesus’ day for whom the signs were ends in themselves, for whom the signs functioned as the reality to which they wished to be bound.
Jesus, we are told, would not entrust himself to such people. He would not entrust himself to their religion. That is why I read for you the conclusion of John 2. Many believed because of the signs, but Jesus would not entrust himself to them, because he knew that their religion ended with the sign.
That’s where they stopped. He later sharply criticizes those who doubt upon signs. You came after me, he says to the multitudes, because I gave you bread to eat yesterday. You have not comprehended the intention of the sign which I have performed for you, which speaks to you about eternal bread and the fact that I, in my person, am that eternal bread, and that you must partake of me.”
At the end of the Gospel of John, Jesus rebukes Thomas as that one who needs the sign for his religion. and his religious well-being. Many in the contemporary church believe the acquisition of signs and wonders for their own spiritual repertoire is an indication of their maturity, if not their own spiritual superiority. but nothing could be further from the truth. Dependence upon signs and wonders with an attitude that stops at the signs and wonders is not spiritual maturity, but the grossest form of spiritual immaturity. Such expressions of religious devotion live at the level of the sign. The sign is an event in the world.
They live at the level of the event in the world and never transcend to the meaning of the sign. They never go beyond it. Their religion lives at the level of the earth. Signs and miracles for these people become ends in themselves, even a means in a sophisticated theology along these lines to achieve and maintain worldly health and prosperity.
My dear friends, religion left at this level is not Christianity. For in the face of the arrival of the reality to which the signs have pointed, this kind of religion continues to live at the level of the signs, which were never that reality but pointers to it. Religion lived at this level is not Christianity. For in the face of the arrival of the reality to which the signs have pointed, this kind of religion continues to live at the level of the sign, which was never that reality, but a pointer to it.
This is the significance of Jesus’ statement to Mary, My hour has not yet come. What he will do now is provide a sign. He does not give the reality. The reality comes when he dies, when he is raised, when the Spirit is given to the church. But if the signs in John’s Gospel are works performed in the earth now by Jesus that point to heaven and a transcendent reality and truth in God’s kingdom above, the signs in the book of Revelation pertain to transpirings in heaven that point to the earth.
Do you notice the inversion as you move to Revelation 15.1? As we traverse the ground from John’s gospel to the book of Revelation, we end up, as far as the signs are concerned, in precisely the reverse direction. In John’s gospel, the signs were in the earth, performed by Christ, pointing to heaven. In the Revelation, the signs are in heaven, pointing to earth.
The sign in Revelation 15.1 is called another sign, and belongs to a series of signs that commences with the opening verses of chapter 12. There, in chapter 12, verse 1, we have that glorious pregnant woman clothed with the sun, the moon under her feet, a crown of twelve stars on her head. But then we move down to verse 3 of that chapter, and we find another sign, the great red dragon with seven heads and ten horns and seven diamonds. By way of these heavenly signs, Here, in Revelation 12, signs in heaven once more.
The spiritual battle that is taking place, that is working itself out on earth, between the Church of Christ and the forces of Satan, is depicted. And what follows in the next chapters, as you move to the end of the fourteenth chapter of Revelation, in full symbolical style, spells out that great struggle. When we come to chapter 15, the introduction of another sign takes us back to the conception of that struggle in order to present to us, in the course of chapters 15 and 16, yet from another vantage point, the history of that warfare between the Church and the Kingdom of Hell. The signs given John are in heaven. In order that he, and also through him, we ourselves might be assured that this warfare in which we are engaged is not outside of the control of heaven, nor does it progress apart from the assurances of God’s saving purpose and intention, just as much The message of these signs in heaven is that our lives are secure in heaven already, despite the ravages in this world which we are made to endure, despite the sure judgments that overtake us as God works out his judgment upon this world. Indeed, the seven plagues are poured out upon the earth.
