SERMON

History of the OPC IV: Finale

January 1, 1996 · Rev. Charles G. Dennison

Book:

Series:

This recording is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison archive, part of the “Lectures” series, delivered January 1, 1996.

About this sermon

Christ’s own words to Pilate, ‘my kingdom is not of this world,’ frame the OPC’s own heavenly-mindedness as it entered the 1940s, still finding its identity against the old-school Presbyterian establishment. Geerhardus Vos’s own theology, unique and largely ignored in his lifetime, is read as the resource the young denomination did not yet know how much it needed. The series closes where it began: with a kingdom not measured by earthly success.

More sermons from John · Browse all sermons

Sermon transcript

And as well, we thank you and praise you for his passive obedience as well. We thank you that because of his active and passive obedience, there is indeed hope, hope of heaven, hope of eternity, hope of being with you throughout all eternity, that the prayer of Christ indeed will in time be answered, that where he is, we might be, that we might share his glory. And we look forward to that time, and with John of old we would cry, even so, come quickly, Lord Jesus. But while time goes on, while that day that only you know and have sat is not yet, we would pray that as well we might, recognizing our position in Christ, seek to be the servants that you would have us to be. to this needy world in which you have placed us and called us. We pray in Jesus name. The text that I have chosen for the beginning of this presentation is John chapter 18 verse 36.

Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight that I should not be delivered to the Jews. But now is my kingdom not from hence. This is the toughest lecture. I realize that the ranks have thinned a bit and I expect that in part that’s because a number of the people that have left realized that they couldn’t stay awake after lunch. So I will not be merciless. By that I mean By that I don’t mean I’ll be shorter. I don’t mean I’ll be shorter, but by that I mean if I see you nodding off, I will not point at you and say something.

Now I concluded the last lecture with a provocative statement, and I realized that. I said the OPC exists for the purpose of recovering in the consciousness of Christ’s church the truth about the other world, and that the OPC’s meaning and mission are intrinsically tied to this issue. And I acknowledge that these statements have the potential of mystifying and even possibly angering some people. Therefore, in this final presentation, I want to fill out these statements a bit and then make some concluding remarks to you.

But before I get into the substance of the lecture, let me make some comments about Orthodox Presbyterian Church distinctiveness. On the one hand, if she is as I have described her, the OPC is a distinctively Orthodox and Calvinistic Presbyterian body which has become what I have called a Presbyterian anomaly. whose very existence challenges the church-culture alliance that pervades the church’s self-understanding, not only in America, but typically throughout the world. So yes, there is a distinctiveness to the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. On the other hand, the OPC is not unique at all. when held up to the biblical definition of the church. Every church is to be defined by Hebrews 13 verse 14. Here we have no continuing city.

The whole church is to be able to confess in the words of Philippians 3.20 that our citizenship is in heaven. And every Christian must follow the Savior who confessed the good confession before Pontius Pilate when he said, My kingdom is not of this world.

Such heavenly mindedness as true Christianity has always acknowledged. does not ruin you for life in the world. Rather, as our God in glory knows, such heavenly mindedness provides the only appropriate and adequate place to stand to be of genuine service in the world. The Son of God, who came from heaven and returned to heaven, had heaven on his mind as he performed his ministry in the world. Obviously, Jesus Christ’s heavenly-mindedness did not ruin him for life in this world.

His true Church must follow him. And it is my judgment that the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, by her existence, not necessarily by her self-understanding, by the providence and by the mercy of God, has been an eloquent and forceful encouragement for the Church of Jesus Christ as a whole to do just this. to live in keeping with the heavenly mindedness that is observed in Christ and prescribed in the Word.

In December 1927, J. Gresham Machen said he could not agree with those Presbyterians who had no zeal to see the Presbyterian Church extended through the length and breadth of the world. Machen counted himself among those who hold the faith of the Presbyterian Church, the great Reformed faith that is set forth in the Westminster Confession, to be true. And holding it to be true, we hold that it is intended for the whole world. But what was the faith of the Presbyterian Church? The great Reformed faith set forth in the Westminster Confession.

