This sermon is from the Rev. Charles G. Dennison sermon archive, part of the “Misc. Matthew sermons” series, and was preached at Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Sewickley, PA, during a worship service on Sunday, February 26, 1989.
About this sermon
John the Baptist’s death, just prior in Matthew’s narrative, already anticipates Jesus’ own, and the walking on water that follows is read as Jesus preparing his disciples for exactly that death. The boat on the water carries real symbolic weight for both Christ and the disciples together. What the scene finally promises is Christ’s own spiritual presence with the church, even in his physical absence.
Sermon transcript
going to be a bit adventurous and turn to Matthew’s Gospel and look at verses 22-33. Matthew’s Gospel, Chapter 14, verses 22-33. to the word of God. And immediately he made the disciples get into the boat and go ahead of him to the other side, while he sent the multitudes away.
And after he had sent the multitudes away, he went up to the mountain by himself to pray. And when it was evening, he was there alone. But the boat was already many stadiums away from the land, battered by the waves, so the wind was contrary. And in the fourth watch of the night, he came to them, walking upon the sea. And when the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were frightened, saying, It is a ghost.
They cried out for fear. But immediately, Jesus spoke to them, saying, Take courage. It is I. Do not be afraid. And Peter answered him and said, Lord, if it is you, me to come to you on the water.” And he said, come. And Peter got out of the boat and walked on the water and came toward Jesus. But seeing the wind, he became afraid, and beginning to sink, he cried out, saying, And immediately Jesus stretched out his hand and took hold of him, and said to him, Little you of little faith, why did you doubt? And when they got into the boat, the wind stopped. Those who were in the boat worshiped him, saying, You are certainly God’s son.
Our Father, we pray that our faith would be such that we would lay hold of all of the certainties that belong to us despite the fact that we must live by faith and not by sight. O Lord, may your word minister to us so that we would not be frightened by the matters and concerns of this world, and place ourselves with confidence in your hands. O God, we ask you that we might be benefited by the calm that comes because of Christ. So, Lord, we are served by you. that we might be at peace with ourselves. Now, Lord, as we reflect on your word, may there be, as we have prayed, those certainties and assurances built up for us. We ask in Jesus’ name. Amen.
This passage has been going round and round in my head for a couple of weeks now, ever since we had the occasion to review it in our family worship, reading the story as it was presented for us by Mary Ann Radius in her book, God With Us. the account of the New Testament, putting words that are appropriate for young readers. It’s the story of Jesus and the disciples, the boat on the sea, Jesus coming to them, his disciples walking on the water.
So rather than returning tonight as I had intended to, the story of Elisha, I have decided to attempt some treatment of this passage this evening. Now you might just judge that I chickened out because the passage that I was going to return to is that that had to do with the floating access. And you’re just as good as mine as to what to do with that. But here we are this evening in Matthew 14. The scene is set for us by what we find in the opening twelve verses of the chapter. That is an account of the death of John the Baptist. Now, let that sink in.
The death of John the Baptist, so that in verse 13 we have, Now, when Jesus heard it, he withdrew from there in a boat to a lonely or desolate place by himself. So there is this impact upon Christ, registered by the death of John, this one who was the precursor of his own ministry. It most definitely then, this death of John, it most definitely precipitates a crisis. It’s almost as if with the death of John there comes an anticipation for Christ of his own. The seriousness of it all settling in upon him in an unprecedented way. The cost to John of his ministry now pressing in upon Jesus, the cost of his ministry sure to fall. for one death begetting the other.”
Jesus reviewing those circumstances, is it too far for us to go in suggesting that Jesus shudders? But this brings in view, then, the fact that Jesus, in his death, will in fact be taken away from this world. There will be a withdrawal for him. So we move into verses 13 through 21, and the story of the feeding of the 5,000. As Jesus withdraws, there is something of a death taking place even there, as his withdrawal anticipates the separation of himself from the world. So it will be when Christ dies. he will be taken out of the world, away from the world, in his flesh. And his people will be left, as it were, to abide in a desolate place, a wilderness, while he is in his body, absent from them.
His absence does not mean that he is forgotten. He withdraws, but the world seeks him. The multitudes still come after him. But the way in which Jesus now treats this circumstance of the multitude’s pursuit is as if he were not there, and that conveyed through the instruction that he gives to the disciples that are present with him. The multitudes go out to meet him, to seek after him, and they find themselves in a wilderness, in the wilderness of this world, a desolate place. They themselves, there, just as Christ has been before them. For they, in seeking him, have become a pilgrim people. a people who truly have no abiding city here. But we have suggested that the way in which Jesus will treat the multitude and the circumstance, this situation, is along the lines of his coming absence.