But there is one other comment that I must make this morning about these signs in Revelation in order to be fair to God’s Word on this matter. For you see, there are other signs in Revelation. There are other signs than those that are in heaven in the book of Revelation. We have the great signs—same word—the great signs performed in the earth by the second beast described for us in Revelation 13, verses 13 and 14.
These signs are performed by that beast which rises from the earth. He belongs to the earth. Then again, in Revelation 16, the dragon and the false prophet are the source of signs, of many signs. These signs, again, rising from the earth, verse 14 in that sixteenth chapter. And finally, in Revelation 19 verse 20, the false prophet again that presented to us there, his lying signs deceiving the nations, his signs belonging to the administration of the earth.
In other words, the signs in heaven from Revelation 12 and 15 about which we commented first, stand over against the signs from the earth from Revelation 13, 16 and 19. But understand this, the signs in heaven are the only positive signs in the book of Revelation. These are the positive signs for the church.
The signs in the earth now are negative and destructive. Do you see where I’m going? Do you feel the force, the direction of this argument? It is going to be the conclusion of what we have been saying previously about the Gospel of John when it comes to the matter of signs. The signs in heaven in the book of Revelation are the only positive signs. The signs from the earth are those which are negative, destructive. and meant to deceive. In Revelation’s categories, only the signs in heaven now are positive, while all the signs in the earth are not.
There it is. There it is. All the signs in the earth are not. They are deceptions. God is done doing signs. It is powerful stuff, it is overwhelming, and it is chastening to the Church. If you missed it, I will repeat it again, and I plead with you who are young that you listen to this because you are walking into it full face. If it has been difficult for your parents on this score, it is going to be a hundred times more difficult for you, because the deception is multiplying, and it is multiplying in all the unexpected places. I will say it again. Only the signs in heaven now are positive. All the signs in the earth are not.
This is the book of Revelation’s way of telling the Church that the time for the signs from God in the earth—that is, the miraculous demonstrations of His saving purposes—has passed. It is completed. It is done. The biblical record provides us with the account of God’s signs in the earth in which we are to believe—those signs, and only those signs. But the time for them now is past, those signs having served their purpose.
We have now entered the time of the signs in heaven, those signs in fact given us by the Holy Spirit through John the Apostle in the book of Revelation. What so-called signs occur in the earth presently whatever they might be, are not from God. They are not from God. What is particularly sad and tragic is the fact that so many in the church, from high church charismatics to vineyard-style sign and wonders enthusiasts, to the emotionally crippled, immature, and insecure among the Reformed, who have become dissatisfied with the Calvinist doctrine of the Holy Spirit, what is particularly sad is that so many in the Church presently are desperate to make room for signs in the earth.
I’ve got to have them. And if I don’t have them, my faith has no adequate foundation, and I have no vindication and authentication. in my belief. These people press after signs as if their very spiritual vitality depended upon them, as if the entirety of their religious devotion depended upon them. So intense is this movement in them that they have traded the experience with their signs for the experience in and with the reality to which the true signs pointed. They have exchanged their experience with their signs for the reality to which the true signs pointed. They give up the true signs for their experience of their signs. And when this happens, talk about experience, there is no convincing of them, there is no reasoning with them about the errors of their doctrine. They have their experiences with their signs, and that settles it. It’s not as if there isn’t hope.
For some of you were there at one time in your believing. But God has loved you, he has mercy upon you, he has drawn you back to his word and to the true signs. By his grace, he has drawn you by those signs to the genuine reality to which those signs pointed. And he has drawn you on to heaven and the only signs in which and by which you must presently live.
Amen. Father, if this is indeed a day of confusion, a day of deception, we ask Lord for the strength of your spirit and the power of the risen Christ to be at work in us that our doctrine will remain true. We would not be dislodged. We would remain adamant and strong in our conviction that the accomplishment of redemption is sealed. Signs were given to the end that they might point beyond themselves, and they have accomplished their purpose. We live in the day of the signs of heaven, not the signs in the earth. Bless us, Father, with a proper humility, even as we would make appeal to those who are struggling with these questions, asking you that you would help them
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