Caspar Whistler Hodge, Machen’s colleague at Princeton Theological Seminary and grandson to Charles Hodge, summarized for himself and also for Machen, I judge the Reformed faith, when he wrote these words. Here was that theology that teaches and upholds the majesty and sovereignty of Almighty God, the total inability of fallen man to save himself, and that the whole of salvation is to be ascribed to the power and grace of God. This is simply the pure and consistent form of evangelicalism, which says, with Paul, By grace have ye been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is God’s gift.” This generic Calvinism has been taught under the specific form of covenant theology, so richly developed in the Westminster Confession and grounded in the scripture statement, I will be your God and ye shall be my people. That from Casper Wister Hodge.

But were there significant differences between this transient definition and what the Reformed faith for so many had become? And just as crucial, if not more so, Were there significant differences between this definition and what the Reformed faith ought to be? Was the Reformed faith here in the 20th century much in need of a retooling for the purpose of bringing out more clearly the essential features of its first impress? Such questions as these raise further questions.

Was it possible, for instance, for some to grab hold of Hodge’s use of the word evangelical, I’m sure you noticed it, and massage that word in such a way so as to compromise the strength and distinctiveness of the Reformed faith? Was that possible? Is that conceivable? But further, was it possible that Hodge’s definition, as fine as it is, was not adequate and would have to be subjected to a radical reevaluation because of the nature of those events that were transpiring at the end of the last century, the beginning of this century, specifically as they focused upon the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America?

And if such a re-evaluation was necessary, could the Hodges and the Machens of the Church remain the same in such a re-evaluation? Or would they themselves have to change in order to be true to the genius of the Reformed faith? These crucial questions would be answered in J. Gresham Machen during the remaining years of his life from 1927 to its conclusion. And they would also be answered by the history of that body that has been formed out of his efforts.

To begin with, There were many problems in the conservative Presbyterianism represented by Princeton theological seminaries. Despite the strong stand for doctrine as such, despite the strong stand for the Westminster standards, Despite the high spiritual view of the Church promoted at Princeton, and the heavy emphasis upon Christian nurture and the ordinary means of grace, the Princeton theology and the so-called old-school Presbyterianism were not without their difficulties. The Princeton theology had an over-inflated view of the human intellect, and an undervalued view of history.

In fact, that is what got Charles Hodge in trouble with the Mercerburg theology boys, with Philip Schaff and with John Nevin. As strange as it may sound, Charles Hodge got in over his head, and he was not able to maintain his course because it was shown in the arguments with the Mercersburg boys that he did not know his church history as he should.

It is also true that the Princeton theology had been over-accommodating to the common-sense philosophy of the Scottish realists. I think we all are aware of that problem. The Princeton theology had been somewhat accommodating to certain theological innovations that rose out of the New England theology. Some people question as to whether Samuel Miller should have pursued peace with the New England theology at the point he did in 1817, for instance. Furthermore, as those trained at Westminster Seminary acknowledge, the Princeton theology had a faulty apologetic.

He had a certain weakness for some forms of piety. Charles Hodge declared that all children dying in infancy were indisputably saved, taking exception to the Westminster standards. Moreover, despite Hodge’s dissent, the old school Presbyterians showed certain new-school habits of mind by allowing post-Civil War political pressures to override their theological convictions. And the stalwart B.B. Warfield contributed to the rise of modern evangelicalism by making the Reformed faith merely the most consistent expression of a broader evangelical theology, and by exalting the individual believer above the corporate character of the people of God. His book, The Plan of Salvation, is quite excellent, but as you read it, you will note that fault.

In addition, If all this wasn’t bad enough, the charge has been more recently made, voiced by a number of alumni who had lived through the experience, that the faculty at Princeton, at the turn of the century and in the years, the early years of this century, while personally devoted to a rigorous Calvinism, for whatever reason, did not communicate that devotion in the classroom. They wrote it, but apparently, according to the testimony of many, they did not teach it rigorously in the classroom. Now, what was happening, I cannot say at this point. Possibly it had something to do with the Briggs case in the 1890s. The fact that the popularity of Princeton men and Princeton theology had suffered as a consequence of that.

But by and large, the faculty at Princeton had retrenched, at least in the classroom, away from an aggressive, vigorous, militant Calvinism to the more comfortable position of being the spokesman for a supernatural Christianity over against the outrage of liberalism.

Now, think about the education of J. Greshamation. He goes to Princeton in 1901. He then is educated in a gentleman’s Presbyterianism. at Princeton during this time. The mood is fairly uniform, and Machen’s experience at Princeton fits in well with the mold. But there was one teacher at Princeton during those days who didn’t fit.

