About this sermon
After breakfast by the sea, Jesus asked Peter three times, “Do you love me?” and restored him with the charge to feed his sheep. He told Peter how he would die and called him to follow, and when Peter asked about John, Jesus answered, “What is that to you? You follow me.” The Christian life is marked by dying and rising with Christ, and believers trust and obey him in their own calling without envying the path he gives to others.
Sermon transcript
You may be seated, please. If you haven’t already turned, let me invite you to turn to the passage we’ll be considering. John 21 verses 15 through 25. The last little section of the last chapter of the Gospel of John. Let me read that in our hearing.
When they had finished breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these? He said to him, Yes, Lord, you know that I love you. He said to him, Feed my lambs. He said to him a second time, Simon, son of John, do you love me?” He said to him, yes, Lord, you know that I love you. He said to him, tend my sheep. He said to him the third time, Simon, son of John, do you love me? Peter was grieved because he said to him the third time, do you love me?
And he said to him, Lord, you know everything. You know that I love you. Jesus said to him, feed my sheep. Truly, truly, I say to you, when you were young, you used to dress yourself and walk wherever you wanted. But when you are old, you will stretch out your hands and another will dress you and carry you where you do not want to go. This he said to show by what kind of death he was to glorify God.
And after saying this, he said unto him, Follow me. Peter turned and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the one who also had leaned back against him during the supper and had said, Lord, who is it that is going to betray you? When Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, Lord, what about this man? Jesus said to him, if it is my will that he remain until I come, What is that to you? You follow me. So the saying spread abroad among the brothers that this disciple was not to die. Yet Jesus did not say to him that he was not to die. But if it is my will that he remain until I come, what is that to you?
This is the disciple who is bearing witness about these things and who has written these things. And we know that his testimony is true. Now, there are also many other things that Jesus did where every one of them to be written. I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written.
Let’s pray again. Father, we thank you that we have, even in this moment, life and breath with which to not only give You praise, but now hear the reading, but especially the preaching of Your Word now. And we would pray that You would make it effectual to us for our salvation, for our sanctification. As You have gathered us, would You so perfect us by this, Your holy counsels. So take this Word, Lord. Take the words of my mouth. the meditations of our hearts, may they be acceptable in your sight, O Lord, our rock and our redeemer. Amen.
I haven’t quite quantified this, but it would not, I don’t think it would be an exaggeration to say that the OPC has had the most profound effect on me in terms of learning the faith once delivered. I don’t think that’s an exaggeration. Attended seminary started by Machen. Had a number of OPC professors. The council of a deacon in Covenant OPC church down on Grand Boulevard in the Wilkinsburg section of Pittsburgh. He probably, to this day, doesn’t know how his brief two-minute greeting and counsel set a trajectory for my vocational and theological life.
And of course, I’ve read many books and things from OPC pastors, so I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that it’s been the OPC and God’s providence that has been most instrumental in my life becoming acquainted, deeply acquainted, with the faith once delivered. I’m so profoundly thankful for that. And I realize that in all the attention that we could give, and many of us have given to the content of faith, it would look wonderful to catechize ourselves collectively and learn and take in deeply God’s word, truth, all the attention and earnest attention we give in taking in the content of faith, all the learning of ways that we can to contend for the faith. What the church must never become is a place where we actually ever lose sight of the fundamental, I want to call this, call of faith. And that call repeated in different ways over and over again in the New Testament is summed up in the two words at the end of verse 19 here in our passage.
That call is this, follow me. That’s Jesus’ fundamental call and summons to all the universe but here particularly to his disciples. Follow me. And so I want us to reflect together a little just on this call of faith and some of what this means. And let’s gather our thoughts around three basic ideas. To follow Christ, to obey his summons and command, his call of faith to us, to follow him, means we follow him in cruciformity, without comparisons, and with a confident consolation. You need those three hooks.
We follow Christ in cruciformity, without comparing, with a confident consolation. Let’s take these in turn. You know this passage, it’s the epilogue to the Gospels. Jesus is resurrected. He has appeared to His disciples. And this passage tells us this is the third time. John says this is true. He took three witnesses. And this is the third occasion that Jesus has appeared.