For when the day draws on toward the evening, The disciples beseech him to send the multitudes away that they might find something to eat, that they might not faint. But Jesus, in verse sixteen, tells his disciples, you give them something to eat. As if they have the resources As if they were the ones equipped, as if he was not even there at all, they were the ones to whom then the multitudes were to look for their provision. Is it not significant then that after The loaves and the fishes are multiplied in that story, and the five thousand are fed. We are told that twelve baskets full of fragments were taken up and one for each of the disciples. The provision remains there to dispense.
The story then anticipates a time in which Jesus will not be present. And those who are the disciples of Christ will have the resources given them of Christ, by which then the multitudes of the world will be fed and satisfied. Jesus fully expects them in that day in which he is withdrawn from this world, his disciples, capable of ministering to the multitude of humanity that seek him. Well, it won’t be merely a physical bread you see that is supplied. I don’t know many ministers today who have been at work multiplying loaves and fishes The supply, you see, is spiritual.
The bread that is multiplied that day is indicative of a greater print by which the multitudes of the earth will be satisfied, if in fact they can be satisfied So that sets the tone, you see, the death of John, anticipating the death of Jesus, John’s removal, anticipating Jesus’ removal, the disciples present and in their presence in the world with Jesus removed, they then to be capable of supplying with that provision that he provides what is necessary for the sustenance of all of those that would seek life from Christ, the people fed by the Word.
But now we move on to this story we read, verses 22-33, and Jesus upon the water. As if one would wobble were not enough. Jesus, there in verse 13, having withdrawn initially, now there is a subsequent withdrawal. There is more yet to teach. There is more instruction to be given along these lines. Here, the multitudes themselves are not central, but the disciples themselves. The cycles are central to this event, not the wilderness, not desolated place, out in the wilderness, but the sea, the wind, the waves, the storm. These become central for the story.
Here, as Jesus withdraws, once more there will be underscored the fact that Christ, in his body, in his flesh, will withdraw from this world. And not just from the world, but from his disciples. There will be a seeming separation between him and his church. And Jesus is the one who forces the issue. It’s something that is under his control. Read well that twenty-second verse, and immediately he made better read. He compelled the disciples to get into the boat and forced them to leave. The separation is not their choice, it’s his.
So, the disciples launch out upon the sea. If that land, that territory into which the multitudes came, spoke of a wilderness and suggested then privation and need such as only Christ could answer, now we are upon the sea. We are upon troubled waters. The wind comes, the storm rages. it is contrary to the movements of the ship that is on the sea. Here is indicated for us all of those powers that conspire to set themselves against the Church of Christ, for that is, after all, what those disciples are in that boat, the Church. Forced to separate at 22nd verse, anticipating Christ’s voluntary withdrawal from his Church he in his body, in his flesh, being taken away from his church seemingly. The boat upon the waters is nothing less than the church herself, opposed by all of those elements in the created order, be they seen or unseen, that set themselves against the Church and her progress. Most specifically, the waves torment the Church. Most specifically, the wind is contrary to the Church. As it seems as if there is no progress for her. As if she is getting nowhere. In the midst of her perplexing circumstance, there comes to her. Her savior. Walking upon the waters. The troubled sea.
Through the wind. he comes to them with the message of resurrection, with the message of power. That by him and through him she herself shall prevail, she shall be triumphant. Who are frightened at what they see, but he extends to them the comforts of glory. Take courage, it is I. Don’t be afraid. What is it out of this gospel specifically, then, that this message would register upon our souls and conscience. Is it not the fact that the Church, in all of her striving, in all of her labors, may well be convinced that she makes little progress, gets nowhere. But yet, in the midst of all that is set against her, she is certain of triumph in the end, Her Savior comes to her, ministering to her in her need. And by root of that, victory is given. Triumph is accomplished. We have as well the incident of Peter. the church represented by this figure, too? Hesitant with regard to the claims of Christ? Drawing back? Doubtful? If it’s really you, Lord, command that I might come to you on the waters.
The invitation is given by Christ Christ extending it to his people, they then venturing forth in their conformity to him. As Christ is on the waters, so Peter as well. As Christ is on the waters, so Peter is on the waters in his conformity to the Savior.