He was an alien. He was Dutch. He came from the Christian Reformed Church. He was a man in whom nations seemed to have only relative interests. There are not many comments about him in his letters to his mother, for instance. The man I have in mind is Gerhardus Voss. Voss was an odd person, extremely so.

He was a lonely man as well, an eccentric, on campus. He was a man more often mocked by his students than listened to, and he was generally ignored. I think that all of you who know the halls of academia well recognized the type. And this kind of an individual has probably been the object of your pranks and your caustic remarks as well. As one alumni put it, Voss was a klutz. whose words were so buried beneath his Dutch accent, you couldn’t understand it.

But it was Vos, who more than anyone else, inconspicuous as he was, it was Vos who would force the issue for a proper assessment of the Reformed faith and build towards its further progress. Now why do I say this? Vos was grabbed hold of by the distinguishing feature of Reformed theology, the doctrine of the covenant, and he would not let it go.

And Vos it was who, in pressing the case for the primacy, for consideration of the covenant, pulled Reformed theology back to its roots and away from the primacy of the intellect, the primacy of the mind, which now was fairly much entrenched in Princeton thinking.

The covenantal character of God’s revelation, Vos Saw, establishes the primacy not of the intellect, but of the historical category. In view, then, is the historical unveiling of God’s purpose in covenantal form, mind and evaluation, mind and even definition subordinate to that sovereign activity of God in history. You must lead with the primal biblical category. And the covenant, the reformed doctrine of the covenant, forces you to that conclusion. In other words, the primacy of the act of God, the primacy of the mighty acts of God.

Voss’s position therefore powerfully challenged the old school Presbyterian position that the reformed faith must refute the primacy of the intellect, as it was held among liberals and others, with its own appeal to the primacy of the intellect. You see the problem that was being addressed. we will confront the liberal’s appeal to the primacy of the intellect with our own appeal to the primacy of the intellect. The Reformed faith instead, said Voss, saw Voss, refutes the primacy of the intellect with the primacy of revelation. and the unfolding story of salvation, the Christian story, as Cornelius Van Til called it. But furthermore, Vos would press his case to the very heart of the He was not going to allow the discussion to live at the level of the mere externals of the covenant itself, the arrangement aspects of the covenant, the legal aspects of the covenant, the documented aspects of the covenant.

He was going to go to the very heart of the matter. Now, in order to illustrate this, let me get real homey here. Say your wife, you men, asks you, as she is bound to do, honey, do you love me? And you say, well, of course I do. And you show her your marriage certificate. Are you with me here? You dare not define covenant by appeal merely to the legal aspects of the arrangement. You can’t do that.

Vos saw that you have to press to the very heart of the matter. And in this, he was standing with Calvin, he was standing with the Westminster Divines, He was standing with historic Presbyterianism in its best form. At the center of biblical interest is the believer’s possession of God and God’s possession of the believer. Do you understand what’s going on in the first question and answer of the Catechism? You see it, right? It’s the covenant right there.

The chief end of man is to glorify God and to enjoy Him forever. What does it mean to glorify God? Do you realize that the first instance for the use of the word glory in Scripture doesn’t have to do with God at all? It has to do with Laban, Genesis 31. sons of Laban were concerned that Jacob would steal their father’s glory. What do they mean?

His possession, his wealth. To glorify God means to demonstrate that you are his possession. That’s what it means. But you see then how the catechism answer reverses it. And to enjoy him forever. Not only are we God’s possession, but God gives himself to us to be our possession. That’s it. If you then are sons, you are heirs, joint heirs with Christ, heirs of God. You inherit Him. That’s it. This, Voss said, is only in its perfect realization, of course, found in the higher heavenly eternal world.

It was this which was Adam’s hope in the garden even before sin—to have God and to be in God’s possession. And it is now, in our circumstance, the gift which God presently gives us in Christ, the down payment of which we have received in his Holy Spirit. In its already accomplished truth in Jesus Christ, this becomes the ground, the motivation, the empowerment for all of our behavior. Our ethics flow from this.

Ross’s contention was, here is the Reformed faith’s fundamental principle and promise of progress. And here is the proper biblical response to all foolhardy worldliness, all millennial fantasies. Here is the proper appropriate response that would also prove to be an appropriate antidote to the vanities of rising nationalism and to the comforts of a gentleman’s Presbyterianism.