And He performs the miracle of the fish. How interesting, when the disciples are not following Jesus, they go back to fishing. Well, He comes, surprises them with the miracle of the fish. They then dock and have breakfast. And after breakfast, Jesus needs to have a conversation with the apostle Peter. And so he focuses on him. And part of that is this point about we follow Christ in cruciformity.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrote a well-known book, Cost of Discipleship, and one of the best things he said in that whole book was this, when Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die. For Bonhoeffer, for Peter, according to verse 19, right in the parenthetical phrases, he said to show by what kind of death he, Peter, was to glorify God. So for Bonhoeffer, for Peter, And for many others throughout the history of the church, up through and including today, the call was and is literal martyrdom.
When John Calvin started his Geneva Seminary in 1559, School for Preachers, it eventually became known as Calvin’s School of Death. Because at least 88 graduates is the number I saw, probably more, who were sent out from there to plant Protestant churches in France were martyred. Because in Catholic France, it was actually taking your life into your hands to plant a Protestant church. In fact, it was said at their graduation that their diploma was actually a certificate of death for many of them. They knew that’s what happened.
But the call to die isn’t just for those who go on to be actually physically martyred. This call to cruciformity isn’t just always in the literal, physical, life-extinguishing sense. The whole design of Christian discipleship is cross, shaped. It’s marked by this reality of cruciformity. Jesus says to all disciples, if anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me. Of course, that speaks to more than the end of the disciples life because it’s a daily duty and call that Christ places on us. So it speaks to the whole of life, day in and day out. It has this cross-shaped nature to it.
If you’re a disciple of Christ, you are one who follows Him, as the Apostle Paul says, in conformity to His death, even as we know the power of his resurrection. As ones united to Christ by faith, we live and experience, as Paul says elsewhere, the sentence of death, which could be literal or by way of various kinds of sufferings that we undergo and endure. We experience the sentence of death in ourselves so that we might not trust in ourselves, but in Him who raises the dead. Also, the apostle reminded the Roman Christians that they were baptized into Christ Jesus, which is to say that they were buried with Him in baptism into death and subsequently raised from spiritual death to walk in newness of life.
We could multiply examples. But the point is, our whole life in Christ is marked by cruciform death and resurrection life. That is the shape of it. So we follow Christ as ones who die daily and who live as ones marked by resurrection life. It takes both of these, of course.
If you only have resurrection, then you tend to minimize the concrete and very real suffering and pain that the fallen order is marked by. You tend to minimize that and downplay it. If you only have resurrection, you skip over it or you make it less than what it really is. You engage in what might be called a naive triumphalism. But if you only have cross, that leads to a kind of Nietzschean nihilism. where everything is destined and intended for pain and destruction.
The life of a disciple is shaped by cruciformity, cross-shaped death, inevitably tied to resurrection life. We are ones who have died with Christ, ones who put sin to death, but who’ve been raised to newness of life, who are marked out for final resurrection. That, of course, includes the presumption that we first have died, that we follow Christ in cruciformity. And of course, this dying takes on many different forms and shapes, as has been alluded to. And it includes dying to self-willed desires and plans, to personal autonomy, having a life that is directed merely by our own wills.
To follow Christ is to die to that kind of personal autonomy. We have a master who leads and guides and directs as we follow. Jesus told Peter in verse 18, you will be carried where you do not want to go. For Peter, for us, following Christ may mean being led where you don’t want to go into some undesirable places. As it was for Peter. I listened to this pastor, or he was actually a bishop in a denomination, having a conversation with a PCA pastor in Alabama.
Didn’t mention his name, so he’s anonymous. But this bishop was having a discussion with this PCA pastor. And this pastor recounted to him that he had previously enjoyed decades of successful ministry, as it were. His church had grown very fast, had a very fruitful ministry. But that was decades ago.