The church then ventures out in confidence not taking heed to all that is contrary, the wind itself blowing, but it is unnoticed until finally it is noticed indeed. The Church is overwhelmed in her lack of faith, and she begins to sink. Christ’s admonition comes As mercy is extended to his church, and he chides her for her unbelief, how could she doubt?
This one brings calm as he enters the boat. Progress is achieved with him on board, and the disciples acknowledge him through worship and a confession that he is truly the Son of God. That’s the story. It is a story not simply about the cycles in the first century or one of them Peter. It is a story that is meant for the church as a whole. For the entirety of her time.
When she is separated from her Lord, he absent from her in his body, they then expected to carry on in his absence. How real that faith portrayed here. The apprehension of the Christ who comes to his people through all of the troubles that assail her, bringing to his church that confirmation of her faith that she does not in fact believe in vain. What is it that conspires to rob the church of her confidence.
There are the waves themselves, the wind that is contrary. Very interestingly, in verse 30 we are told that Peter saw the wind. If he did, he is the first to ever. The impact of that statement, however, is to register itself upon us, because you see there is a substantial approach to the wind that Matthew intends in the telling of the story in this way. The wind was contrary, verse 24. Verse 30, Peter sees the wind.
That is, you see, he saw all those things that were in fact contrary, and he believed the contrary things. He takes his eye off Christ, he sees the things that are contrary, set against the progress of the Church, those things that are seemingly contrary to the faith itself, and in that, you see, he is submerged. His faith fails, doubt triumphs.
What of the Church as a whole? I will start with the collective aspects of the application of this passage. The Church as a whole, she too laboring against remarkable odds, all of the factors of nature, of the creative order, seen and unseen, conspiring against her that she not reach her appointed end, that she not make progress, that she be overwhelmed. We make the mistake, do we not, imagining that the Church of the first century was somehow, some kind of glorious assembly, innumerable in number, unable to be counted, as if it was credible occurrence comparable to what we have witnessed in our own time. Maybe church is just growing up overnight. Littlefloss, rather. That’s, you see, what was the standard of the day. The church of that day, looking at herself and saying, how can it be possible that such a little flock like this can have any impact?
How is it ever going to be able to stand up to all the forces that conspire against her? How shall she succeed? She won’t succeed at all. It’s impossible for her to succeed. But in the midst of all of that, there comes to her that one who seems to be a ghost, a spirit, if you will, disembodied. as if he in the spirit comes to her to convince her of the triumph that is hers, that is assured to her.
In her missionary activities, she sends them out to the ends of the earth, the known world at that time. What about today, the ends of the earth now? What about Japan, a land that has been particularly Resistance to the message of the gospel will be a penetration. What can we look for as the church sits in the midst of that land? Any kind of success whatsoever are not the fees of this world and the wind. Contrary there will the church be victorious? Yes, you shall. Yes, you should. You take stock of your own denomination. The Orthodox Church, the Syrian Church, you look at her, you say, nothing spectacular here, there’s nothing to delay over long years.
Why in the world would I throw in my lot with that sorry lot of people? Why would I throw in my lot with something spectacular, something that can extend to assurances that I’m part of something that is making a difference in the world. Why in the world would I ever give myself to such an enterprise as that?
And what of yourselves? If we start with the Church as a whole and move on to the individual, if you are a leader of these folks, that’s another step down in the water. which is battering waves in a contrary way. What about humans and their own personal lives? You know, beings have tried to say what I can do, and no one controls it. Aren’t we weird? Only if you look at that one who comes to you upon the race and has the power without a boat to stay afloat. I think even Robert Schiller would have liked that. All right. In the midst of it all, he extends a hand to you even though you faltered. He grabs you and you cry out, Lord save me. And he’s faithful to do just that. There comes, though, his interrogation of you and your faith has faltered. Why did you doubt? Why did you doubt? Don’t you know I love you?
Well, whether you’re In the desolated place, or on the sea, in either circumstance, Jesus absent in his body, in his flesh, be assured of your triumph nonetheless. You by faith endure. You by faith are saved. O Lord, we ask you that with regard to your Church we would have confidence and hope. With regard to ourselves, nothing less. The assurances afforded us through Christ would be even more and more confirmed in our souls. We would be content to live by faith. All the things may be contrary to us, but Lord, we know with you, we shall triumph. In Jesus name.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.