It would not be until the twenties that a group, a very small group of students in the interests of the heart of Calvinism, would begin to move toward Voss. You know their names. Cornelius Van Til, Ned B. Stonehouse, and John Murray. And it would be these men, together with an earlier devoted student of Voss, R.B. Kuyper, under whom Machen himself, after the founding of Westminster Seminary in 1929, an institution that included these gentlemen, would begin his own re-education. His own re-education.

From them he would learn that the Reformed faith was far more than a gentleman’s Presbyterianism, that Presbyterianism in which he had been raised and trained. In fact, it was far different from even many of its more conservative expressions among American Presbyterians. Now, the struggle in which these matters were worked out struggle in which these matters were worked out during Machen’s lifetime was with American Presbyterian fundamentalists. At the end of his life, Machen, despite the presence of fundamentalists in the newly formed Church, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, Despite the presence of fundamentalists with him, Machen emphatically distanced himself from fundamentals. He stated his case to James E. Bennett, a New York Presbyterian fundamentalist lawyer. Machen, in correspondence with this man, said, I, for my part, am not a fundamentalist at all, but a Presbyterian.

He went further, saying he found no real commitment to the Westminster standards among the fundamentalists. He found no real proper biblical view of office. He found a tendency towards millennial extremism and towards the heresies of dispensationalism. And he also found an unbiblical legalism that violated the canons of Christian liberty.

But beneath these very pointed objections was the rabid nationalism that for all the pre-millennial pessimism of the fundamentalists about this world was very much alive in them. As George Marsden has pointed out, American Presbyterian fundamentalism was as much alive with the activist, nationalist, crusading spirit as was American Presbyterian liberalism. After the Third General Assembly, June 1 through 4, 1937, the Fundamentalists would leave the New Church in order to start their own, the Bible Presbyterian Synod.

They would be led by Carl McIntyre, J. Oliver Buswell, Al McRae, and H. McAllister Griffiths, all men who were convinced that the OPC had come under an un-American influence. At the root of that concern was not just the figures of Kuyper, Stonehouse, Van Til and Murray, but Gerhardtus Voss. Stonehouse and Murray, as well as Kuyper, were arguing their case against the premillennial dispensationalism abroad in the church by an appeal to Voss. The argument was over his influence and the direction he was proposing.

These then MacIntyre, Buswell, McCrae, Griffiths, and others withdrew in the interests of their version and vision for American Presbyterians. They were unable to see the value and the glory of the New Church in transcending the nationalism and worldliness that had become so much a part of the American Presbyterian scene. Now, it would be in the 1940s, after Machen’s death, that the OPC would face two further challenges that confirmed its identity. The first was with a Presbyterian elitism a residual mainline Presbyterianism that had survived in many moneyed families, including Machen’s own, and in certain individuals who aspired to the cultural standing and influence of the mainline Presbyterian Church.

The chief figure representing the elitist position was Edwin H. Ryan. Ryan wrote an excellent book, back there on the table, entitled The Presbyterian Conflict. But at the same time, he dreamt of the OPC as a large Presbyterian church with the cultural clout of the mainline church.

He wanted a church that would recapture a place of power and usefulness in the life of America. Those are his words. He made two major efforts in the 1940s to realize his goal. In 1941, he masterminded at the 8th General Assembly of the OPC, the organization of the so-called Committee of Nine. At the next assembly, this committee expressed its commitment to a program which saw the OPC as a church to meet the needs of this generation, have an increasing area of influence, and make a greater impact on life today.

But the assembly rejected the committee’s proposals. and the committee was abandoned. Ryan next concentrated his energies on the Christian University Project, an effort by Presbyterian and Reformed people to develop a distinctively Calvinistic university in this country. But Ryan, who served the University Association as General Secretary, was determined to mold the university along elitist lines. And when it became suspected that he was misusing association funds to achieve his goal, he was fired. This happened in the fall of 1946. In the spring of the following year, he left the OPC in disgrace. and return to the PCUSA and to the elitism of that church which he had never actually forsaken.

The other challenge the OPC would face in the forties that would confirm the church’s identity as a vigorously reformed church, driven at root by a transcendent interest, was from the rising tide of the New Evangelicalism. Now, getting a handle on the neo-evangelical movement is not an easy matter, but let me offer to you a few suggestions. Neo-evangelicalism is a reaction to fundamentalism, wishing to be free from the counterproductive aspects of fundamentalism’s reputation, in the interest of better access to and acceptance in American culture. Neo-evangelicalism is fundamentalism made respectable.