In the current, as he was having this discussion with the bishop, he was in a dry or hard season. He mentioned that he was having marital difficulties. His health was failing. There wasn’t much demonstrable fruit in the new church that he was pastoring. And what was interesting is that what the pastor said about that. He said that he was in a phase of life in ministry and following Christ where he was learning that it’s so hard, quote, to work for God when God turns ugly. A little Alabamian phrase.
And that’s actually, I think, a good description of what it feels like when you’re led where you don’t want to go. when you follow Christ into an undesirable place, as it were. And not only often are you led where you don’t want to go, you often are led there with people you don’t want to go with, if we’re honest. Remember this if you find yourself in a hard situation or difficult place that is directly tied to you following Christ. And the thing to do is not engage in navel-gazing self-pity, but to lift your eyes in faith and see the larger story, the larger thing that God is actually doing in that undesirable place you find yourself. And what is that? What is he doing?
Verse 19 tells us what was going to be accomplished ultimately by Peter in his old age, being taken where he did not want to go, and dying, I’m sure, a death he did not intend or expect to die. Verse 19 says that it was by that death that he was to glorify Our gory cross-bearing, as it were, in life is telling a story of God’s glory. His death was intended to glorify God. You know, God’s glory is far more interesting than our self-pity stories.
This is his basic catechetical question one stuff. What is the chief end of man? To glorify God and enjoy Him forever. And that happens even in the most undesirable places, times, circumstances, and situations of Christ’s disciples. We follow him in cruciformity. It has a cross shape to it that will eventuate in full resurrection and vindication of God’s ways and Christ leading of us. So we deal with cruciformity, but the call to follow him is also to be pursued with single-eyed focus without comparing.
Verses 21 and 22. Peter’s response to the particular call on his life was to consider what was in store for his associate, John. It says in verse 21, when Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, Lord, what about this man? After Jesus told him what was to be, you know, what was going to happen in his own life. He looks over and says, what about this man?
I don’t think there’s any reason for us to believe that Peter’s question is still motivated here. I mean, it may have been, but it’s not clear to us. We can’t divine his mind and heart. He asked the question. The Lord told him what’s going to be the case in his life. And he’s curious, OK, so what about John? Maybe it was ill-motivated, maybe not. But nonetheless, Jesus’ response to him is emphatic in verse 22. What is that to you? And then he repeats the call. You follow me. This is theological for Peter, it’s none of your business. Trust me, follow me.
Following Christ, obeying his call of faith to us as his disciples, demands a single-eyed focus that doesn’t veer off into comparing providential dealings with others. other individuals, other families, other churches, other nations. And the folly of this should be readily apparent. One, to compare God’s dealings and leading of us with others is to occupy ourselves with matters that are beyond us.
We don’t get to inquire into the secret ways of God with others. That is something that is truly above our pay grade. Those things belong to God. And those are things He has not revealed to us. I know that many parents are desperate to understand God’s ways in the lives of their children. When the call there is to be faithful, to parent as God has called you, to trust Him, to fulfill His covenant promises. That is something we leave to God. We obey Him in what He has shown and revealed and what His call is and we trust Him.
So it’s occupying ourselves with matters that are beyond us, but also comparing can so easily lead to breaking the 10th commandment. To a kind of envy or jealousy or coveting what God has given or has done in another that we feel he has left undone or not done for us.
There’s a ministerial colleague of mine and we graduated together from undergrad and then journeyed similar denominational paths after college and through seminary and churches. However, this wonderfully esteemed friend and colleague of mine has gone on to author numerous books to have very distinguished positions in denominational agencies, and to pastor even currently large influential historic churches. And I’m pretty sure and expect that his gifts will be seen and he’ll be even elected moderator in the not too distant future in the denomination. And I genuinely rejoice in this brother and the kind providences that God has given to him and that he’s experienced.
But I would be remiss if I didn’t say I have, at times, the question has risen, not specifically like Peter’s question, what about him? But turned back, Lord, what about me? Because I’ve rejoiced and said, am I getting left out here? And you know, this is the seed, the oak is in the acorn. That if you let the kind of thinking that compares go long enough, it sprouts. And it can germinate and become real envy. or coveting. It can grow.