What it craves is an equal footing, a place of an equal within American society. I cite as an illustration of this the recent statement by Ralph Reed, the leader, the executive director of the Christian Coalition. He captured the sentiment of the neo-evangelical movement well, applying it to his own effort, when he recently said that the coalition had become a significant force in American politics. Quote, we have gained what we have always sought, a place at the table. Unquote. That’s a bit short-sighted. But such adolescent short-sightedness as this has become the calling card of neo-evangelicalism.

Such an attitude and disposition was sufficiently attracted to many in the OPC in the 1940s for them to make great concessions to it. This is what lay at root in the famous Clark-VanPhil debate. There were many important and profoundly complex doctrinal issues involved in that debate. Issues such as the free offer of the gospel, the fiducial aspect of faith, and most importantly, the incomprehensibility of God. All of these were on the table.

Some in the OPC who had no real understanding of the theological issues, in fact, they would have been opposed to Clark if they had rightly grasped what he was saying, nevertheless gravitated toward him because he represented to them a means by which they could re-enter American culture and church life. That was the overriding concern.

The Church was not to be a backwater movement. It was to have the position of prominence in order to make an impact upon the society and the culture. Clark became a figurehead in this movement for many who couldn’t have cared less about the particulars of his position concerning the incomprehensibility of God. Clark was ordained to the OPC ministry in 1944, and his ordination survived an appeal process, even to the General Assembly. So that stood. Clark was ordained. He was a minister in the OPC.

On many accounts of what went wrong, the Clark supporters felt that they had the support necessary in order to win the election. One account was that Pastor Dean Adair, a Clark supporter, was so distressed by the manners of the Clark party that he switched his vote at the last minute. Others cite the fact that ruling elder Cyrus Ferguson from Kirkwood, Pennsylvania, flew out to the General Assembly meeting at Cedar Grove, Wisconsin, and arrived just in time to cast his vote. At any rate, the Clark Party lost in its bid to gain control of the Foreign Missions Committee, and they lost by one vote. By the next assembly, Clark, and the majority of his supporters had left the Church. A number of them went back into mainline Presbyterianism. The common element in each of these struggles, be it with the Fundamentalists in the 30s or the Elitists or the Neo-Evangelicals in the 40s, is the desire of these groups to offer the OP a way back into the culture, back into a national identity.

In God’s providence, the OPC has not as yet taken the bait. To this day, the OPC remains a Reformed and Presbyterian church without a cultural bridge That is, without a means back into the American mainstream. The question was asked to me, why is the OPC small? Why doesn’t the OPC grow at a faster rate? Why aren’t there more people in the OPC? Let me tell you something. Given the OPC’s identity, it is amazing that there is anybody in the OPC. Each one of you is a testimony to the grace of God.

Humanly speaking, this church should not exist. It should not have survived. It should not be here. It is the absence of just such a cultural bridge that accounts in some measure for the smallness of the denomination. Do you realize what happens? People walk into your churches and they perceive, they can’t articulate it, they can’t put it down in writing, they can’t state it even. Something isn’t right. They sense it. There is something here with which they cannot identify.

And I might add that it is the absence of just this cultural bridge that provides the reason for the breakdown of union talks with other Presbyterian bodies. This is it. It really isn’t those popular issues that were raised. Well, you know, the OPCs don’t really believe in evangelism, and they’re a bunch of theological nitpickers, so we don’t want to get together with them. Smokescreen.

The real reason for the breakdown in the Union talks with other Presbyterian bodies. is right here. The OPC lacks the cultural bridge. The 1975 attempt at union with the former Reformed Presbyterian Church Evangelical Synod collapsed because the Reformed Presbyterian Church Evangelical Synod was the child of fundamentalism and maintained a cultural vision that could not accept OPC disenfranchisement. Along similar lines, the O.P.’ ‘s attempts at union with the P.C.A. in the eighties collapsed. Much at issue here, although never isolated in the discussion, were the P.C.A.’ ‘s cultural aspirations.

You don’t talk about these things. It’s the ethos of the Church. These aspirations are very much at the center of the PCA’s identity and rise out of an evangelical social vision of which a large, influential, if not dominant, national church is an indispensable part. That is the PCA’s identity. That is what they are about. My thesis has been Historically, the OPC has not shared this vision. It cannot agree with it. The OPC, as was the case with J. Gresham Machen himself, has been forced to a higher vision.

She with the patriarchs is forced to desire a better country that is a heavenly one. She has been stamped with an other worldliness that demands further development and progress in her members as to how they, rather than seeking to regain the world they lost, might be of service to their Lord in this world.

Such service will insist upon the priority of the heavenly consciousness in the pursuit of any task. Such consciousness the fruit of our union with Christ in keeping with the word. This one who even now is in heaven. Beginning here We always begin with and by grace are always in a position of laboring out of what we have not out of what we don’t have. Such labor is progressively informed by God’s gracious provision through his word for expression in the worship of the church in the means of grace in the marks of the church in the ministry and mission of the people of God in the care and counseling of others in the mutual life with fellow believers.

Think of it. A consciousness that rises above thoughts about securities and rewards in this world. You want to talk about freedom, friends? Let’s talk about freedom. a consciousness that rises above thoughts about security and rewards in this world, that is not held captive by the evening news, or by the political prospects of this party or that, or when it comes to ministry, the prospect of a large, successful enterprise. with statistics you can boast about. Think of it, a consciousness that so stands in the liberty of the sons of God, so confident of God as the true and only reward for God’s people, of heaven as the true and only destination for those who here have no continuing city, that it enables us to be of greatest help to the multitude of churches in this land and in the world. We encouraging them with all humility to look above to the Lord, the Savior of the ends of the earth.

Thank you. Take a few minutes for a question. John Frayman in his evangelical reunion suggests that the default position I’m not sure. I know he mentioned John frame and he mentioned his book on the evangelical reunion. Yeah. Okay. Well I’m not sure that I can defend all of the argumentation that. went into the JNR situation from the side of those who were opposed to joining and receiving, for instance.

As far as the ecumenical obligation that is on us, you see, my position is that you always view the imperative in light of the indicative. I mean, okay, what would I say? All right, any command given us by God out of his word must flow from the accomplishment which God himself has worked. And that’s Calvinism, really. Okay, so any obligation that I have must flow from the already accomplished work of God. You’re with me, all right? You understand that much, right?

But if you take that and you apply that to the whole matter of ecumenicity, for instance, you cannot proceed in ecumenicity if you have already allowed to slip from your hand the reality of the union that is yours in Christ, a consciousness of that truth. And I believe consciousness of that truth, as it’s worked itself out, will force us in the direction that the OPC has gone.

It will force us to consider more thoroughly our union with Christ, and that is the foundation out of which we then work. It’s not, therefore, talking to this person and talking to that church and endearing by our own wits and by our own imaginations to construct a unified church. in response to the so-called ecumenical imperative. The command laid upon us to work for unity must flow forth from the unity that already exists for the body of Christ in himself. And therefore, such unity that is observed in us is not to our credit. We don’t pat ourselves on the back and say, We’ve got all these differences ironed out, we’re all back together, we’ve got this wonderful thing going, we’ve moved beyond nationalism, we’ve moved beyond ethnicity, we’re now, you know, doing these wonderful things. Any expression of genuine biblical unity for the body of Christ is merely an entering into the unity that already exists in Him. So it is completely and thoroughly of grace.

Now, from what I, the little I know, and I have tried to work through a little bit of John’s book, I don’t remember that kind of language being brought to the discussion. So in a sense, I’m, you know, I say this isn’t particularly helpful. Now, I think that there are other reasons why John’s approach isn’t particularly helpful and that is that I think that there is a tendency in his writings to be somewhat historically naive or shall I say, do I dare say it?

Yeah, see the OPC couldn’t win and that’s that’s also what I I I personally take exception to in the analyses that have been offered by some. If we, if they voted not to receive us, it was our fault. If we voted not to go in, it was our fault. We could not win in the minds of some. And that just merely reveals the attitude of mind, you know, the attitude of soul at work in the situation. We could not please. regardless. This doesn’t obviate at all, in any sense, the necessity for us to work towards unity.

And I could go through the OPC’s ecumenical philosophy, and I agree with it 100%. And that is that, first of all, we view ourselves as a Catholic Church. That’s primary. We view ourselves as a Catholic Church with international interest and concern that we’re not going to be locked up into some sort of provincialism that that basically a wall in because of the boundaries of this country and other we have a worldwide vision. And that that the commitment that I think is is is very important for understanding the O.P.C. in its ecumenical pursuits.