What is maybe first a genuine rejoicing with those who rejoice can so easily by the machinations of the human heart turn into a disappointment with God’s dealings in your own life. If you let those kinds of things go on, you can begin to question the very wisdom of God in your own life. Particularly if you feel and perceive that your allotted path of discipleship is harder in a demonstrable way than what you perceive it to be in the lives of others. Or if you believe you’ve been given less than what God has, by His grace, granted to others.
And at worst, we see the example of what comparing does. It can lead to the disaster that it led to in the first family, where Cain’s murderous hatred for his righteous brother Abel was spawned because of a kind of resentment that God had accepted one offering and rejected the other. And of course, there are many lesser degrees of this same sentient dynamic of comparing.
By stopping and turning and simply saying, what about him or her? The prosperity of others. may even sting a bit. You read Psalm 73 of Asaph, right? And Gore Vidal once said, he was being a very candid moment, said, every time a friend of mine succeeds, a little piece of me dies.
I think he was showing what a heart that is not content to follow Christ where Christ leads specifically, where it can go. Yet, in spite of whatever is going on in the lives of others, whatever perceived blessings and fruitfulness in others, versus a deprivation or dryness in your own life, whatever is going on, whatever blessedness others may seem to enjoy, the call, the command to Peter and by extension us in verse 22 is you follow me. It comes down back to this fundamental call of faith, which is to follow Christ wherever he leads.
But this fundamental call including This fundamental call, it doesn’t come to us just as a bare directive, just as a divine command, as it were, that we are to summon up human effort, capacity to obey. So that’s not how it ultimately works. It doesn’t come to us, then, as this bare directive. It comes couched in. a consoling confidence. So we follow in the cruciformity, we follow without comparisons, but we follow with this consolation. When Peter answered, in answering Peter’s question, in answering that question, what about John?
Jesus appeals to his authority as the commander of heaven and earth. In verse 22 and verse 23, he says, Jesus said to him, If it is my will…” If it is my will. And he says again in verse 23, right? So the saying spread about John is a false saying, but at the end it says, “…but if it is my will…” John repeats what Jesus said in verse 22. “…if it is my will…”
In following Christ, in answering this call of faith, this summons, this command to us, we aren’t merely striving to keep a command. Christ has said, and has implied, all authority and powers in himself. So if it is his will, this will happen. So we are not being summoned to something outside of Christ’s authority and power to make happen.
We’re actually being led and guided by the will of a sovereign Lord and loving Shepherd, who, as the confession reminds us, is, quote, directing all creatures by His most wise and holy providence. And He is leading His people. He is leading His disciples into eternally good pastors. He that began a good work in us will bring it to completion in the day of Christ. So we’re not left to the reserves of our own strength and power and ability to follow Christ. Christ is working out and in and through us.
He has even given us, His followers, the gift of faith to believe, to trust, and the grace to follow Him. We are His workmanship that God has ordained for us to do good works, for us to walk in. So even the following, even the obeying, even the believing is empowered by Him. That’s the comforting consolation that He’s at work accomplishing that what He commands in His people. May He help us to In whatever it is He says to us, in all that He has commanded, give us the grace to trust, to follow, to believe. Let’s pray. Father, thank you for this basic reality and call to just to follow Christ. to believe Him and trust Him. And that we can have confidence that we are led well, eternally well.
So would you increase our faith, Lord? Would you give us grace to obey in the difficult places when we find ourselves in places that are undesirable to us in our own taste? Would our capacity to trust and believe grow? By your own grace, Lord. Faithful is the one who calls us, who also will do it. So we thank you, Lord. May we receive and may we rest in the Son as he is offered to us in the gospel. And not just for salvation, Lord, for our sanctification, for our perfecting and growth all the days of our life here until we meet in glory. In Jesus name, Amen. Let’s sing together a song of affirmation. Hymn of affirmation number 500.
The sermon text provided above is derived from the sermon audio recording making use of generative tools. It has not been manually edited. While transcription tools have a high degree of accuracy, the output may include generative textual, punctuation, and/or formatting errors.