And that is another reason why we had a great deal of difficulty in working our way through the ecumenical proposals, because we were being asked to choose between two kinds of ecumenicity. It’s getting harder to talk. We had to choose between two forms of ecumenicity. If we go the R.P.C.S. direction, if we go the P.C.A. direction, there is a certain provincialism to which we must submit ourselves.

But in remaining what we were, we can still cultivate and develop this Catholic interest, which is to see Reformed and Calvinist and Presbyterian churches in fellowship worldwide. helping each other. I think John was first in the back. Yes, there are multiple questions. There are multiple issues involved in that question, and that has to do with the question of whether the cultural bridge had anything to do with those who left the denomination after the failure of Jan R. I definitely think that that is the case. I think that the church growth movement, and to a certain degree, the new life movement, insofar as it was influenced by the church growth movement, had those kinds of convictions.

They led with the card of evangelism. Now, see, everything I say gets me into trouble. And somebody will walk away, he’s against evangelism. No, no, no, no. But it’s as the OP has been stating all along, evangelism is unto the end of worship. So evangelism can’t be the goal. It is the means to the goal. The goal is the increased worship of God by those who are being gathered in.

But there was a tendency in the New Life group and in the Church Growth group to move in the direction of the primacy of evangelism. And I think that that moved it away from an OP understanding of things generally. I think that there are other factors. The new, the church growth movement was very much into technique.

I mean, you know what I mean. They had bought into the technique approach to developing, growing a church. It’s only a matter of the right method. You use the right method, it will succeed. And strangely enough, it would succeed for the JWs, the Mormons, the Buddhists. It didn’t matter who it was. You just plug in. You see? The technology’s neutral. You just plug in.

But you see there’s an interesting connection between the church growth movement mentality and the new life mentality. What was interesting, what was influencing Jack Miller as the new life movement was taking shape, was John Wesley’s journal. Now he will tell you that. And what was the consequence of John Wesley’s journal and his theology, this turn towards the experiential, this elevation of aspects within the human personality?

It was Methodism. You get the connection? We’ve got religious Methodism here, we’ve got religious technology over here. There’s a hand in glove or a hand-in-hand kind of relationship between the two. So I think that yes, you see this movement away from what we would consider to be historic classic Calvinism and not much sympathy for the disenfranchisement of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. Yeah, yeah, yeah. As far as I’m concerned, this must be at the forefront of our ecumenical policy with regard to not only churches in this country, but throughout the world. It has to be at the forefront, particularly in our foreign missions efforts. You realize what’s happening to the churches in the third world. You think the forces of nationalism here are rather subtle. They are incredibly, oh, you know, overt. blatant in other places in the world.

These people are under the gun. You have the case of the church in Indonesia. The church in Indonesia is told, the Reformed Church is told, if they want to be licensed, they must join the WCC. The state is making that determination. What do they do? Well, unfortunately, they joined. But what does the O.P. have to say to that? Not just by sending them a letter or sending them a position paper, but by its very existence. No, you do not have to do that. Make your stand. We’re with you. And to the extent we can, we will enter into the suffering with you. We will bear it with you.

What’s happening in Africa? As these churches start taking shape, the pressures of nationalism on these churches is unbearable. And what does the OP say? What is the OP message? You must not be in a culturated church. You must stand in a transcendent position with us. In a position that then transcends all national barriers and all racial and ethnic barriers. You must stand with us. You must stand in Ephesians 2.

There’s a lot of work to be done, and I feel that God in his providence is pushing us in these directions in our foreign missions policies and approach. Mark Beale is a wonderful man. He understands much of this. Our ecumenical Committee as well is seeing it more clearly, what kind of help, what kind of service will they be to these struggling, emerging churches in the world. We have a glorious message and a marvelous stand that we can put before them that hopefully will be a blessing.

Well, it may seem like a contradiction to what I’ve been saying, but I do wish that the OPC did have some men of the stature of Machen and Van Till and Murray and Kuiper today, and we don’t. And the question is, what are we going to do? Well, I know what I’m going to do.

In my own halting way, I’m going to keep preaching it, and as other men in the churches are going to do, but it’s not altogether a negative. The loss of those stalwart theologians pushes us, we who are ministers, we who are ruling elders in the church, to become extremely proficient in the Word and in our identity. We are forced to it. The strength is not going to come from some central theological clearinghouse, it seems.

Okay, so what are we going to do? We’re going to be forced to do a lot of work ourselves. And that may mean that our churches have to undergo some bit of a transformation in their own consciousness, they have to encourage their pastors to study, to work, to think these things through clearly and effectively. They have to give them time to do that.

Churches have to insist on not just passable sermons, but profound sermons. Give me more than I would get down the street at the typical fundamentalist evangelism, certainly more than we would get at the liberal church. You’ve given me more than we would get from an Arminian congregation. It could be an opportunity. The question of a theological seminary continues to be debated in the denomination.

There are discussions right now about that. The usefulness to our denomination of the Westminster campuses, we all recognize that there has been a change. East and West in relationship to the OPC. And yes, we’re suffering as a result of that. So let’s see what the Lord will do. Yes? There’s probably some truth in that. Yes, the question is, what do I say to those who say that the OPC is exclusivistic and looks down its nose at other sincere, genuine believers? I would say that there is a major major of truth to that but at the same time.

I really I really do not. I have never run into anyone in my experience for the O.P.C. And that includes my father-in-law. Bob Graham. that believes or believe that the O. P. C. was the only true church of the world. I mean we realize that was a joke when that name was proposed and that certainly in my experience has not been the attitude that I have found amongst O. P. I mean there is there is a great camaraderie there is a sense of fellowship that should be you find that anywhere within a denominator within denomination There is a strength to those connections, but I have not been aware of people who had the attitude that the OPC was the only true church.

And I have found that the OPs have been very solicitous. They have been very generous. I think that the conviction of OPs has generally been that you don’t have to believe in election to be a lot. Am I am I right. OK. OK. So we can we can graciously and properly. Extend ourselves to others who don’t believe in election. And hopefully we won’t do that in a particularly condescending manner. No, I’m not going to take this is what I’m going to give somebody else. OK, yes, and I hear this. This also gets me into trouble, of course, but the question is, what’s the proper way to take the gospel into the world? Yes, right.

I think one of the primary things is to recognize, recognize the the place, the role that the church has. The OPC is if not by express statement at least by practice and by parachurch. Counter parachurch. So we have been adamant in in in in the position that this is the church is that we take the Westminster Confession chapter twenty five paragraph three very seriously at least in terms of our practice in the past. which sees that the that the scriptures and the ministry and the and the proclamation of the gospel belong to the church they don’t belong there. So that’s first if we’re settled on that question we move ahead and so if the church is tapped out and now we got the question of of who in the church does this well again now we’re faced with a debate with it in the O.P.C. there are those who say well now you see you have the ordained the ministers of the word who are charged with this responsibility It is their job to preach and proclaim the word. They are the official proclaimers of the gospel. I agree with that position. This is where the official proclamation of the gospel takes place. What does that mean? Does that mean that we who are in the pew then are shackled? We cannot share our faith. We’re somehow indifferent. Heavens, no. But what you are doing is not preaching the gospel. Please understand that.

It is living the Christian life. And in the Christian life, you are sharing what you are. You are communicating what you are by what you say, what you do. It’s part of the Christian walk. But it isn’t specifically and narrowly defined preaching the gospel that belongs to those who have been ordained in the church for that purpose. So I think that that’s but ministers need to be encouraged to be proclaiming the gospel faithfully and fearlessly. Thinking of ways that they can get their message out into the community. Yet all of that there, and I think that at the same time, the ministry of the word must also be concerned that the people in the pew are are are living their Christian confession and by living that Christian confession, their words and their deeds are communicating the gospel and they’re not giving themselves an excuse for not doing so.

I might come back to the great reformational recovery of vocation. That has been lost in Reformed consciousness. I think that many of you realize that, where Luther and Calvin saw that our Christian obligation is to do our jobs well, before the Lord and for the Lord. So, if I’m an engineer, if I’m a politician, if I’m a teacher, if I’m an insurance agent, if I’m a housewife, whatever I am, I do this job before the Lord and for the Lord. keeping in mind the heavenly goal and orientation of my existence. And now you see what happens with the evangelical consciousness on this matter and fundamentalist consciousness.

The only real job you have is evangelizing. The only reason you have a job is to evangelize your fellow workers. Now it’s important that your fellow workers know where you stand. I believe that. conduct yourself in a way that the gospel is communicated. But your primary task is not as an evangelist. Your primary task is as a machinist, or that’s your calling. That’s your responsibility. That’s what God wants you to do. And I think if we can recover something of that, we will again have some pleasure in our work. Thank you, Charlie. We appreciate it.

The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.